Member Reviews

The premise of this one was quite interesting, and I enjoyed the way that the author incorporated the past and present timelines. The reveal of information between the timelines was balanced well and helped to maintain interest throughout the read. The use of the folklore and rhyme was also incorporated quite well and added some spookiness of the read. That being said, the horror aspect was kind of underwhelming (the only true horror came from how awful the adults acted in the book) and I don’t think the supernatural element was handled quite as well as it could have been.

Themes of this story focus on repressing your true self to keep others happy, struggling with sexual identity, acceptance of yourself and family, and more. These themes were handled well, and I enjoyed how they affected different characters in different and similar ways.

While I wouldn’t classify this as a work of horror, I do still recommend this if you enjoy YA stories that focus on queerness, identity, and friendship. My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Group for allowing me to read this work. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to review this book.

Told in dual timelines with 3 POVs, this is the story of two young women who are coming to terms with their identity.

I loved a lot of the ideas in this book. I found it dark and a little creepy, but also repetitive. The story is in the present with Jaq and Fern, as well as in the past, when Jaq, Fern, and Mallory are 13. What really disrupted my reading of this book was that age jump. The past chapters do not read like young girls. I have a daughter that is about to turn 13, and she's nowhere near that grown. Those chapters read like an older teen, so there's really no distinction in tone between 13 year old characters and the 18 year old characters they are now. It was quite distracting.

Was this review helpful?

The characters in this novel felt so real, from the main characters and their struggles with their identities to their parents reacting to their children coming out. The horror aspects were creepy without seeming over-the-top, and the villain was revealed at the perfect moment. The only issue with it is that the ending seemed pretty abrupt.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't feeling this one and after reading some reviews, I decided to walk away rather than lower the rating of a book that I would recommend to someone who is looking for a story about growing up having to hide your queer self. Or just learning about how to accept yourself in a society that doesn't want you.

This book would have been a fantastic contemporary look into growing up queer in an overly conservative/queerphobic world. It's the horror/mystery parts that were really lacking for me. Honestly, I was a bit bored. I can see how people are rating this highly and I understand why they are liking it but for me, it just wasn't a great execution of blending the two.

Was this review helpful?

3.65 stars. I thought Fern and Kaitlyn were so cute. I liked the other ship too but not as much. This was an interesting story and the characters were written well with progressive storylines! Leave it to an ancient dead man to steal your gay.

Was this review helpful?

This story explores themes of queer self-erasure, conversion therapy, and coming out in an unsupportive environment.

It's a very interesting horror novel where the horrors are both real and supernatural, sometimes at the same time. The story follows two teens, Jaq, a lesbian, and Fern, who is non-binary. Years ago, they were best friends--along with a girl named Mallory--but when the story takes place, they're near strangers living straight-passing lives and not remembering anything any different.

As their past starts to haunt them, they reconnect, remembering Mallory and who they really are.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for providing the e-arc for me to read! Honestly though I struggled with this book. I found myself putting it down over and over. I did not find the characters very engaging and wanted so much more from it.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely devoured this book.

I really enjoy queer horror, especially when the horrors of real-life are so accurately portrayed and blended with the supernatural elements.
Natalie C. Parker did a fantastic job with all of the characters and had me completely sucked in.
This was chilling, emotional, and a bit hopeful in just the right amounts.
I hope the folks who need this book find their way to it.

Thank you to Netgalley and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group for the opportunity to read an eARC of this book.
All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

“A message from God that He was still here for her. This was the symbol that had brought her so much comfort for so many years, promising unconditional love and redemption for trespasses. Except, it was conditional. She’d just seen it in the community room, in the eyes of her parents. She’d heard it in the voices of her friends. The conditions may not exist in Heaven, but here they were violent and biting.”

The representation in this novel was really great! It's classified as a YA horror, but I think its more a queer coming of age with horror elements. The biggest portion of the novel is devoted to girls discovering themselves and the girls they love/loved. There are creepy parts, but the more horrific elements is the homophobia and the fear of what would happen they accept who they actively are. With parents who weaponize religion, and even parents who are TERFs obsessed with femininity. I think now, in this year of 2024 books like this are so important in light of the climate here in America. When queer people feel like they are unsafe just being alive.

I really enjoyed this novel.

Was this review helpful?

The story follows Fern and Jaq, who, five years after their friend Mallory’s mysterious disappearance, are now haunted by a spirit resembling Mallory.
The chilling presents forces them. To confront their past. and their true selves
This is a gripping LGBTQIA+ YA horror novel that masterfully blends supernatural elements with poignant themes of identity and friendship.
If you enjoy a mix of horror and heartfelt storytelling, this book is definitely worth a read

Was this review helpful?

I love a good queer horror story but I really loved this one because instead of being scary, the real world was more the terror. Acceptance is the main focus of the book & I loved that. I know I say it a lot but THIS is the book I needed when I was younger.

Thank you to NetGalley & the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Queer ya horror novel
2 girls are trying to be forced to conform to what society wants. When they were younger something happened to them that they can quite remember.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this! The characters are likable and it's paced good. This is a unique horror book that I would recommend! Special Thank You to Natalie C. Parker, Penguin Group and NetGalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 3.5 stars!

I originally picked up this book because I thought it was going to fall in line with a "haunted house" story. The story instead is a heartbreaking telling of a group of friends figuring out how to navigate their lives despite their parents and influences in their lives. The house in the woods feels more like a secondary part of the story, but overall its a hauntingly deep story that will have you flying through the book.

Thank you NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Penguin Young Readers Group for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I really really hate DNF’ing books, but I just really couldn’t get into it. I thought it was very boring, and unfortunately the writing style wasn’t for me.

Was this review helpful?

Come Out Come Out was a solid read. It alternated between the current day perspectives of Jack and Fern, as well as flashbacks from Mallory as they all try to come to terms with what happened to them in the woods as young teens. Jaq and Fern's lives are upended as they suddenly "wake up" and realize their adolescence has not fully been in their control. and their town legend of the Patron is not as generous as they initially thought.

The characters were likeable, though at times Jaq acted like Fern and Fern like Jaq. Their voices/behaviors were similar. The setting worked for the story. And scarier than the big bad were Mallory and Jaq's families, which made the theme of found family was bittersweet. While not exactly groundbreaking, it treated Jaq and Fern's identities with care, and there are kids who will see themselves in Jaq, Fern, and Mallory.

Many thanks to the publisher for the ARC via Netgalley!

Was this review helpful?

Loved this story a lot, super fun, and obsessed with Kaitlyn and Fern. The only issue is that some of the characters were supportive all in the same way, John, Cam, Devyn, Kaitlyn. Thet were confronting in a "I know you have something you want to say, but I'll be here when you're ready" which felt one dimensional so I would of liked more different approaches to showing support. The story felt short for some reason, but I had a lot of fun with it, so maybe that's why

Was this review helpful?

For the past five years, Jaq and Fern believed their friend Mallory ran away from home. They’re now enjoying their senior year of high school – Jaq plans a future with her longtime boyfriend, and Fern hopes to follow in her sisters’ footsteps to a career in theater. Until Mallory’s ghost appears to both of them and their memories about their last night together gradually return – along with realizations about who they really are. Jaq is a lesbian and Fern is nonbinary. Sadly, their small town is full of homophobes, transphobes, and more.

I immediately liked Jaq and Fern, but my heart broke for them over their situations. Both are expected to conform to the expectations of their parents, community, and friends instead of being their true selves. Throughout the course of the novel they face both supernatural and real terrors, although I’d expected a little more emphasis on the paranormal aspects based on the beginning of the novel.

Come Out, Come Out begins as a slow burn before wrapping up with a hopeful ending. With themes of love, friendship, and acceptance, it’s a novel I’d recommend to readers who enjoy coming of age stories.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

**3.5-stars rounded up**

This book has so much to offer, including great rep and an unsettling atmosphere. I really enjoyed meeting these characters and going along on this journey with them.

It wasn't always easy, actually it mostly wasn't easy, but I appreciated how Fern and Jaq both grew over the course of the story. There was some great messaging involved with both of their stories.

I also felt it was a nice balance between the Horror elements and the Contemporary elements. For me, certain issues, mainly the Horror bits, were wrapped up a little too easily in the end, but overall, a strong Queer YA Horror novel!!

Was this review helpful?

This was a chilling yet emotionally charged novel that blends the fears of coming out and horror. In a small town, we meet Fern and Jaq, who seem to lead ordinary lives until they suddenly realize they've been hiding the truth from themselves and the others around them. As they start to explore their feelings and learn more about what was hidden and taken from them by the all-protecting Patron, they band together to fight back for the hope of what their life could be.

Was this review helpful?