Realistically bringing to life the struggles faced by the vanishing colonists of Roanoke.

I liked that this novel draws heavily upon what little is known about the disappearance sticking as close to known facts while weaving a riveting plot. I was very intrigued by Roanoke as a preteen, so it was a no brainer to add to my TBR. In a way though, maybe knowing so much of the history made the first portion of the book more predictable for me. I liked Elinor, she is determined and practical, with a big heart for others. I like how she doesn't give in to bitterness and holds to her faith, not shying away from the hard questions.

Overall, a well written read with well built characters. I loved the different perspectives explored in this book, especially Sees Far. Well worth the read, and I thought that it did a good job of realistically bringing the story to life along with the heartaches and struggle to hope.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

The Lost Colony of Roanoke is one that has always fascinated me. What did happen to those colonists? Why did they just disappear? Will we ever know? My own imagination has often run wild with ideas, so when I read the synopsis of this book, I knew I had to read it. I was genuinely curious to see where McNear would take the story.

The first half of the book is a lot of build up and is meant to leave the reader in suspense and wondering where the author is going to take the story. And I do have to say, the build up was well worth it. The further I read, the more on the edge of the seat I was. I couldn't help but to continue turning the pages.

It is clear that McNear did her research, not just due to her historical notes, but just within the novel. There is so much that I did not know about the colony, and it is clear that she wanted to be as accurate and true to the historical events as much as she could be.

Overall, if you are someone who loves history and Christian fiction, I would recommend this book. It is intriguing, with vivid characters, and a strong Christian message.

I had received a complimentary copy of this book through Netgalley and all opinions expressed are my own.

Elinor by Shannon McNear is based on the story of the Lost Colony of Roanoke. Pregnant Elinor and her husband Ananias Dare travel from London to America in the late 1500s. Her father John White is the governor of Virginia. This is a very well written account of a fascinating mystery from history. The author pulls the reader into the story and I couldn't put it down from about 60% to the end. We don't know what really happened to these people, but I love the ending the author created. As can be expected, there is some violence, especially between the colonists and native people but no language or sexual content. In addition, the historical note at the end contains interesting information from the author's research and is worth reading. I look forward to reading more by this author. Thanks to NetGalley for a temporary digital copy to use for my review.

Elinor by author Shannon McNear is a captivating Christian historical fiction. It is based on events from history with fictional fillers. This provided a stunning tale of what might have happened to the Roanoke Colony. I was immediately invested and could not put this novel down.

The author takes readers back in time to 1587 and introduces us to historical Elinor White Dare. She is the daughter of John White, the governor of the new colony. This is a character that I would love to have as a friend. She is strong, dedicated, faithful, and caring. Her husband, father, and other colonists were well described and relatable. Their conversations sounded smooth and authentic. The author displays a creative imagination and pleasant style of writing. She kept me engaged throughout the entire story.

Research done on this project is obvious by the many details. I learned so much about the customs, land, history, and even folklore. Books that teach me things and have a Christian message are my favorites. Elinor checked both of those boxes.

I highly recommend this poignant tale. It remains in my thoughts even though I finished reading it days ago. Be sure to read the Author’s Notes at the end. There the author explains what is fact, what she used for inspiration, and what fictional elements she used. Book Clubs that enjoy historical books based on truth will have much to discuss. I rate this 5 stars. A copy was provided by Celebrate Lit but these are my honest words.

Shannon McNear transports readers to 1587 with imagery and language of the time. Elinor will delight historical fiction readers who appreciate soaking up history through story.

Before reading this book, I had never heard of The Lost Colony of Roanoke. After reading it (and the author’s note at the end), I did some more digging because McNear put faces to this piece of American history and drew me into her story.

This story isn’t always easy as the author did her best to stay true to the time and the fragile relationship between the English people sailing to America and the indigenous people. There were moments in this story that made me gasp because they came as a shock but then there were times of understanding and hope.

It’s the characters (namely the title character) that makes Elinor a read that I will not soon forget.

Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.

What really happened to the “Lost Colony” of Roanoke? Author Shannon McNear postulates an answer in an emotional, suspenseful tale that is sure to intrigue history buffs.
John White is the “older” governor of the Roanoke colony, trying valiantly to lead his small, capricious group of settlers to peace and safety in the New World. When he returns to England to beg for monies and supplies from the queen, the colonists are left with one loyal Native American friend, but many Native American enemies, often because of the white man’s previous dealings.
We follow the saga of Elinor Dare, John White’s daughter. Elinor is also Virginia Dare’s mother. Sometimes I almost forgot to breathe, the suspense is so great. Happiness, fear, anger, puzzlement, and hope are all emotions McNear’s characters experience throughout the novel, and McNear skillfully maneuvered my emotions along with them. Trust, anger, cultural differences, and hope amid heartache are all themes McNear explores in her meticulously researched book.
My favorite character is Sees Far. He is often unpredictable. He is drawn to Elinor, yet can’t decide how to treat her. His culture and his manhood in the tribe insist he act in ways not compatible with his early vision.
I found the novel harder to read than usual, as McNear prefers to use language as close to the times portrayed as possible. While authentic, it slowed my understanding down.
Research is near and dear to McNear’s heart. She has done her homework, many times over. In her exuberance, the author's notes get a little drawn out for my taste.
I received a copy of the book from the author and publisher through Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own. (I also purchased paperbacks for myself and a treasured friend.)

Shannon McNear is a writing powerhouse. Every topic she takes on turns to gold. Elinor is no exception. This is a richly deep text where every line feels heavy with historical detail and care. The attention to detail in this novel is magnificent. It is exceptionally clear that Ms. McNear did her homework for this book. As a reader who loves to continue to learn in my older age, I appreciate Elinor because I feel like it is the best kind of history book — the interesting kind! The settings are so beautifully defined and illustrated I felt like I was with Elinor, Ananias, and John the whole time. As far as characters go, Elinor, Ananias, and John are superbly crafted. My heart went out to these characters SO many times during the reading of this story. I also appreciate how well written the Native Americans are, too. I like how McNear illustrates the vast differences between the two peoples, but simultaneously shows how similar we all are regardless of skin color and circumstances. It is a universal truth that most humans regardless of who they are just want the simple things: a place to belong, sustenance, and love and acceptance. As far as adventure goes, Elinor is non-stop. This book is definitely a story the reader won’t want to put down until the final page is read. All in all, Elinor is a must-read Historical Fiction story that you will not want to miss.

As with all her novels, Elinor by Shannon McNear is another homerun. If you are a fan of well-written, well-researched, highly engaging Historical Fiction texts, then Elinor is definitely the book of you. Purchase yourself a copy of this amazing book today. You won’t be disappointed that you did!

I received a review copy of this novel in eBook form from the author, Shannon McNear, via Celebrate Lit in order to review. In no way has this influenced my review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.

A brilliant read, Elinor, struck a chord in me. It is rare that one reads such moving fiction. Although the scenes were cut short in the beginning, and in some cases hard to follow, I was thoroughly sucked in as the story moved on! Further on in the story, the switching between scenes was done brilliantly. I like Elinor's emotional and spiritual strength and Sees Far's curiosity and tender heart. The author did a brilliant job in keeping to the times of her story, both with the archaic English used, and the tone of voice and language. This is something that is very few authors who write outside of the contemporary manage to pull off well. This is the very first book I am reading by this author, but I do look forward to reading more volumes by her in the future. Kudos to her!

I loved the Daughters of the Mayflower series in which Shannon McNear wrote book #5, The Cumberland Bride and book #10, The Rebel Bride. I also love the True Colors series and am reading her title, The Blue Cloak. Shanon McNear is an automatic buy for me because I enjoy her writing style and am always engrossed in the stories she tells.

Elinor is a book I'll remember. It was heart-wrenching and life-encouraging. Elinor's life takes us on a journey of so many emotions.. How could one endure so much? As is her style, McNear doesn't allow us to constantly dwell in pity for Elinor, but lifted our spirits with hope and determination. At the center of it all is the truth that we must trust God.

If you love historical fiction, then you will love Elinor. The Lost Colony of Roanoke is a mystery to most and there is rich theoretical history to this book.

I received a digital book from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review and the opinions expressed are my own.

If you are interested in the Lost Colony of Roanoke, this book is for you. The Author did a good job with her research. This was my first time reading a book on this era. The book was well written. However, it went a little slow for me. I wanted more time for the characters to develop. I give this book two stars. It wasn't so bad, but I guess towards the end it fell a bit flat for me.

Thank you to Barbour Publishing for allowing me to give an honest review of this book.

Shannon McNear has done her research and has given us a interesting tale, blending historical fact with speculation. Elinor is a blend of actual historical knowledge about the Lost Colony of Roanoke with well written fictional narrative.

This book combines faith, fear, mystery, and suspense to bring the late 1500s in the American colonies to life. The author’s notes and glossary at the end were especially helpful in keeping track of the many characters, as well as understanding some of the indigenous language.

This was a good, although very slow, read.

Many thanks to Net Galley and Barbour Publishing for a copy of this book. The opinions are my own.

Interesting take on the story of Elinor Dare. Any books that notes historian Phil McMullan as contributor gets 5 stars from me.

Delve into the imaginings of the history of a lost colony. What happened to the colony at Roanoke? Shannon McNear expertly pens a possible story for this lost colony, bringing history to rich life. The anticipation of the colonists to arrive at their new home, eager to plant fields and revel in the room and freedom London could not provide. The treachery of sea Captains more interested in pay days and previous misdealings with native communities make each step harder than imagined. Elinor White Daring's father is a gifted artist who is entrusted with starting a new colony in Virginia. From the start things are do not go as planned, the Captain refuses to leave the colonists where they were originally planned to settle. The resulting location brings added danger with an enraged man who sees the new people as a danger that needs to be wiped out. There have been senseless killings and a strange disease that has wiped out his family and friends. Elinor's father is known to him and he holds him personally responsible. When John White has to return to England to report how things are progressing in the new colony, his heart is heavy to leave his only family. But an accurate report must be given in order to receive added resources from England. Once John returns, war with Spain is a constant threat that delays his return. With constant troubles he despairs ever reuniting with his daughter. Meanwhile Elinor and her family joins the other colonists in befriending the nearby native community, learning their language and gleaning help with planting in this new environment. But old angers remain and the colonists are constantly under threat. The most dreaded reality comes true with members of the colony stolen away and sold, death a constant companion. Will they be reunited, or is this the final fate of the Lost Colony?
Shannon McNear brings history to life, making you walk the same steps the early settlers walked. Her imaginings give an answer to the wondering of what may have happened to this colony. What if they found a safe community to befriend, shared their faith them, lived their lives in faith to what God called them to. McNear shows us that faith is not easy but with God in control, there is no reason to fear what may befall us. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

An interesting read. I generally don't like what if historical fiction. However when it ends up being a what if of something like the Lost Colony of Roanoke that we don't really know what
happened it tends to work and I enjoy it, because to me it's not changing history it's just giving another possible outcome.

I was very excited for this title. When I started reading, however, I realized the story was not as I expected and was not for me. The front cover claims this is a riveting tale. That description is far from truth in my opinion. The writing style is difficult to read and their are multiple POV, mostly from Elinor's father and husband. Nothing caught my interest long enough to hold it and encourage me to keep reading. I kept trying to force myself through this book based on other reviewers that have really enjoyed the story. This title may be for some, but is not for me. I have decided to DNF five chapters, 63 pages in and move onto other reads on my TBR.

Whatever happened to the Lost Colony of Roanoke?

Perhaps you’ve heard of this mysterious event.

Historical Context

The English first tried to establish a permanent settlement in America at Roanoke Island in 1585. When that failed, Governor John White returned with more colonists to try again in 1587.

The colonists thought they would be settling north of Roanoke but were forced to stay on Roanoke Island. John White returned to England to secure more supplies for the colonists, intending to return the following year.

However, the Anglo-Spanish War prevented him from returning until 1590. When he finally arrived back to the English settlement, it was abandoned with only one word— ‘Croatoan’— carved in a wooden post, indicating the nearby Native tribe they had relations with.

A storm and ship issues forced his crew to return to England before they were able to locate the missing hundred plus colonists.

No evidence has surfaced as to the fate of these colonists— did they willingly assimilate with the Native tribes? Were they massacred? Were they taken captive?

Artistic License

‘Elinor’ is Shannon McNear’s creation to explore what could have happened to this Lost Colony.

Elinor, the protagonist, is a historical figure— John White’s daughter— who birthed the first English child in the new land and named her Virginia Dare.

We follow Elinor’s experience as a new mother in a new land with new dangers. She endures and perseveres a variety of hardships— one that almost made me cry! We see her strength, resilience, and reliance on God through it all.

We often wonder— where is God in all of this?— and Elinor shares with us her resolve to trust God even when things seem to be going wrong.

I was impressed with all the research McNear did in order to write this book. We know little but she incorporated well what she could find, even including the language of the native tribes.

I had to keep reminding myself that it was a fictionalized account because it seemed so believable.

This is a Christian Fiction novel so she emphasizes the faith and evangelistic desire of the colonists. It is a driving part of the plot and resolution of the story. She acknowledges that we don’t know if the colony was that of Separatists or Puritans or something else so this was her own take.

Writing Style/Formatting

I was given access to an Advanced Reader’s Copy through NetGalley so my copy was not the final publication. I’m assuming my main problem will not be an issue in the finalized version.

McNear shifts from Elinor’s perspective to other characters quite often. However, in my version, these shifts were not indicated or set apart in any way. They ran together and the new character’s identity wouldn’t be revealed until a few sentences in. This made for some disjointed reading and frustration as I had to regularly reread things to recalibrate where I was at in the story and whose thoughts I was hearing.

She uses a lot of different vernacular— both Native words as well as period language from the English during that time.

I didn’t realize this until the end, but McNear includes a glossary at the back of the book as well as a cast of characters and other helpful resources. This is a little harder to regularly access in an e-book compared to flipping back quickly in a hardcover but it’s nice that she put it in.

I also appreciated the details she shares of which parts of her story were historical and which ones were imagined. It’s a fascinating part of history and I’m always curious about these type of ‘mysteries’!

Recommendation

Overall it was a unique historical fiction book. It was a bit slow going for me at first and some parts were a little boring, but about 60% in the plot really starts to thicken as a Native tribe ambushes their settlement and sets off a sequence of suspenseful events!

I liked McNear’s imagination and I liked the ending. Knowing we don’t know historically what happened to the colony created a little suspense in wondering which direction she was going to take the story.

If you enjoy Christian Fiction books, I think you’ll really like this one. If Christian Fiction isn’t really your jam, this might not be your favorite book, but the unique setting and reimagining of the Lost Colony of Roanoke still makes it worth reading— just be aware going in that it’s not a pulsing action-packed story.

We spent time in Virginia and North Carolina back in 2016 and I remember driving by the Roanoke area. Now I wish we had stopped and looked around! Guess we will have to go back!

**Received an ARC via NetGalley**

A deeply touching book about what may have been. The lost colony of Roanoke has triggered many theories and discussions over the years. Shannon McNear has done her research to pen such a poignant tale based on could have happened. Told through the eyes of Elinor Dare, the mother of Virginia Dare, the experiences become real and tangible. The highs and lows are pregnant with grief and joy. The descriptions are vivid and transport you to the same moments in time that these truly remarkable men and women experienced. If you enjoy early American historical fiction, you will delight in this book. It was not a light, easy read, but did move at a steady pace and held my attention from start to finish. I received a complimentary copy from the publisher via NetGalley and all opinions expressed are solely my own, freely given.

Elinor
by Shannon McNear

Synopsis:
"In 1587, Elinor White Dare sailed from England heavy with her first child but full of hopes. Her father, a renowned artist and experienced traveler, has convinced her and her bricklayer husband Ananias to make the journey to the New World. Land, they are promised, more goodly and beautiful than they can ever imagine. But nothing goes as planned from landing at the wrong location, to facing starvation, to the endless wait for help to arrive. And, beyond her comprehension, Elinor finds herself utterly alone. The colony at Roanoke disappeared into the shadows of history. But, what if one survived to leave a lasting legacy?"

Review:
The mystery of the Lost Colony with a twist! In 1587, the colonists arrived in the New World. Soon after, John White, governor of the colony and the father of the book's title character, returned to England for supplies. Once he left the island, what we know about the remaining colonists remains a mystery. White, did return to the island three years later to find no one. He did find the word "Croatoan" carved in a post and even with that clue, he was unable to find any survivors. McNear weaves a compelling story of what may have happened to the colonists. A well-researched story!

I was gifted this advance copy by NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.

Historical fiction is my favorite genre, mostly because I still learn much from well-written and researched historical fiction. My interest was immediately piqued when I first read the description of this book. I knew from reading some of Ms. McNear's earlier novels, that her research is excellent. And I was not disappointed. Her account of what might have happened to the lost colony of Roanoke is believable.
With beautiful prose that appeals to the senses, the life and struggles faced by the early planters come to life under McNear's skillful pen. But more than the history, I found the compelling message of grace and forgiveness relevant, regardless of time or setting. One for the keeper shelf!

I received a complimentary copy from the author/publisher through Netgalley. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.

I really wanted to love this book. The lost Roanoke Colony has always been intriguing and I was hopeful that this would give an interesting take on the disappearance.

However, this book was incredibly hard to read. While I appreciate the sheer effort made in making the dialogue historically accurate, it made it so hard to follow that I nearly gave up several times.

I also had a hard time with the sheer amount of white savior/white knighting in the novel. When I started it I was hopeful for a take on American colonization that didn't perpetuate the myth that the Native Americans were hostile and "savage" and needed to be saved by the good Christian people. This, on top of the hard to follow dialogue, made me really struggle to finish the book.

In short, I found it bland, preachy, and harmful in the way it perpetuates stereotypes against indigenous peoples. I had high hopes, and it didn't even come close to meeting them.