Cover Image: Kid Authors

Kid Authors

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

As a children's librarian, I have several guidelines in evaluating nonfiction: Is the subject matter appropriate for the audience, and is it accurate? Kid Authors fell short on both counts. A wide range of authors are included. Some like Jeff Kinney will clearly interest today's kid. Others may be unfamiliar, like Zora Neale Hurston and Jules Verne, but certainly worth learning about. However the vocabulary ranges from simplistic to this final phrase about Edgar Allen Poe: "theatrical panache of a master thespian" I think the author should pick a style that is understandable to a 9-12 year old and stick with it.
I'm also not convinced that most kids if left to their own devices care about the origins of writers. If this is for a school assignment, this format really wouldn't provide the kind of information students are looking for.
Distilling information for this age range can be challenging. How much to include and how nuanced should it be. Some of these entries appear to be lifted from interviews and memoirs, and I won't argue with the memories of the author being spotlighted, but I did feel that Stabler owed it to his audience to check the information with other sources. One example stood out as he described Judy Blume reading "the latest Nancy Drew murder mystery...which she bought almost every week with her allowance." First the Nancy Drew mysteries, certainly in the early years, dealt more with burglaries and kidnapping than murder, and checking Wikipedia for publication information, I learned a new adventure came out yearly, not weekly. These may seem like petty issues, but if simple efforts on my part at fact checking brought up questions, I would expect the author to do better.
The purpose of this book and the others in this series seems to be to show kids that even our most well-known and loved heroes had challenges to overcome, and readers should thus be inspired to do the same. This is a worthy goal, but I wish the author had allowed the stories to unfold without hitting the reader over the head about fighting bullies and being loners.
One plus in this book are the charming illustrations by Doogie Horner. They should definitely appeal to the fans of today's graphic novels.
In conclusion, I don't feel this would be a good addition to my library although there may be individual kids curious to know more about the childhoods of classic authors.

Was this review helpful?

The newest book in the Kid Legends series doesn't disappoint. This book gives childhood details for well-known authors lives. This book includes both current well-known authors, like Jeff Kinney and J.K. Rowling, and others that are more "classic", such as Edgar Allan Poe and Mark Twain. Hopefully the end matter at final publishing will include a list of titles that each author has written, because there were one or two that I wasn't familiar with, and didn't know what they had even written.

Was this review helpful?

Snapshots into the childhoods of favorite authors. This book made me smile, laugh aloud, and give mental high fives to the authors when relatable stories resonated with my own childhood. This will definitely have a place in my classroom library!

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book! The stories are cute and the chapters are short. It encourages kids to get to know these authors because of the interesting stories.

Was this review helpful?

A collection of mini bios of famous authors as children and their paths to writing. This is part of a wonderful series that's great for middle grades. There are about 15 authors included, from different backgrounds and decades, contemporary ones too. I loved the one about Stan Lee. Fun illustrations and a short section of additional introductions to more writers at the end.

Net Galley Feedback

Was this review helpful?

I've worked in a middle school media center for 2 years and the one thing I have learned is that if a book doesn't capture a student's interest in the first paragraph and maintain it to the next page, that student will not read the book.

What I like about this is the selection of authors. Don't like Tolkien? Okay go on to the next. Maybe by the end a child might want to go back to read about Tolkien. As an adult, this is a very fast read but to a middle schooler, it's a good pace. A child can jump around from story to story without losing any plot points. It's set up like a "Chicken Soup for the Soul" book but is more entertaining. Really a solid effort and I will be recommending this to our book buyer.

Was this review helpful?