Skip to main content

Member Reviews

If you're looking for a book that features a MC that is poised to get his butt-whooped by personal growth, 'I Think They Love You' is for you.

Denz and Bray were the perfect picture of first love throughout college. Denz never expected Bray to leave him behind for a job in London, before Denz even had a chance to decide if he could follow him across the Atlantic.

Fast forward to a few years later and Denz and Braylen get a second chance to put their priorities and expectations to right, it just takes some fake dating shenanigans to get them pointed in the right direction.

The supporting characters are a trip, Denz and Bray are entirely loveable, and the wooing is swoony. This is a light-hearted book about growth, identity and what real love looks like. Through Denz's struggle to earn the promotion "he's always wanted" in the family event planning business, Bray tries to prove that he's someone Denz can rely on while Denz's main concern is proving himself to his family. The romance is key to the story, but 'I Think They Love You' is mostly about Denz finding his place in the world and away from his family’s reputation.

André Santana's narration is so good. He brings out Denz's charm and nails the precarious balance of cockiness and insecurity of his character.

Was this review helpful?

I Think They Love You needs to be optioned for an on-screen adaptation ASAP. Seriously, this story would make an incredible rom-com with its perfect blend of fake dating, second-chance romance, family drama, and an irresistibly lovable protagonist. Readers will absolutely swoon over Denz and Braylon’s relationship. This title deserves far more recognition in the romance genre, as Winters deserves his flowers!

Was this review helpful?

It was good not great. I think the story should have been told in dual point of views. I think that would have made the story flow better and the romance stronger as we would get both sides of their story. I also got annoyed with the extended family, they were annoying to me.

The narration was good.

Was this review helpful?

I did not finish this entirely before the archive date, but I found it a bit hard to get into and enjoy. I do love reading queer stories, so might try to pick it back up in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I think I loved every character in this book except Denz. He is immature, self-centered, and selfish. Denz is a man in his late 20’s, but thinks and acts like a teenager. He projects his insecurities on to everyone around him. If someone tries to help him he takes it as a personal attack because “they think he isn’t good enough”. He dropped the ball several times in his job (due to his own oversight) and then blames everyone else. He doesn’t really see (or care) what is going on with anyone around him nor does he really want to. He is a prime example of someone with main character energy and the world revolves around them. Honestly, I think Braylon deserves better. This is a second chance romance after they broke up in college and I really disliked how Denz made it seem like it was 110% Braylon’s fault when in my opinion Denz was mostly the one who let it go.

I loved the Carter family and all the secondary characters. They honestly made the book for me. I appreciate the message of being true to yourself and life is too short to constantly be someone else.

Was this review helpful?

Julian Winters delivers all the feels in I Think They Love You—a warm, laugh-out-loud fake dating rom-com with heart, family chaos, and second chances. Denz and Braylon’s chemistry is electric, and the emotional depth sneaks up on you in the best way. A joyful, affirming must-read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Dreamscape Media and Netgalley for providing an advanced copy of this! All thoughts and opinions are still my own.

These messy, lost characters completely stole my heart. Fantastic right-person-wrong-time, second chance romance.

Despite Denz always knowing he'd end up working for his family's event business, he is struggling to find his place at work. Determined to prove that he's not completely irresponsible and unreliable, he joins the competition to take over as CEO after his father's sudden retirement... and accidentally tells everyone he has a serious boyfriend.

When Braylon, his ex and only long term boyfriend, shows up at just the right time, Denz convinces him to be his fake boyfriend. Now wrapped up in a fake dating scheme, unresolved feelings emerge making the whole thing feel a little less fake.

Denz is a disaster main character in the best way. His unsureness in himself leads him to make a lot of mistakes and bad choices. But his heart is almost always in the right place. Braylon is his total opposite but the one person who seems to unwaveringly believe in him.

I loved the Carter's family dynamic. Despite the bickering and misunderstandings, they all clearly loved each other deeply. I just loved how realistic all of their relationships felt.

I did listen to this entire book on audio and the narrator André Santana did a fantastic job - even with Braylon's slight British accent in present day vs his lack of one in the past chapters.

Overall I just really loved this romance. I love a messy yet relatable characters and this hit that stride perfectly. I'm so excited Julian Winters is expanding to adult romances and I can't wait to read his next release!

Was this review helpful?

A second-chance romance that truly worked! I loved seeing Denzel grow and come to the realization that people can change—himself included.

Was this review helpful?

I know that I'm not much of a romance fan, so my word shouldn't be taken as truth. But this book was just way too average for me, and so much of the dialogue was far too cringey for me to enjoy. The two main characters aren't bad overall, and they actually make a pretty good pair, so that part wasn't an issue. And honestly, most of the challenges they faced made a decent amount of sense too - it was just annoying that this entire book is just one big miscommunication trope. No one talks to each other, in the past OR present, and it just makes for way too many bad outcomes that are incredibly frustrating.

Also, my biggest grievance was Denz not knowing who Peeta and Katniss are. You mean to tell me that you, a 25 year old who loves movies and pop culture, don't know about the Hunger Games, but your sibling who is like 9 years younger than you does? Don't even lie.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun listen, I really enjoyed Denz & Braylon’s second chance story! 😍

📖 I Think They Love You by Julian Winters
⭐️: 4.5/5
🌶️: open door

💭 overall thoughts:
Denz is in the running for CEO of his family’s event planning business, 24 Carter Gold, and needs to prove that he’s capable of the commitment it entails.

When his best friend Jamie bails as his fake boyfriend, he just so happens to run into Braylon, his ex and only real relationship he’s ever had.

Both needing something from one another, they agree to a deal that involves fake dating, which quickly leads to not knowing what’s real and what isn’t.

Denz is a big personality, being in such a powerful family & as an influencer himself. Braylon is the perfect balance, and they just fit together.

I loved seeing how these two found their way back to each other on an emotional level. I especially loved their texting banter, and Braylon’s cheesy jokes 🤣

The side characters are so fun in this, and I’d love to read more of their stories (how Kami got together with her boyfriend, and for Jamie+Jordan to get their HEA)!

My only tiny bit for the loss of half a star is maybe just more of a "me" problem. This is written in 3rd person single POV, and at times I got confused with all the characters.
It would have helped if the relationships were said more often (like Denz refers to his parents by their names, and I often forgot it was his mom and dad).

🎧 audiobook thoughts:
André Santana really made the characters come to life with his voices & expressions, I could feel their personalities through his narration!

read if you love:
🥸 fake dating
⌛️ second chance
🛏 only one bed
🧡 family dynamics
💜 single 3rd person pov

Thank you to Dreamscape Media & NetGalley for an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Denzel and Babylon were an opposite attract romance when they let their family expectations separate them… Years later, Babylon returns to their old stomping ground and runs into Denzel - the sparks are still there!

Not wanting or having time for a relationship, Denzel uses this opportunity and coincidence to strike up a fake second chance romance with his former love, Babylon in order to get a promotion at work.

Babylon and Denzel soon have a hard time drawing the line between fake romance and true second chances. But will they let their work and families get in the way for a second time? Or will they prioritize themselves and their relationship and strike out on a new path?

This was a fun romance that had a category romance feel to it. I think it felt a little longer than it needed to be but the characters and family dynamics were fun to see playing out.

I listen to the audiobook narrated by André Santana, and found that he did a good job differentiating. The two male leads through his narration. The narration was easy to listen to and had a good flow to it. I was surprised that this did not have a dual narrator, but André stepped up and did an excellent job creating a vibrant setting for this story.

Was this review helpful?

4 stars.

"I Think They Love You" by Julian Winters is such a great book! I thoroughly enjoyed reading about Dez and Braylon's love story. Some of these authors are making me second guess my thoughts on second-chance romances, and Julian Winters is one of them because this is great! Up until now, I have been convinced that this trope was not for me, but this book is so well written that I am coming around to it. This redemption love story, coupled with a fake dating scheme, a bit of family drama, and a terrific amount of personal growth, really hit the spot. I felt every emotion, every bit of tension, every laugh. It's glitzy, steamy, and sweet, well-paced, not too long, and flows remarkably well. André Santana does a spectacular job narrating this story. All of his voices are superb and perfectly embody all of the characters here. I will definitely be buying this book!

Thank you to NetGalley, Julian Winters, and Dreamscape Media for the complimentary ALC of this book. All opinions are my own. I was not compensated for this review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a book that didn't quite keep me. The storyline of the family business and competition for leadership often took more of the story than the relationships in the story which were more important to me

Was this review helpful?

Denz and Braylon met at university, fell in love, then broke up. Years later, chance brought them together. Shared goals lead them to collaborate and pretend to be a couple.

I read it as an audiobook and I really liked the reader; his voice is pleasant and enjoyable to listen to. It allowed me to visualize the characters and situations.

It's a refreshing family story. At the beginning of the story, we quickly understand that Braylon has changed more since university than Denz. The story will focus more on Denz and his evolution. It's well-crafted and makes the ending logical and expected (in a good way).
I liked the relationships between the family members, especially between the father and Denz; they allow us to better understand the characters. They create situations full of humor and tenderness. The book uses flashbacks and allows us to understand why they broke up in the first place.
The characters are Black, and I like how the author describes them. He uses this characteristic wisely, and it adds more depth to the story.
A very good book, a great listen.

Was this review helpful?

Dreamscape ALC
A second-chance, fake dating romance?! Sign me up. This was a delightful romance that also had lots of depth and self-reflection. I am not always a fan when the author focuses on the character's jobs so much, but it worked so well for me here because of how Denz had to compete to run the family business, while Braylon wanted to advance in his career. I liked how their jobs helped them explore their past and futures. There was the perfect balance of lightness and heavier topics and it was just such a sweet story.
The narration was excellent. Denz and Braylon were both captured so well with the performance, and I couldn't stop listening.

Was this review helpful?

Super cute romance that has a heavy focus on personal development and finding ones' own way amidst familial and personal expectations. Loved the romance between our protagonist and love interest. Definitely looking forward to more adult romances by Julian Winters.

Was this review helpful?

This was exceptional, probably my favorite that I've read of Julian Winters.

I love a second chance romance and one of my absolute favorite parts and something I think should be mandatory for romances with characters with history, is that there were multiple chapters that went back in time and gave up the chemistry and history of these two characters.

I liked the family and friendship elements as well as the romance and it's genuinely a very well rounded book. Highly recommend.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

✨ Review ✨ I Think They Love You by Julian Winters; Narrated by André Santana

Thanks to Dreamscape Media, St. Martin's Griffin and #netgalley for the gifted advanced copy/ies of this book!

After dating in college, Denz and Braylon cross paths again - Denz is trying to earn a bid for CEO of 24 Carter Gold, his family’s event planning business and Braylon is trying to grow the LGBTQ nonprofit he works for. They decide to fake date to help both achieve professional success, and they start falling for each other again.

Second chance is one of my least favorite tropes but this one really worked for me. I like that they had a chance to learn and grow and experience life for a bit before their lives crossed again.

I loved the range -- swanky parties and more down-to-earth outreach via Braylon's nonprofit; fancy clothes and french toast grilled cheeses.

The only thing I didn't buy was that Braylon was gone for a few years and now had a British accent that he couldn't part with lol.

🎧 The audio narration was great -- with distinct characters built around both Denz and Braylon's voices! The flashbacks were a little jarring via audio sometimes, but overall, I enjoyed listening to it!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Genre: m/m contemporary romance
Setting: Atlanta
Length: 10 hours 49 minutes
Pub Date: Jan 2025

Read this if you like:
⭕️ second chance
⭕️ LGBTQ+ characters
⭕️ fake dating
⭕️ swanky events and fashion

Was this review helpful?

This was an absolute treat. This was great to read from beginning to end. I was sad that it was over once I got to the last page. I could have lived in the world of these characters for many more pages. I always love my queer romance books, but Julian Winters must put some kind of spell in these books to make them so addictive.

Was this review helpful?

A bit of a slow start, but really enjoyed this story! Equal parts sexy and sweet. A great queer romance with heart.

Great romance read. Sexy characters and several surprises in the plot that I didn't quite expect.

Was this review helpful?