One bed. Two strangers. Zero chance of keeping things simple this Christmas.

Commitment-shy Hannah Doyle’s career is taking off. Now, it’s time for her personal life to catch up. So what if her friends think she’s settling? Soulmates don’t exist, so why waste her time trying to find one? Following that plan, she’s finally asked her girlfriend-of-convenience, Anna, to move in. What she didn’t plan was waking up in a stranger’s bed on Christmas Eve.

Elyse Thornton has never paid much attention to her appearance. But when fashionable and gorgeous Rowena asked her out, it felt nice to be noticed. Now, Elyse hopes their first Christmas together is another step forward in their relationship. This was before Elyse discovered a half-naked stranger in her bed.

Mortified, Hannah apologizes for the mix-up, but neither of them expected the soulful conversations or the connection they formed. Could they be each other’s soulmates? As the night unfolds, deep feelings begin to develop, forcing them to face their fears and hopes—settle for the familiar, or take a chance on each other.