Not quite an academic deconstruction, not quite a fan-rave about some excellent books, this book sets out to show why Iain M Banks was so important to the resurgence of science fiction. Definitely one for those who have already read the books being discussed, as it doesn't stop before the endings, but if you are (and if not, why not!?) a fan, then some excellent nuggets about themes and inspiration.

‘Outside Context Problem’
This is a very readable, concise and scholarly study of Banks’ science-fiction novels. As the title indicates, the author focuses on those under the name Iain M Banks, but also discusses the ‘mainstream’ novels when the distinction is less clear. I suppose the inclusion of M in the authorial designation broadly indicates the novel falls into the space opera category, while the others are more generally imaginative or speculative.
There is discussion of all the Culture novels as well as the Culture itself. The early novels, so imaginatively written, so well structured, even concise, attract the greater part of the discussion. The author suggests that the Culture novels really reached their logical conclusion with ‘Look to Windward’ and subsequently Banks became increasingly devoted to religion and death in the later novels. These are not discussed in anything like the same depth as the earlier ones, even though they are all much longer, perhaps because Banks himself could not take the logical step of ending the series, just as his construct, the Culture, could not take the logical step of ending itself through the process of subliming. The Culture is described as an atheistic paradise and the writer discusses at length the problem about all paradises and heavens – the constant risk of eternal boredom! These novels are linked with relevant ‘mainstream’ novels such as ‘The Bridge’ or ‘The Business’ to demonstrate that Banks with or without an M was recognisably the same writer, one whose own biography had a profound influence on all his writing.
I suggest that this is not simply required reading for all of Banks’ many followers, but that it is thought-provoking, insightful and pleasurable too.

Me he hecho el firme propósito de leer más ensayo, para poder hablar con más propiedad y algo de conocimiento en mis reseñas. También es muy conocida mi admiración por la obra de Iain M. Banks, de modo que un libro sobre su obra parecía algo hecho ex profeso para mí.

El público objetivo de este ensayo son sin duda las personas que ya hayan leído la obra del autor referenciado. No se trata de una somera introducción, si no de un trabajo de análisis profundo sobre toda su obra.

Evidentemente Paul Kincaid es un fan de Banks, pero el discurso del libro no es para nada sesgado. Cuando tiene que cantar las alabanzas de sus primeras novelas de la Cultura lo hace sin dudar, pero tampoco tiene reparos en señalar las debilidades de sus últimas obras, quizá un tanto infladas.

Me hubiera gustado que el libro estuviera más relacionado con la vida del propio autor escocés, pero sobre estas cosas se pasa casi de puntillas. Del mismo modo que cuando Hergé se separó de su mujer su sufrimiento se ve reflejado en las eternas nieves de Tintín en el Tíbet, es de suponer que la separación de Banks tuviera su contrapartida en alguna novela, pero Kincaid no incide apenas en este y en otros hechos conocidos. Por ejemplo, el momento en que rompió su pasaporte y lo mandó a Blair como señal de protesta podría haber dado lugar a un estudio en profundidad sobre la posición política de Banks. Se tiene en cuenta, pero no se explota lo suficiente.

El recorrido que hace Kincaid por todas las obras es exhaustivo, situando cronológicamente cada publicación y relacionándola con el momento de escritura. En este aspecto el libro es brillante.

También es muy de agradecer, la presencia de un listado de autores positivamente influidos por la Cultura y los demás libros de Banks. Incluso China Mièville aparece en este conjunto, en el que hecho en falta por ejemplo a Aliette de Bodard con sus Mentes de Xuya (clarísimo homenaje al escocés) o a Ian Sales. La lista podría seguir, aunque me encanta la decisión de nombrar "heredero no oficial" a Alastair Reynolds.

Me parece especialmente esclarecedor el hecho de que Banks trabajó solo con un editor hasta que este murió. A partir de este suceso, se nota un punto de inflexión en cuanto a la extensión de las novelas, quizá domeñada por esta figura ya ausente.

La documentación utilizada por Kincaid es ingente, parece que no ha dejado entrevista sin mencionar. Al libro le falta algo, quizá que el autor se posicione con más claridad en vez de reflejar tanto las opiniones de otros o quizá hace falta que pase algo más de tiempo para que la obra del fallecido Iain se asiente como lo que es, un pilar de la ciencia ficción moderna.

Creo que este no es un libro para todo el mundo y aunque tiene partes mejorables, me parece fundamental para conocer la obra de Iain Banks. Espero que no sea el último sobre el escocés, un escritor que nos dejó demasiado pronto.

Very well researched and a good read. Would recommend to any Iain M Banks fan

A concise yet comprehensive literary analysis on the works of the late Iain Banks. Kincaid’s writing functions primarily through illustrating and deconstructing the thematic lineage and interplay between Banks’ novels published with and without the M, but also delves into the deeper political and societal backdrop in which Banks’ wrote and lived. The bits of history that Kincaid feels influenced Banks are particularly illuminating for myself, someone who knows little of Scottish or UK life, especially concerning the 70s and 80s.

Not as obviously praising of Banks’ writing as Simone Caroti’s The Culture Series of Iain M. Banks: A Critical Introduction, and in a lot of ways it does feel like a response to it. Caroti called for a need to examine Banks’ entire catalog of writing, not just the M or non-M work as had previously been done. Kincaid’s book takes exactly this approach, but with an emphasis on his science fiction work. It is also a much more balanced examination of the strengths and weaknesses at play in the novels. That being said, the rabid Banks fan inside of me enjoyed Caroti’s book quite a bit more because it more closely aligned with my own reading and interpretation of Banks; which is of course an admittedly subjective, masturbatory reason.

Caroti’s book started a new conversation; addressing the ways in which Banks had been grossly ignored, misunderstood, and misinterpreted in literary circles and criticism over the years. It posited a much better interpretation of Banks’ work than had previously existed. I’m please to see that it appears Caroti’s contribution had it’s desired effect, because this continuation of the conversation seems to have benefited greatly from it. Gone are the misreadings and general sloppy analogies in the pre-Caroti analyses. Of course, as a result, Kincaid is much more objective and more in line with a standard literary analysis, which is more intellectually pleasing, but it remains thoughtful to the corrections and additions that Caroti made previously.

The bulk of this analysis deals with Banks’ writing chronologically, but also takes into account the order in which the novels were written, rewritten and released. Since so many of them -- the Culture novels specifically -- were written very early and then reworked later in Banks’ career before being published, this method helps to trace the evolution of themes and thoughts throughout the novels as they changed and adapted. There are quite a few biographical details and quotes interspersed throughout, which I always welcome, especially considering that there is still no extant proper biography on Banks. The book then comes to a close with an illuminating interview between Banks and Jude Roberts, who received his P.h.d. on The Culture series.

This book is something I’ve been waiting a long, long time for, and I am extremely pleased that Kincaid has not only continued the conversation on Banks’ work and legacy that Caroti jump started, but also added so much to it in the process. This is a fantastic addition to the Modern Masters of Science Fiction series and I look forward to seeing where we go from here. Personally, I feel that Banks’ work needs to endure the test of time, and welcome future writings on him as a subject.

Reading about the life of a person can go two ways; it can be dry and dusty or full of wit and wisdom. Iain M. Banks by Paul Kincaid falls into the latter with a style that represents Mr. Banks very well, I think.

Mr Kincaid's biography of this science fiction/fiction master is light, but yet meaningful. It is comprehensive, detailed and enjoyable. Iain Banks' novels resonated through the world as each book was published. Iain M. Banks walked the line between fiction and science fiction. This novel seems to walk the line between biography and fiction in a similar fashion. Honest, brutal, yet showing a love for the worlds created and words written by Mr Banks.

In this work, Mr Kincaid offers us an insight into the man that was always destined to be a writer. This is a broad and engaging novel that will broaden your understanding of a man that something defied understanding.

5 out of 5 stars.

An overview of the late great Iain Banks' work, with a few biographical details along the way. It focuses on the science fiction in his oeuvre, as a careful reading of the title will hint, but also includes the M-less books where they are relevant to a discussion, or borderline SF (like Transition). Kincaid has an interesting idea about RD Laing's theory of the divided self being the underpinning of Banks' novels, and his argument is pretty convincing. This is a concise and readable book, written for an intelligent reader but not drowning in academic language. As a fan of both versions of Banks, I'd have liked a bit more on books like The Crow Road, but they are understandably out of the scope of this book. It made me want to go back and reread the whole Banks catalogue, so that must be a recommendation.

This is a good survey of Banks' work--science fiction and not, set in a biographical context of Banks' feeling about religion, experience growing up in Thatcherite Britain, fascination with the Forth Bridge in Scotland, and his personal relationships. For fans of his work, this is a useful guidebook to seeing them as a whole, or an introduction for new readers.