Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley and publisher for the free copy. Here is my honest review.

TW: blood, graphic description of death, gore, mutilation, physical torture and abuse, cannibalisms, mental illness, depression, strong language.

This book was absolutely amazing! It griped me from the start, brought me to tears and left me with a massive book hangover. I read it in 3 days and that is something because my usual time for a book of this format is 2 weeks.

The writing style of Edward Cambal is easy to fall into in just couple of pages. There are some weak spots and a lot of repetition which was slightly annoying somewhere in the middle but then it became clear why the repetition is in place and it was all explained so just stick with it. It will make sense.

I love Anthem from the start. A lonely man who saves people from the monsters? Hello dystopian Geralt of Rivia! But as I read on he also felt a lot like Blade. In the end I have to say that Anthem is a unique character. With his believes and family values he always tries to do the best he can. As the plot progresses he learns new information and grows with the knowledge. He changes and it was amazing to watch. One thing I would point out as his flaw is his naivety. He trusted too easy, too fast and it usually worked against him.

The worldbuilding was very well done. I love the book style of "egg shell" - I mean you start in a one small location and learn everything about this place and then the book opens up the wider world. This was well done and I enjoyed every bit. The reader starts in the city of Atlas, the last surviving society in the world. The city felt small, in decay and somehow two dimensional but still very vivid and functional. Things like food supply and lam lighting are explained which give perfect sense of functioning city.

Main theme of this book were of course the monsters - Shivers. These monster would just randomly appear for some people and live with them. Follow them with just one goal. Eat their hosts alive. They had a hunger that nothing could stop. These Shivers were characters. They looked different, behaved slightly different and felt different. Their constant presence in the book was fully supporting the dystopian vibes.

But we have to address the metaphor here. Because the Shivers were symbolizing mental illness, depression, sadness, loneliness, stress... 'we all have the monsters in our shadows". What I found absolutely amazing what how the society of Atlas treated people with Shivers. The people of Atlas would ignore them, not even look at the monster following them. They would not acknowledge their presence. And when a person with a Shiver walled in a most people retrieved to safety, frowned or called the shiver disgusting thing. The stigma of society treating the mental in this way was so perfectly portraited. And thanks to all this effort at the start of the book I loved the progress Anthem made. How he befriended his Shiver, and honestly there was a scene at the end where he carried an injured woman to safety and his knee failed to support him, his Shiver was at his side to prevent the fall.... I WAS SOBBING! YES!

This book was dark, heavy, gory and full of horrors but it was also full of hope, strength and persistence.

Was this review helpful?

This book was disappointing. I felt that the protagonist's optimistic outlook for the entire book given the horror around him was completely ridiculous. For a dystopian novel, Anthem was far too trusting of people, especially the mysterious man in power, The Architect, to follow through on promises and that he really had the good of the people at heart. The man lives in a cemetery for crying outloud and has goons stationed at the door to keep people out.

I was seriously hoping for some good horror and scary monsters. Instead, I felt let down and at times bored with the story. The heavy weight of depression being represented as an enormous monster that slowly feeds on its host is an excellent metaphor but the backstory of these creatures needed more flushing out. The ending also was not cathartic and left me more annoyed than anything else.

Was this review helpful?

This book was very different from anything I’ve read lately. It was very interesting! I would recommend for anyone who wants a bit of fantasy and horror mixed in one. Fast paced read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced ARC of this book! This was one of the more thrilling and horrifying books I’ve read in a while.

The whole universe is built so well and it’s a terrifying imagining of a world where your mental health follows and devours you. The ‘monsters’ in the shadows follows characters and can devour them - this is a great comparison to how stress and our own personal monsters can devour us if it’s not held in check.

This was a gruesome story full of horror + thrills and it was an amazing debut novel!

Was this review helpful?

This was a really profound read, the mix of mental health and existentialism, with the gore and horror was really wuite incredible.
Honestly i need to forget this book so i can read it again and enjoy it again. Ill see it in 6 months.

Was this review helpful?

First of all thank you to netgalley and Edward J Cembal for the opportunity to read The monsters in our shadows.

This isn't my typical genre of choice, but the darkness and gory factors of the book kept me hooked.

I loved the undertones of the book representing the darkness of mental health/depression and how it becomes an all encompassing thing over your life until the day it finally eats you up.

I think anyone who has suffered with mental health will really appreciate this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a bit of a stretch for me as the horror/sci-fi genre is not typically a favorite. That said, the blurb looked like enough of an interesting take to make it with the effort. To set the stage, we have a ruined apocalyptic landscape with enclaves of humans behind walled communities scrambling to survive. From the shadows, a terrifying creature (aka Shivers) emerges that haunts a specific person for a time until its hunger becomes to much prevent it from literally eating its host and if not “exiled” outside of the protective walls by then, going on a rampage devouring anybody else nearby. While there are some obvious analogies and symbolism from these shadow horrors, my interest was more on the basic story that follows Anthem, the city "Exilist" (aka The Reaper) who was responsible for making sure the afflicted were “escorted” out through the city walls into the deadlands before the Shiver goes nuts. Having a Shiver is always a death sentence … it is only a matter of time.

Anthem has a daughter … and his own Shiver, so the clock is ticking to find the truth. Does the Architect (ruler of the City of Atlas) have the answers? Maybe that is why not a single member of that family has ever been “exiled.” Or maybe the truth is outside the walls in the Deadlands. There is a mystery here (and a dark secret); however, you can’t figure it out on your own, so you are left to the whims each tantalizing encounter that keeps Anthem's apocalyptic "hero's journey" from being completely hopeless. If you enjoyed The Road, this story is probably right up your alley. Truthfully it is the end that makes this any good for me, with the obvious nod to depression and the hope contained therein; however, as mentioned above … this was not for me, so I am rounding my final score up.

I was given this free advance reader copy (ARC) ebook at my request and have voluntarily left this review.

#TheMonstersInOurShadow #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Net Galley & Edward Cembal for an eARC of this book for an honest review.

Dystopian/Horror/ Sci-Fi

I need to preface this review with the fact that this book does have some dark themes, but I can't begin to say how much I loved this. Just the sheer concecpt of this book is *Chef's Kiss* and as someone who struggles with some of the themes in this book, is it very appreciated. This story has nestled into my heart & I won't soon forget it. My only compliant is that as the story starts to ramp up, our main character goes mentally from feeling like the 40(ish) year-old that he is, to almost a 20-25 year old.

I'll definitely be on the lookout for more works from this author in the future

Was this review helpful?

Note to Publisher: I have not yet written my review but need to get this feedback posted.

What I will be saying to my audience is that this book is really different, unique and took me by surprise. I have a hard time finding books I can't get away from and this was definitely one of those rare ones. I wish I had it on audiobook as well so I could continue the story while working and sleeping.

These days you find a lot of similar stories and retellings of classics. This was absolutely one of a kind. I've never read anything like it. The Monsters in our Shadows is extremely well written. I found I could relate to Anthem; He cared a lot about the exiled and was determined to find a way to save everyone. Kept me at the "edge of my seat".

Though unlikely, I wish to one day see this on the big screen or as a series. I've already started asking people to prepare for release. I rarely give 5/5 stars but this book deserves it. I love how clean the book cover is and can't wait to buy multiple copies to share.

Please sign this writer for 5 more books. I'll be waiting.

Cheers.

Was this review helpful?

I was absolutely BLOWN AWAY by this intensely dark horror book! I read it in one day because I couldn't put it down. I was so drawn into the shadows, I couldn't make my way out until the end, pun intended!

I have always loved suspenseful, dark books, and I was surely not disappointed with The Monsters in our Shadows.

You get the suspense of monsters, who want nothing more than to devour your flesh. And you get the suspense of not knowing who has a monster, who doesn't, who can or will survive, and what the heck is going on with these monsters!! My brain was begging for more with each page, and I was on the edge of my seat, darn well screaming in my brain at everything happening.

This book is a long one, and it is thoroughly thought out, the world building is absolutely amazing, and the character development is just as amazing as well.

I highly suggest that if you like dark suspenseful horror books, that you give The Monsters in our Shadows a read!!

Was this review helpful?

I jumped at this book once I saw that it was a post-apocalyptic one and it has been a while since I read a good book in this genre. But man, the writing, I did not like it. It was really hard to get into this new universe. I understood from the beginning that this is not one of the post-apocalyptic books you would usually read, so maybe that's why it didn't work for me.

Was this review helpful?

I was immediately sucked into this world. They leave in the near future where your dying body Is preyed upon by visible monsters you can see. Ahhhh… nightmare fuel. I liked that the care taker of the dead new their was more to life and loss.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5. This didn’t go where I was expecting after the first few chapters, but that wasn’t a bad thing. Very pleasantly surprised by the ending. Would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

In a world where monsters live in plain sight, salvation is only for those "lucky" enough to be unaffected by them. At it's core MONSTERS is a metaphor for how society still views those who suffer from depression and other mental health crisis.

THE MONSTERS IN OUR SHADOWS is dystopian horror at it's finest.

Thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for my #arc!

Was this review helpful?

The world has monsters. The monsters can be seen. The monsters will kill you. The monsters are called Shivers. Anthem feels he has a purpose and maybe it's figuring out how to kill the monsters.

I really enjoyed this book and it's storyline, as Anthem travels from place to place in his small corner of the world. He sees people struggle and sees people trying to survive. It's poignant that he is doing the same while trying to complete his mission. I felt the pull of the connections he makes throughout his journey. This book is part horror and part self-discovery.

Thank you to @netgalley and Edward J. Cembal for allowing me to read and review The Monster in Our Shadows.

Was this review helpful?

This was a dystopian story in the vein of zombie apocalypse, or contagion sci-fi/horror. There is a contained group for people hiding from/keeping at bay the monsters ultimately seeking the demise of human existence.

Reminded me a lot of I am Legend.

The storytelling was slow paced, but engaging.
The writing style was good, but maybe over narrated.

This isn't really my taste in terms of the type of story I typically enjoy, but it was very good for what it was. If you enjoy monster apocalypse stories I'm sure you would enjoy this.

Thank you to Edward J Cembal and netgalley for a copy of this AaRC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book had me snagged from page one. I’m not typically drawn to the horror genre but for some reason this sang to my soul. And as it turned out it was one I needed to read at a time I didn’t know I needed it. The main characters ability to hold on to his humanity in spite of the nauseating responsibilities and choices he was forced to make had me holding that fragile strand of hope right with him. The dystopian world brought to light what you as a reader expect to see when the world takes a **** and humans are left to embrace their depravity and greed. And it’s not a shocking landscape, we’ve all seen movies or read books showing what would happen when things fall however the way the author turns the landscape into something more leaves you contemplating how our current society deals with its own shivers. Enjoy this read and be prepared to loan this book out to everyone you know.

Was this review helpful?

Series Info/Source: This is a stand alone book. I got an eGalley of this book through NetGalley to review.

Thoughts: This was a fast-paced post-apocalyptic novel set in a world where humans are hunted by the Shivers they create. This was easy to read and I enjoyed all the action.

This book follows Anthem, a man assigned with escorting people to the Deadlands once their Shivers can't be held in check anymore. The Shivers are shadow monsters that appear to certain people. At some point, people can't control their Shivers and they have to be exiled so that their Shivers don't break free and kill the rest of the town. This is set in a post-apocalyptic world where very little humanity has survived.

The origin of the Shivers was hinted at but never fully explored. I liked what the author was hinting at but it would have been cool to have that concept expanded on and explained a bit more. The world-building here is fairly sketchy as well, we only see a small part of the world and we never get a good explanation of how the apocalypse came to pass.

I did enjoy the secrets of the town of Atlas and there is a ton of tense action in here. The writing was easy to read and the book was hard to put down. I just kept struggling with the "how" and "why" behind the Shivers; as I said above, it's a neat idea but I wish it had been fleshed out more.

As with many post-apocalyptic novels, the ending is fairly open and doesn't resolve everything. However, it fits well with the rest of the story.

My Summary (4/5): Overall I enjoyed this. It's a fast-paced, action-packed, post-apocalyptic read with some excellent twists and turns. I do feel like it's a bit rough around the edges. Some of the concepts in here have potential but weren't fleshed out well. It also has that very unfinished feeling that a lot of post-apocalyptic novels tend to have. If you are looking for an action-packed post-apocalyptic novel full of strange monsters, I would recommend this. I will definitely be keeping an eye open to see what Cembal writes next.

Was this review helpful?

If this isn't in your to-be-read pile, it should be.

Nothing beats a great opening scene. This book has a killer introduction to the world. There is an atmosphere of fear that the author grips into our heads. More than once I found myself going "Who is this author?" For a debut, this is stellar.

I saw others mentioning the pacing as being on the slow side. I don't agree. I feel that the pacing adequately relates to what is going on naturally within the story. It sets the tone. I love creepiness and constant danger. Is it really slow if something deadly is always lurking right around the corner? Then once the world opens up to us, the pace quickens with the struggle to survive. It's delightful.

Overall, the book achieved telling the story it was determined to tell and I'd say it's worth checking out.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for this ARC, in exchange for an honest review!

I absolutely loved this book. I am a big horror/sci-fan, and this delivered on every front. I can honestly say that there wasn’t a single thing that I disliked. I loved Anthem’s character development, the world-building, and the creepy atmosphere; I was constantly on the edge of my seat! I would recommend for others to go into this blind to really get the most out of the story! I couldn’t put the book down, and used every amount of free time to get a few chapters in! The plot had constant twists and turns that I never saw coming! This is easily my favorite book of the year so far, and it will take A LOT to knock it down from its pedestal. To the author, Edward J. Cembal, I will be the first to pounce on anything that you write in the future!

Was this review helpful?