Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Editor's note: This roundup is scheduled to publish in Georgia June 11 online and June 14 print in several newspapers. Will also publish in Mississippi and Alabama during the month in newspapers and magazines, timing up to local editors. Link below will be active June 11.

From new series starters (Michael Connelly’s “Nightshade”) to the tried-and-true (Kendra Elliot’s “Her First Mistake”) our beach bag is already overflowing, and what we offer here are just a few — OK, actually 25 — of the best beach reads published through the end of June. Later this season we’ll round out the list, but for now, find an old favorite, a debut thriller or just about anything in between — including a North Alabama favorite who you just might see dining at a Cullman restaurant.

“Vera Wong’s Guide to Snooping on a Dead Man” (Berkley) by Jesse Q. Sutanto: A lovable Chinese tea shop owner stumbles upon a distressed, young woman — and a murder, the investigation of which she decides to serve up herself. With lots of tea and nosy charm, Vera tackles the project unasked as a “favor” to her (hoped for) future daughter-in-law. Sutanto mixes cozy mystery with smart humor and heartfelt moments.

“When She Was Gone” (Blackstone Publishing) by Sara Foster: When a young nanny working for one of Perth’s wealthiest families disappears, a tense investigation unravels the secrets of a seemingly perfect family, forcing everyone to confront the lies they’ve told themselves and each other. Foster delivers a taut, emotionally resonant thriller that lingers. And as expected from Blackstone Publishing, the story itself is packaged beautifully with subtle and tactile cover art: Buy the hardcover of this one.

“Follow Me” (Thomas & Mercer) by Elizabeth Rose Quinn: An eerie digital breadcrumb trail leads a tech-savvy woman into a web of deception and danger. Quinn crafts a smart, suspenseful mystery that taps into our modern fears of surveillance and online identity. “Heathers” meets “The Stepford Wives” in this tale of twin sisters.

“The Book That Held Her Heart” (Ace) by Mark Lawrence: In this final chapter of The Library Trilogy, a mysterious book bridges love, loss and literary magic in a haunting story that defies time and tests the bond between Livira and Evar — one that has never been more taut. Lawrence blends fantasy and emotion in this lyrical, genre-bending tale.

“The Great Pyramids: Collected Stories” (Arcade Publishing) by Frederick Barthelme: This sharp, wry collection captures small-town oddities, human longing and ironic twists with Barthelme’s signature minimalist flair. A masterclass in short fiction that’s both grounded and subtly surreal.

“The Boomerang” (Thomas & Mercer) by Robert Bailey: Big Pharma is on trial as Eli James, chief of staff to the president, attempts to rescue his daughter from a cancer diagnosis while simultaneously stumbling upon a cover up that could affect millions of lives — and more importantly to the bad guys, billions of dollars. Bailey keeps the thrills high and the emotional stakes higher. He also lives with his family in Huntsville — and has been know to visit Cullman County now and then. Let him know what you think of his latest if you see him around town.

“A Thousand Natural Shocks” (Blackstone Publishing) by Omar Hussain: A reporter fleeing his past while investigating a serial killer becomes entangled in a cult that promises a pill to erase his memory. The story turns to a test of time as dark secrets about the cult and the serial killer surface in an attempt to reconcile everything he’s learned with his past — before his memories evaporate.

“My Friends” (Atria Books) by Fredrik Backman: Backman returns with a moving meditation on friendship, aging, the quiet heroism of everyday people and a famous painting picturing an isolated moment of time of three tiny figures sitting at the end of a long pier. Tender, funny and unmistakably human, this is Backman’s most eloquent and lyrical story to date about how lives intersect in unknowable and unpredictable ways. An engaging read from the author of “A Man Called Ove.”

“The Language of the Birds” (Ballantine) by K.A. Merson: Arizona is no average teenager and when she finds a cryptic ransom note, she sets out to solve the riddles — and save her mother. Unwittingly, she becomes entangled in a worldwide treasure hunt that involves a centuries-old secret her father took to his grave. A quirky, surprising story soars in an introspective mystery.

“The Eternal Warrior” (Blackstone Publishing) by Ari Marmell: An immortal fighter who defies even death — an Eternal Warrior — is caught in a conflict that spans centuries, grappling with his past sins and the future of humanity in an attempt to reclaim everything that has slipped from his personal history. Marmell delivers epic fantasy with grit, heart and unrelenting pace.

“Nightshade” (Little, Brown and Company) by Michael Connelly: Done with Bosch and Ballard, at least for now, Connelly’s new series starter centers on another one-name detective, Stilwell. Due to department politics, the Los Angeles County sheriff detective has been exiled to a low-level post on Catalina Island, where he promptly begins to ruffle local feathers as he unearths secrets the natives would rather keep to themselves. Hopefully Connelly’s flair for backstory and depth will surface in future offerings, but for now, our first meeting with Stilwell offers a familiar, fun summer read.

“Kaua’i Storm” (Thomas & Mercer) by Tori Eldridge: In the lush Hawaiian landscape, a repatriated national park ranger uncovers a mystery surrounding the disappearance of her two cousins. Unfortunately for her, it’s a mystery and investigation that neither the family, the locals nor the police truly want exposed. Eldridge blends action and cultural depth in a uniquely tropical thriller.

“Rockets’ Red Glare” (Blackstone Publishing) by William Webster and Dick Lochte: A high-octane political thriller unfolds against the backdrop of a potentially explosive Fourth of July. Lochte’s sharp storytelling and fast pacing make for a perfect July 4 holiday page-turner. The book is the first in a series with Tribal Police Deputy Sage Mendiluze. Reacher and Pickett fans will find common ground here.

“Written on the Dark” (Ace) by Guy Gavriel Kay: Kay returns with an evocative, elegant historical fantasy set in a world where poetry, memory and fate collide. Centering on a tavern poet who must cater to both rogues and courtiers, Thierry Villar must also navigate churning political waters in a game of assassins and armies. Richly imagined and beautifully told storytelling.

“A Dead Draw” (Thomas & Mercer) by Robert Dugoni: In book 11 of the Tracy Crosswhite series, a pair of cold cases stir ties to the murder of Tracy’s sister in the form of suspect Erik Schmidt. When Schmidt is freed due to an investigative error, the lives of her friends and family are under direct threat. Schmidt is a master of taunt and tease as he draws Tracy deeper into his dark world. Wonderful character building in this story and the sensitive drawing of Lydia, a young woman on the spectrum whose mannerisms echo those of Tracy’s murdered sister, is exceptionally done. One of Dugoni’s best works, the author brings in just enough backstory to both start the series here, and reward long-time readers with vintage Crosswhite.

“The Martha’s Vineyard Beach and Book Club” (Ballantine Books) by Martha Hall Kelly: In a story told through dual timelines, Kelly’s narrative is a personal ode to her mother’s heritage. Involving a contemporary mystery, set at Martha’s Vineyard, whose only answers will come from the past, the story taps a wartime romance set in 1942 — and a beach read written for today. Kelly is touring extensively for this book through the end of July. Meet up with her at marthahallkelly.com/events/.

“The Turn” (Blackstone Publishing) by Christopher Ransom: An heirloom, of sorts, following his father’s death sends Casey Sweet into his dad’s past — and a current country club where Casey might just have met the long-lost son he never knew he had. Written in the tradition of “Caddyshack,” Ransom’s new novel is an engaging summer break.

“The Afterlife Project” (Podium Publishing) by Tim Weed: Humanity is facing extinction. A group of scientists with the capability to send a test subject 10,000 years into the future. One of the last women on Earth capable of getting pregnant. All of this portends that the survival of humankind is at stake in a futuristic setting evoking the ills of today.

“It Takes a Psychic” (Berkley) by Jayne Ann Krentz writing as Jayne Castle: A psychic investigator — actually, a para-archeologist — with a flair for romance and the paranormal dives into a case filled with danger and sizzling chemistry. Castle delivers her signature mix of mystery charm in a story centering on a long-dead cult leader and illicit paranormal experiments. “It Takes a Psychic” is No. 18 in Castle’s A Harmony Novel series.

“The Ghostwriter” (Sourcebooks Landmark) by Julie Clark: An author’s past returns to haunt her in the form of a ghostwriting project undertaken for her estranged father. When the project turns out to be just another one of dad’s lies, writer Olivia Dumont is forced to confront her relationship with her father … and a web of family secrets.

“Stop All the Clocks” (Arcade) by Noah Kumin: Kumin’s debut is a meditative, poetic novel about time, grief and the modern-life moments that define us … in ones and zeroes. The death of a colleague and the collapse of her AI company send Mona Veigh’s life in directions not determined by any algorithm.

“Plays Well with Others” (Blackstone Publishing) by Lauren Myracle: A bout of social media betrayal forces Jake Nolan from her job, house and husband and into a receptive bungalow on Sweetwater Lane. There, she befriends those just like herself — people itching to act on entrenched thoughts of retaliation.

“Her First Mistake” (Montlake) by Kendra Elliot: Elliot has written nearly two dozen thrillers set in her home state of Oregon and this latest offering features a minor character from the Columbia River novels: Here, Deschutes County sheriff’s detective Noelle Marshall gets her own origin story. A cold case murder mystery, this is the tale that explains what happened to Marshall to make her the detective she is today, or at least what she becomes in later storylines. A fulfilling storyline delivers much more than backstory in a captivating summer read.

“Jill Is Not Happy” (Scarlet) by Kaira Rouda: In this darkly comic tale, Jill and Jack live an enviable life in South California and, as recent empty-nesters, an unbearable marriage. A road trip “to reconnect” is really a cat-and-mouse game unknown to each other as they unwittingly match their cunning to pull one in … and push the other over, the more-than-metaphorical ledge.

“The Farm House” (Poisoned Pen Press) by Chelsea Conradt: Looking for a fresh start after her mother dies, Emily Hauk and her husband depart for a farm in rural Nebraska. Learning nothing from centuries of thrillers (“The Amityville Horror,” anyone?), they should have asked why the asking price was so low. Unknown to them, everyone who has ever lived on this farm has died. The lure of the soil is compelling, though, as Emily digs into the mystery enveloping her new home.

Reach book reviewer Tom Mayer at tmayer@rn-t.com or tmayer132435@gmail.com.

https://admin-newyork1.bloxcms.com/northwestgeorgianews.com/tncms/admin/action/main/preview/site/packing-summer-reads-for-the-beach-you-ll-need-a-bigger-bag/article_4cad66f8-8a12-4be2-b2d6-f42bdf4039c0.html

Was this review helpful?

Reading The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club by Martha Hall Kelly was a delightful experience as she is a "new to me author," and I thoroughly enjoyed her book. The novel is set in two very different timeframes: 2016 and 1942. In 2016, Mari Starwood's life is at odds as her loving mother Nancy had died, and Mari simply has a job, not a career she loves, and her current relationship is less than stellar. She decides to travel to Martha's Vineyard for a short visit to meet with the reclusive artist Elizabeth Devereaux. She tells Ms. Devereaux that she wants to take a private art lesson, yet her real intent is to discuss what link there may be to an item she found in her mother's belongings and the artist. Mari was only planning to stay one overnight, however Elisabeth had different ideas. She began to tell Mari a story that started in 1942 about Virginia Smith and her three grandchildren: Tom, 20 years old, Cadence, 19 and Briar, 16. and life on Ginny's farm. On his 20th birthday Tom announces to his family and guests that he will be leaving to join the war effort by enlisting in the elite 75th Ranger Regiment. The women, while proud of Tom are disappointed as maintaining the farm is a struggle with him there; how will they do it without him? His girlfriend, Bess Stanhope is devasted as she expected Tom to propose and announce it that day. After Tom leaves Bess joins the others at the Smith farm to help much to the disappointment and chagrin of her wealthy and prominent parents. The author based the character of Cadence on her mom who grew up in Martha's Vineyard and some of the stories she shared. The book provides insights as to what it was like when English troops were training in your backyard, German U-boats are seen in your tranquil waters and you hear there is a spy amongst your neighbors. It is also the story of 3 young strong and fierce young women pursuing their own goals, yet supporting one another even when they disagree. The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club is a wonderful and richly- written novel; I highly recommend it for readers of historical and women's fiction. Thanks to NetGalley, Random House Publishing Group, Ballantine Books and the author for the opportunity to read an ARC; my review reflects my candid opinion. 4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Net Galley and Random House Publishing for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. I loved this story, first book that I have read from this author and I will definitely be checking out her others. Past and present timelines in a book can sometimes be tricky, as one timeline winds up being more interesting than the other. While the narrative from the past was more interesting and developed more, that didn't take away from the overall story. The book was engaging and this was an easy book to read in one sitting.

Was this review helpful?

The Martha’s Vineyard Beach and Book Club by Martha Hall Kelly is a masterfully crafted, memorable book by this gifted writer. This is my fourth book by Ms. Kelly. I was overjoyed when I saw that she had come out with a new book.

This book is a dual timeline. It takes place in the ‘present’ (2016) and 1942. Mari Starwood is invited to a painting ‘retreat’ on Martha's Vineyard with acclaimed artist Elizabeth Devereux. In the beginning Mari has different motives than to paint. She plays to stay for one day and just leave. Mrs. Devereux picks Mari up at the ferry. Mrs. Devereux starts telling Mari a story about the farmhouse she is living in and all about the family who lived on the farm. The story goes, that during World War II Martha's Vineyard became a training ground for the US Army. There were rumors that German submarines were located off the coast of New England.

The main characters are the creators and members of the book club – Cadence, Bess and Briar. The entire story revolves around these three women and their grandmother. Cadence, Bess and Briar are brave, bold and refuse to conform to the societal roles that are layed out for them. There is so much going on in this book. There is new love, heartbreaking loss, mystery, determination, fearlessness and the importance of friendship and family.

Ms. Kelly’s characters are relatable, deep, and memorable. The setting is described so well that you can picture Martha’s Vineyard in either time frame and feel like you have been there. The mystery isn’t resolved until the end and it will keep you on your toes. This is what I love about Ms. Kelly’s writing. Her research into the events that occurred during 1942 off the coast of New England is bar none. I know that if I read a Martha Hall Kelly book that the historical part of ‘historical fiction’ is accurate and one of the things she is known for. The fictional side of the story is indeed entertaining. Well done! I can’t wait to see what you have in store for us next.

I would like to thank the author, Random House Publishing Group -Ballantine for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House Publishing Group and Net Galley for an advanced reader copy of The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club. I have liked other novels by Martha Hall Kelly, and enjoyed this one as well. Being an avid reader, learning about a book club during WWII was interesting, and I loved learning about life on the island at that time. The characters were so interesting, I would get caught up in the historical part of the story, and then missed them while the story went back to present day. I enjoyed the two storylines and how they were brought together. Kelly continued her use of strong female characters, which I love. A good read for lovers of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the opportunity to read an advance copy of The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club. As a fan of Martha Hall Kelly’s work, I was excited to dive into her latest novel.

While I initially hesitated to start another WWII historical fiction novel, this book offered a fresh perspective. The setting of Martha's Vineyard during the 1940s with the looming threat of Nazi U-boats was fascinating. I found myself captivated by the historical storyline, which brought a lesser-known aspect of the war to life.

The present-day narrative, while still enjoyable, didn’t resonate with me as strongly as the historical portion. One detail that pulled me out of the story was the reference to Fort Moore in the 1940s, which historically would have been known as Fort Benning, an anachronism that didn't fit with the other historical details.

That said, the novel overall was a wonderful read, immersive, and beautifully written. Fans of Kelly’s previous work and lovers of historical fiction will find much to appreciate here.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really interesting and enjoyable piece of historical fiction! Set in a dual timeline this is historical fiction meets mystery meets romance. I enjoyed the book references and the mysteries; both war and present day, but I really loved the character of Briar, a spunky and tenacious 16-year-old who says what she thinks, dresses how she wants, and lives life on her own terms with a "let the chips fall where they may" attitude. That attitude will get her in trouble for sure but somehow, it always works out. Not quite a five-star read but definitely four plus!!

Was this review helpful?

After a slow start, the tide turned on this historical fiction novel. Booklovers will enjoy the publishing and title references while WWII aficionados will marvel at the Smith girls' bravery. Featuring a dual-linear timeline, I wanted more trips to the present to unlock the past's secrets.

By midpoint, the novel becomes a page turner and I eagerly flipped through the pages to discover the truth. Will the young women of Martha Vineyard be able to turn their wartime book club into a bestseller?

Thank you to #NetGalley and the publisher for the early edition of #TheMarthasVineyardBeachandBookClub in exchange for an honest review. To be honest, I picked up the novel a few times and struggled to connect to Briar's story. While intelligent, she holds everyone at arms length including readers making it difficult to bond with the characters.

When Briar joins the book club, the stories weave together blending the past and present. A heart bracelet links the decades and bridges Mrs. D and Mari's lives. For a trip back in time, check out Martha Hall Kelly's latest read.

Was this review helpful?

After a long time away from reading anything about World War II. I was offered this book from one of my favorite authors and knew I had to read it. So happy I did. This is a great book with so many interesting facts of war here in the United States and many mention of where I live on Long Island, that now I need to do some of my own research.
But the story of this family and what they went thru. Of course I figured the secret of whom the girl was and how she was connected to the family.
I do belong to a book club and this will be one of my recommendations this year.

Was this review helpful?

Martha Hall Kelly often builds her stories around the actual figures in her family history and her love of family and history shines through. In her latest, Mari Starwood arrives in Martha’s Vineyard to take a painting class from Mrs Devereaux, a noted artist. However, she has an ulterior motive for arranging this. Mari recently lost her mother. Before her mother’s death she had contacted Devereaux and was planning a trip to meet her. Mari only planned to stay overnight to learn what their connection was. Those plans change when Devereaux begins to tell her the story of the family who owned the farm where she currently lives. In the 1940s, the farm was owned by the Smith family, a grandmother and her three grandchildren, who had lost their parents. Cadance writes a column for the local paper and has dreams of working in publishing in New York. Tom has recently enlisted and is preparing to join his unit. His girlfriend Bess has become a part of the family and works with them on the farm. Briar is a teenager who spends time watching their coast. She has reported several u-boat sightings, although her reports have been ignored and she has been given the nickname Briar the Liar. When the army arrives on the island their peaceful farm is trampled as the men prepare for deployment. Their commander, Major Gilbert, immediately gets off on the wrong foot with Cadence, but Gram has seen a future for them in her tea leaves.

Books, of course, play an important part in the family’s life. The girls form a book club, which is more of a social gathering on the beach. They also gather books to provide reading materials for the men. Gilbert is less than enthusiastic about their plan since the books are only added weight in their packs, but the girls put their minds to it and create smaller editions printed on lighter paper. With the help of one of the island’s visitors, the editions are presented to the army. While the club members are occupied with their books, Briar makes a discovery on the beach. Peter is a medic serving on the u-boat that Briar spotted. He was raised in America and has deserted, hoping to make his way back to his family in the Midwest. Briar is afraid that he will be executed as a spy if he is found. Convincing her family to hide him puts both Peter and the family in danger. A murder, an unexpected pregnancy, the discovery that there is a traitor on the island and a family tragedy brings this family closer together as they support each other. The Smith family’s story is one of heartache, hope and love on the home front as war touches them all. By the time Devereaux finishes her story, Mari has discovered her connection to the island and has found a family. This is a story with characters and a setting that is easy to fall in love with. I would like to thank NetGalley and Random House - Ballantine for providing this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Martha's Vineyard Beach and Book Club will grab your attention right away and will keep you wanting to know what happens to the characters next. This is the first book I have read by Martha Hall Kelly, and it definitely won't be the last.

Was this review helpful?

If you are a fan of historical fiction, this is the perfect book for you. This is my first book to read written by Kelly and I must say I look forward to reading more of her books. She writes with such vivid descriptions that brought the story to life. I highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This book is not as serious as Martha Hall Kelly’s previous trilogy. With the two main characters being 16 and 20 this almost felt like a YA novel. The story of 2 sisters, set during WWII had a lot going on but it did drag on in parts. The 16 year old sister annoyed me at times, but that can be attributed to her being 16 years old. I liked the 20 year old sister, and felt for her. I did enjoy reading about what was happening on Martha’s Vineyard during the summer of 1942, during WWII. I heard stories that the German Submarines were spotted off the coast of US, but this is the first book I read with this story line. The twist at the end was somewhat predictable.

Was this review helpful?

What a wonderful way to start my 2025 beach reads! This was my first read by this author although she came highly recommended. In this historical novel we come to love the Smith family who are doing their best as WWII is reaching its fingers to Martha’s Vineyard. Kelly weaves a present day storyline into her novel which adds depth and dimension in such a beautiful way. I highly recommend this novel if you enjoy historical fiction with intrigue, love lost and found, the complexity of families and hope.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a big fan of Martha Hall Kelly’s historical fiction and her latest book The Martha’s Vineyard Beach and Book Club showed me a fascinating aspect of Martha’s Vineyard that I had no prior knowledge of — its World War II history.

When the story opens, it’s 2016 and we meet Mari Starwood who is grieving the death of her mother and who has traveled to Martha’s Vineyard with nothing but a piece of paper with the name Elizabeth Devereaux on it. Mari has no other family and because she found Elizabeth’s name in her mother’s notes, she has come to meet Elizabeth, hoping maybe there’s some connection between them.

Mari gets way more than she expected when Elizabeth launches into a detailed history about the Smith sisters, Cadence and Briar, who lived in her house long before she did. The story Elizabeth tells is about bold, resilient women trying to keep their family farm from going under while the men are away at war, and it’s about the different ways they try to help the war effort. Cadence and her friend Bess start a book club at first as a way to maintain normalcy, but soon the book club is more than just a book club. I loved how, after hearing that soldiers wanted books, they were determined to create pocket sized versions of books to send to them.

The WWII timeline was also filled with mystery and intrigue, German U boats off the coast of Martha’s Vineyard, and even a spy on the island itself! While both timelines were compelling, I have to admit that the WWII timeline was a bit more engaging because of these elements.

As always with Kelly’s books, everything is well researched and her writing is beautiful and filled with likeable characters.

Was this review helpful?

A good-enough book, set in Martha's Vineyard, mostly in 1942. There's a framing device of a character we don't spend enough time with to care about being told the story in 2016, and the book is inspired by the author's own family history on the island, which makes me feel slightly bad about not enjoying the book more.

My husband and I visited Martha's Vineyard on our honeymoon a few years ago and I quite enjoyed it, so I was interested in this book. The author's research shines and I loved seeing the world of 1942 on the island. Soldiers were stationed there, using it as training grounds for a future amphibious assault, while German U-boats lurked just off-shore. Nods are made to rationing, but there's an awful lot of baking going on. Still, wartime Martha's Vineyard truly comes to life.

There's a lovely story of found family; the book centers on Briar and Cadence Smith, who live with the grandmother on a farm up-island. Their brother Tom has just shipped off, but his girlfriend Bess is staying at the farm as well. Briar is 16 and obsessed with the details of the war; Cadence, 19, works at a beach club and dreams of working in publishing in New York. Kelly throws a bunch of plot into the book--a possible spy! Bess's horrible mother! Gram's poor health! An arrogant British officer! A dead German neighbor! Briar's reputation as "Briar the Liar"! Honestly, I never warmed to Briar; I would've appreciated more development there about how she became interested in war and ship models and things. I liked parts of Cadence's romance, but it felt rushed. Honestly, a lot of my problems with the book boil down to it being so crammed that nothing had room to breathe. Even the titular book club barely factored into the story--it was mostly just the main characters, who already live together, sitting around, talking. The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society this isn't.

Also, on a more nit-picky note, the chapters almost entirely alternate between Briar and Cadence (with a very very occasional one from Mari in 2016). The chapters are labeled, which is helpful, but they're also all labeled with 1942. At first I assumed this meant that we'd be bopping around in time, but that wasn't the case at all; the action of the book takes place over maybe a month. We don't need the 1942 for all those chapters.

Ultimately, there are aspects of this book that are really well done. It would make for a decent beach read--particularly if you're on Martha's Vineyard.

Thank you to Netgalley and Ballantine for the free copy in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! I liked the alternating POV’s so we got the story from multiple people! I can’t imagine being there while the soldiers are training and there’s enemy soldiers coming too. Briar was my favorite character because she didn’t just accept what was told to her. I do wish she had done more after the war, but I also get she stayed for an important reason. I was happy with Cadence’s ending because I loved Gil! The only thing I was really unhappy with was Bess. I don’t get why she didn’t go back eventually. But I’m glad the 2 got to meet in the end.

Was this review helpful?

I finished this book about a week ago and had to think of what to write for it. I really did like the storyline and I LOVED reading about how Martha's Vineyard and other seaside towns were basically the front line for the US during WWII and the German U-boats coming soooo close to US soil. And I loved Briar's character. But it was a book I was able to put down and then get back to later or go to sleep and read the next day. While the chapters would end in suspense, I was ok putting it down. This was a 3 star book for me (which is an average rating) and I love Martha Hall Kelly books, so hopefully this one was an exception.

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced copy. I am not a reviewer who will retell the plot, just my feelings towards the book as the reader can look up the plot themselves.

Was this review helpful?

Kelly has done it again with a heart-warming, well-researched historical fiction story. I really enjoyed this one from start to finish. The characters draw you in with real emotions and reactions to this difficult period during WWII. The setting is alluring and described beautifully. I really liked the tie to modern-day but with the bulk of the story in the 1940s. I feel like this could be set up nicely for a sequel...one can hope! Recommended for anyone looking for a cozy tale with lots of little stories within.
Thanks to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for this ARC. All opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

This was a unique story about the families left behind when young men went to war. Girlfriends, sisters, mothers and grandmothers all were left to deal with homes and businesses and the uncertainty that their loved ones may not return. I enjoyed this perspective and the story of the young women on Martha’s Vineyard and how they helped each other deal with their losses. The book club is actually a very small part of the story, but it was one of the several ways they were able to distract themselves during the war.
Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for the digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?