The One That Got Away with Murder was an average YA thriller for me. It had the usually teen angst and drama, but I constantly forgot this was YA. There was so much talk of drugs, sex, and drinking, plus the way the characters spoke, that it felt like they were college age instead of high school. It felt way too adult to be a YA book, so I was constantly pulled out of the story.

I also had an issue with the main romance. There was little chemistry between the characters, so that part of the story was pretty boring. The drama between the girls on the soccer team was ok-my interest ebbed and peaked throughout the story- but the pacing was the best part of this novel.

I half listened to/half read this book, so I would highly recommend picking up the audiobook. The narrator does a good job of bringing the main character to life and capturing my interest more than when I read the book with my eyes.

*Thank you to NetGalley, Macmillan’s Children’s Publishing Group and Macmillan Audio for both the digital and audio arc. All opinions are my own.

Not a groundbreaking thriller, but it was still fun.
Lauren is starting senior year at a new school after a tragedy at her old one. She finds herself involved with one of two brothers accused of murdering their girlfriends, but what is the truth? As she digs to clear her own name and his, she reveals family secrets and the true murderer.
The pacing was a little slow and I got bored through certain parts. The mystery wasn't at the forefront enough to make it interesting and the characters were not interesting enough to drive the story on their own. The ending was lackluster and there was no real resolution. This book is good for people looking for a low key thriller beach read.

The One That Got Away with Murder is a sharp, addictive thriller that had me flipping pages like I was chasing secrets myself. Trish Lundy blends dark academia vibes with a twisty narrative full of tension, betrayal, and the haunting power of memory. The main character is flawed and fascinating, and the lines between guilt and grief blur in the best possible way. This story asks what it means to survive and what you become when you do. Moody, smart, and totally unputdownable. Perfect for fans of secrets buried under privilege and the cost of uncovering the truth.

This was a fun, YA thriller. And an amazing debut for Trish Lundy!

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!

This story touched a bit of everything, thrill, eating disorders, sex, drugs, and of course MURDER. While the story started a little slow, by the end, I wasn’t able to put it down to find out what really happened!

This book was so fun and fast paced! I didn’t see the ending coming and I would definitely read this author again!

Lauren only needs to get through her senior year and she can disappear at a college in another place and start over. Hooking up with Robbie Crestmount was only meant to help pass the time, but when the girls from the soccer team tell her about the tragic deaths connected to Robbie and his brother, she isn't sure what to believe. Heading to Robbie's lake house for one last weekend before she breaks it off for good, keeps her head down and powers through senior year she accidentally stumbles upon evidence that implicates Robbie without question. Not knowing who to trust, Lauren realizes that the killer thinks she knows a little too much.

Good YA/Teen drama suspense book in the vein of Karen McManus.

I really enjoyed this one! It was fun and the big reveal got me! It was an easy read and kept me intrigued the whole time. So being entertained and surprised, what more could I ask for?

This is an edge-of-your-seat debut YA thriller about a teen who is forced to confront her past to catch a murderer before she ends up the next victim. This one is Perfect for fans of Karen McManus and Holly Jackson.

The One That Got Away With Murder follows Lauren, a newcomer trying to escape her troubled past. She soon gets involved with Robbie, a guy with a reputation—both he and his brother, Trevor, are under suspicion for the mysterious deaths of their ex-girlfriends. The entire town believes the brothers are killers and warns Lauren to stay away. But Lauren has other ideas. Instead of backing off, she’s determined to uncover the truth. Is she dating a murderer, or is someone else responsible?

The plot is full of unexpected twists and turns, keeping you guessing until the very end. Just when you think you’ve figured it out, another surprise hits. I was completely taken off guard by the ending—it’s a thrilling read that’s impossible to put down.

My only critique is that some of the minor characters could have been more developed, such as Lauren's Mom and her mom's boyfriend Mark.

Okay, so I just finished The One That Got Away with Murder by Trish Lundy, and wow – what a ride! Seriously, I couldn't put it down. Lauren's situation – trying to lay low after a traumatic experience, only to get tangled up with the possibly-murderous Robbie – is just the kind of drama I love. Lundy does a great job of building the suspense and keeping you guessing about Robbie's involvement. I was flipping pages like crazy trying to figure out what really happened. Honestly, my only little niggle is that the ending felt a bit too tidy. Things wrapped up a little too neatly, you know? I kinda wanted a bit more. But overall, this book is a total winner for anyone who loves a good YA thriller. Definitely recommend!

Big thanks to NetGalley and Trish Lundy. All thoughts are my own.

I enjoyed this YA mystery. The characters were intriguing and I enjoyed all the plot twists. It was suspenseful and kept me engaged the whole time.

I'm honestly just so confused by what I just read.... What the heck was that ending?! It ended with a twist, but not in a good way. There was no explaination or supporting evidence to allow readers to understand why it ended the way it did. This book makes me wish I would have read it in print instead of an ebook so I could throw it across the room.

Thanks to NetGalley and Henry Holt & Company for my advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own

3.5 Stars. Thanks to Netgalley and Macmillan Children's Publishing Group for the E-ARC. This had total AGGGTM vibes but different and I was here for it. It had short chapters which made it such a breeze to read. I was super into it trying to figure out who dun it the whole way. I was engaged till the very end and the twist were twisting I was totally here for this.

Trish Lundy’s The One That Got Away is a psychological thriller that offers plenty of suspense, but may leave you with a few lingering questions. It’s like the perfect date: charming and full of promise, but by the end, you’re left wondering if it’s going anywhere—or if it was all just a little too convenient.

The story follows Abby, whose life is turned upside down when she reconnects with her ex, and soon becomes entangled in a dangerous game of cat and mouse. The premise is intriguing—a mix of romance, psychological tension, and mystery. As Abby unravels the truth about her past relationship, things start to spiral, and suddenly, the one that got away becomes something much more sinister.

Lundy’s writing is sharp and propulsive. The pacing is quick, with short, snappy chapters that keep the pages turning. The suspense is certainly there, with enough twists to make you raise an eyebrow (or two). The tension between Abby and the people around her feels real, and Lundy captures the confusion and paranoia of being stuck in a situation where you don’t know who to trust.

However, the characters, while interesting, sometimes feel a bit too one-dimensional. Abby, as the protagonist, has a few moments of relatable vulnerability, but her decisions can be frustratingly impulsive. The pacing of the story is fast, but at times, the plot feels a bit too convenient for its own good. The big reveal, while satisfying, isn’t as jaw-dropping as you might hope.

The One That Got Away is an entertaining thriller with enough twists to keep you hooked, but don’t expect it to leave you with your mind blown. It’s a fun ride, but one that might not stick with you long after you finish. Perfect for a weekend binge—just don’t expect it to be the one that stays on your shelf forever.

Wonderful story, great character development, great writing! Highly recommend this book. I thoroughly enjoyed it

Read 4/12/24

4.5 stars
I was a very, very good kid. My parents have no idea how lucky they are. This was a wild story. The fact that these kids were doing this stuff when they were 14/15 blows my mind. Also, I kind of guessed who the bad guy was; there's just no way they were THAT nice. I'm also very glad the reason they moved wasn't left open in the end, but I wasn't expecting the cause of the fire to be what it was.

A fun and interesting thriller

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this review copy and the opportunity !

The One That Got Away with Murder was an intriguing, twisty, kept-me-on-the-edge-of-my-seat kind of read. The story was suspenseful and engaging, and had me guessing until the end. And that ending- who would have ever thunk it!

This was a great debut and I can't wait to see what's to come from Trish Lundy.

Really enjoyed. Captivating mystery/thriller. If you’re a fan of Holly Jackson then I definitely recommend. The twists and turns were everything.

I received an ARC of The One That Got Away with Murder by Trish Lundy through NetGalley. This was my first time reading this author, and while the book had some intriguing elements, it didn't fully meet my expectations. The story follows Lauren O'Brian, a high school senior who moves to Happy Valley, Pennsylvania, for a fresh start after a scandal at her previous school. She quickly becomes entangled with Robbie Crestmont, a wealthy and enigmatic classmate. Robbie and his brother Trevor are suspected of being involved in the deaths of their ex-girlfriends, Victoria Moreno and Jess Ebenstein. As Lauren's relationship with Robbie deepens, she discovers evidence that might implicate him in the murders. With danger closing in, Lauren must navigate a web of secrets and lies to uncover the truth before she becomes the next victim. Lauren's journey begins with her move to Happy Valley, where she hopes to escape her troubled past. She starts a no-strings-attached relationship with Robbie, but soon learns about the dark rumors surrounding him and his brother. The plot thickens when Lauren finds incriminating evidence at Robbie's family lake house, leading her to question his innocence. As she digs deeper, she uncovers a series of shocking secrets that put her life at risk. The story builds to a tense climax as Lauren races to piece together the truth and protect herself from becoming another cautionary tale. While The One That Got Away with Murder offers a compelling premise and well-developed characters, some plot twists felt predictable, and the pacing could have been tighter. Lauren's character is relatable, and her struggle to reconcile her feelings for Robbie with the mounting evidence against him adds depth to the narrative. However, the story's reliance on familiar tropes and a somewhat rushed conclusion detracted from the overall experience. Despite its flaws, the book's strong character dynamics and suspenseful moments kept me engaged. Fans of YA thrillers and mysteries might find this book an interesting read, even if it doesn't fully deliver on all fronts. I would consider reading more from Trish Lundy in the future. #netgalley #theonethatgotawaywithmurder