Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Wow! If you like dark and twisty stories full of suspense and mystery, you'll love this book! Helen Monks Takhar managed to draw me into this story and I never knew what to expect next. This is not my typical type of read but I was immediately hooked and had to keep reading. Thanks #NetGalley #RandomHouse and #HelenMonksTakhar

Was this review helpful?

This was a very dark but compelling read - what will a mother do to improve the life and fortune of her child?

For Rose, living on the shabby side of a rapidly improving neighborhood, watching the well dressed and ambitious mothers push their children at the prestigious Woolf Academy right across the street from her house, jealousy sets in. She is stuck barely making ends meet, in her job as a bank teller, with a good looking husband who is struggling to get work as a plumber. Rose is the daughter of a well known local con artist, and lives in the shadow of his name.

She manages to get her son Charlie a place at the school, but both he and she struggle to fit in with the students and mothers who all look down on Rose and Charlie. She watches enviously as members of "the circle' - the small group of mothers who run the school under the leadership of the formidable Amala Kaur - seem to have everything going their way at the school. When one of the circle is found dead on school grounds, Rose finds herself chosen as her unlikely replacement. Once on the inside, her fortunes start to improve, but at what terrible cost.

This was one of those books that made me truly wonder at the evil and devious minds that exist in this world. The plot took several turns that I didn't expect, and left me thinking about the roles of victim and villain long after I finished reading the book.

Was this review helpful?

Rosie O’Connell is a wife and a mother struggling to get by. She knows she doesn’t belong at the prestigious Woolf Academy but she is determined to put her son Charlie in the school. She will do whatever it takes to fit in to be like the rest of the Woolf Mothers and especially The Circle.
The Circle is an exclusive club in the Woolf Academy run by a woman named Amala Kaur. All the woman inside the Circle are horrible people who obey whatever Amala says. Rosie believes her life will turn around for the better if she can just get inside the circle. She won’t need to struggle, she won’t need to worry about child care not only in the morning but after school too. It will all be there for her.

However, once she is inside the Circle she learns things are not what they seem.

This book had so many twists and turns which I really enjoyed it kept me very intrigued. Just when I thought I had things figured out, we are hit with another big twist. The writing was great and the story is very compelling.

A big thank you to Netgalley and Random House for an eARC in exchange for my honest revew.

Was this review helpful?

This was definitely an interesting read. I picked it up because I seen it was about a school and rich people. Which honestly is my jam. I love me some drama, and moms who have way to much money. I am not a mom and I still could kind of relate to the main character. I say kind of because some of her characteristics were odd. I would read more from this author as I enjoyed the writing style.

Was this review helpful?

Such a Good Mother by Helen Monks Takhar

Published: August 2, 2022
Random House
Pages: 354
Genre: Thriller
KKECReads Rating: 5/5
I received a copy of this book for free, and I leave my review voluntarily.

Helen Monks Takhar worked as a journalist, copywriter, and magazine editor, having graduated from Cambridge in 1997. She began her career writing for financial trade newspapers in 1999 before contributing to UK national newspapers, including The Times and The Observer. Born in Southport, Merseyside, in 1976, she lives in North London with her husband and two daughters.

“Magis et Magis.”

Rose has not always lived a healthy and safe life. Her father was a talented con artist who wouldn’t hesitate to make his daughter participate in a con if it meant succeeding. Now, as an adult, Rose wants her young son to have every opportunity life offers. So when the chance to enroll him in a prestigious school occurs, Rose doesn’t hesitate. She also doesn’t realize she may not survive meeting the other hardworking mothers.

HOLY BUCKETS. This was intense. I devoured this novel in hours. I could not put it down. Just when I thought things couldn’t possibly get more complicated, that did.

I liked Rose. She was a significant lead. I enjoyed how she was presented and how she played the game. Amala was also a great character. She was just as intelligent, determined, hardworking, devoted, and passionate as Rose.

Though, they two seemingly lived in different worlds. I loved the themes in this novel. The concept of privilege and hierarchy that comes along with it. The balance between rich and poor, opportunity and destitution.

The game was set and played by absolute players. As much as I hate women being pitted against each other, the portrayal was accurate and intense. There was a very dramatic “Mean Girls” element to this book.

Fast-paced and full of twists you never expect, the last several chapters will give you whiplash and leave your eyeballs tired from flying along the pages. An excellent thriller about the lengths a mother will go to for the health, happiness, wellbeing, and safety of her child.

Was this review helpful?

Rose, the daughter of a scam artist, lost everything when her father died. Now she and her mostly unemployed husband struggle to make ends meet in a neighborhood turned upscale by the presence of an exclusive school, the Woolf Academy.
Despite her social insecurity and his difficulty fitting in, she applies for her son to attend the Woolf and he is accepted. There are strange goings on here, including a tight group of women called The Circle who run the school, the death of one of them, and their charismatic but suspicious and overbearing leader. Soon Rose is called upon to enter The Circle, but at what price?

Many have really liked this book; I am an outlier. It was well written with twists and turns but it just wasn’t for me. I really had to force myself to stay with the book as I found it tedious. I couldn’t get invested in the story; most of the characters were unlikable and I just didn’t care what happened to any of them. Incidentally, I the saw genre of this book as more of a horror story than a mystery.

Thanks to #Netgally and #RandomHouse for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I just finished reading "Such a Good Mother", by Helen Monks Takhar. Thank you to NetGalley and RandomHouse for a free copy in exchange for an honest review. I would describe it as a psychological thriller based on the way the story evolves and changes direction so many times, and especially for the way it ends.

The story is about all mother's desires to give their child, and by extension, their family, the best possible chance to succeed. Sometimes this desire leads women down paths where they compromise their own standards to 'fit in' or be accepted.

Such is the character of Rose, the daughter of a trickster who has to escape her own sketchy past and reinvent herself when she decides to enroll her son in an elite school. What follows is a searing look into how we compromise ourselves to accomplishour goals of a better life. All told to an exageratted story but the point is made nonetheless.

There are some twists which I enjoyed and surprised me...especially the final couple of pages. There is some great storytelling and interesting characters which made me interested to read the entire book. I hated the main culprit which is a result of how she was written.

However, the main character was not my favourite. I really wanted to like her, but some of the things she did just didn't make sense to me. I found her quite unrootable.

Overall, a good book...not my favourite..bet good enough to recommend to readers of this genre

Was this review helpful?

This dark suspense novel focuses on a mother’s relentless pursuit of what she believes is the best for her young son and her own future.

Rose O’Connell is a struggling bank teller, trying to get her son into an elite school, The Woolf, located within her gentrified neighborhood. All major decisions made for The Woolf are controlled by a powerful group of women, known as the Circle. For reasons she can’t explain, Rose’s son is admitted into the school, but struggles to be fully accepted by his peers and teachers. When an opening in the Circle becomes available and Rose is asked to join, she sees this as the chance to make her son’s future even brighter, while silencing her own demons of self-doubt. She focuses solely on being accepted by the Circle, going to whatever lengths necessary to become the person she wants to be…worthy, elite, powerful. But as she is drawn deeper into the Circle, she ends up in a game of cat and mouse, where everything she holds dear is now at stake.

This book certainly has some major twists that I did not anticipate, and the last half of the book was a quick read for me. The author did a fantastic job of portraying Rose as a woman seeking worth and power, while trying to conquer the ghosts of her past. With that being said, I must admit that I was not a huge fan of Rose at all. I struggled with Rose’s character throughout the entire story. Her personality came across as narcissistic, and she justified her decisions regarding Charlie and Pete based solely on what she wanted. She dismissed the unhappiness that both of them expressed to her, without any genuine compassion. I ended up hating Rose, and feeling so bad for her family. The conclusion of the story left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I believe that some readers will enjoy this dark portrayal of the elite, but it wasn't a book that I enjoyed personally.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishers for this advanced copy, in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It’s not often that y have just a visceral reaction to a fiction book. I’ve never wanted to smack a main character as badly as I wanted to punch Rose. She is a vile, repugnant creature who has no morals. She wanted to climb the totem pole so she sold out her entire family in the process. My mouth dropped as I kept,reading about the extreme lows she stooped.
I almost came unglued when she expected others to fix the messes she created.
I hated the main character, but the writing was very good. It has to be to evoke such a strong reaction from me.

Was this review helpful?

Good one! This was one of those books that puts you in the character’s shoes and see it from that perspective. There was a lot of intrigue and the storyline was interesting.

Was this review helpful?

I will be recommending this to my followers who are obsessed with thrillers. This will be a good beach read

Was this review helpful?

Compulsively readable dark take on the myth of having it all as a mother. What are you willing to do to make sure your child/your family has everything you want. Everyone has secrets, everyone has a past they want to hide. Just as you think one character is the most horrible, you find something to soften your view. Some people may think these women were horrible to each other (and they were), but if you've even experienced a toxic PTA, you know this hits a little closer to home than fiction often does.

Rose O'Connell is barely surviving. Her relationship with her husband is on the rocks and their son has isn’t fitting in at his new school, the prestigious Woolf Academy. Their tiny flat in a rapidly gentrifying neighborhood--the very place Rose grew up as the daughter of an infamous local con artist--can barely contain her family. Rose can’t catch a professional break either, trapped in the same junior bank teller role for years. Life as the only mom in a nametag and uniform at The Woolf’s shiny school gates isn’t easy.

Not so for those in the elite and secretive Circle, a tight-knit group of mothers who rule the school, led by the charismatic and glamorous Amala Kaur. In exchange for supporting The Woolf’s relentless fundraising and public image drives, the women enjoy lucrative business opportunities, special privileges for their children, and the admiration of the entire community.

After the mysterious death of one of The Circle’s members, Rose dares to hope that filling the vacancy could set her family up for success. And when Amala makes the shocking decision to invite Rose into their clique, her fortunes, self-esteem, and status soar. But the deeper Rose gets inside The Circle, the darker the secrets lurking within every perfectly Instagrammable life. Far from being a dream come true, being inside The Circle could prove Rose’s worst nightmare…

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the free ARC in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed herein are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book from Netgalley. I really wanted to like this book. The storyline didnt compel me to continue reading the book. I found the characters annoying. It did not seem suspenseful and did not hold my attention

Was this review helpful?

DNF. Unfortunately, this was a book I started multiple times but could just not get into. I appreciate having the opportunity to read this book, it was just not a good fit for me as a reader. Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for my gifted review copy.

Was this review helpful?

When I heard Helen Monk Takhar had a new book out, I knew I had to read it! Such a Good Mother was a story of the dark and twisted lengths a mother will go to in order to secure the best life for her child. I found myself racing toward the nail-biting conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

AS CAWPILE:
Characters: 9 | Atmosphere: 8 | Writing: 6 | Plot: 7 | Intrigue: 7 | Logic: 7 | Enjoyment: 8
Total:

This thriller was beyond anything I expected. Most domestic thrillers can be boring, bordering on funnily detached from the world around them. Such a Good Mother manages to avoid this by being aware of itself, with characters from both poor and rich backgrounds. Instead of leaning too heavily on untrustworthy men, we do the opposite. While there were times I wondered where we were going, and who was going to win, the ending truly floored me and I was pleased with the outcome.

Was this review helpful?

✨Book Review - Such a Good Mother by Helen Monks Takhar✨

Rose O’Connell is barely holding on. Her husband has been out of work, she is barely making ends meet with her job at the bank, and her son, Charlie, isn’t doing so well at his new, prestigious school, Woolf Academy. Compared to the other “put together” mothers at the school, Rose is scraping by. That is until the elite and secretive Circle, a group of close-knit moms who rule the school and get all the advantages, notice Rose and asks her to join their ranks when one of their own dies. All in exchange for “support and fundraising attempts.” The deeper Rose gets into this group, the darker the secrets she uncovers. Is this a dream come true or a nightmare?

Being a mother is something else, you want the best for your kids but how far are you willing to go to make it happen? This book reminded me of Big Little Lies because there are just so many secrets and drama and the willingness to do whatever it takes to be on top. The book kept my attention just enough to keep reading because I was curious where all of this was going, but I was annoyed by pretty much all the characters. Sometimes I just wanted to shake them all and yell at them to get over themselves. I just couldn’t find myself rooting for anyone. But, it had suspense and drama and that’s a good combo.

⭐️⭐️⭐️STARS

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Any good and/or decent parent wants the best for his/her own child. After all, this little human is someone you created—a better version (or so you hope) of yourself. No matter what status you are in life, most parents want their children to have the best education and live in the best neighborhoods and have the best options that life has to offer. And Rose O’Connell was that such parent. She wanted her little Charlie to have the best of the best. He deserved to go to the best school and schmooze with the rich, entitled children that lived in their neighborhood. Rose was a bank teller and her husband, Pete, worked in construction. There wasn’t any way their measly salaries could afford the tuition to The Woolfe Academy. But Rose didn’t let a little thing like money stand in her way of getting her son in that prestigious school.

In fact, mothers from far and abroad would kill to get their child into that school. So, imagine Rose’s surprise when she learned of the open house taking place and she was asked to attend. This was the news and moment Rose had been waiting on. Immediately she noticed that there appeared to be two types of mothers at this school. Several women who wore designer clothes and had their noses so far up in the air, they couldn’t see anything below them. And then there was the room Rose was in with mothers that looked more of her caliber that didn’t have much flare or personality. Rose wasn’t anybody’s fool. Knowing that she was going to be out of her element, she brought her sister-in-law, Jacqueline, in tow to help ease her nerves. Even though Jacq knew straight away that something wasn’t quite right with The Woolfe Academy. Hmmm. . .one could argue there’s something in a name, right?

Even though Rose’s spidy senses were tingling strong, she wasn’t going to let that stop her from getting Charlie admitted in. One such mother in a rush grabbed Rose’s arm and tried to warn her that she should leave while the getting was good, but Rose figured this woman must not have had what it took to be a Woolfe Academy mom.

Amala Kaur was the “it” woman! If she selected you to be in the “circle,” you have literally died and gone to heaven. She was the crème de ’la crème and life just didn’t get any better than Amala Kaur. She could make or break your life within The Woolfe Academy. Was it any wonder when the ever beautiful Amala stepped to Rose and moved her to the room where the fancy mothers were chatting it up and rubbing elbows? Rose was stunned and couldn’t believe she had made it to the next level much like the electronic games her son played. This is it! Rose had finally made it. But, you may be wondering to yourself—well, who exactly made it? Where did Charlie, her son and Pete, her husband, fit into the grand scheme of things? Well, you’ll have to read this story to find out.

OMG! I must admit this story was too long for my tastes and a bit slow in the very beginning. At that time, I was leaning toward giving this story three stars, which in fact, when I first listed it on Goodreads, I did. That is, until I continued to read and finish the story, I had a change of heart. Rose O’Connell was such a narcissist it wasn’t even funny. I found the character to behave in ways that just didn’t appear believable to me. She angered me on so many levels, I wanted to Will Smith her face, and that’s when it hit me that this author was pretty brilliant, actually. Whether she intended for the reader to feel as I had or not, the fact that I was able to see this character through and come to some much-needed understanding, was a feat in and of itself.

What I most enjoyed about this story are the many levels you get to see from Rose’s perspective. Not only do you see the levels, but you get to see how those levels play out among the other characters in the book leaving in the reader’s wake a sense of awakening like no other. I found that even though I totally disagreed with many of Rose’s decisions, I realized for this character she had to do what she had to do and when you learn of her background, the pieces of the puzzle will meld together to form quite the picture.

Was this review helpful?

A solid 4.5 stars! Deep, dark & thought-provoking! Not at all what I was expecting. After finishing “Such a Good Mother.” I had to go back & read parts to make sure I hadn’t missed any clues that hinted at the conclusion. Takhar’s evolution of Rose and the subsequent downfall of Amala was unbelievable. Her character development is very well done. Looking forward to her next work!

Was this review helpful?

Rose O’Connell's father was a con artist. She has been living under the shadow of his influence and reputation all her life, but dreams of more. Now working at a bank and married with a child ready to start school, Rose has her eye on The Woolf, an exclusive academy across the road from her apartment. The Woolf is run by Amala Kaur, a charismatic woman who is living the life of luxury and respect that Rose wants, and who might help Rose get it for herself when she is invited to join the exclusive Circle of four mothers who enjoy special privileges in exchange for their tireless efforts on behalf of the school. But Rose finds that "more" comes with a price, and "more" isn't always good; what lengths will she go to in order to give her son a better future? I enjoyed the book, and it definitely held some surprises, but I didn't really like or identify with Rose O'Connell, which (for me) makes it harder to engage with the book. However, one of my biggest issues with Rose throughout most of the book became an "ah-hah" later (I always try to avoid spoilers, so I won't say anything more than that), and for that I give the author kudos.

Was this review helpful?