Cover Image: On the Spectrum

On the Spectrum

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I did not review this book on my blog as I had to stop blogging due to time constraints. I did not yet read this book.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this book was very sweet. I am not terribly knowledgeable about the topics discussed in the book, however to me it seemed as if they were well researched and handled well. I love anything that is set in Paris, also. I think this is a classic YA coming of age novel and would recommend to teens.

Was this review helpful?

Content warning for disordered eating. Many thanks to Second Story Press and NetGalley for a copy.

Clara has lived in the shadow of her ballerina mother, a woman who has been telling Clara to "suck it in" since she was 6 years old and ranting about the poisons of candy. Clara gets pulled aside by the school counselor who is concerned about her eating and they get CPS involved. Clara's mom realizes the damage she has done to her body and Clara's and tries and fails to help Clara make some changes. So Clara gets shipped off to her Dad's in Paris for the summer to go help take care of her six year old step-brother, Alastair, who is "on the spectrum."

And that's where the book went off the rails for me, honestly. I think I would have rather read about Clara and her mom healing together. The comparisons of being on the spectrum for autism against on the spectrum for eating disorders were a little weird. The romance aspect of the book was also really weird and didn't work for me.

I also took issue with people trying to fix Clara by shoving food at her thinking it would fix her eating disorder but maybe that's just because eating disorders are such scary territory and in my mind, should always be worked on with a therapist/specialist, instead of the baker you happen to be dating.

The premise of the book was good but the execution failed for me.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely appreciate the fact of the mental health and neurodivergent representation in this book and wish that there was more of it in YA. Not only is there rep, but it's, for the most part, handled well and portrayed accurately and that is so important and invaluable. More of stories like these please.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this read! Shed some great light on ASD! So so important! Individuals on the autism spectrum are so often misunderstood; this book brings some much needed information to the world about ASD and allows readers to relate to an individual on the spectrum and understand things from their point of view! Definitely worth the read! I'm so glad I had the opportunity to read and review this!

Was this review helpful?

I confess I purchased this title for our collection long before I got around to writing this review. This is a unique book in its take on eating disorders and manages to provide a thoughtful look into several major topics - autism, body image, family life, teen relationships - while making the main character's voice believably her own. The romance is key to the plot but not overwhelming, and is mercifully lacking in the everything-is-solved-once-you-find-a-boyfriend trope. The protagonist's relationship with her autistic stepbrother is endearing and realistic. Plus, it's a fun, quick read. Nicely done.

Was this review helpful?

The story was cute, but there were a lot of grammatical errors that caused me to get so frustrated I had to put down the book. The story jumped around a lot and could be incredibly cheesy.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I didn't finish this book, as I couldn't get into it - nothing against the author or book, just not to my personal taste. Thank you for the opportunity to read it.

Was this review helpful?

While the premise sounded promising, I didn't feel connected to the characters so I couldn't immerse in the story. The writing, however, was captivating to an extent.

Was this review helpful?

A well-written book with an important purpose. It deals with a lot of issues important to young adults as well as showing a truly wonderful relationship between a 16-year-old and a 6-year-old with autism.

Was this review helpful?

I loved on the spectrum and how it looked at autism in children and how non-autistic siblings react to the needs of their siblings. I loved the relationships in this novel and its take on seeing the world through a carer's eyes.

Was this review helpful?

A realistic book, that was an enjoyable read. I haven't read anything like it before, and will be looking for books on a similar topic in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. Fact. The prose was beautiful and the writing is distinctly the authors own.
Overall, the story the good and believable. Perhaps it tried to tackle too many issues in one novel, but it covered them all well enough.
I personally wasn’t familiar with orthoexia before I read this book, so it was definitely an eye-opener and I definitely feel like I learned a lot about this ED.
I adored Alastair, he was definitely my favourite character. He was so well written and developed!

Definitely a great read that I would happily recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Clara lives with her famous prima ballerina mother in New York City, and with that comes an unhealthy obsession with eating healthy. She decides to spend a summer in Paris with her estranged dad and his family after a social media disaster back home. While in the city of light, she meets Alastair, her six year old half-brother who is on the autism spectrum, as well as Michel, a young baker’s apprentice – both of whom teach Clara about how to look at life in a different way.

This was a really sweet story that encompassed life lessons in several different facets. Set against the backdrop of an iconic city, all the characters – not just Clara – go through a journey of realization and growth. I felt that a lot of the overall theme in many of the situations were about perception; what would people think? What would they think about her weight? What would they think about him being different? I really liked how this was expanded upon, that there is a balance between not wanting to change for other people vs changing for your own happiness and self acceptance.

Mental health takes many different forms and I appreciated Gold’s take on Clara’s eating habits. It wasn’t strictly black or white of Clara being anorexic or bulimic but her intense obsession with healthy eating could be considered on the spectrum of eating disorders as well. The characters go on a journey of acknowledgement and action in this book that feels hopeful for others that may be experiencing similar situations in any form.

I loved the dynamic between Clara and Alastair. When the book starts out, Clara is unsure how to be around someone on the autism spectrum, and it was great to see that sibling bond progress throughout the story as both their horizons were expanded by the presence of the other.

On the Spectrum has a strong focus on mental health and family dynamics. It’s got some drama, sightseeing fun and a little bit of romance. This would be a great book for fans of YA contemporary and anyone who has some wanderlust!

Was this review helpful?

I liked the idea of this book a lot, but I found it's execution to be lacking. Much of the way the characters with an eating disorder and the character with autism were written was reductive and childish. The novel implies that both autism and ED can easily be "cured' or "overcome" with the power of family and an emotional Come To Jesus moment. While the book had potential to be really influential, it fell short of the mark for me.

I received a free copy of this novel from Netgalley in exchange for a fair and unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

As a mother of a daughter with Autism, this book was a wonderfully powerful novel that I believe can really change the way people see others with Autism. It was so well written with characters that really jumped off the page, and I found myself completely enamored with how great the overall story was.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! I think if the characters were more fleshed out and we were able to see a bit more development, the story would have been a bit better received. Thank you for this opportunity!

Was this review helpful?

Very interesting book - I loved that it dealt with autism in a healthy way, though they really avoid use of the word austisitc. And the descriptions were amazing - I want to go to Paris so badly now.

Was this review helpful?

I just read a chapter of this and wanted to throw my laptop across the room. I didn't like it

Was this review helpful?

Genuinely enjoyed this book, especially the French setting but felt sometimes the eating disorder subject was not dealt with sensitively.

Was this review helpful?