Member Review
Review by
RoXXie S, Reviewer
A Haunting, Lyrical Gothic Tale That Tightens Its Grip with Every Page
Jennifer Kennedy’s Our Gifted Hearts is a haunting, atmospheric gothic novel that transports readers into a world of superstition, isolation, and buried secrets. From the very first chapter, Kennedy’s prose wraps you in an uneasy stillness — the kind that makes you check the shadows twice — and never quite lets you breathe easily again. While not without a few imperfections, this book is an elegantly crafted piece of historical suspense, blending emotional depth with a constant undercurrent of dread.
Our Gifted Hearts ♦ Jennifer Kennedy - A Review
Opinion
At the heart of the novel is Fortune Blythe, a young woman who lives in near-poverty with her mother on the outskirts of a small, suspicious settlement. The story begins with a chilling reminder of how easily fear turns into cruelty: a woman from the village is executed for witchcraft, and Fortune herself soon finds the same accusations leveled against her. Kennedy captures the paranoia and brutality of the time with precision — it’s not just the threat of hanging that feels real, but the social suffocation, the whispered accusations, the collective terror.
When a mysterious foreigner, Isaiah, arrives and offers Fortune marriage — seemingly rescuing her from certain death — the story takes a darker, more complex turn. The journey that follows is not one of romantic deliverance, but of disquieting discovery. The isolated island estate where Isaiah brings her is vividly drawn: battered cliffs, wind-lashed trees, and a house whose walls seem to hum with secrets. Kennedy’s command of setting is remarkable; every gust of wind and creaking floorboard contributes to a sense of mounting dread. The environment itself becomes a silent, malevolent character.
Within the house, Fortune encounters three key figures — Esme, Isaiah’s eccentric and unnerving mother; Zena, the curt and watchful housekeeper; and Mathis, the taciturn gardener and handyman. One of them emerges as a true ally, while the others kept me guessing until the final pages. Kennedy excels at layering her characters with ambiguity — no one is entirely what they seem, and their motives shift like shadows in candlelight.
The tension builds slowly, but effectively. There’s an omnipresent sense that something awful is lurking just out of sight — in the tunnels beneath the house, in Isaiah’s evasive explanations, or perhaps in Fortune’s own memories. Kennedy’s pacing deserves particular praise: she manages to maintain suspense without ever resorting to melodrama or cheap thrills. The hints and clues are scattered like breadcrumbs, and when the full picture comes together, it feels both shocking and inevitable.
If there’s a shortcoming, it lies in Fortune herself. Though she’s sympathetic and emotionally complex, she occasionally feels too passive in the face of the horrors and manipulations surrounding her. Her reticence fits her background — a woman traumatized, silenced, and taught to survive by keeping her head down — but at times I longed for her to assert herself more decisively, to confront those who sought to control her. Even so, her evolution into quiet strength by the end is satisfying and believable.
Our Gifted Hearts succeeds most brilliantly in its tone and atmosphere. Kennedy has a gift for the gothic — the uncanny, the claustrophobic, the beautifully grotesque. The imagery lingers long after the final page, and the sense of mystery is sustained until the very end. Without spoiling anything, I can say that the conclusion is both unexpected and deeply fitting; it ties the novel’s themes of loss, identity, and resilience into a haunting finale that left me genuinely impressed.
Conclusion
In short, Jennifer Kennedy delivers a rich, slow-burning gothic mystery with emotional resonance and razor-sharp tension. The novel’s only flaw is that its heroine’s voice sometimes feels muted — but perhaps that, too, is part of the point. Fortune’s story is one of finding one’s power in the most perilous of circumstances, and in that respect, Our Gifted Hearts earns every one of its four shining stars.
Jennifer Kennedy’s Our Gifted Hearts is a haunting, atmospheric gothic novel that transports readers into a world of superstition, isolation, and buried secrets. From the very first chapter, Kennedy’s prose wraps you in an uneasy stillness — the kind that makes you check the shadows twice — and never quite lets you breathe easily again. While not without a few imperfections, this book is an elegantly crafted piece of historical suspense, blending emotional depth with a constant undercurrent of dread.
Our Gifted Hearts ♦ Jennifer Kennedy - A Review
Opinion
At the heart of the novel is Fortune Blythe, a young woman who lives in near-poverty with her mother on the outskirts of a small, suspicious settlement. The story begins with a chilling reminder of how easily fear turns into cruelty: a woman from the village is executed for witchcraft, and Fortune herself soon finds the same accusations leveled against her. Kennedy captures the paranoia and brutality of the time with precision — it’s not just the threat of hanging that feels real, but the social suffocation, the whispered accusations, the collective terror.
When a mysterious foreigner, Isaiah, arrives and offers Fortune marriage — seemingly rescuing her from certain death — the story takes a darker, more complex turn. The journey that follows is not one of romantic deliverance, but of disquieting discovery. The isolated island estate where Isaiah brings her is vividly drawn: battered cliffs, wind-lashed trees, and a house whose walls seem to hum with secrets. Kennedy’s command of setting is remarkable; every gust of wind and creaking floorboard contributes to a sense of mounting dread. The environment itself becomes a silent, malevolent character.
Within the house, Fortune encounters three key figures — Esme, Isaiah’s eccentric and unnerving mother; Zena, the curt and watchful housekeeper; and Mathis, the taciturn gardener and handyman. One of them emerges as a true ally, while the others kept me guessing until the final pages. Kennedy excels at layering her characters with ambiguity — no one is entirely what they seem, and their motives shift like shadows in candlelight.
The tension builds slowly, but effectively. There’s an omnipresent sense that something awful is lurking just out of sight — in the tunnels beneath the house, in Isaiah’s evasive explanations, or perhaps in Fortune’s own memories. Kennedy’s pacing deserves particular praise: she manages to maintain suspense without ever resorting to melodrama or cheap thrills. The hints and clues are scattered like breadcrumbs, and when the full picture comes together, it feels both shocking and inevitable.
If there’s a shortcoming, it lies in Fortune herself. Though she’s sympathetic and emotionally complex, she occasionally feels too passive in the face of the horrors and manipulations surrounding her. Her reticence fits her background — a woman traumatized, silenced, and taught to survive by keeping her head down — but at times I longed for her to assert herself more decisively, to confront those who sought to control her. Even so, her evolution into quiet strength by the end is satisfying and believable.
Our Gifted Hearts succeeds most brilliantly in its tone and atmosphere. Kennedy has a gift for the gothic — the uncanny, the claustrophobic, the beautifully grotesque. The imagery lingers long after the final page, and the sense of mystery is sustained until the very end. Without spoiling anything, I can say that the conclusion is both unexpected and deeply fitting; it ties the novel’s themes of loss, identity, and resilience into a haunting finale that left me genuinely impressed.
Conclusion
In short, Jennifer Kennedy delivers a rich, slow-burning gothic mystery with emotional resonance and razor-sharp tension. The novel’s only flaw is that its heroine’s voice sometimes feels muted — but perhaps that, too, is part of the point. Fortune’s story is one of finding one’s power in the most perilous of circumstances, and in that respect, Our Gifted Hearts earns every one of its four shining stars.
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.
© 2025 NetGalley LLC
• All Rights Reserved
