Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Idea of You is the latest novel by Amanda Prowse. From the very beginning the reader feels a connection to Lucy, the main character. At times incredibly sad there are also more than one occasion that the reader will be moved to tears. As pages turn the reader becomes very invested in the story. I was given a copy to review.

Was this review helpful?

When you come to write a review for a book you love it;s hard not to use the same phrases you've used before for good reads and I'm afraid it's the same for me today...A lovely, lovely read which made me cry but filled me with happiness too.
What craftmanship Amanda Prowse shows in her style, characters and plot. Difficult subject which thankfully I've not experienced but know many who have.
Cannot recommend highly enough and frustrated that my writing skills do not do it justice.

Was this review helpful?

I could definitely see why many women would identify with this book. It touches on the sensitive subjects of infertility and stepparenting, second marriages and family secrets. Lucy is a young, forty something, successful woman who has finally found her person in Jonah, the one who understands her, who loves her unconditionally. But not everything in life is so easy. Struggling with infertility is a terrible strain, no matter how stable a relationship is. Throw in a stepdaughter who is now staying with you and a secret so large, it could rock the very foundation you live on, well, you get one stress-filled life. If you're not careful, those fissures that are so small could turn into cracks that could never be healed. The Idea of You can be an intense read for some, but enlightening as well and for the subject matter, I was very pleased with the ending. Well done.

Was this review helpful?

This is such an engaging, tenderly crafted, beautifully written novel that speaks soul deep. The subject matter is painful and haunting but it is handled with dexterity and grace. Our main character, Lucy, has an ache in her heart which never entirely goes away, despite how successful her life looks on the surface. She has a burning longing to become a mother, a huge desire to conceive, though it seems to be thwarted at every turn. One miscarriage after another not only leaves her terribly sad, disappointed and reeling, it also begins to make holes appear in her marriage. All she thought she was certain of before becomes as uncertain as her ability to conceive.
As we read on (tissues at hand), we discover how she slowly starts to see motherhood, family relationships, secrets kept and finally shared, in a whole new light. And as she opens her heart to the love that already surrounds her, she comes to realise how parenting isn’t as limited a concept as she had thought it was. In opening up about her past, letting the light of truth into her life, growing wiser in her own understanding of things, she eventually reaches a place where the elusive happiness she sought is already a large part of her days—albeit shaped a little differently, but just as precious, nevertheless.

Was this review helpful?

The Idea of You is a powerful story about family hope ,loss and motherhood .The writing is so beautiful and poignant,I felt so sad but also so elated at the end and it's true sometimes you can't have everything you want but as long as you are happy perhaps it doesn't matter so much .

Was this review helpful?

The Idea of You

I was very excited to get my hands on a copy of this book and so would like to extend my thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for that.

The Idea of You is a highly emotional read that centres round Lucy and her yearning to be a mother. We go on a journey with Lucy and her husband through this; a gut wrenchingly powerful journey that will lead to lost babies, step daughter's, the angst of blended families and how things aren't always as they seem. I don't want to say much more as I don't want to spoil anything for you as a reader. Just know that this is an amazing book and you don't want to miss out on reading it. 5 bright and shiny stars from me!

Was this review helpful?

This story is well written and easy to read. The subject matter, whilst dealing with the events in many womens' lives is at times difficult to process. It connects on a very emotional level.

Was this review helpful?

The Idea of You is a powerful story that should be read by any woman, no matter her age or circumstances. It’s also a story for the men in our lives, those who say they want to understand us better and truly mean it. It’s a story for blended families, for couples who want children even if they themselves are no longer in the bloom of youth. It’s a story that will touch hearts, open dialogue and perhaps make people think before they offer words of comfort or give sage advice of things they know nothing about.

It is quite simply a powerful story. One that will make you feel and think, cry and chuckle, and wonder how you would face such challenges in your own life.

I believe The Idea of You is a story that needs to be read, then shared with friends and family. I do not believe it’s one that a reviewer can or should tell you about in detail. To know too much lessens the impact of this family’s struggles, pain and outcome. What Jonah and Lucy face could easily happen to any of us readers, and already has for some. The little letters simply broke my heart, for I have written a few of them myself.

If you are looking to take a realistic journey that will change how you view life, then this is a story for you. I’d highly recommend this one.

*I received an e-ARC of this novel from the publisher via NetGalley. That does not change what I think of this story. It is my choice to leave a review giving my personal opinion about this book.*

Was this review helpful?

This story is about Lucy Carpenter who has a successful career, but as she’s getting closer to 40 and single she feels she has no chance of getting the family life she so desires. Then she meets Jonah at her best friend’s daughters christening. After a short whirlwind romance they get married and try for a family of their own. Jonah already has a daughter, Camille, from his previous marriage but she lives in France. Unfortunately, Lucy suffers miscarriage after miscarriage. Whilst trying to deal with this and her very busy and stressful job, Camille is sent to stay with her father for a while.
This book was just not for me and I only read half of the book before giving up. I felt this book didn’t grab me and there was nothing for me to keep me wanting to read it. I couldn’t engage or sympathise with any of the characters, even though I have been through miscarriages myself, I still couldn’t connect with the book.
Although my experience of this novel is negative its not to say no one will enjoy it, as I’ve seen from other reviewers that they have loved the book and would highly recommend, this is just my personal review and feeling.

Was this review helpful?

I always look forward to a new Amanda Prowse book and this one did not let me down. This is beautifully and poignantly written. I had tears in my eyes as I went on a rollercoaster of life with Lucy and Jonah.. This is a story which resonates with so many people.

Sit down and prepare to be there till the book is finished!!

Was this review helpful?

I was invited to read The Idea of You by Netgalley and the publishers Lake Union Publishing. I'm not sure why as I exclusively read crime fiction but somehow, probably due to my incompetence, it arrived on my Kindle.

This is a heartwarming tale of Lucy, her husband Jonah and her teenage stepdaughter Camille who comes to visit. Camille is a disruption to Lucy's life and her attempt to have a baby of her own but it is Lucy's own secrets which cause the most disruption.

Although it is well outside my normal reading matter I quite enjoyed it although I found Lucy and Jonah's relationship a bit sickly the ending extremely trite. I liked Lucy's character as she is strong and not afraid to stick up for herself and her story is a sad one. I think it is a well planned and plotted novel with good pace.

I can't say I'll be rushing out to read another novel by Ms Prowse but The Idea of You was a pleasant change of style for me and I can see why her novels are popular.

Was this review helpful?

This is a touching, beautifully written book. I laughed and cried with Lucy and a Jonah.

Was this review helpful?

This is a very engaging book about a heartbreaking subject. Lucy and Jonah, who are newly married, want a baby. After several miscarriages, happiness seems so far out of reach for this couple. Jonah's daughter, Camille, comes to live with them over the summer and adds more stress to their lives. This is the story of how this little family learns to find happiness and love, even if you don't always get what you want. The Lord always has a plan for your life. Amanda Prowse does a very good job of taking the reader into this story and knowing the pain these characters are going through. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and Lake Union publishing for allowing me to read The Idea Of You by Amanda Prowse. Following is my review.
An inspiring and heartwarming story of love and strength that is necessary to move on after so much heartbreak.
Lucy's dream has always been to have a baby of her own. Jonah supports her through the loss of several miscarriages. This story will grab your heart and won't let go.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book after a slow start. This is the first book by Amanda Prowse that I have come across, it tells the tale of Lucy and her desperate attempts to have a baby. Running parallel to the main story is her history and as the story develops, we learn of her past too. The book tells of her developing relationship with Jonas
her husband and the turbulent arrival of his 17 year old, French, daughter in their lives.
A good story, very moving at times which develops convincingly and at a good pace. I'm going to track down some more of Amanda's books to read after reading this one, which has to be a recommendation.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful story.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful, wonderful read! I had not previously read anything by Amanda Prowse but after reading this book she goes onto my 'must read' author list. This story is beautiful and heart-breaking. Lucy seems to have the perfect life, a terrific, supportive husband, a great job and all they need now is to start their family. But as time goes on and Lucy does not conceive, she becomes more sad at the prospect of never having a child. Her husband, Jonah, has a daughter by his first marriage, but he sees her seldom as she lives in another country. Then she comes to stay with Jonah and Lucy and from there the story picks up the pace. This book had me in tears more than once, crying for all the characters. The characters are alive, warm, and totally believable. Can't wait to read more of Amanda Prowse!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.

This was a page turner and a very fast read. My first pregnancy ended in a miscarriage so I could relate to some of the storyline in a very real way. While Lucy's reactions to much of her life events seem overly dramatic, I gave her a pass based on her past. But Jonah's were a bit puzzling to me. Didn't completely ring true. However, it was a good read and worth recommending to readers with an interest in happily ever after stories.

Was this review helpful?

What a sweet book! I was aggravated at the husband character at times, how insensitive he was but it made this book seem real. This is real life, bad things happening to good people. I really liked how the author showed each characters flaws. Nice work!

Was this review helpful?

I struggled with this book. I enjoyed some of it, but I felt that I never connected with Lucy, the main character.

I thought the scenario between Lucy and her mother was interesting and would have liked to have seen more of that. I also would have liked to have seen a little more of the development of Camille I thought that most of the characters seemed a little one-dimensional.

Lucy's secret was interesting, and I was pleased that it didn't end wind up becoming a cliche.

Was this review helpful?