I sadly DNFed at around 20% in. I really wanted to love it and tried really hard! The writing is fantastic but it's very slow moving and nothing has drawn me in. I find myself not wanting to pick it back up.

A solid read throughout - would recommend to all sorts of patrons.

DNF @ 16%

I liked what I did read, but it wasn't enough to hold my attention. It's been sitting on my "currently reading" shelf for six months now, and I haven't had much of a desire to return to it. Like most, I would say I wasn't a fan of the narrative. The world building was pretty lackluster to me as well.

What an exquisite book - unusually for me, as I normally prefer a non-narrated story. But the writing! Framing the story of The Empress in the words of the one who grew through all her changes with her and loved her the most gave us an amazing love story that spanned decades. I also loved that while these were 100% kick-ass warrior women, the author wasn't afraid to show them as women - strong women don't have to become men or cold blooded to be strong.
I'll be hanging out for the second novel in the series.

I actually adored everything I was reading but I do want to point out that the Japanese representation is definitely not good. I know bloggers that are Japanese and they say it better than me and I listen because it's their culture and sadly this book was not for them. So even though I liked it of what I read (I DNFed sadly) I trust these opinions and I hope the next book in the series is more well-researched and on point.

I initially thought I would put this book on pause because I wasn't in the mood to read a long letter, which is what the first few chapters are. Then I read some reviews and discovered that the entire book is a letter. As if the awkward info-dump exposition wasn't bad enough for those few chapters, it actually takes up the whole book? No thanks.

I love the concept, I just wish it had been written like a normal book. Even if it had begun with the main characters' childhoods I wouldn't have minded!

Also, as soon as I started reading the book I was leery of the pan-Asian mashup going on here, but I am not Asian and I had not read the whole book yet, so I chose not to say anything. However, other reviewers have pointed out that Rivera does a very messy job of portraying Asian cultures.

I'm really disappointed; this was one of the books I was most looking forward to this year.

DNF @ 5%

I just... I don't understand the languages and the references... it all made me feel uneasy.

Present tense kinda throws me, which made the beginning awkward, but then it went into a letter/book. A book (from i'm assuming one lover to another) which is just going to go on and on about their lives? INCLUDING a word for word replication of a letter that one of them sent the other when they were five. Are you kidding me? No. I can suspend my belief only so far. And how long is this letter going to be??? And why??

So, I just couldn't do it.

I really wanted to like this book, but I put it down before I reached the halfway point. It has all of the ingredients to be a book that I'd absolutely adore, but my interest kept fizzling out until I set it down and forgot about it.

Still; we need more f/f fantasy!

I was beyond excited to pick this book up, even if the reviews I read on Goodreads hadn’t been very positive. It’s a f/f fantasy epic (the book is 500+ pages long) about warrior princesses. Everything about this book sounded perfect when I requested it on NetGalley...the cover, the story, the fact that it was a f/f romance (we need more of these), etc. and it didn’t let me down. I loved it!

One thing I think readers need to keep in mind when they pick this book up is that it’s a slow burn. There are a lot of pages and the story takes time to build. Yes, some sections were a bit too slow for my liking, but the author took her time building up the world and characters. Everything felt fully formed...as if I could reach out and touch it, which to me is the hallmark of a beautifully written fantasy world.

What I really enjoyed about this book was how the relationship between the two main characters, Shefali and Shizuka, took center stage. Their adventures, challenges and love for each other took hold of my heart. I just wish that I would have gotten to see both sides of the relationship as it is mostly told through letters from one POV. Besides my love for the main characters, the supporting cast was also superbly written. Ren, a little used but intriguing transgender character, really stood out. I hope that she has a larger role in future books.

Overall, I was quite pleased with this book and look forward to picking up the sequel. The author has created a gorgeous character-driven world that completely hooked me from the very start. So, while it may have been a little too long with some slow sections, it’s well worth it! This really is a book that you need to read.

I'm going to be that person and I'm probably going to get some side-eye for this but. . . I didn't like The Tiger's Daughter. I wanted to. I REALLY wanted to. It feeds into all that I could want from a fantasy novel, at least on the surface, but beneath the cover I just struggled so much.

A lot of this comes down to the writing style. It wasn't exactly strange, but it wasn't what I expected either -- and it didn't work for me. We see the story told through letters back and forth between the two protagonists which details their history. And I was bored. I mean flat out, don't want to keep reading ever again bored.

I made it about a quarter of the way through and prepared to DNF the book completely but I checked the reviews (you know, maybe I was missing some key element) and it had a bunch of 4-5 stars so there must be something redeemable, right? I pushed through to the end which took a while and I honestly didn't like the book any more than I did to start. There was just so much filler and I didn't understand why the novel would be in this format. Obviously I can't say if it would have been better if a different style had been chosen but I have to wonder.

Now I can't speak to the East Asian influence in this story as that is not my place but in terms of looking at it as a reader, the world didn't feel like it had its own uniqueness (if that makes sense). For me, it almost read like historical fiction of sorts rather than fantasy which is totally fine, mind you, but not what I was expecting or how it's been marketed. That may have just been my reading experience, though. 

I don't have much more to say about The Tiger's Daughter. I'm happy so many people enjoyed it but I found it boring to the point of nearly DNFing it which is a shame. Can't say I recommend this book but I encourage you to check out some of the positive reviews before making your own decision!

I enjoyed this book. I loved parts of it (that ending is magnificent!) and parts of it dragged on for me. It took me almost 2 months to read, partially because of the slow parts, partially because other things kept distracting me, partially because I slipped up and read other reviews on Goodreads before starting and so they were always niggling in the back of my mind.

The two protagonists are both very well characterized, and it's easy to empathize with both of them. Their motivations largely make sense, and I didn't have any believability issues with them.

I liked the narrative style, with most of the book written as a letter and only little bits taking place in the present. It does take a little bit to get used to in the beginning, but it's not horribly jarring.

I can see where the rather notorious Goodreads review is coming from with some of the cultural sensitivity issues. I don't know enough about any of the cultures that are so obviously borrowed from to say whether they're accurate critiques, but I will say that it would have made just as much sense to borrow less and make up more, and made people far less unhappy.

I liked the plot, both all the action and developing romance, as well as the focus on family relationships.

There's a lot to enjoy about this book, and I'd recommend it for folks who are looking for Asian-inspired fantasy, epic fantasy, LQBTQ fantasy, women-centered narratives, and people looking for non-linear narration styles.

I was provided a review copy of this book courtesy of Net Galley.

I really struggle to write this review. I didn’t dislike this book, but I also didn’t really like it either. The story surrounds 2 main characters that live in an Asian and Mongolian based setting where they have to fight demons. The story is told as flashbacks when the Asian-esque Empress reads her and the other main character’s life story written by a Mongolian-esque warrior woman. Did I mention that they are lesbian lovers? But of course, their life is not all rainbows and sunshine because of that (and some other drama that we find throughout the book). I’m not sure what it was for me, but there was just something off with the whole book.

This book blew me away! I loved the writing, the characters and the plot was not what I expected at all. This has lesbian romance, asian-inspired world-building and action-scenes that took me by surprise! This is truly a fantasy book which I will gladly recommend! Thank you so much to the publisher and netgalley for allowing me to read this beforehand. 4.5

I really wanted to like THE TIGER’S DAUGHTER, but sadly it didn’t work for me and I ended up setting it aside.

Born to the leading houses of two formerly warring empires, the Hokkaran princess Shizuka and Qorin child Shefali shouldn’t have been friends; but destiny has other plans, and the two warriors have many battles to fight together.

I like the idea of the world K Arsenault Rivera has created, but I wasn’t a fan of the execution. The vast majority of the story is told via flashbacks and one massively long letter, which made what little fantastical world building I saw in the first 51% feel like an info-dump. The political and cultural side of things was much more smoothly developed, but I found the representation of Qorin culture particularly troubling, as it is riddled with racist stereotypes and slurs. Your mileage may vary on this, but I wasn’t a fan.

K Arsenault Rivera is clearly a gifted writer, and I appreciate the risk she took with the narrative structure in THE TIGER’S DAUTHER. I get what she was going for here, but I found the combination of Shefali’s letters and Shizuka’s flashbacks distanced me from their stories. I wasn’t able to connect with their characters nearly as much as I would’ve liked to, and I think the use of second person is largely to blame. Normally I’d be all about two badass queer women of colour!

THE TIGER’S DAUGHTER is by no means a bad book, but it isn’t the book for me.

DNF

Unfortunately, this one just is not going to work for me at this moment. Because of density of this story, and the way that it's written, I can't give it the time it needs. What I read was confusing as all hell, and though I've heard amazing things about this book, I just don't want to continue? I can't focus right now, and I don't see myself finishing this one even if I did keep reading. But I do want to give it a try again someday, because I would probably love it, but that could be a really long time. So, I'm DNFing.

I'm afraid I'm going to have to DNF this one at 17%. After a painful reading slump and multiple goes at trying to read this one, I give up. I was looking forward to reading a developed high fantasy with a well-developed f/f romance. But I found it extremely hard to concentrate on the story as the writing was not working for me. But it was ultimately the pacing that did it for me. It was far too slow paced with little happening over multiple chapters. Ugh. I've also heard mixed reviews about this, especially regarding the racial representation, how Japanese culture was appropriated and offensive slurs were used.

Very well written, beautiful love story. Some of the author's world building is slightly problematic.

K Arsenault Rivera's The Tiger's Daughter opens a most unusual fantasy series, Their Bright Ascendency. Its leads are two magically powerful young women whose destinies have been intertwined since they were infants.

I have to admit that I found the epistolary style in which this story is written difficult to connect with. Readers follow past event through letters. We watch love bloom and grow between these two women, a love that survives even demonic possession.

The following DNF review was posted to Every Day Should Be Tuesday on 11/14/17:

I stuck with The Tiger’s Daughter for either a short time or a long time, depending on how you look at it. On one hand, I only made it 20% through the book according to my Kindle. On the other hand, I spent over a month getting to that 20% according to Goodreads. If a book is that much of a slog, and I have a figurative stack of ARCs sitting on my bedside table I am excited about, why grit my teeth and push through?

It’s a bold strategy to structure at least the first fifth of your book as an As You Know, Bob. I say at least a fifth because Rivera was still doing it at the point in the book at which I bailed. The book (apparently) focuses on two women, and in particular their relationship. Each is the daughter of a powerful woman in Mongolian and Chinese analogs, respectively. The portion I read is entirely structured as one of the women telling the other women about their childhood together by letter.

Does it pay off for her? No. The first fifth of the book contains exactly one action sequence (involving a tiger). It is a bit much considering out young the girls are at that point, but I generally pretty happy to overlook that sort of thing. The rest is presumably intended as setup of their characters, their relationship, the setting, the underlying conflicts, and so forth. I’m not even sure that stuff in uninteresting, but the basic structural choice of presenting it as an As You Know, Bob absolutely deflates the setup. A good story told poorly isn’t a good story at all.

The only good news is that now I really want to finally open Elizabeth Bear’s Range of Ghosts to wash the bad taste out of my mouth. Based on Karen Memory, Range of Ghosts can’t possibly be as bad as The Tiger’s Daughter. Which maybe gets good at some point! But life is too short to stick through to the end for every single book.



Disclosure: I received an advance copy of The Tiger’s Daughter for review.

Well, it took me nearly three months to complete this brand new fantasy series. I came close to DNF'ing a number of times. Personally, it was the perspective from which the story was told. Relating a story in which one character is reviewing for another, all that has happened when the latter was actually there for those events, was a bit strange. It felt very similar to reading a prequel which fills in all the little hints that were given in the series. On the other hand, I will give the author acknowledgement for steeping the series in the traditions of Japanese and Mongolian culture. Also I liked that two strong young women framed the basis of the love story. As a teacher, I think it is important that students have examples of different relationships not just the tried and true- one girl, two guys, who will she choose?

I will settle on a 3 star because I neither hated nor loved the story.