Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Huge 5 Stars! I absolutely loved this book, from page one to the very end. Here we learn about one of the greatest people of our past, The Queen Mum is so truly amazing. What a strong, brave, heroic person and one of the greatest influences of our time. From her came the beautiful Queen Elizabeth II and one merely has to know a little bit about the Queen to see her mother and the great influence her mother had on her life and her leadership. This story is filled with great detail to history, very accurate yet with a song-like flow that draws the reader in and reads nothing like a textbook. You will not be displeased with this tale at all, I would highly suggest this to anyone who loves history but also loves the Royal Family.

Was this review helpful?

“The Queen’s Secret” is a wonderful story about Queen Elizabeth, the current Queen’s mother. While fiction about the royal family is common and popular, I’ve rarely seen books with the Queen Mum as the main character, so I jumped at the chance to read this.

The story is told from the Queen’s perspective and in first person, so it feels like you are reading her diary or listening to her thoughts. The timeline focuses on the days leading up to and including WWII, with some flashbacks to her childhood and early life with the King. The “secret” actually refers to three that are actual rumors that have floated around the Queen Mum but are just that-rumors.

I will say this, at times it seemed that she was worrying about her “secrets” too much, but again, this book was written from her perspective, thoughts going through her brain. How many times have you worried about whether or not you wore the wrong shoes? She was worrying about not being the perfect QUEEN for her husband and the EMPIRE during a war. Perspective people.

Look, this isn’t a hard hitting true to life book. This is a fictional story. I love historical fiction, especially this era, but I felt over saturated recently and hadn’t read any WWII books in a bit. Maybe this was the easy to read, quick, not so serious read I needed at this time.

I’m excited to read more from Ms. Harper! I have the American Duchess on my shelf!

Thank you to NetGalley, the publishers and the author for a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was only okay to me. I finished it, I didn’t have a desire to not finish, I just kept hoping it would get better and it didn’t. I didn’t care for the way the queen was portrayed, I think she was a far more intelligent woman than the book make her out to be. While I understand this is fiction, and I’m normally a huge historical fiction fan, this book missed the mark for me. I love historical fiction based on fact that makes me want to go out an learn more about a particular subject, this book was based on gossip and made the queen mum out to be a self centered, man crazy, shallow human.

Was this review helpful?

The Queen has a secret she keeps close
Even from the people she loves the most
Her beloved England is at war
With the Germans across the shore
But Elizabeth is a mighty queen
The neck that turns the king unseen
What Hitler calls her brings her hope
“the most dangerous woman in Europe”
A glance inside the royal family
That reigned through a tumultuous part of history

This was an easy historical read. Heavy on detail and quite in-depth. It’s not a page-turner, but you are dropped right into that part of history. It’s easy to get wrapped up in that time period and feel like you are right there with Her Majesty. Although not necessary to enjoy the story, it would definitely enhance the reading experience to have a better working knowledge of the royal family and their associates. I did take issue with the varying “reveals.” They were a bit on the repetitive side and didn’t pack near the punch they thought they did.

Was this review helpful?

The author, Karen Harper, seems to be a popular one, and since I loved the Crown series on Netflix, I was hoping that this book would be enjoyable.

However, I have mixed feelings about the book. While I know it’s fiction, some of the information in it came up so often that I couldn’t help but Google it. It appears there are rumors that Queen Elizabeth, the Queen mother, did date Bertie’s brother who abdicated the throne for Wallis. This theme overrides so much of the book with Elizabeth’s continued obsession with him and Wallis, that at times it was irritating. I won’t give away the secret; it isn’t until around the three-quarter mark that it is revealed; although, it is hinted at throughout. .

Okay, so it’s a fiction book, and the rest of the book about England’s part in the war with Hitler was interesting. I came away from this, not liking Elizabeth very much. The book portrays her as a good leader, who was overly concerned with peoples opinions and going to extreme lengths to hide things in her past. Perhaps, I would have liked the real Elizabeth better than the fictional one.

Was this review helpful?

The Queen's Secret by Karen Harper is likely a good read for Anglophiles and lovers of historical fiction. For me, this exploration into the life of The Queen Mother felt just a tad imbalanced in terms of focusing too much on the war years and in terms of leaning a bit heavy on the fiction.

Many thanks to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for a free copy of The Queen's Secret in exchange for an honest review.

Hitler once referred to her as the "most dangerous woman in Europe" and she was not afraid to hold her own with the likes of Prime Minister Winston Churchill, First Lady Elanor Roosevelt or General Dwight Eisenhower, after all she was the Queen Mother, Queen Elizabeth. She was strong raising two princesses and helping to lead a devastated country through a world war but internally she has been battling her own war to keep the secrets of her past buried.

I am a big fan of historical fiction and the WWII era novels and this was an intriguing one. Karen Harper brings a new perspective and insight into the genre. I liked learning more about the Queen Mother who was know to be a great support to King George during his reign, but also dealing with her own struggles. The characters are well written and is an enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

The Queen's Secret has some really good moments, but unfortunately did not keep my interest as much as I originally thought it would. I enjoyed the tender moments between the King and Queen and their relationships with their children. The details about World War II were especially interesting to me. The book fell short for me personally though, because I found the language formal and stiff, which despite understanding the setting and time period, I still found cumbersome. There were also times that the mention of the "secrets" seemed repetitive rather than exciting or intriguing. Overall, I welcomed the unique opportunity to read something from the Queen Mother's perspective.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced e-copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoy all things British., so I was interesting in reading this book. It wasn't quite what I expected. Some parts were well done, but other parts were gossipy, and from other things I've read, I question that this was based on fact. I enjoyed the writing itself, but it was more fictionalized than I was expecting. Some parts were quite repetitious, too, which caused the pace to slow, and even drag, at times.

Was this review helpful?

I guess I went into this book thinking it would be an exhilarating read, but it turned out to be just.. dry. Long and dry and I found myself quite bored, putting it down for days at a time, struggling to pick it back up. As a self-proclaimed Royals obsessive, I was very excited by this book description, but it just didn’t appeal to me like I was hoping and expecting it would. Overall, just an “okay” book... nothing special.

Was this review helpful?

The Queen's Secret by Karen Harper is a story about the “Queen Mother”. She was Queen Elizabeth Angela Marguerite Bowes-Lyon. She was married to King Albert "Bertie" who became King when his brother abdicated. We meet the Queen at the height of her reign, against the backdrop of World War II.

The book portrayed the “Queen Mother” as a spurned woman who plotted out revenge in a spectacular way. The dialogue was on repeat 'poor Bertie', 'harlot woman', and 'mean David'. It was incredibly repetitive. It was an exhausting read every time the Queen thought about her “secret”. This novel, at it’s best, could be considered light historical fiction. It seemed more like 'chick-lit'. At its core the story is a long drawn out rehashing of why Queen Elizabeth Bowes- Lyon detested former King Edward who gave up the throne to be with Wallis Simpson. King Edward was known as David the Duke of Windsor to the royal family.

It seemed like it took me an abnormally long time to read considering it had less than 350 pages. I am a huge historical fiction fan especially during WWII, as well as, a “Royal” fan. Unfortunately this book left me disappointed on both counts.

I would like to thank the publisher, author and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to be an early reader for the The Queen's Secret by Karen Harper. Unfortunately, I was not able to connect with the story or the writing.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored this book, and the audio is fantastic. This is an important piece of history, told from the perspective of Queen Elizabeth's mother (then queen of England during WWII). She was quite the powerful force for the British monarchy, and this book gave glimpses into her personality. I look forward to recommending this book to others!

Was this review helpful?

A novel by #Karen Harper filled with intrigue and royal secrets.Hitler himself calls her the “Most Dangerous Woman in Europe.”For behind that soft voice and kindly demeanor is a will of steel.
Thank you#Harper Collins,#Netgalley and #Karen Harper

Was this review helpful?

I LOVE pretty much any book relating to WWII and the British Royals have always captured my attention so I assumed a book about Queen Elizabeth and WWII would absolutely be up my alley.

I was wrong.

I wanted to love this book but it was an absolute slog to get through. It's very repetitive, slow and not remotely engaging.

Unfortunately this wasn't for me.

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins for an eARC copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Fans of “The Crown” and the Royal Family will love this tale featuring the Queen Mother herself, Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon.

Even members of the Royal Family have secrets in their closets. Queen Elizabeth is of no exception. This story takes place during WWII and sheds light on her Majesty’s role as the voice of reason for both the King and the PM Winston Churchill. Her strength, compassion and wisdom help guide their kingdom through perilous times. But, in the back of her mind...Elizabeth harbors secrets about a previous relationship and her heritage. She spends much of the story debating sharing these secrets with her husband and why she insisted on certain marital stipulations.

What I love most about this story is the fact that we get a chance to experience WWII through a completely different set of eyes...Queen Elizabeth’s. She is able to not only rub elbows with world leaders but also find a way to relate to the people of her country. It’s just a captivating tale and I couldn’t put it down!

My only complaint is that because my copy was an unedited ARC, thanks NetGalley, no authors notes were included. With any historical fiction....I think the authors notes are an extremely important part of the book. So I will definitely be getting a hold of a published version so that I can read those notes!

Highly recommend!!

Was this review helpful?

Queen Elizabeth (more commonly known as the Queen Mother as she's the current Queen Elizabeth's mother) sounded like an interesting and not too overdone topic for a historical fiction novel. It is was- mostly. This book covered her life as Queen during WWII and her interactions and motivations were interesting except they were constantly dwelling on two of her biggest secrets. It was very heavy handed in this area and it made it seem like the author didn't think the reader could remember a major plot point for more than ten pages. OK, but could have been better. I did really enjoy Harper's previous book The Royal Nanny, which I think succeeded in being a lesser known topic and better edited.

Thank you to Netgalley for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book this story was about Queen Elizabeth (Queen Elizabeth II's mother.) This is a great storyline it tells mostly of her trials being married to the king during World War II and how she has to deal with some family issues that she keeps to herself but it also deals with the Royal family and the exile of Edward VIII and Wallis Simpson.
Another Great Read by Karen Harper. She never disappoints.
#TheQueensSecret #NetGalley

These opinions are my own and I received an ARC via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 67%. I just couldn’t finish this. The book *begins* by telling us the queen’s big secret—that she and her younger brother were actually the biological child of her father and the kitchen maid. While presented as true in the (fictional) book, in reality it seems this is actually a grossly unsubstantiated rumor from one source, The Queen Mother: The Untold Story of Elizabeth Bowes Lyon, Who Became Queen Elizabeth The Queen Mother. Other “secrets” spill in the next few chapters, including that the king and queen were celibate and that our narrator absolutely hate the Duke and Duchess of Windsor—especially the Duke because of “what he did to her” and “how he humiliated her.” At 67% I still hadn’t gotten to where this was discussed, but I was so tired of it being hinted at.

The best part of this book was the scenes of life for the king and queen during WWII. I think I would have found that enjoyable enough to continue usually, but I just don’t want to right now during the COVID-19 pandemic. I have enough drama in my real life thanks!

Was this review helpful?

A historical fictionalized account of the life of Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother.

As a young woman, Elizabeth never assumes her path will lead to her being queen. As the wife of the second son of the reigning king, the possibilities of her husband ascending the throne are quite low, until Edward VIII abdicates to marry Wallis Simpson.

Thrust into the palace with little preparation, Elizabeth needed to support her husband, the new King George VI and protect her own daughter, the new heir. Working tirelessly behind the scenes during WW2, she forms alliances with Churchill and the Americans, in order to banish the former king and his spouse from England, and become a co-leader to the people of England.

I have always enjoyed the history of the British Royal family, especially stories of the current Windsors. With much being written about Queen Elizabeth II, it's wonderful to read a take on the Queen Mum instead. Even the WW2 timeline takes a backseat to the relationships between the main characters, allowing the story itself to overshadow the wartime setting.

Was this review helpful?