While there were a lot of interesting elements at work in this book, it overall was just unfortunately not for me. It took a while for things to build up, and it made my interest in the mystery weaker, even when things started ramping up. I found the historical aspect the most interesting. I also found the narration of both Casey and Sutton draining, even as an audiobook,

I’m so glad I finally got around to reading this book. It was definitely a wild ride. I stated in a previous review that thrillers about sisters where one goes missing is something that seems to really capture my attention. This book was no exception.

I feel like this book took it a step further and included the missing sister, Sutton, being found. She returns home but isn’t acting the same as before. I liked how Casey was wary of her since they didn’t get along prior to Sutton’s disappearance and now Sutton only wanted Casey by her side.

I found myself trying to guess the ending. I had no idea what was in store. I definitely didn’t expect it and for whatever reason, it totally worked for me. I hope to see some of my fellow bookstagrammers read this one just so we can discuss it. I will definitely check out more from this author in the future.

Unfortunately The Shadow Sister was not the book for me. I was really excited by the synopsis but I found the start of the book to be slow and I lost interest. After attempting to continue with the story a few times, I was unable to finish reading it.

I don’t typically read speculative fiction or fantasy, so this book was a new reading experience. I loved the concept of a teen who goes missing under suspicious circumstances and reappears under even more questionable circumstances. In this book, Casey’s disappearance and reappearances raises questions that no one is really prepared to answer. The pacing of the plot is manageable, and there aren’t noticeable plot holes. The fantastical element isn’t overly predictable, but to someone new to the genre, it can be a lot to keep up with. Overall, enjoyable read.

Thank you for the ARC Copy of The Shadow Sister. This was a fun thriller fantasy to read and I thought it was a great story. I loved all the characters and I thought they all had a great connection and I could feel it as I read it. This one just flowed very well and was a great book for a YA one.

Unfortunately this one just want for me. I thought it had potential but I just couldn't get into it as much as I hoped for.

Told from a dual-perspective split between two sisters: Casey and Sutton. The novel opens with Casey managing her family's expectations of how she should manage her sisters' disappearance after a run with Andrew--she is furious but cannot let it show. Sutton manufactures a trip for her jeep to Seattle (via Andrew, her ever loyal boyfriend) to settle a score of some kind). There is an element the author maintains, the family legend of their grandma and the bracelet gifted to Sutton that draws readers in and questions what is real.

The story is gripping and the flashbacks to Sutton's POV three years, five years prior, and day of her disappearance maintains a mystery that is hard to put down.

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebooks publishing for an opportunity to read an advanced copy of the book.

Casey and Sutton do not get on, so when Sutton goes missing, she's sure it's just another one of her sister's selfish and dramatic stunts for attention. However, as the days go by, Casey struggles to cope with her warring feelings of hatred towards Sutton, who always seems to get under her skin, and the grief lingering beneath the surface that she may never argue or see her again. When Sutton is found miraculously alive, Casey is relieved, but all is not as it seems, she may be alive, but she doesn't remember anything or anyone. Diagnosed with traumatic amnesia, Sutton only seems to remember one person, Casey. Sure that this is another one of her sister's twisted games, Casey is determined to unearth her sister's deception, delving deeper into the mystery of her disappearance, but things slowly appear to be much more complex than they first appeared.

'The Shadow Sister' is an eerie, disquieting mystery, that captivated me from the very first page. A complex and raw portrayal of sibling rivalry and love, it feels at once relatable and refreshing. Full of beautifully human characters, who grab hold of you and refuse to let go. I adored Casey and Sutton, both stubborn, head-strong and unapologetically themselves, they are two powerful young women.

This story explores some really poignant themes including black history and generational trauma and culture, it's profoundly moving, thought provoking and an incredibly important read. I especially found the items from the families ancestry being immortalised and celebrated, for all they've lost and how hard they've worked to get where they are incredibly touching and so beautiful.

Overflowing with gorgeous and immersive writing, palpable teenage angst, and powerful messages of familial love, trying to figure out who you are, and the strength and unbreakable bond of sisterhood and generational trauma. The last couple of chapters chilled me to my bone. I had to put it down and pace for a little while because I was shocked. I guessed who the perpetrator was early on, but the plot twist actually broke me, and that's when you know it's an astounding and remarkable book.

Yet again, I wrote a book that I shouldn’t have. I thought this book was a fantasy read and instead it was thriller. And usually I like to read thriller books. But I wasn’t into this book. And I didn’t like the characters at all.

I went into this book blind and was slightly confused about the direction it was going. It has a bit of a thriller, mystery, and magical realism all mixed together. It was an interesting read though and I’m happy I finished it.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

This book unfortunately was not for me. There were several parts that I enjoyed especially the the bond of the sisters but the story itself felt disjointed. I had a hard time finishing this book.

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for gifting me an advanced reader copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review and opinion.

I loved this book – incredible read!! It is a bit of a heavy read so TW if you have complicated family relationships. I loved how Casey’s character grew and evolved as the story continued.
Many of us have experienced sibling rivalry. However, to be at odds with your sister and then she goes missing? Once Sutton is found, Sutton all of a sudden is fine with her sister and literally only trusts her. This book was incredible – could not put it down. Thank you NetGalley for the amazing read!

Striking and hard to put down in the second half, this book shocked me. There was a lot to get through that was hard to read on the emotional side—a really tense and competitive relationship between sisters that cleaved through most of the story. However the payoff in the end is big, with Sutton and Casey’s individual transformations worth the read. There are elements of magical realism and rootwork in the text, which I wish were more prominent throughout.

Lily Meade's debut novel, The Shadow Sister, is one of the best debuts I've read in a long time. Perfectly paced with unforgettable characters and thrilling twists, The Shadow Sister is a book you don't want to miss.

I mean, it's fine, or at least an inoffensively dull blade, but there isn't a universe in which you can convince me that teenagers think this...slowly. Meade treats her characters like half-formed, intellectually challenged pod people who gestated in bland soup.

Overall I enjoyed this. Realistic relationships and great characters. My only complaint is the ending, very rushed and felt unfinished

I'm a mood reader and this one just hasn't been in my mood wheelhouse for awhile so it is a DNF for me. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity.

This is a YA story about Casey and her sister Sutton. Sutton is missing at the beginning of the novel and Casey is dealing with her feelings of fear and resentment. When they find Sutton she is a little off. This book has supernatural aspects and twinges of horror to it. The relationship between Casey and Sutton was realistic and complicated. They love each other but hate each. The book also deals with the feelings surrounding being biracial and the way black victims are treated by the media and police vs white victims. Colorism is also discussed.

Lily Meade’s debut novel, “The Shadow Sister,” is a gripping thriller about a missing teen who is not the same when she returns.

When Sutton goes missing, it’s the worst thing that has ever happened to her younger sister Casey. As she tries to help her family find her sister, Casey struggles to keep her emotions—in particular her anger—under control. Sutton had a reputation for being perfect: the popular cheerleader with a devoted boyfriend and the sky as her future’s limit. But people only look for missing Black—and half-Black—girls when they believe they’re helping to save an angel. That’s why Casey can’t tell the truth about Sutton, that she always manipulated everyone around her and even stole a beloved family heirloom from Casey.

To everyone’s relief, Sutton reappears, but she isn’t the same. In Addition to remembering nothing about her old life, there’s one thing unsettling about how she acts now. What happened? As Casey unravels the mystery surrounding Sutton’s disappearance, she begins to learn more about her and starts to realize that she never really knew her sister at all.

“Shadow Sister” was a powerful story about familial bonds and generational trauma. The plot was interesting and had twists and turns that kept me on my toes the whole time. I particularly enjoyed how the chapters switched POVs between Casey and Sutton, showing experiences from their perspective. The addition of two unreliable narrators added to the mystery surrounding Sutton’s disappearance.

My only complaint about “Shadow Sister” is that the ending felt rushed. It felt like at least one chapter was missing, or at least several pages. It ends during a scene, which was disappointing since I wanted to see how it was resolved.

Despite the ending, “Shadow Sister” was a terrific debut novel that tackled some difficult topics regarding race, generational trauma experienced by the descendants of enslaved peoples, and familial bonds.