Well put together and helpful book club kit. I loved having this a resource for potential book clubs for my library in the future.

Thank you We Are Bookish for creating another great book club resource! Beautifully created book club kit! The author interview answered all of my questions, the discussion questions were diverse and well-crafted. The book club beverages and printable bookmarks are wonderful bonuses to use during your club discussion.

So good for bookclubs.
Whether you’re a seasoned club host or just starting out, this Book Club Kit is a total game-changer! It includes everything you need to spark great conversations—thought-provoking discussion questions, author Q&As, and ideas to set the mood.

What I loved most? The kit makes reading feel like an experience, not just a solo activity. It brings the book to life in a whole new way and helps everyone connect deeper with the story—and with each other.

Review: Book Club Kit for If the Shoe Fits by Julie Murphy (We Are Bookish)
Score: 3.8/5

Strengths:
Thematic Discussion Prompts (4/5)
The kit includes thoughtful questions exploring the novel’s modern Cinderella retelling, body positivity, and career aspirations. These align well with the book’s focus on Cindy’s unapologetic embrace of her plus-size identity and design ambitions.

Engagement Tools (4/5)
Features like quizzes (e.g., a “Before Midnight Quiz”) and bookmarks add interactive elements, encouraging lively discussions. The playful nods to fairy tales (e.g., “choosing joy” prompts) creatively reinforce the book’s themes.

Structural Organization (3.5/5)
Materials are logically grouped (discussion questions, activities), making it easy for book clubs to navigate. However, deeper literary analysis (e.g., comparing Cindy’s journey to traditional Cinderella tropes) could elevate this further.

Weaknesses:
Limited Critical Context (3/5)
While the kit sparks conversation, it lacks scholarly depth—no references to feminist theory, retelling conventions, or Murphy’s authorial intent. Including analysis of the “Meant to Be” series’ broader themes would enrich academic use.

Minimal Supplemental Resources (3/5)
Absent are author interviews, reading lists, or cultural critiques (e.g., on fat representation in romance). Adding these would bridge the gap between casual and academic audiences.

Recommendations:
Integrate comparative analysis (e.g., parallels to Bridget Jones’s Diary for modern romantic tropes).
Include a “Further Exploration” section with articles on body positivity in contemporary literature.

Verdict: A vibrant, accessible resource for book clubs, though scholarly audiences may need supplementary materials.

This is such a great companion for a book. I particularly love the recipe suggestions and the recommendations for what to read next after finishing the book. The author interview and questions would be great talking points for book clubs or even just to get yourself thinking.

This book club kit is pretty comprehensive, and has a mix of discussion prompts and activities that could be done during the book club meeting (quizzes, crafts). It is very Cindy-centric though, and I would have liked more questions about Cindy and Henry. There are also next book recommendations, which is helpful for book clubs that find it hard to decide what to read next!

This Book Club Kit for If the Shoe Fits is a game-changer for anyone looking to elevate their book club experience. It’s packed with insightful discussion questions, fun activities, and even personalized book recommendations—everything you need to spark lively conversations and keep your group engaged. The materials are beautifully designed and easy to use, making both virtual and in-person meetings feel seamless.

This is a good book with a good story line. I just think it was too predictable. So that makes this book not for me.

This is a cool book club kit. I like the discussion questions as they are a good conversation tool while conducting a book club meeting.
The “How far would you make it to midnight” looks fun as well. Bingo is a plus in itself, who doesn’t love bingo! This is probably one of the best ones I’ve seen, it has an enough to have a book club meeting well over an hour.

Thank you Disney Publishing Worldwide for sponsoring this kit and We Are Bookish for creating this kit! This is an amazing and perfect resource for anyone looking at hosting a book club for this Julie Murphy book. There are lots of great resources included, such as an author interview, recipe ideas, and discussion questions.

I love Cinderella-inspired stories, and this book had such a fun and dramatic premise. But I really wished there was more depth. The characters and romance felt rushed—like it needed at least 50 more pages to fully develop. The insta-love was a bit too much for me; I wanted more emotional build-up and slower, meaningful moments. Still, it was an enjoyable read with a charming concept!

I love these interactive book club kits! Even if you're not reading the particular book featured, these kits provide tons of inspiration for book clubs. Definitely keeping the bingo idea in my back pocket!

Thanks NetGalley!

I love this kit so much! I love the discussion prompts, the quiz and the challenges. Definitely want to decorate my own glass slipper! I also love that it comes with a pizza and drink recipe. This kit includes everything to have the perfect book club night. An amazing and thought provoking book club kit for If The Show Fits by Julie Murphy!

This is a great idea to assist book clubs. While I don't currently participate in a book club I wanted to see what this included.

This kit did exactly what was expected. It is cute, fun and functional. I would defiantly recommend.

Amazing book club kit for Julie Murphy's IF SHE SHOE FITS from We Are Bookish/NetGalley! This book club kit contains everything to read, discuss and enhance your reading and book clubs experience. It comes with bookmarks, recipies and author interviews! Definitely recommend to use this for book club meetings!

This book club kit will help me to read If the Shoe Fits, this kit will help provide analysis and make me think about questions that I otherwise wouldn't have thought of.

It will also allow a more accurate review of the book because I will have been asked questions and this kit will have provided me with an easy to read synopsis.

Super fun idea!! I'll be doing this with my friends for our April bookclub. Can't wait to play book bingo!

charming, feel-good romantic comedy that delivers both heart and humor with a dash of fairy-tale magic. The novel centers around Cindy, a plus-size fashion designer who unexpectedly finds herself competing for a coveted spot on a reality dating show. As she steps into the world of glittering glamour and larger-than-life personalities, Cindy must navigate the highs and lows of public life while staying true to herself.

Murphy, known for her knack for writing authentic, body-positive characters, brings Cindy to life with depth and wit. Cindy is a breath of fresh air—confident, kind, and unapologetically herself in a world that often sidelines people who don’t fit conventional beauty standards. The beauty of If the Shoe Fits lies not only in the romance but also in Cindy’s journey of self-empowerment, self-love, and navigating societal expectations.

The romance, which blooms in the midst of the reality show chaos, is sweet, slow-burning, and filled with tension, making it impossible not to root for the couple. The love story unfolds against the backdrop of a bright and colorful world, with a perfect blend of humor and vulnerability that keeps the pages turning.

What makes If the Shoe Fits even more enjoyable is its clever commentary on fame, the pressure of social media, and the superficial aspects of reality TV. Through Cindy’s eyes, the reader is reminded of the importance of staying true to oneself, even when the world seems fixated on the surface.

Julie Murphy’s writing is engaging and accessible, making this book an easy and delightful read.
The book club kit was delightful and made reading the book more delightful.

Julie Murphy absolutely never misses for me. Feeling very emotional right now about the amount of comfort and joy her books bring me and this was no exception.

me: I'm kinda sick of Cinderella retellings
Julie Murphy: here's my first Adult novel and it is a Cinderella retelling with a plus-size main character
me: SIGN ME UP!!!

The Book Club Kit for If the Shoe Fits by Julie Murphy was a phenomenal addition to reading this book with friends! The interview with the author gave amazing insight into Murphy’s development of the characters and her thinking in writing the book. These additional pieces provided amazing context and really made us think about the characters deeply. However, my favorite part of this kit was the activities. I had so much fun with the Before Midnight quiz and the bingo card. It added a new experience to book club that was outside of the normal discussion questions and kept people engaged. I really appreciated the list of books at the end and even added several of them to my wish list! This was a fantastic addition to the book, and I am grateful to We Are Bookish for making this, and also looking forward to trying the pizza recipe!