Cover Image: The Closer

The Closer

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This book is the story of one woman's journey into uncharted territories and surmounting many odds, becoming a success.

The first realization at the completion of the book was that I would have enjoyed it more if its content had been split over two or three books. The book's tone toes the line between a self-help non fiction and actual fiction. Since the information comes from a treasure trove of actual business experience, it is an interesting read but for a person like me who is not very comfortable with reading non-fiction, does not hit the right note.

Apart from the actual narration, the story has it all, the struggle to achieve in a world stacked against you as well as scheming untrustworthy people. It highlights actual struggles and could very well be a discussion centerpiece at a reading group but I need to mention again, it would have been a better read if told in multiple books.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC!

This book caught my eye because it was advertised in a runner’s blog. The plot is not mainly about athletic ability; it’s about a businesswoman trying to break through the glass ceiling at a fictional Nike rival. It began with the main character, Vivien, being lauded at her job for solving crises and rescuing sales accounts in danger of being lost. This part sets the stage to show Vivien as an overachieving Type A that succeeds at everything she does. All her friends are equally perfect, having MBA’s from the Wharton School, shiny hair, and stunning wardrobes. It began to be too much for me, and the book was almost a DNF. There was a lot of girl conversation and wine; then the plot twist saved the day – Vivien quits her job as a consultant to move across the country to work for Smart Sports in Portland.

Things improved a great deal with the change of venue. There was less perfection and more struggle, with the glass ceiling in full effect. Misogynistic coworkers lay traps for Vivien, which she occasionally falls into. I had a hard time believing someone so savvy could be tricked like that. She was way too trusting – I kept thinking about how obviously the men were plotting against her and she was just trying to be “friends” with them.

The best part of the book for me was reading about the clothing and shoes, and how they were designed and marketed. Second best was seeing Vivien out-think the men, despite treachery and politics everywhere. It’s too bad that this book is designed to appeal to women; more men should be reading about the struggles that we face in the business and sports world. None of these things seemed over the top or impossible; I’m sure that the author is writing from personal experience, with names changed to protect the guilty.

There is satisfaction as Vivien lives to fight another day against the evil male empire, but I may not be picking up the second book in the series. It’s enough that I live it, I don’t want to read about it.

Having said that – this book is recommended for its erudite and resilient main character. Chick lit fans should grab this to experience a different kind of strong woman.

Was this review helpful?