Third Wave Capitalism

Everything that’s wrong in one tight package

The proposal is that there are three stages of capitalism. The first wave was industrial, the second was corporate, and the third is corporate strangulation, which John Ehrenreich calls Third Wave Capitalism. As evidence, the book is an endless litany of failure at the hands of special interests. The focus is two chapters – healthcare and schools - which are Ehrenreich’s fields, being a clinical psychology professor.

Corporations have overrun government. They extract rents from all of us by obtaining the rights to formerly government services. They charge more and perform less because they need to show massive profits, and because they pay themselves exorbitant salaries not found in the civil service. The result is a frustrated, overeducated workforce pathetically underemployed and underpaid, fear of everything from job loss, to debt, to a poisoned environment, the breakdown of families, friendships, empathy, solidarity and even of faith that America is the land of opportunity. Business has finally conquered the last bastions of government services, and is in the process of dismantling them for their own profit. These include education (“the last government monopoly”), healthcare, prisons and defense. Corporates now write the laws that congressmen present, and hide their profits overseas, declining to invest in the US. Inequality is unprecedented, and the fear mongers instill the need for even less government than what little remains in its purview.

The problem with Third Wave Capitalism is that it does not actually describe an aspect of capitalism. This third wave is not foreordained, required or inevitable in economics. It is not a predictable outcome or separate phase. It is not falsifiable, proven or replicated. There are no other countries in the world that have ever passed through this stage. Canada’s Central Bank is not a club for private bankers. France’s medical system is far less expensive yet more effective. Japanese schools produce graduates without compromising the economy. The USA is doing this to itself by itself.

There is no shortage of gloom in the USA. There is a firm and widely held (72%) belief that not just the economy but all of American society has derailed. People hardly vote, because no matter how many support something, it will not be done (unless it benefits business). The examples of healthcare and education are stomach churning confirmations, but it doesn’t mean that this isn’t just standard graft and greed gone wild. Calling it The Third Wave of Capitalism is not fair or accurate, either. Rather, this is the logical progression of the Corporate Capitalism era, where (now) giant corporates take advantage of their ever-increasing size, political connections and donations to extract rents from the last bastions of public good. After that is accomplished and the ensuing disaster it portends plays out, we will then see what the new phase of capitalism might be. It might not be capitalism.

Ehrenreich blames the Left for not being as astute and manipulative as the Right. Americans therefore lost all that society achieved under numerous presidents righting clear wrongs. There is essentially nothing standing in the way of complete corporate dominance in the USA.

The final (unintended) impression is what a miserable place to live.

David Wineberg

Professor Ehrenreich patiently develops and documents his narrative as he describes the current demise of the capitalistic system, as we know it, as it morphs into an aggressive tapeworm feeding the self-interest of the power and money elite. Left behind are the poor who are poorer, the disenfranchised middle class and the politically indifferent. He challenges both the liberal and right wing narratives and provides some vision to those who say it is too complex. This is a must read for anyone sensitive to our political destiny particularly those who look to the tax dollar to sustain the public weal.

I was provided with an electronic copy in return for an honest review.