Cover Image: Fallen Eagle

Fallen Eagle

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This was a very detailed book about the movement of troops on the Eastern and Western fronts. The book is one of military strategy and the decline of the third Reich. This book is definitely for a student of military history, specifically World War II, this not a book for a casual history reader. This is a great book for someone that is writing a thesis. It can be a little boring but overall a well written book.

Was this review helpful?

First of all I have to thank Thistle publishing and Net Galley for giving me a copy to read and review this superb book written by Robin Cross.

The book has an exhaustive account about the last days of the Third Reich. From the reading we can understand how much the author has took pain in collecting the relevant information of the Second World War, the heroes & zeros of the war, types of war machines used and in depth detail to the Corps level.

The author's description about Hitlers status is riveting "In the summer of 1942, Hitler had sat at the centre of a vast communications web stretching from the Atlantic coast to the Caucasus. Now his links with the outside world had dwindled to a switchboard of the size required to run a modest hotel, one radio transmitter, and one radiotelephone link with the OKW headquarters at Zossen, fifteen miles south of Berlin".

The author has cleverly placed journal entries, letters and documents, which gives an authenticated look but sometimes they might turn a bit odd and feels us to skip. I like to quote one account given by Janina Bauman, who had escaped from the Warsaw Ghetto in 1943 and was living on a farm when a German soldier was hiding in her farm.

…. Just before dusk I went out to fetch some wood. In the semi-dark shed, crammed with logs and tools, something stirred. I sensed a human presence. I pushed the door wide open to let more light. Only then did I notice a flap of field-grey military coat sticking out from the between two logs. Calmly, I locked the shed and ran back to the cottage. In the kitchen, Mrs.Pietrzyk, tired and worn after the restless night, was busy cooking. Gasping for breath, I told her what I had seen. But she was not surprised. She already knew. Staring full in my face with her ancient, all knowing eyes, she said, as if quoting from a holy book, 'Whoever comes under my roof seeking shelter, no matter who he is, no matter what he believe in, he will be safe with me'. In a flash I understood. Shocked, I watched her fill a tin bowl with hot dumplings and pour pork fat over it. 'Hold it child', she screeched in her usual way. "Take it to him'. As if mesmerized, I blindly obeyed and went back to the shed. It seemed as deserted as before, even the field-grey flap had disappeared. I stood benumbed, the hot dish burning my fingers and filling the air with a strong smell of food. There was a brief commotion behind the pile of logs and unkempt head suddenly popped out. I saw the pale face of the German, a boy rather than a man, staring at me in terror. He grabbed the steaming bowl from my hands and fell on the food with unspeakable greed. He was still trembling from hunger and fear. For a long while I watched him blankly. I felt no pity, no hatred, no joy.

A soul stirring account of the bombing of 7th largest city in Germany, Dresden, was provided in the book. The author has mentions the people behind the operation and ends that chapter with quotes from cemetery Heidefriedhof in Dresden:

"How many died? Who knows the count?; In your wounds one sees the ordeal; Of the nameless who in here were conflagrated; In the hellfire made by hands of man".

The book ends at 88% and the remaining 12% is about Appendix 1 Key Items of Weaponry, Appendix 2 Notes on Personalities (which is more important as some might find difficultly in finding who the person the author mentions about) and select Bibliography.

I thoroughly enjoyed the book, with 500 pages this book is must for World War II enthusiasts.

Was this review helpful?

A big thank you to Robin Cross, Thistle Publishing, and Netgalley for the free copy of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.

I debated on my rating. I really wanted to give it a higher star, but the book was just riddled with quotes, to the point that I felt like it was abused. Who was writing this version of history? Some pages were an entire journal's entry. I could go for pages and not come across one that didn't have a significant amount of the text not come from a primary source. This was not how the book is marketed, at least not how I interpreted it. It got to the point where I just skipped over those portions and read the rest of the page. I don't feel like I missed out on anything by doing that because the majority of the information included in those passages is superfluous and should have been integrated into the storytelling if the author had taken a little more time in drafting.

Yes, this book was informative, especially about the Russian front. But I just can't let the composition slide.

Was this review helpful?