Cover Image: Her Darkest Hour

Her Darkest Hour

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Wasn't a fan of the book. I love historical fiction but this seemed more like a soap opera than a book about WWII. The characters were my least favorite part of the book. Pretty much I hated all of them, most of all Marie-Claire. There were so many characters between all the siblings, but Victoire and Marie-Claire were the only two the reader really got to know. We got a glimpse of Jacques and Juliette, but not enough. Lucien and Leon were just the brothers who ended up fighting for the French and then the Germans. They had no backstory. Pretty much everyone complained throughout the whole book. Victoria whined about being a girl and not being able to do what the boys were doing. Then there was Marie-Claire. I can't find one good thing about her. Her views about jewish people and how they should have left the town when they were supposed to, so it's there on fault for being arrested. She was so shallow and did the exact opposite of what everyone told her. She blamed everyone for the mistakes she made. She had no redeeming qualities. She tried to seduce a son and then his father. Then gets mad because a boy shows her sister attention. Marie-Claire was completely unlikeable. When the war was over, I don't think Marie-Claire would be welcomed back home by the townspeople. There seemed like there was so much missing from the book. I have so many questions about - the absent father living in Paris, the family hiding Jews, Margaux and Max dropping their secret to Victoire without much explanation.

I did not know that the Germans made the people of Alsace change their names to something German. That was one interesting fact I learned. I loved the cover of the book.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bookouture through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

A tragic story of the danger and struggle to survive the horrors of war. A time to live with brave hearts, A time to die for the greater good. A time to cry for unbearable loss.

Was this review helpful?

Marie-Claire a flirtatious young woman from Alsace, France is forced to marry Kurtz, who has raped her. Kurtz is a Nazi commander in charge of one of the most brutal labor/ concentration camps in France, Natzweiler-Struthof. This is the story of her family and her sister Victoire and their interactions with the Nazi’s. There is an intriguing plot regarding family relationships as a side line. This was a great historical novel with interesting characters. The story is narrated by Marie-Claire and Victoire.

Was this review helpful?

First I would like to thank Netgalley and the author for an advanced copy in return for my honest review.

I have read a lot of WW2 era fiction so I was pretty excited to read this story. The synopsis grabbed me and I was all in. Let me start with the characters first. They lacked personality and depth. Not a single one of them was likable, not even Victoire, who I am assuming was suppose to be the sweetheart of the story. I couldn’t get past her whiny “I’m just a girl and they won’t let me do anything blah blah blah” whoa is me schtick. Throughout the book her character doesn’t “grow” despite aging. The author has her attend nursing school but so vaguely touches on each topic in the story that you never get a sense of feeling for anything each character does. Then there is the other sister, Marie Claire, shallow as a crepe pan, which is used to describe her no less than five times throughout the book. It’s accurate though if nothing else. There is nothing to like about this character, she is materialistic, a brat, a betrayer and yes shallow. If that’s how the author wanted her to be seen as then bravo, nailed it.
So many other things bothered me about this book as well such as the brothers that suddenly get released as POW by the Germans without a back story or explanation. That made no sense whatsoever. That would have never happened back then. I get that it is fiction but at least provide some plausible explanation such as they escaped. Then we have the story of the mother and the neighbor, Juliette, the absent father in Paris....what is that about?

Overall I don’t think the description of the book properly describes the book itself. It really wasn’t about Victoire and Marie Claire’s relationship until the last 10% of the book.

Was this review helpful?

It's a beautifully descriptive read that made me feel as if I was standing on the sideline watching the story play out until the end which was just a bit rushed so hopefully there will be a sequel to finish the story. I did enjoy reading it and I would like to thank the publishers and netgalley for letting me have the book to review and the opinions expressed are entirely my own views and are completely unbiased.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Sharon Maas, Bookouture and NetGalley for this ARC.

I love historical fiction, and I really enjoyed this. It's my first novel by Sarah Maas, and it definitely won't be my last. The story is beautifully written, and I love how some of the chapters are told by different characters. I really liked Victoire's character, and thought it played nicely against the vapid, at times annoying character of Marie-Claire. The ending was a nice surprise, but I thought there could've been a little more expansion on that ending.

Overall, this was a great book that tells the story of how one French town was affected by the horrors of WWII.

Was this review helpful?

Historical fiction takes many different routes to get you to the end.  This book is more of a tear jerker than any of the others I have read.


It is hard to put into words this type of book because it affects everyone differently.  I must say though it was very well written. It left a warm feeling playing over my entire body when reading this book.


This type of book is why I read.  The writing and characters were simply put great.  The pace was excellent and i really like how there isn't a lot of unneeded information.


It shows such great depth as this author writes so much in historical fiction and all so completely different from each other

Was this review helpful?

WW II era historical fiction is one of my favourite genres of fiction so I was excited to read this.

The first few pages were so wordy. Overly flowery and descriptive. I actually thought "where was the editor to make this more concise?" at one point. I remembered that I was reading an ARC (advanced reader copy) and I decided to keep reading. I am glad I did. The writing suddenly changed and the book started to flow.

I have not read any other books by this author but it seems some of her characters appear in her other books. Perhaps that would make them more likable (especially Jacques). I really enjoyed most of the characters but I felt that they could have been better developed for sure.

I read why the author left out most of the details about the work camp and did not situate any of her story there. I can respect that but I would have liked more backstory on Marie Claire's husband's involvement. Yes he was a villain and we found out a few details about what was happening at that camp but I wanted more.

I finished the book feeling unsatisfied. It seemed to have a lot of detail in the first half of the book and the last few years seemed rushed to me. I liked the story but never really connected with the characters. The only exception being Victorie..

Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for the advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this novel, with its wonderful cast of characters and gorgeous prose. The storyline was engaging and flowed seamlessly.
Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

I would like to begin by thanking NetGalley, Bookouture and the author Sharon Maas for the opportunity to read this book. I have read numerous books centred on WWII and it was refreshing to read one that was centred on one city, giving me insight on how the war affected Alsace. I did not know how much Alsace suffered during WWI and how they had been forced to become German instead of French. To lose your identity not only once but yet again during WWII must have been horrible. I found many of the characters in this book difficult to like. Marie-Claire appeared to be shallow in the beginning but her character didn’t seem believable as the book wore on, she couldn’t have been that shallow to not believe or recognize the harm the Nazis were doing. Further on she became more realistic but I found the author didn’t go in-depth enough with her or describe her well enough to make me feel for her. Jacques was also another character that seemed noble but was, in reality, an uncaring man. The characters simply lacked depth and I couldn’t feel for them. The book seemed to jump from one event to another without giving anything the proper closure. In my opinion it seemed that the author had a list of events she wanted to include in the book and shoved them in without blending it. Jumping though two years was another point that bothered me. I feel if each chapter simply went from one character to another it workday have made a better book. The idea was great but the follow through was not there. When I read a book I want to feel for the characters, I want to be able to place myself there and I couldn’t with this book.

Was this review helpful?

I adore, admire and look up to this author. She is one of my absolute favourite writers - I read anything and everything she writes and needless to say she never disappoints. I know I always say this with every one of her books that I read and I always mean it but this is definitely her best book yet. Beautiful and powerful, heartbreaking and empowering. Just amazing. Very few authors have the ability to tell a wonderful story as well as teach you something but with Sharon's books I always come away having learned so much. Especially hard to do when there are so many war stories and documentaries out there but Sharon does it effortlessly and with aplomb telling a stunning story and relaying a powerful message. Everyone needs to read this book now more than ever. If you are going to read one book during these strange extraordinary times we are all living through make it this one.

Was this review helpful?