Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Beatrice Quinn is a genius, who has spent the entirety of her life studying at home to get into Oxford University. Now that she has finally gotten in, her parents aren't sure that she is ready. Beatrice might be super intelligent, but she has not been very successful at socializing with people her own age. She is determined that she will finally find people like her at Oxford, but her parents don't think it is enough. Concerned that she will get lost in her own world where they can't intervene, her parents want Beatrice to prove that she can do something outside of her comfort zone and make new friends. Armed with a list of teenage experiences, Beatrice is sent off to Shakespeare Theater camp. She has a short summer to prove that she can handle herself in a new environment. Beatrice soon learns that having relationships with others may not be as easy as she thinks. Surrounded by a new group of friends, and some enemies, she will tackle parties, pranks, dares, and maybe even love.

This book is a delightful look at an awkward teenage girl’s experience finally putting herself out there. Reader’s will see some part of themselves in Beatrice as she navigates the teenage world. Beatrice is all at once awkward, shy and clueless, while being strong, sassy, and endearing. You cannot help but fall in love with her, just like her friends in the book do. And the chemistry between Nik and Bea is hot, with the best part being that she doesn’t even see it. Your reminded of your first love when you were just as clueless about it as you read about Nik and Bea. Even those who aren’t fans of Shakespeare, will delight in the banter between Bea and Nik as they battle to see who knows the Bard best. And to top off the cast of great characters, and chemistry is the story of a girl who has struggled socially for her whole life finding out who she is and that she can live a more fulfilling social life. I thoroughly enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and St Martins Press and Wednesday Books for allowing me to read and review this title! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Bea is a long time homeschool student who is working hard to get into a good University. When her parents need convincing to let her go she is enrolled in a theater camp to help socialize and understand how to interact with teens her own age. She is "adopted" into a group of different kids and learns about life, relationships, interacting, and learning more about herself.

This is a sweet and cute young adult read! I love all the characters and especially Bea. I found her to be very relatable and understanding. The friendships are great and the all the experiences Bea has are exciting and develop her character well through out the book.

I really liked the writing style and the story itself. I think a lot of teens will love Long Story Short and will see themselves in these characters.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

this book intrigued me by the title alone because i was like ….. taylor swift? and it was just super cute and i loved everything about it

Was this review helpful?

This book. I cannot even tell you how much I loved it. I stayed up until 1:40 reading and then got up early to finish it.

The setting! If you love Emma Lord and camp books, this is for you. Throw in a Shakespeare theatre camp and it was perfection.

I love when romance books have more to their story and this one definitely did. The found family and friendships formed throughout this book made my heart so happy.

The anxiety representation was fantastic. It was authentic and real. However, it wasn’t super heavy. I loved how much Bea grew and how amazing her friends were.

Then there was the romance. Holy wow I adored it. It was enemies-to-lovers, but also some miscommunication with a side of missed signals. The banter was perfection and the Shakespeare battle? Couldn’t get enough. In one word, SWOONY.

Preorder this book, add it to your list, and do all the things because you won’t want to miss it. I am a new Serena Kaylor fan!
★★★★★/5
🔥🔥/5 (make out)

Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/p/CWTJlcFLSk6/
Goodreads:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4339423277
BookBub:
https://www.bookbub.com/reviews/1930981422?source=link_share

Was this review helpful?

Reading this one, I was concerned the entire plot was going to to be what I begrudgingly call the makeover plotline. Which is basically just the mc buying new clothes, taking their glasses off, and basically having a whole personality change. I am so happy that Long Story Short challenged this idea. The character development of Bea was not for a guy, but for her own volition.

Yes, it was motivated by her parents (who are actually involved in this one! yay for non-orphaned ya protagonists!) and the list at first, but as the story progressed became more of an internal motivation to change. I really appreciated the character development Bea went through throughout the book and the commentary on the whole idea of the makeover trope that we do see a lot of times in romcoms.

Long Story Short is so incredibly nerdy in the best way possible. Theater kids, Shakespeare, and just good ole summer camp energy that I’m absolutely here for. It is a fun romcom, complete with all of the romcom antics we know and love, as well as a perfect summery read.

---
Bea isn’t the only fabulous character in this one! I mean, yes, she is snarky and 100% a hoot, but the side characters also had their own moment in the spotlight (hehe bad theater jokes)! I’m so glad that Kaylor gave them all room to breathe throughout the book. From the love interest, to the friends Bea makes along the way, and even the antagonist, they all have strong motivations and are well rounded.

The friendship in particular is strong in this one. I’m so happy that Bea found such supportive and loving friends. They never wanted to force her to change, instead helping her along the way and unafraid to call Bea out when she was being clueless. This is the type of friendship I love to read about!

---
There were a couple comments made in regard to costuming that I didn’t jive with. Just comments like "oh don’t breathe so I can get your costume to fit" or "I hope you didn’t lose any weight since your last fitting!" It doesn’t sound like a huge deal, but similar comments were made multiple times when it really was unnecessary to begin with.

---
All and all, Long Story Short is so much fun. It is a fun and nerdy romcom complete with coming-of-age themes and bucketloads of snark. Totally recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

This heart warming Contemporary YA read put a huge smile on my face. Highly recommended!

Beatrice is a sixteen-year-old genius whose very careful routines help to keep her anxiety at bay. Homeschooling worked out best for her, but now that she wants to attend Oxford University, her parents have concerns about her ability to socialize and be on her own.

They agree that if Beatrice can prove she can have a "normal teenage experience" while at a four-week theater camp, she can attend Oxford. She immediately gains a bestie in her roommate Mia, and Mia's camp bestie, the Nolan, takes her under his wing as well. The relationships between these three gems are truly the definition of #FriendshipGoals.

Comically, she gets off on the wrong foot with the son of the camp's owners, Nik. As lead of the play, Nik is everywhere and Beatrice finds she cannot avoid him, try as she might.

Was this review helpful?

A perfect YA camp romance. The awkward girl being adopted by the dramatic pair to overcome her social anxiety to become the star. Really hit the spot!

Was this review helpful?

First, thanks to Netgalley for the ARC.

This book was a delight. It's not often we find YA books that center around a girl interested in STEM and is also neurodivergent. I don't want to diagnose Beatrice, because I'm not a mental health professional, but it is was clear throughout the novel that she's very much neurodivergent, and throughout the book, we see Bea because okay with that while also growing as a social creature. I found the plot a bit far fetched, what parent wouldn't be thrilled that their only daughter got into OXFORD? I understood her parents' concerns, because I honestly don't think Bea would have been successful at Oxford once she realized that her fantasy of the university was just that, a fantasy.

I really loved the characters in this, especially Mia and Nolan. They took to Bea immediately, tucked her under their wings, and with gentle prodding and support, shoved her out of the nest when needed. Mia was an absolute GEM of a character, and she had her own story outside of being Bea's emotional support person aka a friend. Nolan as well was lovely, and he as well is going through some things with his twin sister, Shelby, who at first plays the role of the "rival", but because this is YA and everything needs to be tidied up at the end, she becomes more of a respectful acquaintance.

There was definitely a nod to Pride and Prejudice with Nik being Darcy and Bea being Lizzie Bennett, if Darcy and Lizzie flirted using Shakespeare quotes. I will say, I never really appreciated how saucy some of Willy's lines could be until they were used in the context of a verbal sparring/flirting. The chemistry was there, and although Nik kind of came off as a dick at first, he does redeem himself. He fully accepted Bea as she was, and who doesn't want a hot brilliant boyfriend at the age of 16?

All in all, this was very cute. Bea learns how to accept herself, to open herself up to love - not just romantic love but platonic love as well. This was a book was more about friendships than romance, and I think that's where this book really shines. Once the typos and final edits are done, I can see this really being a great debut.

Was this review helpful?

To start off, I want to say thank you to Netgalley for giving me an ARC of this book!

Okay, so I read this in one day and says a lot about how much I loved it. This story is about friendship, love and just overall finding one’s identity. I related a lot to the main character (Bea) and how she felt about opening up in general. You see her in the beginning as someone who is shy and doesn’t really feel self-assured. Throughout this story though you see her grow and gain confidence in herself and others. The plot was amazing and the characters I loved so much. Bea and Nik are my fav like they were so cute. It was like enemies/maybe Shakespeare rivals lmfao to lovers. This was such an amazing story and again I’d like to say thank you to Netgalley for allowing me to review it! 5/5 stars. :))

Was this review helpful?

What a cinnamon roll of a book! It was adorable. I loved the summer camp setting, especially with the Shakespeare/acting twist, and the characters were so fun and fresh! Nik and Bea are banter goals, and I loved how she worked on her socializing skills with all her might. Mia was a delight as well, what a good friend she was to our heroine who hasn’t had a friend before. The Shakespeare line competition and performance at the end of the book was pure joy.

Was this review helpful?

Homeschooled and a whiz at statistics, Beatrice knows that she belongs at Oxford, where she will finally find people who understand her. She thought the hardest part would be getting in, not convincing her parents to let her go. They've put a halt to her plans until she can prove she's able to make friends with people her own age and function in social situations. Their solution: Shakespearean theater camp and a detailed list of teenage milestones to check off. She has six weeks to show her parents she can pull off the role of "normal" teenager and won't spend the rest of her life hiding in a library .As the summer draws to an end, and with Oxford on the line, this girl genius stumbles through illicit parties, double dog dares, and more than your fair share of Shakespeare. But before the final curtain falls, will Beatrice still feel like Oxford alone is enough?

A fun teen book. :) I love YA genre actually. This one does the teen rom-com perfectly.. All the awkwardness, the sweetness and the single-mind focus of teenage love. The secondary characters are interesting as well and make the book much more fun. The heroine's growth is wonderful to read... A terrific, sweet rom com

Thanks to the publisher for providing an arc.

Was this review helpful?

I love this book with my whole heart! I had the pleasure of reading an early draft back in 2018 (!!) and reading the most updated version this week had me falling in love with these chaotic theatre children all over again. I'm so excited for this to be out in the world!

Serena is such a master of character and romance. I root for these characters every step of the way, from awkward auditions to opening night. Nik and Bea are the kind of slow burn YA romance I wish I could bottle up for cold days. They're prickly with each other, yes, but when it comes down to it, their relationship is build off mutual respect and trust. This is the kind of romcom my theatre kid self would have adored in high school and I can't wait for everyone to fall in love with this book.

Was this review helpful?

Fabulous YA, G-rated, romantic comedy with a brilliant STEM heroine

Beatrice (“Bea”) Quinn is the sixteen-year-old daughter of two avant-garde, Berkeley, California, Ph.D. psychotherapists who have a joint practice, operating from a home office, that specializes in sex therapy and marital counseling. Given that professional background, it is not surprising that Bea’s parents have made sure she has had her own personal therapist on speed-dial since childhood to help her deal with what appears to be a generalized anxiety disorder. In addition to talk therapy, her therapist has also taught her CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy) techniques. It is not overtly stated in this novel, but much like the character Don Tillman (by author Graeme Simsion), Bea clearly has a milder (AKA “high-functioning”) version of autism spectrum disorder (which mental health professionals until recently called “Asperger’s disorder,” a term that has been dropped from the DSM-5). Also like Don Tillman, Bea is a genius with a photographic memory whose career of choice is genetics. She has been home-schooled since age five because her parents have believed since then that her unique combination of special needs cannot adequately be met in either a public or private, K-12 school. Without any sense of irony, as mental-health professionals themselves who formally diagnose clients on a daily basis, Bea’s parents have refused to ever allow her to receive any kind of mental-health diagnosis because they have never wanted her to be “labeled, judged, and diagnosed into some box.” (Which in and of itself, unfortunately, indicates they have an unadmitted, negative perception of the autism spectrum.)

At age 14 Bea received a high school diploma (presumably from an accredited, online, K-12 school catering to home-schooled students) and, for the past two years, she has been plowing through a huge number of online community college courses in math and physics. Her longtime, passionate goal is to attend Oxford University in England and, on a whim a few months ago, without discussing it with her parents first, Bea applied to attend Oxford the upcoming fall semester. She is amazed and elated when she receives a letter of acceptance. Unfortunately, when Bea informs her parents of this extraordinary accomplishment, they are not convinced she is old enough, emotionally mature enough, or has enough interpersonal skills and basic survival skills to handle being so far from home. Bea is an extreme introvert who has, by choice, never had any friends and spends the vast majority of her time holed up in her bedroom. In addition, she has trouble with any change in her rigid, daily routine of many years which includes, among other things, wearing the same nondescript, wrinkle-free polo shirts and khaki slacks every day and eating the same rotation of bland meals for dinner every week (the latter another spectrum trait that she shares with Don Tillman). Her parents fear she would forget to eat entirely most of the time if they were not around to shop and cook for her.

When Bea begs her parents to reconsider forbidding her to attend Oxford, they relent enough to devise a plan for her to gain some of the vital experience and life skills she would need to effectively navigate Oxford. (Skills which they take no personal responsibility for failing to teach Bea themselves.) They decide a good place for Bea to learn much of what she needs to know would be at a summer camp, specifically one focusing on theater. It will allow her to test out her response to spending extended time away from home, functioning in an alien environment, living with a roommate, relating on a daily basis with a mass of colorfully unpredictable, wildly extroverted theater people, and very likely performing onstage. Bea negotiates with them to allow her to, at the very least, attend a “dignified” theater camp that focuses on Shakespeare, and her parents enroll her in a prestigious, four-week, summer program at the Connecticut Shakespearean Summer Academy.

In preparation for her voyage into the frightening unknown, Bea reads Shakespeare’s entire repertoire of plays twice and, because of her photographic memory, has them all memorized. She also studies articles and books on the rules of modern-day friendship and how to engage in casual conversation. But it becomes clear to Bea’s parents shortly before the day of her departure that they need to spell out concrete objectives that she must successfully achieve in order for them to be satisfied that she is ready to go to Oxford. With very little planning or forethought, and giggling like kids the whole time, they scrawl on a piece of paper the following list: (1) Make a friend. (2) Share a secret. (3) Walk up to someone and make small talk. (4) Accept an invitation you don’t want. (5) Do an outdoor activity. (6) Pull a prank. (7) Execute a dare. (8) Hug three people.

Bea has no idea how she is going to check off every item on this seemingly insurmountable list of goals, but she is determined to give her all to the Herculean task. Because nothing whatsoever can be allowed to get in the way of her going to Oxford!

On Bea’s overwhelming, initial day at camp, she meets four fellow campers who will each have a huge influence on her:

—Mia Parker is an 18-year-old, beautiful, enormously talented, charismatic, warm-hearted, African-American actress who is Bea’s roommate at camp. She generously volunteers to be Mia’s personal coach to help her complete her parental list.
—Shelby Walsh is an 18-year-old, beautiful, enormously talented, white actress, who has been assigned to the same cabin as Mia and Bea, but with her own separate bedroom. She is a classic Mean Girl who is Bea’s main antagonist.
—Nolan Walsh is Shelby Walsh’s twin. He is a handsome, white, gay, clever, uninhibited, enormously talented costume designer who, across many past summers of attending this camp, has always been Mia’s camp BFF. He warmly accepts Bea into their little circle and gleefully volunteers to join Mia in helping Bea fulfill her list.
—Nikhil (“Nik”) Shah is an 18-year-old, handsome, enormously talented, mixed-race actor of East-Indian and white-British descent who is the son of famous actors, Rishi and Miranda Shah, who founded and financially underwrite this theater camp. In an homage to Darcy of Pride and Prejudice, he and Bea start off on the wrong foot when, similar to how Elizabeth overhears Darcy insulting her looks to his friend Bingley at a community dance, Bea overhears Nik insulting her looks to one of his friends at the dance held on the first night of camp at the community hall. This results in the arc of their romantic relationship becoming the ever-popular, “enemies to romance” trope.

How do I love this book? Let me count the ways:

1. Bea is an absolutely fabulous protagonist. The entire book, as is typical for YA, is entirely in her first-person point of view. This means that we experience every character in the book, including Bea herself, from her perspective as a fascinatingly quirky “unreliable narrator.” Every YA novel inevitably contains a “coming of age” story arc. In this particular novel, Bea has a well-motivated, heart-warming, and frequently hilarious personal transformation as she discovers amazing hidden talents within her that she never knew existed.
2. Mia and Nolan are wonderful, affectionate, compassionate, supportive, loyal friends to Bea. I fell in love with the two of them and enjoyed everything about them. Though they both exist as a “Manic Pixie Dream Girl” version of the stock character, the “Confidante,” neither of them come off as one-dimensional. They both have their own mini-growth arcs across the novel, with a bit more focus on Mia than Nolan.
3. Shelby is also a classic stock character, the “Mean Girl,” but she is not a one-dimensional, cardboard-cutout either. Her bad behavior is believably motivated, and she, too, has her own personal growth arc in the story.
4. Nik is a wonderful romantic hero. He isn’t just a pretty face. He is presented as an extremely talented actor who is passionate about and fully dedicated to his art. And though, like Darcy, the initial impression he gives is that of a bored, privileged, Alpha male, over the course of the story his sensitive, Beta, inner core is carefully and convincingly unveiled. Most of all, the repartee between Nik and Bea is a constant delight.
5. This is a romantic comedy that lives up to its billing—it is both romantic and frequently laugh-out-loud funny. I greatly appreciated the fact that none of the humor is rooted in slapstick—which I personally do not enjoy because it inevitably involves humiliating the person, usually the heroine, who trips and falls flat on her face. Instead, the humor arises from witty internal and external dialogue and zany situations.
6. I’ve read a number of romance novels set in summer camps during this past year (including several set at a summer camp catering to nostalgic adults). This book does, by far, the best job at making that concept entertaining, mainly because the focus is on the performance of Romeo and Juliet, rather than endless scenes of predictable summer camp activities, such as water recreation, crafts, eating s’mores around a campfire, and noisy, buffet meals in a rustic dining hall. Yes, many of those activities do appear in this novel, but there is so much going on with the theater component and with Bea’s seeking to fulfill the items on her list, those activities exist merely as a type of authentic backdrop.
7. The novel as a whole is structured with sophisticated finesse. Every major turning point is foreshadowed sufficiently to feel well motivated, but it is never done so blatantly that any Big Reveal is telegraphed, spoiling the surprise.
8. The basic writing skills of this author are superb. There is sufficient description of the setting and characters to make Bea’s surroundings and fellow campers come vividly to life without ever overloading the story with excess narrative that might bog down the forward motion of the plot.
9. Kudos to this author for performing the rather unusual feat of creating warm, loving, attentive, YA parents who are strongly involved in their daughter’s life. It is essential that YA protagonists be “orphaned” in order to solve the main story conflict themselves. But far too frequently YA authors orphan their protagonists by assigning them horrible parents who emotionally and/or physically abandon their children due to incompetence, callous disinterest, short-sighted workaholism, mental illness or a rigid, controlling attitude. In the case of this terrific story, Bea’s parents have reasonable, “tough love” motivations for insisting that Bea must make her own way during her extraordinary, “fish out of water” adventure.

I only have one small quibble with this story, which I admit is pretty much unavoidable. Though this book, with admirable inclusivity, features a multicultural cast and at least one onstage LGBTQI character, there is a crucial, defining feature that every teenager in this novel has in common: they all come from an equally elevated, prosperous background, which allows their parents to afford the undoubtedly exorbitant tuition for this specialized camp. That kind of privilege creates a socially homogenizing effect such that there are no noticeable, overt cultural differences between any of these teen characters—other than Nik’s having a British accent due to he and his parents’ being British expatriates living in the US.

Parental advisory: In my perception, this book is for the most part fully G-rated. Bea has never been kissed and has never dated. All the other characters are much more experienced, but none of the characters, including especially Nik (thank goodness!), are presented as casually promiscuous. There are no blatant sexual innuendos, no sexual harassment, and no sex (either offstage or onstage), only some fairly mild kissing toward the end of the book. This book is basically the G-rated version of a “slow burn” romance. In addition, the story includes no foul language and no wild parties. There is one scene in which Bea engages in underage drinking, but it is not presented as desirable.

Overall, for me personally, as an extremely jaded reader, this book is a keeper. I am sure I will reread it many times in the future, and I am avidly looking forward to the eventual release of the audiobook version.

I rate this book as follows:

Heroine: 5 stars
Romantic Hero: 5 stars
Parents: 5 stars
BFFs: 5 stars
Antagonist: 4 stars
Romance Plot: 5 stars
Coming of Age Plot: 5 stars
Comedic Elements: 5 stars
Setting: 5 stars
Writing: 5 stars
Overall: 5 stars

Note: I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher, MacMillan, via NetGalley, and I am voluntarily leaving a review.

Was this review helpful?

Long Story Short by Serena Kaylor is a lovely young adult romance that is sure to pull at your heartstrings and leave you wanting more.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. The writing was spectacular and Bea was such a relatable character. I really loved the other campers and the location of the camp. Mia was especially a wonderful character and I loved her friendship with Bea. This book has everything from romance to friendship to character development and a ton of Shakespeare. This is definitely a YA book you’ll wanna keep on your radar.

Was this review helpful?

This was a delightful read! The relationship between Beatrice and Nik played out nicely over the course of the book and the addition of the supporting characters added to the story. I felt like the end of the book wrapped together nicely but did leave me hoping for a sequel to hear more!
I really enjoyed this story and the main character’s growth and development over her summer at camp, and I’m already looking forward to the next Serena Kaylor story.

ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?