Member Review
Review by
Kimberly H, Reviewer
I don’t even know where to start with this book… I had high hopes for it based on the description, but I didn’t think it would go so far beyond my expectations. It was one of the rare books where I didn’t want it to end; it could have been twice as long and I still would have devoured it in just one sitting. As it was, I started and finished in less than a day.
Lanie Bloom is living her dream - she’s engaged to the man that checks off every one of the 99 items on The List and she loves her job as a senior editor at Peony Press, assisting in the editing the books by her favorite author Noa Callaway, the famously recluse author who never makes appearances or takes interviews. The books that got her both the job and the man. The first book by Noa that she read changed her life: she changed her major from premed in hopes of working for Noa’s publisher, and prompted her the write the lists of 99 items to look for in her one true love, who she eventually meets. But when she’s offered to opportunity to become his editor and meet the woman behind the name, she’s shocked to realize the picture of an older woman she has in her head couldn’t be more wrong. The author that she needs to squeeze a four-month overdue manuscript out of is in fact a very attractive man her own age, Noah Ross. Shocked to finally put a face to name she’s been rather intimately corresponding with for the last seven years, they are immediately at odds with each other. But the time that Lanie begins spending with Noah in the interest of curing his writer’s block and deliver his new book on time, the more the tension threatens to upset the balance between their professional obligations and desires.
In short, I loved this book. It’s the very definition of a slow burn romance - they didn’t come together until later the last page, and as much as I didn’t think I’d enjoy an - [ ] open ending, I like how you can decide how their story goes from here. There’s a little bit of a warning in there about meeting your idols, because Lanie’s hung so many of her values and aspirations on Noa’s books, and it required so many recalculations on her part when she met him as Noah because what she thought she wanted in love was tied up how she saw her mom in Noah the author instead of Noah the man. Once they met and she was able to reconcile the two identities in her mind, the tension and chemistry between them was palpable, from the sparks of lightning at their first meeting as Lanie and Noah but also the rapport they had via email for 7 years as author and editor. I felt like the tension was able to build so naturally because for two people who are normally so good with words they have a hard time finding the right words between them to express how they felt. Lanie felt a kinship and attraction to Noah that she was uncomfortable with, but Noah clearly loved her from far for long before they met.
For a book that felt like a very fast read, there was a lot of details woven into the story that gave a lot more depth that you’d usually find in a more more lengthy verbose book. It was heartwarming and funny. This book gave me Beach Read vibes, but if you like any books by Emily Henry or Sarah Jio, you’ll love By Any Other Name! Thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Publishing Group/G.P. Putnam's Sons for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
Lanie Bloom is living her dream - she’s engaged to the man that checks off every one of the 99 items on The List and she loves her job as a senior editor at Peony Press, assisting in the editing the books by her favorite author Noa Callaway, the famously recluse author who never makes appearances or takes interviews. The books that got her both the job and the man. The first book by Noa that she read changed her life: she changed her major from premed in hopes of working for Noa’s publisher, and prompted her the write the lists of 99 items to look for in her one true love, who she eventually meets. But when she’s offered to opportunity to become his editor and meet the woman behind the name, she’s shocked to realize the picture of an older woman she has in her head couldn’t be more wrong. The author that she needs to squeeze a four-month overdue manuscript out of is in fact a very attractive man her own age, Noah Ross. Shocked to finally put a face to name she’s been rather intimately corresponding with for the last seven years, they are immediately at odds with each other. But the time that Lanie begins spending with Noah in the interest of curing his writer’s block and deliver his new book on time, the more the tension threatens to upset the balance between their professional obligations and desires.
In short, I loved this book. It’s the very definition of a slow burn romance - they didn’t come together until later the last page, and as much as I didn’t think I’d enjoy an - [ ] open ending, I like how you can decide how their story goes from here. There’s a little bit of a warning in there about meeting your idols, because Lanie’s hung so many of her values and aspirations on Noa’s books, and it required so many recalculations on her part when she met him as Noah because what she thought she wanted in love was tied up how she saw her mom in Noah the author instead of Noah the man. Once they met and she was able to reconcile the two identities in her mind, the tension and chemistry between them was palpable, from the sparks of lightning at their first meeting as Lanie and Noah but also the rapport they had via email for 7 years as author and editor. I felt like the tension was able to build so naturally because for two people who are normally so good with words they have a hard time finding the right words between them to express how they felt. Lanie felt a kinship and attraction to Noah that she was uncomfortable with, but Noah clearly loved her from far for long before they met.
For a book that felt like a very fast read, there was a lot of details woven into the story that gave a lot more depth that you’d usually find in a more more lengthy verbose book. It was heartwarming and funny. This book gave me Beach Read vibes, but if you like any books by Emily Henry or Sarah Jio, you’ll love By Any Other Name! Thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Publishing Group/G.P. Putnam's Sons for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.