Member Review
Review by
penny s, Reviewer
Anointed by Toby Stuart is a fascinating journey through one of humanity's enduring puzzles: social status. This isn't an academic treatise on sociology; it's an accessible study of how status has shaped civilizations throughout history and continues to influence us today in ways we're only beginning to understand, thanks to the rise of social media and AI.
Stuart centers the book on an idea that is both simple and profound: social status operates as a unique form of currency. Unlike material wealth, you can't simply acquire status through purchase or conceal it for safekeeping, no matter how desperately some might try.
One of the book's strongest demonstrations shows how hierarchies emerge naturally, even in societies that actively pursue equality. These social rankings don't appear out of nowhere; they're built on subtle cues, signals, and markers that we often process unconsciously. From the way someone dresses to the words they choose, from their social connections to their cultural references, we're constantly transmitting and receiving status information.
Once we have a solid background of how this happens, Stuart explores the concept of "anointment." Status isn't gained by climbing a straightforward ladder with globally expected and accepted results. It's remarkably fickle and context-dependent. Someone who commands respect in one setting might find themselves completely overlooked in another. The author illustrates this through compelling examples from various fields, showing how the same person can be simultaneously high-status and low-status depending on their environment.
This dynamic became painfully clear when my late mother-in-law was advised to introduce herself as "Dr. —" to medical professionals during her cancer treatment. She had a doctorate in economics. Using this title earned her better attention and clearer explanations. It bothered us both: what about those without her education? This is what Stuart calls "Competence Confusion", status markers influencing even life-and-death interactions.
The book truly shines in its interdisciplinary approach. Stuart doesn't confine the text to business case studies or academic research. Instead, he weaves together insights from literature, art, fashion, technology, and organizational behavior to create a comprehensive picture of how status operates across different domains. This makes complex sociological concepts surprisingly digestible for general readers.
What makes the book feel urgent is Stuart's look at how social media and AI are reshaping status dynamics right now. Traditional gatekeepers are crumbling, new influencers are rising, and status shifts happen at lightning speed. Where does this leave us? Stuart captures our challenge perfectly with a Robert Louis Stevenson quote: "The worst historian has a clearer view of the period he studies than the best of us can hope to form of that in which we live. The obscurest epoch is today."
Anointed is packed with insights that will have you reconsidering everyday social interactions and questioning assumptions you didn't even know you held.
Stuart centers the book on an idea that is both simple and profound: social status operates as a unique form of currency. Unlike material wealth, you can't simply acquire status through purchase or conceal it for safekeeping, no matter how desperately some might try.
One of the book's strongest demonstrations shows how hierarchies emerge naturally, even in societies that actively pursue equality. These social rankings don't appear out of nowhere; they're built on subtle cues, signals, and markers that we often process unconsciously. From the way someone dresses to the words they choose, from their social connections to their cultural references, we're constantly transmitting and receiving status information.
Once we have a solid background of how this happens, Stuart explores the concept of "anointment." Status isn't gained by climbing a straightforward ladder with globally expected and accepted results. It's remarkably fickle and context-dependent. Someone who commands respect in one setting might find themselves completely overlooked in another. The author illustrates this through compelling examples from various fields, showing how the same person can be simultaneously high-status and low-status depending on their environment.
This dynamic became painfully clear when my late mother-in-law was advised to introduce herself as "Dr. —" to medical professionals during her cancer treatment. She had a doctorate in economics. Using this title earned her better attention and clearer explanations. It bothered us both: what about those without her education? This is what Stuart calls "Competence Confusion", status markers influencing even life-and-death interactions.
The book truly shines in its interdisciplinary approach. Stuart doesn't confine the text to business case studies or academic research. Instead, he weaves together insights from literature, art, fashion, technology, and organizational behavior to create a comprehensive picture of how status operates across different domains. This makes complex sociological concepts surprisingly digestible for general readers.
What makes the book feel urgent is Stuart's look at how social media and AI are reshaping status dynamics right now. Traditional gatekeepers are crumbling, new influencers are rising, and status shifts happen at lightning speed. Where does this leave us? Stuart captures our challenge perfectly with a Robert Louis Stevenson quote: "The worst historian has a clearer view of the period he studies than the best of us can hope to form of that in which we live. The obscurest epoch is today."
Anointed is packed with insights that will have you reconsidering everyday social interactions and questioning assumptions you didn't even know you held.
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.