Member Review

I found this book to be delightful, with beautiful descriptive writing, but also humor and drama. There is a Magic School Bus sort of feel to it. The format is enticing, with little sidebar boxes inserted to explain unusual words or fantastic concepts:
“Enchanting Details” (real-life sciencey facts)
“The Codex Arcanum” facts about magic, spells, etc. unique to this story
“Cryptid Corner” Magical Animal facts.

Interspersed in the story are full-page sheets on individual magical creatures (similar to a Pokemon card) with height, weight, and magical abilities. Many of these were familiar to me, but when I googled some of the others (such as the kongamoto), I was astonished to discover they already existed in myth.

I have not read the prequel, but I found it didn't matter. There was never a time when I was confused or frustrated. Since Star Wars has taught us that stories can start in the middle and expand both forward and backward, I don't think young readers will have a problem reading out of order, either.

Matt Harry's diverse ensemble includes a lesbian character, Trish, and Jacinda Greyeyes, a member of the Cree nation. There is a coming-out/romantic subplot that tied into the over-arching narrative nicely. This story is anchored by Trish, and I found her to be a strong, likable character. As with many stories with larger casts, I didn't feel the other characters were as fleshed out, but then if I had read the first book I may feel differently.

Note for sensitive readers: some animals get wounded or killed.