Cover Image: Minor Dramas & Other Catastrophes

Minor Dramas & Other Catastrophes

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I enjoyed both Where’d You Go Bernadette and Small Admissions, which, in the marketing copy, this book is compared to. It shouldn’t be. It does feature those insufferable helicopter parents that I don’t know personally but have read about. Maybe it’s because I’m not a parent myself and I grew up in the days that preceded Law and Order being on TV twenty-four hours a day on multiple channels, so my parents let my sister and me play outside all day and simply figured we’d show up at dinner when we got hungry. Their idea of interfering in our studies was taking us to the library every week so we could read all the books we wanted.

The students in this novel are all wonderful. The villains are the adults. Not just the parents, who were far worse than any character from the movie Mean Girls, but also some of the teachers and administrators who only want to not anger the parents—getting the students to actually think for themselves is obviously too subversive because then they might not agree with their parents on everything.

Maybe if I recognized parents like that, I would have liked the distinctive soap opera drama over things that were outstandingly trivial more, but this story line just didn’t quite do it for me.

Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book, which RELEASES FEBRUARY 4, 2020.

Was this review helpful?

This funny book totally skewers high school in the same way that Class Mom by Laurie Gelman shreds the elementary school experience. At Liston High, it's time for Julia Abbott's son to take a lead in the school play. After all, the Abbotts donated the costume shop. But Julia's interference causes a stir, especially when an incident with her at the school is filmed by a student and shared on every social media site there is. This, along with the "Marxist" leaning ways of teacher Isobel Johnson, sets into a motion an over-the-top romp that, while extreme, will be recognizable to those of us with high school-aged children. Minor Drama gives the term "helicopter parent" a whole new dimension. Social media plays an aggressive and realistic role in the story, a suitable warning for our times.

The novel succeeds on so many levels, but I particularly enjoyed how we dipped in and out of the perspectives of parents, the students, the teachers, and the administrators. It's a tremendous feat to have so many characters, and at no time was I confused about who was who, as each has his or her own voice. At times, you're rooting for different people, and it's not always clear who the "bad guy" is. The ending is absolutely satisfying. This was a really fun read, and I'm grateful to Netgalley for sharing the book with me.

Was this review helpful?

Kathleen West's upcoming novel, Minor Dramas and Other Catastrophes, tells the story of teachers, admin, parents and students at privileged Liston Heights High. The characters start as stereotypes -- the crazed theater mom with a not-terribly-talented son, the liberal English teacher, the naive and overworked new teacher, the dully officious admin, the teenage girl following her Feminism 101 checklist -- but soon the interlocking stories pull you in.

The setting is great, and while the characters are set in conflict with each other, pseudo-voluntary educational dumbfuckery is the real enemy here. It's not enough for teachers to teach well and be liked by students, they also need to make a certain number of positive phone calls to students' parents and be well-liked by helicopter mom brigade. It's not enough for students to go to class and do their homework, they also need to be busy filling their future college app with sports, arts and community service. And, not everyone can be the lead in the school play (or the captain of the sportsball thingy), and that's where high-strung helicopter moms come in. A college-prep high school is full of conflict and drama, and the story takes us through all different aspects.

There are too many moments when the characters are Just Too Much for me. The English teacher is just a little too amazing, and that made it hard to empathize with her. (All her lesson plans are tops and she has time to mentor a new teacher? Sounds fake, but ok.) Some of the backstories were way too much, so it felt less like a slice-of-life novel about real humans at a real school, and more like a morality play about the dangers of helicopter parenting and the stress of high school.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading about the differences in how different generations approach social media and how it has become such a big part of our lives and how we move in the world. The involved mom was a little over the top but I know people who are in a similar place.

Was this review helpful?

A humourous and interesting read, for fans of contemporary literature and issues. Set in suburban Minneapolis, "Minor Dramas & Other Catastrophes" by Kathleen West interweaves the stories surrounding teachers, parents and students at a high pressure college prep high school. AThe two main story lines revolve around liberal English teacher, Isobel Johnson, and helicopter parent Julia Abbott. Each becomes targeted within the community for poor dexicions and personality differences, and the ramifications ripple through their lives and those of their families, coworkers, and friends. An engaging read, will suit fans of Maria Semple and Jennifer Weiner.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this story took me back to the days when my children were in high school. As I watched Julia navigate and manipulate her way through her kids' high school years, my sense of doom just kept growing. No way was Julia going to be able to make it out of this one without some major burns. Kathleen West does an excellent job telling the (sometimes heartbreaking) stories of two very interesting women; one, a passionate high school English teacher who wholeheartedly believes in teaching her students of a private, competitive high school how to learn to see life from others' points of view, even though she can't seem to stop herself from judging others if they don't agree with her, and the other, a bright woman who is living her life through her childrens' triumphs, who is so heavily invested in their success that she has lost all sense of perspective and self-preservation.

MINOR DRAMAS... is a compelling read, because the characters are so relateable, and that's not necessarilya good thing. Well written, well developed characters, I was hooked from the very first page, and winced my way through the very end!

Was this review helpful?

I found this truly frightening , especially for teachers who must navigate this minefield every day. I'm hoping the author exaggerated for comic effect, but I'm inclined to think that this is the world we live in. Probably I'm in the wrong demographic.

Was this review helpful?

As a former classroom teacher AND parent, I can truly relate to both sides of the narrative. I wouldn't necessarily call myself a helicopter parent, but when you are a parent, you want only the best for your child - at all cost. I have to say I am truly glad I am no longer in the classroom or have a child in school I think it would be difficult to be in either situation, especially with society always having a microscope on teachers, but not truly appreciating the time, effort, and patience that goes into actually teaching.

Was this review helpful?

I must start by saying, BEEN THERE, DONE THAT! As a classroom teacher for many years, I felt West managed to capture the politics of teaching in today’s world. It is the story of the well-meaning, super teacher, Isobel Johnson who gets caught in the web of political manipulation of school administrators, parents and other teachers.

The main culprit is the parent of 2 of her students, a truly hideous helicopter parent. Julia Abbott managed to stir up a wasp’s nest of negative feelings toward Isabel because she felt jealous of her daughter’s admiration for her teacher.

All this cruelty and anger is broadcast to the school community by a FACEBOOK group, mysteriously full of details and accusations which almost ended in disaster for Isobel.

I really enjoyed this book. I am adding it to the reading list I give my student teachers. I hope to prepare them for the political intrigues of dealing with administrators, parents and colleagues.

Thank you Netgalley for allowing me to read this delicious book. I know that reading groups will enjoy discussing it and connecting it to their own experiences in schools.

Was this review helpful?