Cover Image: When I Close My Eyes

When I Close My Eyes

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

When I Close My Eyes by Elizabeth Musser is such a different book. It is a deeply moving book, full of drama with very believable characters. A book that will draw you in from the very first chapter. It deals with serious depression but in a well written way. You cannot always tell what goes on in the heart/life of a person. Even though it seems they are famous and well adjusted, they may be fighting their own demons. This book was emotionally charged, deeply thought provoking and you will find it hard to lay down, and the ending was so surprising and different........ Thank you to Bethany House Publishing and NetGalley for this book. I was under no obligation to write a positive review and all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

When I Close My Eyes by Elizabeth Musser was such a different book for me. I was not expecting this story to be so full of drama and deep.

The story begins with an attempted assassination of a well known and loved writer. While Josephine is in a coma, she relives areas in her life. Her struggle with depression is a main focus of the story. Henry, the would be assassin, himself struggles with PTSD. Finding that he has failed in his mission, he begins to read Josephine’s books and has questions that need answers. When he tries to reach out and talk with Josephine, he finds something he never experienced before. Love and forgiveness.

Although a secondary character, I loved the introduction of Drake, Paige’s close family friend. When Paige asks Drake if he has a girlfriend he again say no. When she questions him further, he confesses,
“But I have already found the girl. I’m just waiting for you to grow up Bourdy.”
He is such a realistic character. Patient and kind in all ways.

The mystery is a surprise that keep you wondering until the end.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from Net Galley and Bethany House. All views expressed are my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Told from the alternating perspectives of Josephine, Henry and Paige, "When I Close My Eyes" tells a story of how the lives of two dysfunctional families intertwine. It also addressed mental health challenges, including depression and suicide.
Henry has tried to murder Josephine because he needs money for his son's heart surgery. As Miz Bourdillon lies in a coma, her daughter Paige must put the pieces together and find the murderer. At the core of the story is the secret of The Awful Year, experienced years ago by Paige and her sister Hannah and their parents Josephine and Patrick, and the way it continues to affect each family member today.
It took me a bit to get used to the alternating narrators. I also was bored with the plot halfway through until the story took a huge twist that made me glad I kept reading. While I appreciated the message, the book is just okay for me. However, it does offer important insight into depression and faith and is an important book for readers who want to know more about how mental health and faith coincide.

Was this review helpful?

"When I Close My Eyes " by Elizabeth Musser is a Christian fiction book. This story deals with important issues like how do people cope physically and emotionally when trauma strikes. and depression. When trauma strikes the patient is faced with lots of emotions like shock, anger , depression. The author describes the characters well and their dilemmas in their lives. The daughters response to the trauma of their Mom is expressed very well. The book is written from the past and then to the present. The reader sees the characters from different ages. I commend the author for addressing the problem of a serious trauma and depression. Often in our society people with depression and trauma are not given what they need to meet their needs. The author put some helpful resources in the back of the book for people dealing with depression. I know that people dealing with depression will receive help from those resources. The author stated that she has dealt with depression and understands what it is like. I found the story hard to put down. The opinions about the story are my own. I appreciate the publisher for allowing me to read and review this book. I also appreciate netgalley for allowing me to read and review this book. I am posting my review on Amazon, Goodreads, facebook, my blog, CBD.com, church staff.

Was this review helpful?

When I Close My Eyes by Elizabeth Musser

Publication Date: 11/05/2019
Publisher: Baker Publishing Group
Imprint: Bethany House
Genre: Christian Fiction
Pages: 272
ISBN-13: 978-0593099735


Purchase: Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Indiebound, Book Depository

Elizabeth Musser on the Web: Website, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Goodreads

Excerpt from When I Close My Eyes courtesy of Amazon’s Look Inside feature

Synopsis:

Could she ever share the secret of The Awful Year?

There is one story that novelist Josephine Bourdillon shirked from writing. And now she may never have a chance. Trapped in her memories, she lies in a coma.

The man who put her there is just as paralyzed. Former soldier Henry Hughes failed to complete the kill. What's more: he never received full payment--funds that would ensure surgery for his son.

As detectives investigate disturbing fan letters, a young but not-so-naïve Paige Bourdillon turns to her mother's turbulent past for answers. Could The Awful Year be worse than the one they're living now?

Set against the flaming hills of North Carolina and the peaceful shores of the Mediterranean Sea, When I Close My Eyes tells the story of two families struggling with dysfunction and finding that love is stronger than Anything.

Was this review helpful?

There’s so many profound issues cleverly presented in this engrossing novel, the most striking being that of depression and its effects on a family. The subject of depression is portrayed in a very sensitive yet realistic way. Written in the voices of the three main characters, I was at once drawn into their stories. It centers around the attempted murder of a popular Christian author, Josephine, and the search for her assassin. But so many other intricate, yet relatable characters’ stories are woven throughout. What was the Awful Year they allude to about? This is one book I guarantee will keep you up all night reading and thinking about long after the last page.

Thank you to Bethany House Publishing and NetGalley for sending me this book. I was under no obligation to write a positive review and all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

What a gift you are about to receive as you turn the pages of this amazing read, tough subject, yes, but keep reading.
As we move along, your mind wants you to tell the character not to friend someone, but they don’t know the facts, and when the facts start to unfold, the hard thing for Christians begins, forgiveness.
We know who commits the crime, but who ordered it, and yes, I guessed wrong, and wrong again, but you will come to love this family, and in the end, I wanted more.
Often swept under the rug, depression is focused on here, and loved the author’s notes at the end.

I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.

Was this review helpful?

When I Close My Eyes is an emotionally difficult book to read as it tells the story of a murder gone wrong, a women living her life in a coma, and the stories of each of these characters as they deal with the consequences of their lives. The book tells of a difficult year but also shows the grace that results from love that survives difficult situations.

Was this review helpful?

Oh. My. Goodness. This book was emotionally charged, deeply thought provoking, and seriously amazing! I absolutely fell in love with each of these characters as they face tests of faith regarding God’s purpose and plan for their lives. There are realistic struggles with depression and the overwhelming demonstration of forgiveness. I found myself crying more than once over the emotion behind what each character experienced. It was extremely difficult to put the book down, and even when I paused in reading to do activities of my daily life, I found the words and themes of the story sticking with me. The ending is so beautiful and wraps everything up well. The writing was real and touching. The author has such a unique ability to craft such rich characters and themes! It was easy to connect with the characters and to relate to their growth and the spiritual lessons to my own life. Like all of her novels, Elizabeth Musser pens yet another book that is deeply powerful and definitely worth the read. I cannot recommend this book enough!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. Opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the premise of this book, an assassination attempt gone wrong, but the execution didn't click for me. The writing felt choppy, and I struggled with all the different points of view. The constant switching from one character to another kept me from connecting with any of them very deeply. I appreciated the message the author was trying to convey, but it felt heavy handed at times. I wish I had enjoyed it more. It's getting great reviews on Goodreads, so it's probably just my personal taste. There's nothing content wise that would keep me from recommending it. It just wasn't for me.

I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley for the purpose of review.

Was this review helpful?

Another excellent read by Elizabeth Musser and very un-put-downable! It's a puzzle I tried to figure out, and she kept me guessing with all the twists and turns. The book deals with some dense subject matter - but with themes that affect everyone today. Someone in our lives is affected by this, and it may be ourselves, that are going or have gone through mental illness. Our broken lives require healing, forgiveness, and hope. To be able to walk in the light and out of the darkness.

Elizabeth writes, "entertainment with a soul," and her new book fits this description perfectly. She is one of my favorite Christian authors as she presents the gospel so clearly, plus there is usually a hint of French culture in her books! I highly recommend this new novel of hers! I am thankful to the author and publisher for furnishing me with an ARC for this my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was surprised when I realized this was a mystery. It was an unusual book for Elizabeth Musser. I found it a little slow in the middle, however, I was more than rewarded as I kept reading.
I started to be concerned that this was more Elizabeth’s story than it was the character in the book. It turned out to be partially true.. You could tell from her emotional and heartfelt telling of the story.
I absolutely loved the characters Henry and Paige. I loved the way they put Christianity under a microscope and asked all the right questions. It was raw and honest. The author supplied truthful, honest, and thoughtful answers.
Kudos to Elizabeth Musser for writing it. She was very brave.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book from start to finish.
Joesphines story is a heart stopping book that leaves you thinking about this book long afterwared.
I didn't look at the blurb before choosing this book. I just seen the authors name like someone elsed and and I'm pretty sure that some in the future will choose this book for the same reason.
I have to admit I was shocked when I first opened this book and seen what the subject was about.
Elizabeth Musser can really write the best stories! It's clear she cares about her characters. I love to see how they cope with their situations so to speak.
This is a dark subject ( PTSD, depression, mental illness among many others) that isn't talked about in the Christian fiction world.
I feel that the author has pulled it off quite well. She's added some excellent supporting characters.
The only thing that I didn't like was how Josephines memories are written in present tense. So I had a little bit of a hard time following. Sort of made it dry and boring sorry.
Y'all just have to read this excellent book to find out and you will be shouting at the characters along with nail biting too.
I really recommend this book. This book might be a blessing and helpful to others.
My thanks to Netgalley. NO compensations were received. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was a riveting story line! I really was intrigued from the beginning of the first chapter to find out more about who shot Josephine. The author did a great job at developing the back stories of each character. Usually when an author writes in a memory, it’s a little bit dry and boring but Josephine‘a memories really added intensity and a bond with her as a main character. I would recommend this book to anyone dealing with depression.

Was this review helpful?

"When I Close My Eyes" is a Christian fiction with three point-of-view characters: Josephine, an author that struggles with depression, Henry, the assassin that came from an abusive background, and Paige, Josephine's teenage daughter. Since Josephine was in a coma from the assassination attempt, we mainly got her viewpoint through flashbacks of her life from 1968 up to the present.

Josephine wrote impactful novels showing people who dealt with difficult circumstances who found hope through forgiveness and trust in God. Henry began to read Josephine's books after his assassination attempt went wrong. Though there was some mystery about who hired Henry, the focus of the novel was more about if Josephine really believed in the grace that she wrote about since she struggled so deeply with depression. The main characters were complex, realistic people, and I cared about what happened to them.

There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this well-written book.

Was this review helpful?

"Faith and mental stability aren't mutually exclusive."

Wow. Can we just go back and read this quote from When I Close My Eyes by Elizabeth Musser again!? This is a message that I think is so very needed in the church today! As a Christian who struggles with mental illness, I know that there can be a true stigma within the Christian community about the issue. We so often hear that sadness or worry are not from God, and that if we only have a stronger faith, we can overcome these issues. That's a really harmful message for anyone dealing with anxiety and depression who already feel that that are falling short. What so many fail to hear is the illness part of that term: mental illness. Anxiety, depression, PTSD, etc are ILLNESSES. The symptoms may be different, but our attitude toward them should not be... we no more ask for depression than we ask for cancer... nor can we overcome it so easily with a change of attitude.

When I Close My Eyes speaks to that much needed message in such a beautiful way. It tells the fictional story of novelist Josephine Bourdillon, who has been a victim of an attempted assassination. She survives the attack, and the book tells the aftermath of this event through the eyes of Josephine, her daughter Paige and the shooter Henry. While there is some mystery as who hired Henry, and just what happened during 'The Awful Year', it is interesting that this book lets us know right from the start who the shooter is and into his thought process through the ordeal. It truly gives us a great sympathy for him and really brings home the idea of forgiveness and grace that are so important in this story.

As we go back and forth between each character, more and more details are revealed both about the current attack, and the details of Josephine's past and the events during 'The Awful Year'. It is a fantastic in depth look into the mind of someone who is dealing with depression. It is not a lighthearted read, dealing with mental health issues as well as discussion of suicide, but it is one that again is just so needed. For someone who deals with mental health issues of my own, I relate to Josephine's character so strongly, and love that the author truly wrote a character who was very strong in faith, despite her struggles. This is so true for so many Christians who are so often made to feel shame for the thoughts they cannot control. For those who have never dealt with depression, I really hope this book can be eye opening. It may be a work of fiction, but it is such a beautiful representation of that struggle and one that I hope others will take to heart. Despite the heavy nature of the book, it's actually quite an uplifting read with messages of grace and forgiveness.

This is one of the best books I've read this year, and one that I highly recommend.

**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley for consideration. All thoughts are 100% my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting book, though it took me a bit to get into it.

Musser's latest is full of secrets, love, mystery, and complicated family dynamics. The author tackles mental illness in a sensitive manner. Overall, themes of grace and forgiveness are woven throughout. She shows that Christians can also battle depression and PTSD, which is an area many authors shy away from. The story is a reminder that God's grace is truly enough.

Discussion questions make this a good option for book clubs.

Was this review helpful?

Oh, how I LOVED this book! Such a great storyline and an attempted murder that threw me off track as to who may have been behind it…exactly the kind of book I like to read. I love how the author tackled topics that are disturbing to some (mental illness, suicide) with such honesty and clarity.

The hired hitman was someone I didn’t want to like for obvious reasons, but I found myself having compassion for him. I have a deep respect for Paige with her continued interest in him and his family.

An outstanding novel by an outstanding author!

Was this review helpful?

Wow! It is hard to put into words just how amazing this book is! It kept me up until after 2:00 this morning finishing it. I find it hard to categorize it. When I Close My Eyes is a book of mystery, suspense, family dynamics, secrets, budding love, and mental illness. I was captivated from the opening scene and had difficulty putting it down to actually function in the real world. At its core Elizabeth Musser weaves a story of grace and forgiveness, not just of others but of oneself. She illustrates how even a person of faith can suffer through mental illness such as depression and suicidal thoughts. Her work helped me understand myself and others who have dealt with depression and struggled with guilt and how that affects how we view ourselves and our relationship with God. I can't recommend this book enough.

Was this review helpful?

I loved it and seriously couldn’t put it down because I wanted to know the whole story!! It is such an honest account of how mental illness can occur in the best of times and the worst of times.
Henry reminded me of so many children who I have known; coming from trauma but still hoping for something more. And the author’s story was a realistic account of how secrets never stay hidden.
“God’s Grace is sufficient” could be the title because that was certainly the overriding gift of this book! I fear that some might find this book “too spiritual” but the best way to fight darkness like depression is with God+medication+therapy+transparency, and I so appreciate Elizabeth’s candor in making that so real here!

Was this review helpful?