Member Reviews
2.5 stars rounded up
I was super excited when I received this book for review, it's a cozy mystery set on an Island off the coast of Italy. It follows numerous perspectives, but we mainly follow the perspective of Nonna Maria, who knows everyone and everything about her small town. She is asked to help in solving the disappearance of a high valued piece of jewelry, but also the death of an unidentified woman.
I loved the setting of this story. I was excited to be immersed in the descriptions and details of this village. However, the writing style of this story really did not work for me. This book did not have us following the thought process of the characters, or clues, but each chapter was basically Nonna Maria telling us and handing over what she already found. There was no way for the reader to speculate on who might have done it because there was no back story for us to really get a grasp on other characters until after the fact when evidence was presented.
Finally, Nonna Maria kept talking about her dead husband a handful of times every chapter. It was repetitive and did not need to be in the story that much, we get that she loved him very much. Also she never ate or drank anything especially outside her home which was also brought up a lot. This story was fine I guess, but I found it to be dull and the writing style was not for me.
I received this advanced ebook, via Netgalley. This review is my own honest opinion.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advance copy of this book.
Nonna Maria lives on the island of Ischia in Italy, where there are two cases occupying her time, a necklace that has been reported stolen from Grand Hotel Excelsior, and the second case involves a dead body. It's like a who done it case.
I thoroughly enjoyed this one, mysterious and from Italy. My first read from this author, this mystery kind of story.
Nonna Maria is back to solve more crimes being committed on her beloved island of Ischia. She is a great character, stubborn and fiercely caring, and of course the setting is filled with beautiful views and great food. It's a gentle mystery in the style of the Mma Ramotswe series. I enjoyed the characters’ relationships, which make up the majority of this book.
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley.
This is the second in a wonderful series about Nonna Maria, an elderly grandmother in a small Italian city. She loves her family and friends and is well-respected in the community. In addition to being a great cook, she has helped the police solve a number of crimes.
When a visitor to the island claims that an expensive necklace has been stolen, Nonna Maria's talents are called to the fore. It is no surprise that she ultimately solves the crime, but the journey is highly enjoyable for the reader.
I look forward to future Nonna Maria cases.
Nonna Maria and the people of Ischia are some of my favorite characters in mystery literature these days and this new adventure is a fabulous follow up to the first in the series.
The close knit community combined with Nonna Maria’s quick with and cunning mind put me in mind of an Italian Miss Marple, where a deep knowledge of human nature and logical thinking pave the way for solutions to the problems. Here, Nonna works out the life story of an unidentified woman found dead on the roadside, but also saves her goddaughter from a bogus charge of theft. In both instances, Nonna knows the human compulsions and foibles that form the basis for both murder and fraud, and she uses that knowledge to flush out the guilty parties.
Mystery readers looking for a Marple-esque series for the 21st century will enjoy Carcaterra’s series.
Recommended.
NONNA MARIA AND THE CASE OF THE STOLEN NECKLACE
Lorenzo Carcaterra
A cozy mystery at the start of summer? Only if it’s set in Italy.
In this installment of Lorenzo Carcaterra’s Nonna Maria novels Nonna is contacted by her goddaughter who is being accused of a crime. Elsewhere in the city of Ischia a woman turns up dead with very few clues as to who the murderer is. But have faith Nonna is on both cases. And surely if anyone can solve it, she can.
I was won over by Nonna Maria and her amateur sleuthing ways. At first, I admit Nonna Maria was a little annoying. She has a particular way of going about things which to me looks a lot like hindering a police investigation. And it took a while into the book before I turned off my annoying inner voice and just enjoyed the book.
The writing is cozy and transportive. It is a great book for armchair travelers as there is a lot of descriptions of the area and the characters themselves are walking billboards for the small town. Their demeanors seemed different, they talked at a slower pace and talked of things seen by sitting still and being observant.
Nonna goes about solving the cases in a series of logical next steps and conclusions come by thoughtful observation. It felt somewhat like a traditional mystery without modern ways of solving a crime being used. It reminded me of reading THE TALENTED MR. RIPLEY earlier this year.
Thanks to Netgalley, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, and Bantam for the advanced copy!
NONNA MARIA AND THE CASE OF THE STOLEN NECKLACE…⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I loved rhe first book in this series, but dare I say I got bored of all the scenery and food descriptions ad this one went on? Or maybe I was just frustrated I couldn't enjoy them myself. Either way, it didn't capture me like rhe first.
I requested this book because I have a very special Nonna Maria in my life!
I did not realize that I have read another book from this author. I read Sleepers when I was in a Brad Pitt phase. I mean, who wasn’t?!
It did not disappoint, and I especially fell in love with Nonna Maria. She is witty, sharp, and the backbone of her community.
I enjoyed the interwoven theme of family in this mystery who-done-it x2! I was not expecting to have 2 different mysteries unfold in the book.
While this is a part of a series, it was not necessary to read Book 1, and is a standalone.
I thoroughly enjoyed this one, and plan to pick up Book 1 in this series, for more of Nonna Maria!!
If you love books with Italy as a backdrop, this is for you!
Rating: 3.5 - rounded up
Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for allowing me to provide my unbiased opinion!
Nonna Maria and the Case of the Stolen Necklace is a charming whodunit with a very smart amateur detective!
Nonna Maria lives on the island of Ischia in Italy, where she cooks and bakes and takes care of not only her family, but many other residents of the island as well. Her range of influence goes further, though, into all parts of Italy, as she is one of those people who everyone knows, and earns people's love and respect by doing the right thing (at least most of the time).
There are two cases occupying her time. One is the case mentioned in the title, a necklace that has been reported stolen from Grand Hotel Excelsior. Arianna Conte insists that the maid must have taken it, but, unknown to her, the maid is Nonna Maria's goddaughter, and Nonna Maria isn't going to let her be blamed for something she didn't do.
The second case involves a dead body. Nonna Maria is fairly sure she knows who the dead body is, and if she knows that, she also knows why she was killed and who did it. Nonna Maria feels guilt about her death because she knows that there was something she could have done years ago that might have prevented this death.
This book focuses on the solving of these cases, but it also focuses on Nonna Maria and the other residents of Ischia. I enjoy mysteries that expose the minutiae of daily life in a new place, like this small island in Italy. I had to get used to the rhythm and structure of how this story was told, because it is different from other cozy mysteries. The third-person structure separates you from the character in some ways, but it still makes for a good story.
Thanks to Netgalley for the advance copy of this book.
Nonna Maria's small island of Ischia is suddenly experiencing a crime wave. Her goddaughter is accused of stealing a hotel guest expensive necklace and a body is found on the side of the road. Nonna Maria, who knows everyone, is determined to get to the bottom of both crimes in this charming mystery with a delightful cast of characters. The writing is vivid and draws you into the setting and the characters. This book is a first time read for me by this author, but I will definitely be reading more.
I received this advance review copy from from NetGalley & the publisher for my honest review.
Nonna Maria and the Case of the Stolen Necklace by Lorenzo Carcaterra
Thanks go to the publisher and Netgalley for providing an eARC of this lyrical beautiful "love note" of a novel by an author who is a true artist of the written word.
There are likely only a few of us who didn't experience the innocence-obliterating heartbreak of Carcaterra's bestselling novel, Sleepers, a story you experienced heartbeat-by-heartbeat, along with the youths in the novel (especially during the most painful passages).
If you have not read this author before, this is a wonderful introduction to a uniquely talented writer.
However, if you are already familiar with Carcaterra's writing, this is not the writer of angst-filled drama who you have come to know and love.
Rather, Nonna Maria and the Case of the Stolen Necklace is a love letter of a novel, told in honor of a beautiful soul,a woman who is a protector, a friend, a mother and a grandmother to all who embody the wide group of individuals who are lucky enough to be labeled her friends.
Being one of Nomma Marie's friends is a top designation indeed, one that offers phenomenal cooking, warmth, as well as a unique wisdom borne of vast intelligence and experience, all joined with love, intelligence, honesty and ageless wisdom, such are the traits embodied by Nomma Maria.
Having such a wealth of loved ones nearby allows Nomma Maria to back her wise suggestions with help from her friends who work in various fields, all of who are happily wiling to provide support or assistance at Nonna Maria's request.
lessons, strong espresso (with a hint of
chocolate) and an iron-will combine to make a Nomma Maria someone we should all be lucky enough to have in our lives.
Until next time...
A somewhat cozy mystery set in Ischia, Italy. The location does come to life, but I had a hard time placing the timeframe of the story. It seemed like something that would have happened in the 1960s, but apparently it is set in more modern times. This threw me off as the characters acted like some from many years ago, so it felt less believable.
As a comparison to Miss Marple, I get why they say that, but this was a far different book and not as compelling as Christie's writing.
Read it if you want more of a family drama and beautiful setting, and would enjoy hearing about an Italian grandmother, instead of a true mystery.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this novel,
I dove right into the second book on this series without having read the first when #NetGalley and #RandomHouse offered me an advance readers copy.
After spending several hours with the Nonna Maria I’ve already ordered book 1, and have followed the author so I’ll be alerted when book 3 comes out, we’ve already been given a teaser about it as this book ends.
Nonna Maria has a granddaughter who has been accused of stealing a priceless heirloom necklace from a guest at the hotel where she works as a maid. She also needs to help a young friend determine if he was responsible for the death of a woman whose body was found along side the road. Living on the small Italian island of Ischia, Nonna Maria has a network of family and friends, including the police captain, who help her find the answers to solve the mysteries. I enjoyed that she isn’t just a perfect little old lady, but one who has her dark side, is willing to befriend those with questionable pasts, admits to being imperfect and feels guilt for not having always done the right thing. Oh, and wine, and espresso. She certainly enjoys those. Her only trait I couldn’t relate to was her not eating or drinking anything at the wonderful restaurants described. Imagine sitting in a sun drenched garden looking over the sparkling sea and not enjoying any of the fresh seafood! Nonna Maria does cook up fabulous foods herself, so don’t read this when you’re hungry.
A wonderful mystery when you’re in the mood to travel via your book, I’m happy to have been introduced to her.
Nonna Maria’s goddaughter has been charged with stealing a necklace and has lost her job as cleaning staff in one of the prominent hotels on the island of Ischia. Nonna Maria tends to know almost everyone. She wonders about a necklace that no one has seen. She also is involved in a side case of a woman killed and left by the side of the road. There’s a lot of charm in these mysteries. And Nonna Maria is an old-time village sleuth. I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
A Satisfyingly Cozy Mystery
Nonna Maria is the most delightful amateur sleuth to come along in a long time. She approaches every interview with a basket of food and perceptive questions. That is why everyone on the tiny island of Ischia turns to Nonna Maria in times of trouble.
Nonna Maria and the Case of the Stolen Necklace is the second Nonna Maria book by Lorenzo Carcaterra. I enjoyed this one so much I have downloaded the first and can’t wait to spend a lazy afternoon with Nonna Maria. I don’t know how she finds the time to make all the delicious food she is always giving family and friends, but I sure wish I was one of the lucky recipients.
The author and characters of this ARC were totally new to me. I quickly was engaged by Nonna Maria and her story. She's definitely a quirky character and one you will stay up late reading. The author has a smooth style and moves you right along. Everything you need to know is enfolded into the action. I was left with a feeling of completion and am a new fan of Nonna Maria.
Nonna Maria's goddaughter has been accused of stealing a very expensive necklace from a guest at the hotel she works at. Nonna Maria knows she is innocent, but how to prove it? A stolen necklace isn't the only mystery. A woman is found dead on the side of the road. No one knows who she is or why she is in Ischia. Nonna Maria thinks she might know the answer to both questions and even perhaps who killed her.
Nonna Maria and the Case of the Stolen Necklace is the second book in the Nonna Maria cozy mystery series. You don't have to read book 1 to enjoy this book, but they are quick, fun reads so you might want to read them both. Check out my review of book 1.
This series is a great read for summer. I felt like I took a little vacation every time I picked up the book. The descriptions of this small island in southern Italy made me feel like I was just there. There are also a number of mentions of coffee and wine - I don't drink coffee but I found that I wanted to pour a glass of wine while reading the story.
If you saw my Mother's Day post about memorable mothers in fiction, you saw that I included Nonna Maria on the list. I love this character. She is amusing but not in the usual quirky cozy mystery way. Yes, she has some quirks like she won't eat or drink anything except that which comes from her kitchen. She is amusing in the way mature women are when they no longer care what people think or social conventions.
Both mysteries are interesting. The book would have been good even if the stolen necklace was the only mystery to be solved. But the murder of the woman gave us a look into Nonna Maria's past and provided background on the town.
If you are ready for a vacation but can't right now, take a book vacation with this book.
My review will be published at Girl Who Read on Wednesday, May 17 - https://www.girl-who-reads.com/2023/05/nonna-maria-and-case-of-stolen-necklace.html
A fun mystery. This is from an experience author and he knows how to create a good plot and interesting characters. Nicely done.
Thanks very much for the free copy for review!!
It was such a delight to return to Ischia with Nonna Maria.
This book has two separate mysteries that Nonna Maria, in her unique way of talking to people, helps solve.
I love how everyone on Ischia wants to help her. There is of course the odd one here or there that doesn’t really like Nonna Maria, but that is to be expected.
Between the descriptions of food and of the island, I found myself wanting to travel there.
I love the way this series seems to also be slowly revealing parts of Nonna Maria’s life. Her love for her friends and family is one of my favorite parts about these books.
The set up for the next mystery at the end has me anxiously awaiting the next installment.
Thank you to Random House for the copy of this book. All views are my honest opinion.
This is the second story in this series that I have read. Although you can read both of them as stand-alones. The author makes me want to be a part of this community. I love it when an author can make you feel like that. I love all the characters and how they interact with each other. It’s seems like such a loving community. If you like mystery and suspense, I believe you would like this story, and I can’t wait till the next one comes out.
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley. This is my honest and voluntary review.