Manhattan Beach

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 03 Oct 2017

Member Reviews

This multilayered story is on the surface a story about New York City and gangsters and what happens when you  lose favor with them. But dig deeper and it is a story of survival and escaping the hand that life has dealt you (being controlled by the gangsters that ruled your neighborhood, etc.). It is a story of not being afraid to make tough choices and accepting the potential consequences. The story starts slow and at times didn't hold my attention.
Was this review helpful?
Started but not for me, no review for incomplete book, it isn't fair. Loved Goon Squad but couldn't connect with this one. Sorry!
Had to add a star rating to send this.
Was this review helpful?
messages and money between gangster club owners.   One day he walks out the door never to return, leaving Anna, her mother, and disabled sister behind.  
  Year pass, the world is at war, and Anna moves to New York.   It was so interesting to read about the many women working as welders and labourers, jobs that were previously only considered for men.  Working in an office in the New York shipyard, Anna desperately wants to train as a diver and encounters a lot of resistance from the bosses who think it is ludicrous for a woman to attempt such a difficult and dangerous job.  A contact that Anna makes at this job gives her a lead to follow on what happened to her father.  
Meanwhile, the narrative shifts to Anna’s father and the reader follows his story as well.   
The main characters, Anna, her father, and the gangster are all so well developed, each one flawed and complex.   
I highly recommend this novel!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
After Anna Kerrigan's gangster father disappears, she comes of age during WWII and begins a career as a diver working on warships but her father's legacy lingers on in her life.

Jennifer Egan's Visit From the Goon Squad was a masterpiece in entangled stories. Manhattan Beach weaves a few narratives together in a much less haphazard but also less enticing story: Anna Kerrigan's father is a gangster in New York, her mother is an ex-Follies dancer, and her sister suffered a birth injury and is permanently disabled.  After Anna's father disappears, Anna is working a tedious job doing parts inspections for the war when she notices the divers going under water in the harbor and is suddenly drawn to them. After becoming a diver herself, she becomes entangled with Dexter Styles, a nightclub owner who was a contact of her father's. Styles lives in Manhattan Beach on Coney Island, and Anna visits his home as a child with her father and then visits again with her sister as an adult.

It is clear from this book that Jennifer Egan did her research on women in the war, gangsters in New York of the era, and the war in general. But in her attempt to pull it all together to build a narrative, it gets bogged down in the story lines of Anna, her father, and Dexter Styles.  There is little suspense and the characters lack dimension. During the time when Anna's whole family is together in their apartment, the story holds together and the characters come alive. The forays into gangster conversations and even Anna's career seem plastic and the characters' motivations are just not clear. It reminded me a bit of Elizabeth Gilbert's The Signature of All Things-- like the author's desire to paint a picture of a woman's life at a certain point in history just made the story overly earnest and stilted. In some ways it seems like too modern of a perspective, in that there is little mention of the shaming that would have been directed at a woman with her status. Although Anna experiences adversity, it's hard to really grasp the amount of strength she would have to have to pursue her diving career. Class is an issue, but it's just not felt in the way that makes it real. Anna is too impervious. The thing I loved about Egan's previous book, A Visit from the Goon Squad, was how it captured the different phases of people's lives, the miasma of disappointment and indecision and inertia that engulfs people as they get older. Manhattan Beach shows glimpses of that, for example when Dexter Styles tries and fails to redirect his career, and when Anna's father does the same. But the story seems so stretched to force Anna into her diving career and into the storyline with Dexter Styles, it loses sight of her humanity.

Egan's descriptions of war ships residing in the bays of New York City are moving. The machinery of war dominating the shorelines of New York is an overwhelming image. Her portrayal of the tedium of the work done by women and the men who were not fighting is fascinating.  Anna's dive-mates are all men who are not fighting in the war, and I wish their stories had eclipsed some of the gangster stories.  Marle, the only black person on the dive crew, is marginalized in the same way that Anna is. Their wary interactions and eventual friendship were interesting.

The book was recently longlisted for the National Book Award, and Jennifer Egan won a Pulitzer Prize for A Visit from the Goon Squad.
Was this review helpful?
I love Jennifer Egan's books, but this one fell short for me. It lacked the glamour, nostalgia, and thrill of her other books. Set during WWII, this book follows the story of Anna as she becomes a diver in the Naval Yard. Jumping between present time and memories from the past we learn of the mysterious disappearance of her father and his connections with NYC gangsters. This all sounds exciting, however it fell short. The mystery lacked excitement and was quickly explained without drama. At times it took a second read for me to understand if the narrative was about the past or present since the shifts in time were sometimes abrupt and lacked transition. This book could've been so much more entertaining giving the subject matter, but with so much details on diving, ships, and the Navy Yard it struggled to hold my attention.

Thank you to Netgalley for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
I was looking forward to reading this but sadly didn't like it. It was extensively researched, the historical atmosphere and tone were all in place, but I found the characters and a lot of the plot to be just... meh and uninvolving. In some ways it felt like the author was trying to write a romance novel, but left out all the heart and soul that make romance novels work and make us care about the character's lives and fates. All the emphasis was on Eddie and Dexter stories, and I didn't like or care about them. So, unfortunately, not a recommended read.
Was this review helpful?
Thanks to NetGalley and to Scribner for providing me with an ARC copy of this book (due for publication in October) that I freely chose to review.
I read Egan’s A Visit from the Goon Squad a few years back and I was fascinated by its language, the stories, the way the story was told, and its inventiveness. When I saw Egan’s new book on offer at NetGalley I couldn’t resist. I have not read any of Egan’s other novels, but this one is very different from A Visit. For starters, this is a historical fiction novel. Both from the content of the novel and from the author’s acknowledgements at the end, we get a clear sense of how much research has gone into it. The novel covers a period around World War II, in New York and the surrounding area, and focuses on three stories that are interconnected, and are also connected to seafaring, the seafront, New York, and to the war era. The story goes backwards and forwards at times, sometimes through the memories of the characters, and sometimes within the same chapter, we get to see how that particular character got to that point. Although the story is narrated in the third person, we are firmly inside the character’s heads, and we can be at sea one minute, and the next at home remembering one gesture, a smile… 
Anna Kerrigan is the strongest character and the one we spend more time with. We follow her story and know of her circumstances: a severely disabled sister, a father who disappears, and a mother who decides to go back to her family. Anna is a young woman, independent and determined to live her own life. She has never made peace with her father’s disappearance and remembers a strange encounter, when she accompanied her father as a child, with a man later revealed to be a gangster. Anna’s story was the one I was most interested in. Partly, because she was the character we got to know in more detail, partly because of her eagerness and determination, as she decides to become a diver and does not give up until she achieves her goal (at a time when being a woman severely limited one’s options, even during the war, when there were a few more openings, as she was already working at the Navy Yard). Her relationship with her sister, her training to become a diver (and you feel as if you were with her inside the incredibly heavy suit), and her obsession with finding out what happened to her father make her somebody to root for, although I found it difficult to engage at an emotional level with the character (it was as if she was contemplating herself at a distance and always analysing what she was doing, except for some brief moments when we get a sense of what she is feeling). 
Dexter Styles is a strange character: he married a woman of the upper-class, and he has a good relationship with her father and her family, but by that point he was already involved in some shady deals and the underbelly of New York clubs and gambling joints, and he is smart, elegant, classy, but also ruthless and a gangster. I’ve read in a number of reviews that there are better books about New York gangsters of the period, and although I don’t recall having read any, I suspect that is true. I found the background of the character interesting, and his thoughts about the links between banking, politics, legal business, and illegal enterprises illuminating, but I am not sure I would say I completely got to know the character and did not feel particularly attached to it. (His relationship with Anna is a strange one. Perhaps it feels as if it was fate at work, but although I could understand to a certain extent Anna’s curiosity and attraction, Styles did not appear to be a man who’d risk everything for a fling. And yet…).
Eddie, Anna’s father, makes a surprise appearance later in the book and we get to learn something that by that point we have suspected for a while. From the reviews I’ve read, I’m probably one of the only people who enjoyed Eddie’s story, well, some parts of it. I love Melville (and the book opens with one of his quotes) and when Eddie is at sea, in the Merchant Navy, and his ship sinks, there were moments that I found truly engaging and touching. He is not a sympathetic character overall, as he takes a terribly selfish decision at one point in the book, but seems to redeem himself (or is at least trying) by the end. 
This is a long book, but despite that, I felt the end was a bit rushed. We discover things that had been hidden for most of the book, several characters make life-changing decisions in quick succession, and I was not totally convinced that the decisions fitted the psychological makeup of the characters or the rest of the story, although it is a satisfying ending in many ways. 
The novel’s rhythm is slow, although as I mentioned above, it seems to speed up at the end. There are jumps forward and backwards in time, that I did not find particularly difficult to follow, but it does require a degree of alertness. There are fascinating secondary characters (Nell, the bosun…), and the writing is beautifully descriptive and can make us share in the experiences of the characters at times, but I also felt it didn’t invite a full emotional engagement with them. I was not a hundred per cent sure that the separate stories interconnected seamlessly enough or fitted in together, and I suspect different readers will like some of the characters more than others, although none are totally blameless or sympathetic. An interesting book for those who love historical fiction of that period, especially those who enjoy women’s history, and I’d also recommend it to those who love seafaring adventures and/or are curious about Egan’s career.
Was this review helpful?
The story begins in the depression with 12 year old Anna and her father, who later abandons the family. During WWII, Anna becomes the first woman diver at the Brooklyn Navy Yard and learns the secrets of her father who she suspects was involved with the mob. A good historical fiction about this time in US history, the role of women, merchant marine life, organized crime and class distinctions.
Was this review helpful?
Anna Kerrigan is a strong willed young woman trying to carve out a meaningful life in Brooklyn during WWII.  Anna has a sister who has muscular dystrophy, and she spends her evenings and weekends, helping her mother care for Lydia.  Anna's father is a bagman for mobster Dexter Styles.  As a child, Anna always accompanied her father on his business visits, and they were very close.

The war gears up, and Anna's dad has disappeared. Anna works in the shipyards of Brooklyn setting her sights on getting a job as a diver.  It isn't an easy for women to get accepted in those kinds of positions, so Anna turns to her supervisor in the welding department, Mr. Voss, for help. With iron clad determination and an unwavering vision, Anna becomes the first female sea diver.

The rest of Anna's story is about her love of life and nature.  Jennifer Egan presents the story of WWII, Irish Americans, and young women of the day with a finely tuned ear for young love and the grief of loss, and the ravages of war.  I enjoyed this novel and learned so much about a part of history and life in Brooklyn at Manhattan Beach.

Thank you to Net Galley, Jennifer Egan, and Scribner for the opportunity to read and review this e-ARC (pub. date 10/3).
Was this review helpful?
What a page turner!  I love historical fiction and this book really delivered.
Was this review helpful?
Loved this book! Fictional characters with a flare of historical fiction about the first civilian woman diver working in the New York naval yards during the war. Also a rich blend of the mob & crime & violence during this era. Truly fascinating.
Was this review helpful?
**** 4.5 stars: Loved it and probably stayed up all night reading and developing real feelings for fictional people.

This Great Depression to WWII-set novel is great for anyone.





Recommended readers:

If you like novels with history and drama
If you want an action-packed, historical read
If you like strong female characters
Anyone!
Here's my Rankings:

5/5 for characters
4/5 for plot
4.5/5 overall
REVIEW FROM BOOKS FOR HER:

A single woman in Brooklyn, Anna Kerrigan is essentially on her own in during changing times as the US fights WWII. Anna fights for her career as a Navy diver, while trying to uncover why her father mysteriously disappeared.

Delving into history from The Great Depression to World War II, Jennifer Egan weaves a mysterious tale with a mix of elements of history. Through the eyes of Anna, you experience a fascinating story of crime and mafia, class tensions and family drama, with historical significance. Grab a copy for you, your husband and friends to enjoy: Manhattan Beach is a perfect read for anyone - lovers of drama, history, mystery and more.

Available Oct 3: Manhattan Beach by Jennifer Egan
Was this review helpful?
I admit I fell in love with Jennifer Egan's prose in Visit from the Goon Squad. This book is unlike that one in nearly every way, except that again here the prose can be taut or elegant, often both at once. The story is radically different, focusing on the ports of New York City rather than the music scene and aging artists. In fact the water is as much a heroine as the family depicted, and inform everything they do. From mobsters to sinking ships and diving for the war effort as well as to retrieve the past- everything surrounds the water. It is clearly well researched, but the details never get in the way of the story.

All that said, I never loved our heroine. Anna is in many ways a cold and unknowable young lady. That distance is what allows her to thrive as a diver, despite being a woman. It also makes the book more complicated. There are no truly right or wrong people in this, except for the sister whose disability makes her inherently pure, but the occasion for so much grief.

Powerful and interesting. Not my favorite, but written well enough that I didn't mind. Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review!
Was this review helpful?
A very interesting read about diving in World War II.
Was this review helpful?
The author's writing is lyrical and her style continues to evolve. She has clearly done her research into the many varied elements of the book and constructed World War II era New York with clarity and precision.
Was this review helpful?
The beginning of the book I liked.   The writing style was exceptionally good.   It was interesting to read about how divers were used in WWII/  Furthermore, it had a stronger plot line than much modern that I have recently read which I liked.

However, the ending of the book was very weak.   The book just stopped with no resolution; the style of the first half of the book required a strong finish that had a twist.
Was this review helpful?
Wonderful second novel from one of my favorite writers.
Was this review helpful?
This book was provided to me in exchange for an honest review. What can I say?!? Run don't walk to get this book! 5 big stars!!
Was this review helpful?
I loved the beginning of this book and was fully engaged until about the half-way point.  Then the story began to drag for me and I didn't love the story within the story about her father.  I felt like a got to know Anna yet some of things she did just didn't work for me.  I don't think some of her actions fit her character.  I did find it interesting to read about women's roles at the Navy Yard during WWII and specifically the scenes that involved Anna at the YARD when she was trying to become a diver.

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an early release of this book.
Was this review helpful?
I’m a sucker for historical fiction and a female protagonist and when you throw in a mystery it becomes a triple threat. Choosing this title was a no brainer because it seemed right up my alley. 

	I loved the setting and the time period. The time of Rosie the Riveter is perfect for a strong female who wants to make a difference in the world. Enter Anna, growing up with the thought that women should be important in the work force. She sucked me in with her brazen choices in her personal and professional life. She has gumption and at the bare bones of her existence, she wanted what was best for everyone. 

	There are a ton of side stories in the novel. Anna’s father has his own backstory, then his current story and his associates have their own place in the timeline, so there is so much information about each character that it can be tricky to wrap your mind around. It was clever in the way Anna was integrated into each of the other character’s presence. She is dominate even when she isn’t actually in the scene, so I thought she was demanding in a good way. 
	
	The sense of mystery in Anna’s father’s disappearance is intriguing all the way through the story because it appeals to that raw want to know whodunit.  All of these elements add up to an intriguing plot and an interesting lead. Since most of the scenes revolve around the Naval Yard, and the occupation of Anna is a major aspect of the story, there were lengthy descriptions of maritime elements. Some were fantastic and really helped sell the setting of the story. The descriptions added to the intensity of what was happening and it created a good sense of tension. Other times, specifically of the different types of boats, it seemed a little too dense and detracted slightly from the story, using a little too much language. Overall this was an entertaining work that checked many genre boxes.
Was this review helpful?