As someone who has always been fascinated by the story of Lizzie Borden — from the infamous rhyme to the countless documentaries, books, and film adaptations — this anthology immediately caught my eye. The very idea of revisiting that chilling legend through a collection of dark, imaginative tales was irresistible, and I’m pleased to say it mostly lived up to my expectations.

The Lizzie Borden House Anthology brings together a range of authors who each explore the eerie and unsettling history surrounding Lizzie, her family, and that infamous house in Fall River. The result is a varied yet cohesive selection of stories that blend horror, gothic atmosphere, and psychological tension in all the right ways. Some tales lean heavily into the supernatural, conjuring ghostly presences and lingering spirits, while others focus on the human side of horror — guilt, grief, obsession, and the stories that houses themselves can tell.

The tone throughout is deliciously macabre, and the sense of place is wonderfully strong. The house itself feels like a living, breathing character: you can almost hear the creak of its floorboards, sense the shadows moving across the walls, and feel that ever-present weight of history pressing down on each page. It’s the kind of collection that makes you want to curl up on a stormy evening with a cup of tea and let yourself be completely immersed in its unsettling world.

While, as with most anthologies, a few stories resonated more strongly with me than others, the overall quality and atmosphere are impressive. Some authors experiment with modern settings, others stay close to the historical roots, but all manage to capture that haunting essence of the Lizzie Borden myth.

What I particularly appreciated was how the anthology balances the real and the imagined. It never loses sight of the tragic reality of the Borden case, yet it gives each writer the creative freedom to ask “what if?” — what if the house really was cursed? What if Lizzie wasn’t alone? What if evil leaves an imprint that time can’t erase? These questions give the collection a thought-provoking edge that lingers long after the final story.

A solid four stars from me. This is a must-read for anyone who enjoys haunted house fiction, gothic anthologies, or true-crime-inspired storytelling. It’s beautifully eerie, deeply atmospheric, and pays respectful homage to one of history’s most enduring mysteries.

🪓📚
#TheLizzieBordenHouseAnthology #HeatherGraham #SèpheraGirón #LizzieBorden #BookReview #NetGalley #ARCReview #GothicFiction #HauntedHouse #HorrorReads #BookstagramUK #SpookySeason #HistoricalMystery #MacabreReads