Cover Image: Bellewether

Bellewether

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Susanna Kearsley is such a beloved novelist. Her stories transport you to another time and place. "Bellewether" does this as well. Such a great novel.

Was this review helpful?

Not my favourite Susanna Kearsley book but LOVED the Canadain content. I thought is was overall a bit of a slow novel, with not much happening. The history was very interesting though, as a fellow Canadian and her romance is always spot on.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars: Thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for an advanced digital copy of this book in return for an honest review.

You may enjoy this book if you like: historical fiction, Canadian authors, dual timeline told with a historical POV and a present-day POV, romance, ghosts, historical research.

A good historical read with lots of detail. I like the dual timeline and always enjoy a story with someone who is doing historical research but the pacing was slow, the ghost story wasn't scary and I didn't love the romance.

Was this review helpful?

Susanna Kearsley has quickly become a favourite author. I am absolutely obsessed with her ability to weave factual history with a fictional romance. Unlike typical historical romances, the reader really gains an education based on this time period - the Seven Years War and the tensions between New France and the American colonists. As a high school history, this time period is right in my wheel house so it was neat being able to place some of these people and places in my own understanding. The slow burn and angst between the two protagonists was frustrating at times - but only because I figured they didn't have a chance at a long future so they needed to get together ASAP. The only critique I have for this book is that the final scene wasn't quite as satisfying as I wanted it to be. But ultimately this shows Kearlsey's expertise in storytelling, as I didn't want the story to end! 4.75 stars for this absolute must read.

Was this review helpful?

I have sold a couple of these already. Recommended to people who like historical fiction and romance.

Was this review helpful?

I attended a local book signing to meet the author for this book. I've read every book she's ever written and was prepared to love this one as well as her others. It lacked just a tinge of the urgency and passion of The Winter Sea, Mariana, and my personal favourite - The Rose Garden. While the developing romance between her historical characters is fraught with tension and the reader waits for calamity to strike, there isn't the same conflict or surprise in the contemporary love story that there is in her other books. And the debated twist ending of the book left something to be desired. I was really rooting for this book, having waited two years for it to be published, and wish I could give it 5 stars. Especially when it's based on the author's own family history. I just wanted MORE depth in both story lines and more passion. And naming the book after the ship in the historical line didn't really seem to capture the essence of the story.

Was this review helpful?

Susanna Kearsly writes some of the most well researched, fascinating books. They are quiet and sometimes a bit slow moving, but for me that enhances the experience more than anything. Her books are ones I continually reread, and this one is the same. I can’t wait to read her next book.

Was this review helpful?

I received a digital copy of this book from Simon and Schuster Canada and Netgalley for an honest review. I really enjoyed this book. There is a mix of a present day story and a historical story with a ghost story thrown in. I’m not usually too fond of ghost elements but it worked for me in this book. This book was well researched historically. Charley is one of the main characters and her story is present day. She moves to Long Island to work as a curator for a museum. The historical part of the book is the story of the previous owners of the house that is now the museum. Lydia is one of the central figures in the historical story as an occupant of the house. Jean-Philippe’s story is also told in the historical part as he is a French Canadian officer sent to live with Lydia’s family as a form of imprisionment during the late 18th century. There are both Canadian and American details in the book. There is also some romance in the book but not in great detail. Overall a very interesting and entertaining book. There was also a bit of a twist at the end that I was glad happened.

Was this review helpful?

Susanna Kearsley has spun a tale, both enthralling and memorable. Charley has been given the opportunity to fill in blanks in both her family’s history, and the history of the local museum. With the help of the local handyman and the resident ghost, she may just find the answers. A romantic, addictive story.

Was this review helpful?

My thoughts on this title will appear on my blog on July 9/18.

Due to some personal matters that required my attention, the time between reading this story and getting around to writing this review has been significant. As a results I feel I may be doing a disservice to the story and Kearsley since I couldn't write it while it was fresh in my head. If I have done so, I apologize.

Susanna Kearsley is one of my go to authors when I want a read that I know I will enjoy. The way she weaves the past and present to tell a story that is both interesting and educational is something I look forward to each time I pick up one of her books.

In most historical fiction stories that feature both present day and historical plots, I tend to favor the story set in the past. Not this time. I was equally invested in both Charley's story and Lydia's which made flipping the pages pretty easy for me. Both characters were dealing with grief and finding a way in their new reality and both stories depicted strong woman who were easy to like. Both also featured a love story that was sweet and believable. I love how innocent Lydia's was.

I will refrain from divulging any plot details but if you are already a fan of Susanna Kearsley than do not hesitate to pick this story up, you will not be disappointed. If you are not familiar with her work and are a fan of historical fictions, read this and then go back and read her other novels! It is fantastic that I have found such a great (and local) author to support

Was this review helpful?

I did not enjoy this book as much as I was hoping to enjoy this title. It is a great historical novel, but I found the writing style choppy, which made it hard to follow the story. The story drew my attention at the beginning, but did not keep it throughout the narrative.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for a review.

This book was a double romance, one version taking place in the present, and the other taking place during the war between the French and British colonies in the mid 1700's. Both stories piggybacked off the other and it was interesting to see how the generations of families continued over the years. It is also a ghost story, but in this case, the ghost has good intentions.
Historically it was interesting to read about the attitudes during the time periods as well as see the rules of war in action. I had no idea that prisoners of war were released for the winter, only to come back and fight on during the spring. Nor did I have any idea, that prisoners were billeted by the enemy for however long.
It was a cute story, and I did learn quite a bit. I got a bit frustrated with the way the book is narrated. It takes turns between 3 characters in the same order. I found myself really getting into one story, only to have it abruptly end, and I'd have to switch out into the past again.
Good, quick read and I'd recommend

Was this review helpful?

interesting story but i did not like the change in story line from past to present, i found it difficult to keep all the characters straight.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been a huge fan of Susanna Kearsley’s books for a few years now. The Winter Sea and The Firebird, along with A Desperate Fortune are three of my favourite books, so I was excited when Bellewether was announced, especially because the setting is completely different from Kearsley’s other books, which have been set in the UK and Europe.

I hate to lead with the negative, but I’ll get it out of the way so I can focus on the positive. Within a few pages of the book, I remembered something I’ve thought with every one of Kearsley’s other books I’ve read: she’s a fantastic storyteller, but not a great writer. Her style is awkward and choppy, with a lot of telling instead of showing (for example, saying ‘He explained’ before a line of dialogue when the dialogue itself should stand on its own), and she constantly breaks up dialogue with tags thrown in the middle, which I find really off-putting. All of this combined makes it hard for me to turn off what I call my ‘editor brain’. I found it jarring and it made it hard to really sink into the story because I was constantly being pulled out of it.

With that being said, Kearsley really is a fantastic storyteller. I love how she weaves the past and present together, and I love learning about historical events and time periods I didn’t know much about previously (I’ve always said that until Outlander, almost everything I knew about the Jacobites came from Kearsley’s books). It’s obvious Kearsley puts a ton of work, thought, heart, and research into her books.

I had a couple of personal connections to Bellewether that made me enjoy it even more. I honestly knew next to nothing about the Seven Years’ War, so it was all new and fascinating to me. I loved the ties to Canada and that Jean-Phillipe was Canadian, and I also loved that Kearsley included an Acadian character, since my family is Acadian and they’re so rarely seen in historical books (the only book I’ve read about the Acadians is Genevieve Graham’s Promises to Keep). Something else I really appreciated was that Sam was Mohawk; it’s rare to find Indigenous characters in literature, and I’ve never come across Mohawk characters (other than the love interest in one of my own novels). I live about five minutes outside a Mohawk reserve, so it was nice to feel that personal connection to the various characters.

As always, the romances were fantastic. Kearsley is a master of slow burn, and I loved watching Charley and Sam, and Lydia and Jean-Phillipe slowly fall in love. Another aspect I enjoyed was the haunting. It was so creepy, I ended up dreaming about ghosts in my own home, and had to stop reading the book late at night!

Overall, I really enjoyed Bellewether and would definitely recommend it to lovers of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars Oh dear...this book was disappointing for me on so many levels. It sounded incredibly intriguing and seemed to have all of my favourite elements including a fascinating historical back drop, war, romance and even a paranormal aspect. Unfortunately I found it challenging to care and engage in the plot. I will even admit there was an instance about a third of the way through in which I considered abandoning it altogether although I'm glad that I pushed on. The second half of the book picked up a little.

Bellewether is the name of a ship owned by one of the Wilde brothers and captained by his younger brother. Although there is reference to the Bellewether and a small plot line that focuses on the ship, most of the story is really about the history of the house owned by the Wilde's and a rumoured romance between Lydia Wilde and a French soldier that is said to have ended tragically and the source of a modern day haunting. The author uses two timelines - 1759: and present day - to build mystery and invoke a first hand account of life in the 18th century. I quite enjoyed the 1759 timeline - told from Lydia and Jean-philippe's POV's - but aside from the ghost element, found the modern day time line - told from Charley's perspective - to drag. Charley has her own family dysfunction and has recently been hired as a curator for the Wilde house turned museum. Charley's plot line felt one dimensional and somewhat contrived.

If I could pinpoint one suggestion it would be to PLEASE EDIT THIS STORY! Oh my goodness, it felt long and the descriptive prose was overwhelming. I think taking several paragraphs or pages to describe a setting or an element like a room in a house was excessive and could have been edited to a sentence or two. I felt bogged down by the unimportant detail. I wanted more focus on the characters' emotions, what made them human and their internal struggles. The war was referenced and a central theme but again I craved more historical detail of its impact on the characters. The romance was too slow with description interfering in its emotional development. I wanted to feel depth but instead felt removed and detached. And the ghost story...don't even get me started...while there was so much opportunity to invoke a little spookiness or an eerie chill, there wasn't any and it became more of an afterthought. There was a little mystery as to who the ghost was but that's as far as it went.

I really don't like to criticize as I appreciate all of the hard work that goes into writing a book but I felt quite let down by this one. It promised big things but the execution fell flat. Not a book for those looking for strong emotional connection. May be better suited to readers who enjoy flowery narrative descriptions and a slow moving plot.

Was this review helpful?

I'm surprised and sad to say that I didn't enjoy this book as much as I had hoped. There's lots of good things going on in this story: excellent writing from Susanna Kearsley, great contrast between past/present and a slow burn love story on both sides of the timeline. However, I couldn't find myself connecting with any of the characters through no fault of the author. It just didn't carry that same feeling that I got from The Firebird. 

First of all, there's a lot of family history to sift through in the first few chapters. This seemed more like a history lesson than an organic narrative experience. There's a great eerie retelling of the legend of the ghost at Wilde house here and there, but then it flips to a different form of writing that's more factual and dry in both narratives. I loved reading Charley's parts more but I think that was due more to the ease of the language in comparison to Lydia's side of the story. You can tell that Kearsley did her research though which I appreciate and respect. Yet it didn't come off as naturally as I would have liked.

My second issue with this book was the fact that the ghost makes only a few rare appearances. Each timeCharley tries to rationalize it away which I became irritated - I'm just that type of reader. It almost felt like the ghost parts were cameos - so quick you might miss them, and just enough to lend some significance to the rest of the story. If I had to pinpoint the real problem though, it would be that the magic realism that I had encountered in The Firebird is at a lighter level in this story. Give me more magic realism, please!

Then there's the two heroines themselves. They're both strong in different ways but their stubbornness irked me to no end. Charley's in a nowhere relationship with a guy she's only briefly met and dated in person before moving to New York. I wanted to shake some sense to her, especially when a tall, strong and handsome guy walks into her life. Meanwhile, Lydia's anger towards her French soldier is plain awful to watch. The animosity was so real I wondered when they would ever progress beyond that. Denial isn't a good look on most people, and it's frustrating to read it on these (otherwise) strong female leads.

However, I will say there's great diversity presented in this book. There's even mention of Canada which I love Kearsley for including as she's a Canadian author herself. I had no idea about this period in Canadian history. There's also discussion of Native Americans history, and people of colour pop up here and there.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book by this Author that I have read but I know it will not be the last one. This is a well-written story that I could not put down once I had started it. I received a copy of this book and I am voluntarily reviewing it.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster Canada for an ARC of this novel for my honest opinion. The description of the novel was enticing to me and I thought it would be a good novel, though it didn’t keep my interest as I found it to be long and boring. The writing itself was good and flowed, though, unfortunately did not hold my attention or kept me riveted to the story.

Was this review helpful?

Once again Susanna Kearsley brings both the past and the present wonderfully to life, with a historical narrative as compelling as her contemporary one. Family, community and romantic relationships deftly weave together into a story I could hardly bear to put down. I also learned about aspects of Canadian, American and world history I hadn’t known before, without ever being distracted from the characters’ personal story. Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

( 3.5 Stars )

I don’t generally gravitate towards historical fiction, but I adore Susanna Kearsley’s books, likely because she mixes the historical romance with a tinge of supernatural and always sweeps me away to a realm somewhere between reality and fantasy. She is an author I keep tabs on, so I was thrilled when Simon and Schuster Canada sent me a copy of her new book, Bellwether.

Bellwether follows the reliable standard for a lot of Kearsley’s books; we have a present day woman somehow stumbling onto a mystery from the past that she has to untangle and figure out. This time around, it’s Charley, a museum curator who joins a team at an old house-turned-museum and dives deep into the star-crossed love story of Lydia Wilde and a French-Canadian soldier name Jean-Phillipe.

I always enjoy Kearsley’s writing and characters. The women are strong and colourful, standing their ground and always very lively. The historical facts are interesting and relevant, but they aren’t overwhelming, which for someone like myself who isn’t totally fixated on history, is a blessing. There’s enough to ignite an interest and perhaps offer a lesson about the events of that era, but not too much as to completely dominate the story itself. She always creates a beautiful balance.

While I enjoyed the story of Ms. Wilde and her Canadian soldier, I wasn’t entirely wooed by this book. I felt that the romances, both the historical and the present, weren’t given enough time to properly blossom and build, like I’ve seen in other books. It seemed like in each case, the characters were harbouring interests and flirting with the concept, and then all of a sudden they were involved. I felt that previous books spent a bit more time in between, building that relationship, and I usually quite enjoyed that.

I also felt that the supernatural element this time around was far too subtle. It didn’t really give a lot of weight to the story, it was meant to be helpful to present day Charley, but she pretty much discovered everything on her own anyway and I think eliminating this aspect from the book wouldn’t have really changed anything significant in it.

As always, this was beautifully written, but I felt like it was a little slow moving and anti-climactic. It was a nice story, but not much really happened other than the romance elements and as I mentioned, I felt those could have been a little more thoroughly explored. But Kearsley does always provide a wonderful balance between fact and fiction, past and present, and I will always gravitate to whatever she puts out.

Was this review helpful?