I received this as an e-galley from the publisher via NetGalley in return for an honest review.

As a librarian, I know so many kiddos that LOVE dinosaurs, my own child included, and that the age range spans several ages. So, I was super excited to see this, especially since *I* love graphic novels.

This Magic School Bus meets graphic novel for older readers is a fabulous concept...
But, sadly, this one lost me early, while we were still in the Triassic. :(

Here's why:
I had a hard time buying the story that this kid is walking home talking aloud about how badly they did on the test topic, which just so happens to be what their eccentric neighbor specializes in, who just happens to be in her magic recycling bin at that moment and offers her services. It felt a bit like a very convenient means to an end, like they had the concept for traveling back in time and learning about dinosaurs all mapped out (and well!) but just threw this in as a way a to get to that point. It felt a bit rushed.

Then, once they time-travel in the magic recycling bin, this graphic novel is so incredibly packed with information that, at times, the speech bubbles look as if they're going to burst from the panels. And while there is dialogue, it still feels like someone took a textbook and adapted it to a graphic novel format often.

So for me, it was just okay.

That being said, I absolutely think this graphic novel will have appeal to many readers. Kids who love dinosaurs will likely eat this up. And I really do love having some good non-fic graphic novels on my shelves!

Dinosaur Empire is a dense, fact-filled graphic exploration of the rise and fall of dinosaurs that conveys a lot of information for readers in the MG and YA range, though it could use a bit more spark in its storytelling.

Ronnie has just failed her test on dinosaurs horribly, though she has a chance to retake it the next day. Resigned to failing it yet again, and wondering “Who needs to learn about dinosaurs anyway,” she tosses her test into a nearby recycling bin. Lucky for her, a neighbor, Miss Lernin, happens to be hanging out inside the bin. Even better, the bin is a time machine and Miss Lernin is a former paleontologist, who after a quick lesson in general evolution theory quickly whisks Ronnie away to the Mesozoic Era to show her first hand all she needs to know (and more) for tomorrow’s test.

They begin in the ;ate Triassic, then move into the Jurassic and finally the Cretaceous, ending of course with the demise of the dinosaurs. Along the way the reader is treated to a densely thorough description of all sorts of dinosaurs, as well as an introduction to a wide panoply of other creatures of the time: flying reptiles, marine reptiles, mammals, and others. The information is up-to-date and besides descriptions of the animals also includes explanations of convergent evolution; the development and possible purposes of feathers, frills, and crests; the development of plants, and their co-evolution with insects; the use of phylogenetic trees, and so forth.

The explanations are concise and clear, and the diagrams often helpful. The presentation is straightforward and more than a little talky, with the few attempts at humor appreciated but weak. The artwork is solidly adequate I’d say; without a lot of detail, and I didn’t always have a clear sense of scale (or at least if the scale shown was accurate or not). And the pages felt a bit cluttered; I would have preferred more space given to the illustrations.

There’s no fault to be found at all with the amount or detail or thoroughness of the information, and Dinosaur Empire is certainly a book that young readers will learn a lot from, even if they might be somewhat overwhelmed with the number of creatures, names, etc. Where it falls a little short is in the style and presentation, which may not grab young readers not already largely interested in the topic.

This is a very educational, but kind of boring graphic novel about Dinosaurs. The concept is that the neighbor lady has a special recycling bin that contains her whiteboard and the ability to travel through time. And since she is a paleontologist she is going to help our kid study for his dinosaur test. This is a galley copy so everything is black and white. I would love to see it colorized in the final version. The book is very dense. I would say 4th grade and up. Lots of talking and lots of information. In fact there are more words than illustrations per page, which is unusual for a graphic novel.

Added Goodreads
Added Litsy

This is THE book I needed when I was little! This is an incredibly entertaining and in depth look at dinosaurs from Late Triassic to Late Jurassic and beyond! The illustrations are great and not too detailed, whilst dropping in lots of interesting facts and tid-bits about every dinosaur imaginable. I really enjoyed reading this and I Know that any dinosaur lover will too!