Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I absolutely LOVED this book! Archaeology has always fascinated me, and after spending some time on a dig in Israel, I could not pass up this book when it came around.

Jerusalem has always had a varied past, and this book brings about the different religions that make up the center of Jerusalem, and the many controversies that have surrounded some of the digs that have gone on.

Andrew Lawler brings a delicious history of the times, excavations, and unrest that has run through the streets of Jerusalem, and sheds more light on the different areas of controversy.

An absolute must-read for history lovers! You will not be disappointed at all!

Was this review helpful?

Andrew Lawler brings a beautifully researched account of the excavations of the city of Jerusalem in the 19th and early 20th centuries. These were the days before archaeology was a precise science and more of an adventure excursion. He takes us on the quest for the Ark of the Covenant by these amateur adventurers and how their digs created an international crisis.

I can't help but point readers to the superb article in the current Smithsonian Magazine about this book by its author.

Was this review helpful?

Considering how many various powers have held sway over Jerusalem through the centuries and how many of its historical buildings have become mishmashed structures built with and on top the ruins of others, it shouldn’t be that much of a surprise that the history of archaeological digs beneath it’s Old City is a messy one, to put it kindly. What may be a surprise however is the extent to just how absurdly complex and fraught it is. Since the mid-1800’s, the city has been host to an almost dizzyingly long and eclectic line of different foreign and local figures, organizations, and governments scraping around and under its ruins and holy sites. Just as varied as the men and women doing all the digging have been their respective motivations and agendas, and almost as diverse are the many controversies that have erupted in their wake.

So such is why I give Andrew Lawler enthusiastic kudos for what he has accomplished with his latest title, “Under Jerusalem.” It feels like he did an incredible amount of work to wrangle his complicated and volatile subject material into something digestible for the everyday reader, all while striving to be as objective as he could. At least, that seems to be the only explanation given the final result - a book that is accessible, almost shockingly fair given the topic, and last but not least, quite the fascinating read.

Was this review helpful?

I found this to be a very interesting book, a little hard to keep turning the pages at first. But the more I read the more I wanted to know. . Having visited Jerusalem myself, I found that by the time I finished this book I actually enjoyed reading it,

Was this review helpful?