I hadn’t read the previous books in the series and so didn’t know what to expect, but this was a surprisingly good read. For a nerdy, book-loving, sci-fi fan this book hits all the marks. Now I need to read the others!

I love Ashley! I love everything she writes. This was lived up to my expectations. I love how inclusive she is and her writing style. I cannot wait until it comes out, it needs to sit on my shelf.

I thoroughly enjoyed this read, but there were a few things that made this not quite as good as the other two volumes in the series. Namely, there were too many nerd references. As a nerd, I approve of fandoms and nerding out. But I also want it as realistic. There were parts in this, especially in the beginning, where things Rosie, her friends, or her dad would say would feel forced. Rosie tells her dad
"I love you 3000" as she runs out the door, and merely sentences before there was another reference to a whole other fandom. There was even a super unsubtle nod to Sarah J. Maas's Throne of Glass series in the form of a "giant gold tome" that was described as "trashy fantasy." The amount of time spent on this one inconsequential thing made all of the other moments before it ridiculous. Near the middle, the story tones it down and focuses less on homages to every nerd thing ever and instead the plot.

Rosie is a likable character. She's suffering a lose, and yet it doesn't define her. It's a part of her, but it's not her whole character, unlike what characters like Garrett assume. She's funny and quirky and has a good heart, even if she feels generic YA protagonist at times.

Her friends were so supportive--the boom box scene was straight from every romcom ever, but I loved it to bits--and they also provided immense comic relief.

Vance was a mess. My favorite part about this story was how both he, Rosie, and the reader never once is led on to the "oh he's a bad boy but he has a rough past" idea. He was a bad boy because he did it himself, and despite being a pain in the rear to Rosie, both Rosie and Imogen (from Fangirl) taught him what friendship was as well as the fact people could like you for who you are despite your fame. He grew in this, not that it was a shock to anyone, but it was a good progression and showcased how much he understood he had been awful to people, and himself, in the past.

The plot was cute, and I loved how everything tied in at the end. I knew it would happen because these are nerdy fluff books, but it's so satisfying when it does happen. I genuinely don't know how Aashley Poston does this because I can't stand contemporary, but here I am obsessed with this series. It's a cute continuation to Once Upon a Con, and it's perfectly comedic and heartfelt.

This wasn't a bad book by any means, but it was just incredibly disappointing for me. I just did not get the relationship between the leads in any way, why they were drawn to each other in the first place, why they allegedly had issues with each other, it just did not work for me. I was way more interested in the potential romance between two minor characters than Vance and Rosie, and that's a huge problem. I really don't have anything else to say because their relationship was so much of the book.

I LOVED THIS SO MUCH.

Bookish & the Beast is officially my favorite Once Upon A Con book. I cannot WAIT to buy it, and add it to my collection, and pour over it again when it gets published in June!

Ashley does a fantastic job of taking the Beauty and the Beast plot we all know and reinventing it in smart ways that work, including character origins. I especially think that using Vance's status as a Hollywood heir works perfectly to match the original tale of a prince cursed and cast away! Bookish is also full of references to make any media consumer smile - from fandom to books to dating sims and a particularly wonderful Howl's Moving Castle reference.

Also, this book - and all the books in the series! - feature a diverse and wonderful cast of characters. Come for the fairy tale retelling, but stay for the hijinks and laughter and swoon-worthy romance! I can't wait to see this published and to get my hands on her next book! 🥰

Also, thanks to Netgalley and Quirk Books for providing me access to an e-ARC of this for consumption and review!