Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A realization that suits in the modern era and millennials. The story is really great! There's a bit of LGBT but overall the book will surely make you think of your next decision.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quietly engaging novel of a family struggling to understand one another, amidst a lifetime of misunderstandings, prejudices, and long buried pain. Yet, despite sounding heavy, it was warm and filled with gentle humor, and you felt like the characters were an extension of your own family. The artwork was skillfully executed and filled with heart; very eye-pleasing.

Was this review helpful?

This was one of the most moving graphic novels I've ever read. As you could imagine, it was heavily centred on this idea of generations, and with that came the meaning of family and how they can be there for you when you undergo things that will make you question yourself and those around you.

We mainly follow Matteo, but thorugh his eyes we take a glimpse into the lives of his Aunties, cousin, nan and father. There were a few sad moments and times of happiness, which I really enoyed. There were a lot of themes that made good points to reflect on and I found this to help teach people about the morals of life and how that can be seen differently throughout all the different generations within a family unit.

I wasn't expecting the black and white colour palette for some reason but it worked, especially with the contrast of the simplicity in the lack of colour when in contrast with the wonderful story telling.

The reason I didn't give this a 5 stars is simply because there were times where I couldn't connect to the location or really get a feel for it and that may just be because I have no knowledge of the place this is set in.

Overall, a really solid read and a very impressive, emotional graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

Generations is a beautiful story about family and a young man finding his place in the world. There is also an undercurrent surrounding Matteo's sexuality as he tries to settle back into life in a small town.

Matteo begins the book listless, without purpose or motivation after his first major relationship blows up. He's defined himself by his sexuality up to this point and feels like he can't reveal that aspect of himself to the family he is relying on.

I found it amusing that his aunts are referred to as A, B, and C instead of by name. They are important to his life and his growth over the course of the book, but it didn't feel flippant or degrading toward them that they aren't known by their names. The women in Matteo's family act as a counterpoint to his sadness. Despite some harsh circumstances, they are able to find the joys of life. There is excellent growth for the characters over the course of the book and they felt very realistic.

This is a very moving book that features a homosexual protagonist without being preachy. Instead it captures the struggles that everyone faces and leaves the reader with hope that things can get better. The art was fine. It doesn't need to be anything extravagant to go with this story, but I felt a little underwhelmed at times. It doesn't detract from the point of the book though.

Was this review helpful?

Heartfelt and sincere - I loved the simple tory revolving around intergenerational family drama, and the clean art style. After finishing it, I was surprised to read that this was a translation! Oftentimes you can tell, but this was well done and seamless. A nice sentimental and short read!

Was this review helpful?

Generations is a story about family and growing up. Matteo left his hometown after coming out to his father as gay. It's been three years and he returns home to live with his grandmother, three aunts, and pregnant cousin. He realizes that each of his aunts has their own past, things they did that effected the rest of their life. This story shows that awkward time when as a young adult you start to see your elders as real people.

The storytelling is lyrical, but at times it is evident that it's been translated. The artwork is simple, but matches perfectly with the tone of the story. I laughed out loud at the "only gay in the village" reference. I give this book a 5/5.

Was this review helpful?

This is a sterling book that raises one question above all others - is it wrong to expect such a convincing character study about a gay Italian man from a [whatever, really, who-cares?] Italian woman? It reads with the veracity of autobiography, as we see our lead come back to stay with his nan and several aunts when his first adult relationship in Milan fails. He finds himself, he realises duty, and he realises that being gay should not be the defining factor in his life story. It's all pretty much heart-warming, and intelligent, and speaking volumes in quiet fashions about Italian family life. I didn't get a full grasp on all the aunts, but our hero is bound to stay in the mind for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

Story about family, acceptance and growing up.

I really like how the author depicts the struggle of being yourself and how to know who you are in the first place. The fear of what others would think and mainly your family. Big family in which every member has their own problems. I also like the interactions between the characters and the different personalities of each of them.

I would describe this story as bittersweet and really emotional. I didn't expect it to be so heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time.

Was this review helpful?

This was a touching coming-of-age tale written in graphic novel format. The story especially appealed to me because it was about a big Italian family. I, personally, I came from a very small family so I really enjoyed family interactions. Good, bad, or ugly, I could relate to these people.

Was this review helpful?

Generations tells the story of Matteo's return to his strict, dysfunctional Italian family after his boyfriend dumps him. Now that he's home, he's confronted by his overbearing aunts, his sick grandmother, and a father who he doesn't believe will accept that his son is gay. Through the panels of this graphic novel we see Matteo grow into a more mature man, learning how to apologize, forgive, and be present for those who need him. The story was great, but the style of artwork isn't one that I particularly care for.

Was this review helpful?

A very interesting coming-of-age story about a young, gay man and his struggle to reunite with his family. The artwork is very nice, clean and clear shapes. There are a couple of characters but each one of them so distinctive it feels like you've known them for a long time. The story-telling is very subtle. I couldn't really take to the protagonist as he seemed to me a bit too whiny but also too forgiving of the mistreatments he has suffered. (Btw I adore Matteo's shirt he wears on the cover.) I wish some pages or panels or even only single persons (like on the cover) would have been in color as the black and white felt sometimes a bit monotonous. Still, a calm and friendly story about growing up and family bonds.

Was this review helpful?

Actual rating: 4,5 stars

This is a story about growing up, taking control back, and coming to terms with the past. This book reminds me of The Complete Persepolis. It has the same type of bittersweet emotion that is normal when describing life and growing up. My connection with Matteo really grew while I was reading, just like my experience with Persepolis.
I definitely recommend this to anyone trying to find out what they want to do in life, how to shape their future.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my unbiased opinion.

After coming out as gay, leaving home 3 years ago, and not talking to his dad since, Matteo returns to his hometown. Still not ready to face his dad, he moves in with his Nan, 3 aunts, and pregnant cousin. Matteo has plenty of time for introspection with no job and an uncertain future, and with time, he begins to see things from a new point of view.

I absolutely loved this graphic novel. Its themes will resonate with many in the millennial generation. I liked the growth of the main character as the story went on. The end of the story made me cry.

Was this review helpful?

A touching graphic novel about a young man accepting his homosexuality and finding peace and a place in his larger family. A book about acceptance, forgiveness and hope. Lovely illustrations take you on the protagonist's journey from angry young man to responsible, caring adult.

I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thanks!

Was this review helpful?

Bondi's "Generations" is about Matteo, a gay man returning home from Milan for the first time in 3 years. He returns to his hometown with little money, no job, and no wish to see his conservative father, opting instead to spend time with his extended family.

What unfolds is very much a family based story that is also rather sad. It's definitely a wonderfully drawn and written story. I didn't know what to expect going in as I didn't know of Bondi or what the story would pan out to be. It's a rather touching but short tale that I think fans of LGBTQ stories would enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

Biondi's Generations is quite a wonderful family relations story set in Italy. It's melancholic, sad even, but full of hope at the same time. Matteo returns home after his life in Milan breaks apart and now he has no job and no home. Instead of returning to his father, he moves in with his grandmother, aunts and cousin. The reason why Matteo is avoiding his father is that Matteo is gay and even returning was hard and soon even harder when his relatives get to know this fact. He has to grow up and find his own path to make things right again. Perhaps he actually grows a bit too fast as in I would've wanted him to connect the dots with more carefulness and thought. Also, Matteo's relationship with his ex-boyfriend and the whole situation is lacking in someways not to forget that Matteo's reasons are left unclear. All in all I'd say all this is because the comic is too short to convey such depth with these pages alone. The story in itself is interesting and well put together, so that's really not the point.

I like the art. It's somewhat crude and realistic, but very smooth and heartwarming at the same time. The art fits very well with the story line, theme and image. This would've looked awesome in color actually. The view angles look nice and the structure is very defined! What I liked the most is that the comic is set in Italy, the street views and the way of life are refreshing to boot. The characters are well built with persona and a role that makes the family, the generations. With more pages this could've been easily four stars if not even more.

Was this review helpful?

" I feel guilty for all the new generations that do nothing but expect from the past without ever giving"
This is a beautiful graphic novel about what it truly means to grow up, and take responsibility for our actions, but also about the real meaning of family, the interconnections that link us to those who have gone before, and those who will follow.
Matteo fought with his dad about his sexuality and moved away, but when the relationship breaks down and he is forced to come home, unwilling to face his father he moves in with his grandmother, aunts and pregnant cousin. As he is literally forced to be closer to them he learns more about their pasts and relationships, and gains a deep understanding of how much he needs to grow up, and step up, so that he can become the man he wants to be, and a man that his family not only loves and respects but can be proud of.
Short , simple and sweet , this was a joy from cover to cover.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting story with nice artwork, I liked the focus on different generations of a family rather than it just dealing with coming out or romance. However, I had a big problem with the tone of the book. It made out that it was Matteo's fault that his family didn't accept him for being gay and that he was to blame for leaving town instead of staying until they changed their minds. For young LGBT people reading this graphic novel, that's an untrue and damaging myth to perpetuate.

Was this review helpful?

Matteo, due to some issues with his lover, decides to leave Milan and come back home. Not at his father house, however, because maybe he never forgave Matteo for being gay. Matteo moves with his grandmother, where he finds also his three aunts and his pregnant cousin.

Matteo must then learn how to live with his family, and this change will bring him new responsibilities, since he will have to help his invalid grandmother and do the house chores.

Generations is a moving and compelling book, and at the same time it is light as a feather; Matteo's coming of age will happen also by discovering the past of his family and the difficulties faced by the previous generation.

This book was truly a beautiful discovery, both concerning the narration and the illustrations, a book I absolutely suggest to read.

Thanks to the publisher for providing me the copy necessary to write this review.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't crazy about this graphic novel at first, and it took me forever to get into it, but once I got there I really liked it. It's a little different from a traditional "coming-of-age" story in that the main character Matteo, comes to a realization about his family dynamics that help him realize his own short-comings. In my reading experience, coming of age novels usually do this the other way around.

Matteo moves back to his small hometown after living in Milan for three years with his boyfriend. He's somewhat ashamed to be back, since he left in a huff three years before, and hasn't had any contact with his father, or with his extended family that includes three aunts, a cousin, and a grandmother. He moves in with this extended family where he proceeds to drift and complain until realizing that his family is not as cruel, angry, and judgemental as he always thought of them. From here he slowly begins to turn his life around, finding a new appreciation for his roots along the way.

Part of the reason why I wasn't a huge fan of this graphic novel is because I didn't really like the illustrations. All the characters looked the same (I mean, most of them were related, but even the ones that weren't looked eerily similar). I was especially spooked by the resemblance between Matteo's ex-boyfriend and his father.

However, this was a book I would recommend to people who like graphic novels that aren't fantasy or dystopian focused.

Was this review helpful?