4.5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️


Out of His League by Caroline Richardson is a delightful, slow-burn romance that blends charm, heart, and a touch of sports drama into one very bingeable read. With lovable leads and feel-good chemistry, this book hits that sweet spot between swoon-worthy and emotionally satisfying.

What I Loved:
The character dynamics are the heart of this book. Richardson gives us a strong, intelligent heroine and a surprisingly sweet hero whose vulnerability and sincerity make him impossible not to root for. Their relationship unfolds naturally, with just enough tension and flirtation to keep the pages turning.

The writing is clean and light, with moments of humor that don’t feel forced. I especially enjoyed how the story flips the “he’s out of her league” trope and gives it emotional depth. The romance feels balanced—built on mutual respect and real connection, not just attraction.

Bonus points for the sports backdrop—it’s present without overpowering the story, and it adds a nice layer of context and stakes.

What I Didn’t Love:
While the book is incredibly charming, it does follow a pretty familiar rom-com formula. If you’re a frequent romance reader, you might see some of the beats coming. Also, a couple of side characters could’ve used more development; they were fun but didn’t get much page time to shine.

Final Thoughts:
Out of His League is a warm, feel-good romance with a lovable cast and just enough depth to make it memorable. It’s a perfect weekend read—especially if you like underdog stories, strong female leads, and a romance that makes you smile the whole way through.

Highly recommended for fans of sports romances, slow burns, and sweet-but-smart love stories.



❤️shaye.reads

I finished "Out of His League" by Caroline Richardson... And, well, it was okay. Cute concept - small-town romance with a sports twist. But it fell a little flat for me.

The characters were...fine. The plot was pretty predictable, and I just didn't feel the connection I wanted to. It was a quick read, but not one I'll be raving about.

It took me a bit to get into this story. I wasn't the biggest fan of the MC and some situations made me have to put the book down for a bit. Overall I enjoyed Gretchen and Joshua's story, and it hit the marks for a baseball feeling read.

It was a so so read. Started out okay but at some point it was not enough. Everything move so fast and too insta-lovey. I truly hate the miscommunication. What I enjoyed was definitely the smut. Others not so much.

This was a book. It had words. The words went together to fork sentences. Those sentences made paragraphs. Eventually it was a story.

We had such a strong start but I slowly lost interest as I went on. I just couldn’t connect to the characters unfortunately.

Much appreciation to the publisher and netgalley for the chance to review.

this book was a quick read! i would definitely recommend this book to a friend who is in a reading slump, as it got me out of mine!! all the tropes that were in this book, like the sports romance were right up my alley!

I was so excited for this one, but it definitely missed the mark for me. The story was easy enough to get through without getting too frustrated (I did finish it), which counts for something. The baseball theme added a nice touch, though the insta-love was not my vibe—especially given the somewhat cringey sex-dialogue that felt out of place. Overall, it wasn't terrible, but I wouldn't rush to recommend it either.

I love a good sports romance and this definitely fit the bill! Richardson did a wonderful job with Josh and Gretchen's story. So much fun!

Thank you NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review. Sports romance has my heart! The plot was fun but the characters felt a little flat to me. Quick and easy read.

2.5/5
pretty average read, nothing insanely spectacular but not horrible. I don't usually care for insta-love so that definitely sullied my experience reading this but if you like that then go for it. the smut was a redeeming quality but also not the best ive ever read. I have very neutral opinion about this and prob wouldn't recommend to others unless I knew that they'd enjoy.

I finally got around to this and it was just not great. It absolutely reads like a Wattpad book, and had I known that before requesting I wouldn't have. Insta-lust/love, falling for a celebrity, and a horribly annoying best friend that constantly gets in the way. It tried to be like 4 different books simultaneously

Thank you NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review. I like baseball, which was why I was drawn to this novel. I think the characters and the writing fell flat to me.

Overall, this book was decent, but not great. I don't think any of these characters will stick with me after I finish it, but it is a quick and easy read.

I feel like this book didn't get the hype it deserves. It wasn't a 5 star read, but it was definitely worthy of a read. Love a sporty little romance! This was so sweet!

This cover really drew me in and I love any sports romance I can get my hands on. This one was definitely good and worth the read.

Thanks NetGalley for the preview!

This book was addicting and frustrating. The main characters fell in to bed very quickly, and everything seems so rushed. They end up building a nice relationship, but still seems like they know nothing about each other at the end. The spice was nice but also lacking details.

I love a good sports romance, especially baseball. This was a good story, one I'm glad to have read.

The meet cute made this novel. In good ways and bad. It was unique, but simple and it is also the cause of the second act break up. Yes, second act.

I liked the writing style by the author, but the sequence was off for me. The characters get together really quickly and then are separated for a while and then back together for their happy ever after for the second half of the book. And yet I still felt the love interests didn’t get enough “screen time” together. But because they get together so quickly I wasn’t interested in reading more. There was no tension I was waiting for them to break for the second half of the book.

It was spicy, and then would close the door?

If you like baseball and wine, this is a cute read.

This was not a bad read overall.
It gives quite a heartwarming tale but also, gives the feeling of an instant love, that is quite pure.
I'm not that much into the writing style, but overall, for beginners and for a light read, this one was not bad.

3.25🌟