Not a big fan, but before you hold it against me, hear me out, I was sent this ARC by Netgalley, and I was curious, I don’t normally read LGBT simply because I don’t relate? But this one was quite popular so, I went ahead and tried it.
It wasn’t the best written book in my opinion, the characters weren’t half as deep as I’d have liked them to be, and the chemistry almost didn’t exist. The cover’s a beauty tho. Sorry.

Super cute club kit!
It has fun activities, cute recipes, the most ADORABLE bookmarks and I loved the book recommendations to read after finishing the book.

This book club kit is the perfect addition to The Nightmare Before Kissmas, I loved seeing all the fun activities and the printable bookmarks are so cute! I think more books should have a book club kit, it is such a fun idea.

The Nightmare Before Kissmas was already a truly wonderful book and I feel like having this available for individuals to use for a book club is an inspired idea. I hope to see more books get these book club kits.

This was great! I used this in a virtual book club and it was really fun. I loved this silly romantic fantasy.

This is such a great companion for a book. I particularly love the recipe suggestions and the recommendations for what to read next after finishing the book. The author interview and questions would be great talking points for book clubs or even just to get yourself thinking.

I was so excited to use this book club kit. My club loved everything it came with! Very useful for us and we had a blast!

Who do I petition to have book kits created for all books? How FUN. And are those not the CUTEST BOOKMARKS YOU HAVE EVER SEEN????

Once again, this book kit surpasses all expectations. I want to gather my nearest and dearest and wow them with these curated offerings.

Nice resource for people reading The Nightmare Before Kissmass. I haven’t read it yet.

These kits seem to have some content warnings listed and links to StoryGraph for the full list of reader-submitted content warnings. I have mixed feelings about this and would prefer all the necessary warnings to be in the kit itself rather than behind a link.

Loved having the author interview and questions for discussing the book right at the beginning. The questions can be a bit spoilery, so maybe don’t read them before or in the middle of reading the book. I know some book clubs have discussions about the book in the middle of reading so maybe the questions could be sorted in a way that there would be some about the beginning of the book, etc, and it would be marked what chapters they’re about? These seem to work well after you’ve finished reading but not so much when you’re in the middle of reading.

The printable bookmarks and the recipes were a nice addition. Once again, I would personally prefer having all the recipes written in the kit instead of having to go through different links. Two of the recipes were actually written down and had nice pictures attached to them and I wish all the recipes were like that.

Loved having the playlist, both as a Spotify link and written down. And the activities seemed fun!

What to read next, about the author and highlighting the author’s other books were a nice addition.

Thank you We Are Bookish for creating another great book club resource! Beautifully created book club kit! The author interview answered all of my questions, the discussion questions were diverse and well-crafted. The book club beverages and printable bookmarks are wonderful bonuses to use during your club discussion.

I borrow the audiobook from my public library and loved it so much it might become a yearly listen. This packet provides author interview, activities and recipes related to the author and the book. It's really cute and I might try some of these recipes.

Definitely my favorite Christmas book! Will most likely be a yearly re-read! I loved Coal and Hex’s relationship as well as Coals relationship with Kris and Iris! All of the Christmas activities gave the book the perfect atmosphere! I’m really looking forward to annotating the book during me first re-read!

Was a cute little addition to the book. Disappointed it’s not a permanent download as wanted to go back and try some of the recipes and crafts but it was really adorable and thoroughly enjoyed it.

I love when kits like this are made! Such a fun and cool way of getting readers to interact with the books more. This is a great kit for anyone who wants to read this book as a group or want to dive in some more on their own.

This book club kit is perfect for a holiday read. This book is hilarious and touching. It is perfect for fans of Red White And Royal Blue. The kit has good discussion questions and activities.

I didn't know book kits existed and I think that's a wonderful idea for book clubs! I thought this one was detailed and contained good questions and material to discuss and animate a book club.

This Book Club Kit is a game-changer for anyone looking to elevate their book club experience. It’s packed with insightful discussion questions, fun activities, and even personalized book recommendations—everything you need to spark lively conversations and keep your group engaged. The materials are beautifully designed and easy to use, making both virtual and in-person meetings feel seamless.

I loved this Book Club Kit. I am most interested in the discussion questions which I thought were light hearted enough for this fun read. I also enjoyed the recipes to make at your book club. Would like to see more Book Club Kits in the future!

It wasn’t bad… but it wasn’t great? In theory it’s a great concept & I wish it had been thought out a little more. Just kinda boring & borderline cringy at any and all moments

I love seeing authors provide book discussions questions! They're always so much fun, and this book Kit goes the extra mile by providing fun extra festive content!

I read The Nightmare Before Kissmas with my book club and my biggest regret is that I wish I found this while I was eagerly awaiting Go Luck Yourself or while we were reading the book together! The activities, recipes, and playlists are adorable, and they would've added an extra holiday cheer. I could see us all choosing a recipe and bringing out creations to a meet up. My book club loves it when books include playlists the author either curated or listened to while they wrote, and the Kiss, Marry, Banish section is a fun play on the classic!

I noticed the small link to storygraph, and I'm so happy to see that site slowly gain popularity. Its always been a small indie site in my heart and seeing it mentioned in this pdf makes me feel like it's grown to be beyond that!

I would love to see more book kits in the future.

I love this Book Kit. Though this is my first official time ever hearing about abook kit, this definitely makes me want to dive into getting more for my other books. The interaction between the two is really interesting and helps me stay in touch with the story and the activity. I highly recommend this to everyone. Maybe add some more content to be more engaging.