Cover Image: The Immortalists

The Immortalists

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The Immortalists di Chloe Benjamin è uno dei romanzi più attesi del prossimo anno e in giro iniziano a spuntare le più entusiaste recensioni.

Io ho rimandato a scrivere due righe sul libro a lungo, perché in sostanza non mi ha detto molto.

La storia inizia nel 1969, Lower East Side di New York, quando si diffonde la voce dell'arrivo di una donna che pratica una magia particolare, una viaggiatrice psichica che sostiene di poter predire a chiunque il giorno della morte.
Quattro adolescenti, Varya, Daniel, Klara e Simon, particolarmente sensibili ed evoluti interiormente, decidono di incontrarla, tra mille reticenze e dubbi (conoscere quando si morirà quanto può influenzare la vita?).

La trama li segue nei successivi cinque decenni: Simon fugge sulla costa occidentale alla ricerca dell'amore nella San Francisco degli anni ’80, la sognatrice Klara diventa una maga a Las Vegas, ossessionata dal confine tra realtà e immaginazione, Daniel cerca la sicurezza e diviene medico, sperando di poter controllare il destino, infine Varya si lancia nella ricerca della longevità, testando il confine tra scienza e immortalità.

Il romanzo ha ambizioni notevoli per quanto riguarda i contenuti ed è qui che per me ha in parte fallito.
Di assoluto interesse il tema fondante, sottile e sempre presente, tra destino e scelta, libero arbitrio e fato, realtà e illusione, nonché quanto una profezia, un timore, o comunque qualcosa che riguarda il futuro, vero o meno che sia, possa guidare o cambiare le nostre scelte.

Purtroppo l’autrice ha voluto metterci dentro mille altri argomenti, dai legami familiari, all’amore, alla discriminazione, all’AIDS, ecc. – tutti molto gettonati nella narrativa di questi ultimi tempi, ovviamente con esiti diversi a seconda degli autori –annacquando così la tematica portante e risultando un po’ artificiosa (e noiosa) nel voler per forza parlare di tutto con una serietà per nulla genuina.

Lo stile è sicuramente apprezzabile e i personaggi ben costruiti, benché Simon su tutti mi sia sembrato quasi patetico da un certo punto in poi.
Ecco, torna quel senso di esagerazione, di voler sbandierare “sto scrivendo un libro serio! tutto deve essere melodrammatico, pesante, tristissimo!” che non mi piace, perché ha il gusto di qualcosa di finto – per quanto ami anche le storie serie, cupe, deprimenti, queste devono risultare naturali e credibili.

Per questi motivi il libro non mi ha lasciato nulla ed è un peccato perché la tematica portante è eccezionale, molto interessante e se l’autrice si fosse concentrata su quella, lasciando vivere e respirare i propri personaggi, invece di renderli così rigidi e innaturali, ne sarebbe uscito qualcosa di davvero pregevole.

Almeno per me; dato che la mia voce è in assoluta minoranza, potrei essere io a non aver colto il quid in più nella storia.

Was this review helpful?

In the midst of a long hot summer, four siblings hear of a fortune teller hanging around town that can tell people the exact day they will die. The siblings go see her and all find out the day they will die, some very young, others not so young. The reader then gets to follow each sibling throughout their life to see how it all transpires. Great book on relationships, and makes you wonder if fate really is real or if they made the decisions they did because they knew they'd be dying soon.

Was this review helpful?

I loved 'The Immortalists'. I couldn't put it down. What if you could know the date of your death? Would you want to know? How might knowing shape the rest of your life?

'The Immortalists' has a fascinating premise, but the best thing about the book are the wonderful, flawed and complex characters. Every section of the book is from the point of view of a different sibling, and I loved each one more than the last.

I truly wonderful book. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful and poignant tale about 4 siblings who venture out an old woman who can foretell when you will die. We share the turmoil of Simon, Klara, Daniel and Varya as they navigate their lives despite the burden of what they know. The writing is solid, the characters fleshed out. You will devour this novel from beginning to end. It is unflinching and transparent. It brings to light what a life entails--living and pursuing, always trying to make the most of what feels important and the value of family.

Was this review helpful?

It is a fascinating idea - If you knew the date of your death, how would you live your life? Clearly the moral of this story is that we are better off as we are - not knowing!

I found myself deeply involved in each of the siblings' lives as we went along, and was intrigued to ponder the question for each of them - did they bring about their own death because of the prediction or was the fortune teller correct? I was very interested in their familial relationships the dynamics of those relationships. The author left me with some very poignant thoughts on how regret & guilt impact the quality of your life.

I enjoyed the book and will recommend at the library. My one comment would be that the book may have tried to cover too many things lightly rather than concentrating on fewer things and covering them more deeply. Still - a great page turner!

Was this review helpful?

A remarkable, moving, beautiful book, that asks the question, what is a life well lived? Do we have a choice in how we live our lives or is it all fate or destiny? This book will stay with me for a long time. Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

The Immortalists gripped me from the first sentence and didn't let go. Chloe Benjamin has written a gorgeous book! The Immortalists follows the lives of the four Gold children - Varya, Daniel, Klara, and Simon. Daniel hears rumors of a fortune teller who can predict when ypubwill die. The kids sneak out of their apartment one hot summer day and see this fortune teller. This one afternoon changes all of them, forever. How would you live your life if you knew when it would end? Would you live with heedless abandon? Would you plan every step carefully? Would you believe the prophecy was real?
Chloe Benjamin weaves big ideas about destiny, choice, and faith into a compelling, relatable, heartbreakingly beautiful story. The Immortalists is the best book I have read this year.

Was this review helpful?

Developed characters, elegant and description prose, The Immortalists is a text that will stand the test of time. The issues Benjamin addresses are ones that everyday ordinary people will relate to which is why the novel works so well.

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating look at what knowing (or thinking you know) the date of your death can do to you. Great premise and it kept me turning pages. I was so interested in how things concluded. Some people may find the shifts in time during each characters' section to be confusing but I had no problem following what was going on. A very enjoyable read!

Was this review helpful?

This is a very smart book that explores the idea of whether we would be changed by knowing the date of our own deaths. The Gold children visit a fortune teller in the late 60s who tells each of them when they will die, and they are irrevocably scarred by the information. Their relationships are tested and shattered and rebuilt as each sibling both builds their own prison out of the knowledge and seeks freedom from it.

Was this review helpful?