If you're a fan of creepy middle-grade stories that feel like a modern take on The Monkey's Paw with a touch of Goosebumps and Coraline, The Haunting of Old Splinter is definitely worth picking up.

The story follows Peter and his half-brother Adrian as they become entangled in the mystery surrounding Old Splinter, a decaying mansion filled with dark legends. When they discover the existence of a magical wishing claw capable of granting any desire, it quickly becomes clear that every wish comes with a terrifying price.

What I enjoyed most was the atmosphere. Jack Mackay creates an unsettling setting where every creaking floorboard, forgotten room, and whispered legend makes the mansion feel alive. The horror isn't overly graphic, but it's genuinely eerie, building suspense chapter after chapter instead of relying on cheap jump scares.

Beyond the supernatural mystery, the novel also explores family dynamics in a thoughtful way. Peter and Adrian's blended family feels authentic, and their relationship gives the story emotional weight, making you care about what happens long before the horror truly unfolds.

The pacing starts off a little slower as it establishes the characters and the legend surrounding Old Splinter, but once the wishes begin, the tension escalates quickly. The consequences become increasingly disturbing, reinforcing the classic lesson to be careful what you wish for.

Overall, The Haunting of Old Splinter delivers an entertaining mix of haunted-house mystery, cursed magic, and emotional storytelling. It's spooky without becoming overwhelming, making it a perfect choice for readers looking to transition from children's horror into something a little darker while still keeping that adventurous, page-turning spirit.