Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Widows' Guide to Murder is the second Widows' Detective Club village cozy mystery by Amanda Ashby. Released 10th March 2025, it's 270 pages and is available in paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout. For Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this book is currently included in the KU subscription library to borrow and read for free. The other books in the series are also currently available on KU.

Small village cozies are perennially popular and it's lovely to find a solid series. The book is populated by small town eccentrics, undercurrents of rage, jealousy, and scandal, into which the new local village library assistant has been unceremoniously thrust without warning. It checks all the boxes: intelligent late middle aged sensible widow/librarian, small town gossip, an outlandish ensemble cast of apparently harmless oddball characters, and a satisfying resolution and epilogue.

Compared to the first book in the series, this one is a bit more scattered, with a host of secondary characters who are a bit of a handful to keep track of, but overall, still readable and enjoyable.

It's not derivative, but fans of Robert Thorogood (Marlow Murder Club), Janice Hallett, and Richard Osman will find a lot to like here. The author has a genuinely good grasp of character and setting, good pacing, and a satisfying denouement and conclusion.

The unabridged audiobook has a run time of 8 hours 54 minutes and is capably read by series narrator Diana Croft. She has a well modulated alto voice and an impressive command of regional accents (East London, Midlands, etc), and switches seamlessly between a range of ages and male and female (even Scottish) without a hiccup. Sound and production quality are high throughout the read.

Four stars. It's a diverting read. It would be a great choice for home library, or a binge/buddy read. There are two books extant in the series, with a third due out at the end of June 2025.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

Was this review helpful?

The Widows' Guide to Backstabbing by Amanda Ashby

This is book two in the Widows' Detective Club Series.

Ginny has taken on the role of Little Shaw's new library manager, and she's settling into life in the small village with her group of friends and her kleptomaniac cat, Edger. Life gets more complicated when she stumbles upon a body in the haberdashery store while helping her friend Hen return some fabric.

The victim is the spring fete judge, Timothy Harlow, who isn't known for his charm; after Ginny and Tuppence find the body, they call the police and receive a stern warning from Ginny's neighbour, DI Wallace, to stay out of the investigation but the victim's daughter, Megan, comes to them with questions, the widows can't sit idly by. They're convinced the main suspect is innocent and are determined to help Megan get to the bottom of the mystery.

Between her work at the library, returning 'gifts' that Edgar has stolen and whipping up marmalade for the spring fete, Ginny and her crew attack the puzzle and create an arts and crafts style felt murder board, possibly my favourite cosy mystery prop ever! The Widows' Guide to Backstabbing Village has all my favourite cosy mystery tropes, library shenanigans, busybodies, arts and crafts, a naughty cat, rival bakers... If you like The Thursday Murder Club, The Marlow Murder Club or The Paradise Heights Craft Store Stitch-Up, then I think you'll enjoy the Widows' Guide series.

Body Count = 2

Thumbs up.

Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for this ARC in exchange for my review.

#NetGalley #StormPublishing

#Bookstagram #booksdeevaareads #2025bookshelf #goreadabook #allthebooks #booknerd #Designer #GraphicDesign #DesignNerd #designdeevaa #CreativeLife #DesignInspiration #ArtAndDesign #Designer #Grapcan'tsign #DesignNerd #murdermystery

Was this review helpful?

Ginny is settling in well to her new home and town, mainly thanks to the widows (Tuppence, JM, Helen) of the town who took her under their somewhat chaotic but warm arms. Ginny is also now the manager of the library, and is keeping the peace between volunteers, finding people what they want, and looking out for her teen employee Connor.

When Ginny accompanies Tuppence to the local haberdashery, they find the owner stabbed in the back and very much dead. Ginny is upset, but calls in the police, and listens to Detective Wallace's stern warning NOT to get involved.

That works out till Megan, the deeply distraught daughter of the owner shows up, and the widows decide they must investigate, since Megan's boyfriend is taken in for questioning, and Megan is convinced he's innocent.

Despite Ginny's reluctance, she joins in, and though they turn up numerous clues and red herrings, they do get closer to finding out who the killer is. At the same time, Ginny's cat Edgar keeps bringing home odd things, though in this case it's two sets recipe cards that two local bakers, who are at loggerheads, have reported missing.

The widows' sleuthing is haphazard and well intentioned, though it's usually Ginny who makes the big breakthroughs, as she does here, to her horror.

This is light, silly fun, and a nice diversion. Ginny is a good person, and however frustrating I sometimes find the widows chaotic behaviour, their hearts are in the right place, and they have proven to be good friends to Ginny, the likeable, quiet, and somewhat anxious main character.

On to the next book!

Thank you to Netgalley and to Storm Publishing for this ARC in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

Ginny is back and with another murder!! Ginny and her friends are back at it again.
I really liked the first one but I felt this one was a lot slower than the first one. I do like the characters and the small town charm of the books. \

Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for an advance copy in exchange for a honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Same review basically as the other book in this series. Writing is good, story is interesting enough, just something about it didn’t grab my attention as much as it should have. It took me quite a bit longer to finish than I normally do because nothing about it made me want to go back.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book in this series that follows a recently widowed and newly head librarian as she an her friends become involved in another murder investigation. The characters in this series are interesting, and the case had enough twists to keep the story going. If you enjoy cozy mysteries as I do you might enjoy this addition.

I received an advanced copy of this book from Netgalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Another fun book in the series. I love Ginny and her possie and secretly like Wallace too.his gruffness and frustration is so over shadowed by his caring. The mystery was nuanced and peeled layer by layer to get to the villian. Nicely written, well paced and even though the cast of characters is long, each has a role to play.

#netgalley #TheWidowsGuidetoBackstabbing

Was this review helpful?

It was such a joy to return to Little Shaw in this second instalment of Amanda Ashby’s delightful cosy crime series. I absolutely loved being back with Ginny and her wonderful widow friends - JD, Tuppence, and Hen.

This fabulous foursome have become quite the amateur sleuths, despite DI Wallace’s repeated (and often ignored) requests to leave the investigating to the professionals!

Since moving to the village, Ginny has now stumbled across her second murder victim - this time it's Timothy Harlow, the owner of the local haberdashery shop and a celebrity judge for the upcoming Little Shaw Spring Fete.

Found stabbed in the back with a pair of scissors, his death throws the fete plans into chaos and raises plenty of questions. Can the show still go on? And more importantly—who killed Timothy?

While the police quickly arrest a suspect, Timothy’s daughter Megan insists they’ve got the wrong person.

Naturally, the widows can't resist taking on the case, complete with a brand-new mobile murder board and a growing list of suspects.

Meanwhile, Ginny’s cat Edgar is causing mischief of his own—bringing home mysterious objects and unwittingly helping to uncover hidden village secrets.

Ginny soon finds herself playing negotiator between neighbours, which just might lead to some valuable clues...

This is another charming, funny, and twist-filled mystery, packed with secrets, love affairs, rivalries, and plenty of red herrings.

Amanda Ashby continues to deliver well-paced plotting, witty dialogue, and an endearing sense of community that makes Little Shaw such a pleasure to visit.

The bond between the widows is a true highlight—heartfelt, hilarious, and refreshingly empowering.

With danger never too far behind, you’ll be turning the pages eager to find out if Ginny and her friends will crack the case before DI Wallace and whether they’ll come out unscathed.

A thoroughly enjoyable read, perfect for fans of cosy crime. I can’t wait for book three!

With thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"The Widows' Guide to Backstabbing" delivered exactly what I hoped the second part would – familiar characters, new secrets and more fun mayhem in the charming little town of Little Shaw. Ginny Cole is slowly settling into her new life, and although grief still lingers in the background, she has now not only accepted the company of the widows, but practically lives and breathes with them.

This time the story begins with another murder – the owner of the small town's beloved haberdashery shop is stabbed in the back with a pair of scissors, and Ginny is the one to discover him in the back of the shop. Timothy Harlow, judge of the Spring Festival, was not a popular figure among the locals, so there are plenty of suspects. Ginny – driven by curiosity, logic and a sense of justice – is once again drawn into an investigation, once again with the inevitable trio. JM, Hen and Tuppence continue to form an unbreakable unit, however different they may be. The team dynamics are now even livelier, even more cohesive and full of humour, making every moment with them a pleasure.

The spring fete, the homemade jam, the kleptomaniac cat (who is also impossible not to love), and the secret relationships, old grievances and petty revenges that lurk beneath the surface of the small town all serve as a backdrop that is both charming and unsettling. Behind the idyllic view of the small town, there is always something stirring – and Amanda Ashby builds it masterfully in this part too.

It was especially enjoyable to watch Ginny evolve – simultaneously trying to keep her common sense while being forced to confront again and again that the world is far more complicated than the familiar and well-ordered life she lived before her husband's death. And Amanda Ashby is at her best this time again, just when we think everything is clear, she adds another twist to the story. This part brings all the strengths of the previous book – likeable characters, well-dosed suspense, and a community you want to belong to, even if it means solving a murder with them.

I highly recommend this novel to all fans of cozy mysteries. I'm already looking forward to what the third part has in store – because one thing is for sure: life is never dull with these widows.

Was this review helpful?

The next book in the Widows Detective Club series and it is just as amazing as the first. I was so excited to continue on with an adventure with Ginny. Just when you think life is normal Ginny goes and finds a body, again. This time it's the arrogant shop owner of the haberdashery. Stabbed. Ginny is once again swept into the middle of things and needs to solve the mystery. Along with her friends they try to solve the crime themselves. She soon discovers the quiet town isn't so quiet after all. It is full of rivalries, affairs and hidden secrets. Can she solve it before more danger finds her?
It's a fun on the edge of your seat mystery. Twists and turns you never expect. Once again I love the characters,like her friend Hen who is obsessed with crafts. Asby gives a real story with such great detail we become a part of the mystery. The story is easy to follow yet keep you guessing. You will love this adventure. I can't wait for more.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my god this was so freaking good!
I really enjoyed sitting down and reading and honestly read it in one sitting’!

Was this review helpful?

Ginny Cole is now the head librarian at Little Shaw library and is enjoying her job and adapting to her life as a widow.
One day after leaving work she visits the haberdashery shop and find a body and it’s not looking like a death from natural causes due to the scissors sticking out of its back.
Ginny along with her friends (also widows) have become amateur sleuths and don’t have to think twice about investigating this death.
This book is full of village charm and likeable characters that make it an enjoyable and entertaining read.
There are plenty of twists and turns to keep the reader interested and a great addition to the cosy mystery series.
Thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing.

Was this review helpful?

The village of Little Shaw in Lancashire is proving to be as murder prone as the villages of Midsomer when Ginny Cole, the new head Librarian, finds another body in suspicious circumstances. Harlow is the owner of a haberdashery store and a local celebrity. Despite his overeager sense of self-worth, he had many enemies, which meant many suspects. Ginny and the other widows are determined to investigate when they believe the police have arrested the wrong person. What I like about this story is the number of mistakes the amateur sleuths make in their investigations. It gives the mystery an authenticity and allows the reader to suspend belief on the number of murders the village has. The mystery has a multitude of motives, and it makes immersive reading. I like the amateur sleuths, the web of lies and secrets the village community reveals and the conclusion.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

EXCERPT: She pushed open the front door and stepped inside. Her arrival was announced by a tinkling bell. The interior was crammed with large glass jars of buttons, cubed wooden shelves of homespun wool, and an old oak cutting bench next to the counter.
No wonder Hen had declared a self-imposed ban. It would be easy to spend a fortune in the stylish shop. Despite having lived in Little Shaw for seven months, Ginny had never been inside before, mainly because she'd stubbornly brought as much as she could of her old furniture - and her old life - with her when she'd moved here.
But since the first anniversary of Eric's death had passed, she had been considering some changes. Until this morning, she'd been thinking of a fresh coat of paint, but now the idea of curtains, cushions and new upholstery swam in her vision.
There was no sign of anyone behind the counter, so Ginny continued to walk around, running her fingers along a soft red version of William Morris's 'Strawberry Thief', before inspecting a duck-egg blue Laura Ashley with delicate flowers. There were more large wicker barrels of fabric, as well as a French Louis XV armchair with stripped-back walnut legs and reupholstered squabs in a straw-coloured linen. It was stunning and she studied the small, gilded frame perched on the seat. Vanya Petrovic Upholstery Services. She didn't recognise the name, but the address was local, and his work was exquisite.
Was this what had inspired Tuppence to attempt her own reupholstering?
Ginny turned to ask, only to discover her friend wasn't there. That was odd. She scanned the shop, but on finding it empty, she went outside to where Tuppence was pressed against the wall of the post office next door, her hat pulled low over her face.

ABOUT 'THE WIDOWS' GUIDE TO BACKSTABBING': When librarian Ginny Cole discovers a body in Little Shaw’s beloved haberdashery shop, she finds herself embroiled in a murder investigation. The victim? Arrogant shop owner and spring fete judge, Timothy Harlow, found with a pair of sewing scissors plunged into his back. While the police are quick to arrest Milos, a charming young upholsterer, Ginny thinks the case has been sewn up too neatly.

Together with her friends – no-nonsense JM, craft-obsessed Hen, and irrepressible Tuppence – Ginny delves into the village’s secrets. Between apologising for her kleptomaniac cat and making marmalade for the spring fete, she discovers that behind Little Shaw’s quaint façade lies a tapestry of rivalries, affairs, and deadly ambitions. And when her own car brakes are sabotaged, Ginny realizes the killer is still at large – and getting closer.

With help from the widows and an increasingly exasperated Detective Inspector Wallace, can Ginny unpick the clues before the murderer strikes again?

MY THOUGHTS: A fun small town mystery featuring amateur sleuths 'of a certain age' in which Ginny discovers her second murder victim within months of moving to Little Shaw.

Yes, suspend your belief but go along for the ride because it is certainly another enjoyable one.

After moving to Little Shaw Ginny has been befriended by a group of women who are also all widows. JM has half a law degree and a rather fearsome personality. Tuppence can be a bit gung-ho, and Hen is more the shy, retiring kind. Ginny just wants to fit in with her new friends and, unfortunately, usually goes along with their schemes. DI Wallace tends to be quite dismissive of the women, but secretly I think he enjoys their antics. We also meet his father for the first time in this story.

Ginny has a rescue cat, Edgar, who causes more than a bit of mayhem with his light-pawed tendencies - he has taken to bringing home odd shoes and other items, causing accusations of theft and cheating amongst the villagers.

A lot of village secrets are uncovered during the investigation into the murder of haberdashery owner and spring fete judge, Timothy Harlow, including love affairs, family secrets and competition rivalries that get out of hand.

I was completely taken by surprise by the revelation of the identity of the murderer and yet, once it was explained, it was all perfectly logical.

BTW, I am NEVER moving to a small English village. I don't have a death wish.

⭐⭐⭐.7

#TheWidowsGuidetoBackstabbing #NetGalley

MEET THE AUTHOR: Amanda Ashby was born in Australia but now lives in New Zealand where she writes romance, young adult and middle grade books. She also works in a library, owns far too many vintage tablecloths and likes to delight her family by constantly rearranging the furniture.

DISCLOSURE: Thank you to Storm Publishing via NetGalley for providing an e-ARC of The Widows' Guide to Backstabbiing by Amanda Ashby for review. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions.

Was this review helpful?

Ginny from the library discovers a body in the habadashers. He’s been stabbed by a pair of sewing scissors. While trying to solve what’s going on the brakes on her car get cut but luckily she’s ok. There’s her other widow friends that help out. But she keeps making marmalade and jam.

Was this review helpful?

Well, Ginny and her small group of friends, JM, Hen and Tuppence, have become a neat little group of amateur detectives. In one of the town’s shops, a gruesome discovery was made—a body. Remarkably, Ginny was the one who stumbled upon the scene. When the police arrested a young man named Milo, who seems their most likely prime suspect, Ginny decided to step in on his behalf.

Just like before, these older widows power on, much to the consternation of DI Wallace. He doesn’t want any of them involving themselves in this case, finding them to be an annoyance. The victim’s daughter appeals to the little group that the police have the wrong suspect, just as Ginny herself believes. Interestingly, not only had Ginny become the owner of a black cat she named Edgar (after much deliberation), but he keeps bringing home little gifts for her. One of these gifts is undoubtedly connected to the murder, much to Ginny’s surprise, so she stays firm in her resolve to solve the crime.

The Widows’ Detective Club series made a strong debut with the first book, The Widows’ Guide to Murder, and this second book in the series was just as delightful as the first book. I very much look forward to continuing the series with The Widows’ Guide to Skullduggery, set to be released this June.

Many thanks to Storm Publishing and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

A solid addition to the series. While I enjoyed this one, it didn’t have the same fun feel as the first one and, at times, seemed a bit more serious. It also was well-plotted but moved slower than the first, making it more difficult for me to follow along at times. The cat did provide some levity but I missed scenes like the gravedigging in the first one. Still, I found it entertaining and look forward to the next in the series.

Was this review helpful?

The Widows did it again!
Ginny and her gang managed once again to get involved in a murder and solve it too.
It really feels quite weird that Ginny once again finds a body and gets entangled in the mystery. However, even she could not believe that this was happening again.
I did not like this book as much as the first one because the premise and the twists are too similar. It was a fun read and a nice break from romancelandia!

Thank you @NetGalley for the copy!

Was this review helpful?

This is the second in the series and I would highly recommend, Ginny is very down to earth in the way she thinks and goes about solving crimes and has made lots of new quirky and interesting friends since moving to Little Shaw. There’s plenty of twists and turns, with secrets revealed and suspects to tackle. It’s a nice, cosy mystery and I look forward to seeing how the series develops. I would definitely recommend this book..

Was this review helpful?

The widows are back in action in the second book of this cozy mystery series! The newest resident, Ginny, is starting to feel at home in her new life in Little Shaw when she is once again thrust into a murder mystery: this time, the murder of Timothy Harlow, local shop owner and spring fete judge. The widows will not rest until the correct culprit is caught.

I enjoy spending time in this fun village with exciting and humorous characters. Ginny is becoming a more well-rounded character, and it's a joy to join her on her adventures. And who can't love more Edgar antics?
I look forward to #3 in this cozy mystery series.

Thank you to Netgalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?