Cover Image: Emma in the Night

Emma in the Night

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

It isn't often that I'm compelled to stop everything to finish a book the day I start it. This book was a captivating read. The plot is well done and characters very well developed. The complex play between family members with their lies, half truths and power struggles caught my interest and never let go. I highly recommend giving this book a try. It's now compelling me to add this author to my list of favorites.

Was this review helpful?

Given that I ended up DNFing , All is Not Forgotten, I was a bit skeptical going into Emma in the Night. I'm always willing to give an author a second chance. I was pleasantly surprised at what I found in this book. Sisters, Cass and Emma, disappeared three years before and now Cass has returned with an unbelievable story. The hunt for Emma is still on, but can Cass be trusted?

At times, I did find that this book dragged in places. But for the most part, I thought it was a solid mystery. The story did keep me engaged and I wanted to finish it to see what the truth was. The entire time you read this book, you are unsure if Cass is a reliable character. The was the story told between Cass's first person account and Abby's third person Point of view. The plot is laid out well, revealing information at just the right time. I thought I had the ending all figured out, but I was mostly wrong.

There is a lot of dysfunction in this family. The mother, Mrs. Martin was sickeningly narcissistic. That just touches the surface of what is wrong with this family. How that all plays into the disappearance of the girls is something you will have to read to find out. I do recommend this book. It's one that will make you want to keep reading to find out the truth.

Was this review helpful?

Emma in the Night looked interesting so I thought I'd give it a shot, especially because we tend to stay in Romancelandia for most of our reviews. This novel was what I call a palette cleanser-- it's job is to take me out of the romance genre for a few days so that when I go back in I've missed it and I'm ready for more. I think Emma in the Night did that for me. It was an interesting read--full of psychology and psychology jargon, the dynamics of a really fucked up family, and some really astute observations about how people manipulate and use and or succumb to the machinations of others. As much as this was fiction, it felt equally real. It was that realism that drew me in and repelled me. I liked how observant this writer is and yet I found myself so overwhelmed by the truths she offered through her characters that it almost felt like it was too much. The redemptive qualities of the characters and plot were few and far between. The idea of hope? Just a glimmer on the page.

While I wasn't blindside by the ending, I did find myself curious as to how our characters would get to the conclusion I'd figured out --and it was that journey that kept me interested and reading.

*Link to review will come when review is live*

Was this review helpful?

Two sisters disappear, three years later one returns and what seems like the end of the mystery is really only the beginning.

Was this review helpful?

First thoughts after finishing the book:
Wow, wow, wow!! I did NOT expect this to end the way it did, at all. One of the best thrillers I've read this year. The second book I've read by this author, and I'm hungry for more from her.

Full review:
Cass's family is incredibly dysfunctional, and sometimes difficult to read about, but she never lets them break her or dim her desire for justice, closure, and a new life.

The entire book is filled with twists, turns, and suspense. Every time I thought I knew what had actually happened, the next twist would send me off in another direction. Things are definitely not always what they seem. I enjoy the alternating viewpoints and the way they keep the reader off balance.

**I received a copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher, with no expectation of a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.**

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from NetGalley for an honest review.

I read this book while pregnant with my first child. There have been several occasions where I think to myself, "Am I just going to magically know how to be a mom?!". After reading this book, one thing was clear... don't do anything the mother in this book does, and I will probably be fine.

This is not a twisty, turny, on the edge of your seat thriller. But it is a well written, well paced, building story that suddenly slams.

I really enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

A rabbit warren of theories formed in my head whilst reading this book but never did I expect the end. A great, tense read with lots of potential suspects. Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

ARC copy via Net Galley - Thank You

Haven't read this Author's other book but liked the title cover & synopsis for this book.

'We believe what we want to believe. We believe what we need to believe.'

Enjoyable read told from different characters view points each one giving you that little bit more information telling you that all is not as it seems and needing you to read on. The author definitely knows her subject matter and I did find myself glossing over some parts as they seemed repetitive but I suppose helps you understand that the illness is not just selfishness & self centredness.

The characters certainly change from how they were introduced and goes to show what goes on behind closed doors.

Enjoyed the ending . Enjoyed the whole book. 4 stars from me

Was this review helpful?

This was incredibly creepy. I can usually piece together a mystery before it is revealed, but this one kept me guessing constantly. 10/10 would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

The way this ultimately weaved together was fascinating, but ultimately not something I was super excited about.

Because the way this book was told was all gearing up for the ending, for the "plot twist," but it didn't really make the rest of the book that interesting to read. I was intrigued, yes, but I picked up a couple of other books while reading this and probably would have forgotten it had I not been reading to review.

This was another book were the details were quite clever and the way that they were strung together to create a picture was done well. I think perhaps I'm over having something at the end be a big reveal and then having all those details explained. I didn't feel like Walker had much respect for the reader in thinking that they could put pieces together.

Walker has strong concepts and I'll look out for her next book, but this one didn't quite do it for me.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars
This really worked for me. I loved delving into the psyches of different characters and seeing some really interesting psychologies there.

Was this review helpful?

This book was hard for me to read as way to long and really didn't keep my interest. Hate giving bad reviews but this was not up to my usual thrillers I like to read.

Was this review helpful?

This book takes you for a wild ride through the viewpoints of two characters, Cass Tanner, one of the girls who disappeared, and Dr. Abby Winter, one of the ones that searched for her. I was shocked over and over again throughout this book--good job, Walker!

When Cass returns home after being missing for a number of years her mother didn't even recognize her. But as her story unravels between the countless interviews with police and other government forces you begin to realize that part of her might forever be away. All Cass wants is for her sister, Emma, who also disappeared, to be found. As the reader of the book even you don't know what to believe or how Cass, a narrator who seems to be completely candid (at least in her thought life), could fool even us.

Read this, no really...do it.

Was this review helpful?

This book ended up being a hard one for me to get into. In the beginning of the book, when Cass has returned from wherever she has been, she begins telling a story about this island that she and her sister Emma were living on. She goes on to explain that she had her way with Emma and they went to this island to get help from a couple who aids runaway teens. There's a bit more to the story, but I'll let you figure that out as a reader.

The entire story that she tells sounded very far-fetched to me from the beginning. I found Cass as a character to be a bit intolerable. While the other characters were excited about her return, I did not feel the same excitement. I don't think she was built up to be a character who was particularly likable, which made it hard for me to celebrate the fact that she was home. I was more invested in Dr. Winter, a psychologist from the FBI who was working the case when Cass and Emma disappeared about three years ago. Her insights into the family in the way that she piece together the actual story behind the disappearance was what kept me reading.

The end of the novel does have an excellent twist ending, so you do get the pay off that you're looking for all the way through. Overall I did enjoy this book, although it was not the page turner than I had hoped it would be. I still recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely magnificent book! This story of narcissism is equally as informative and educational as it is entertaining. A brilliantly complex piece of work with great attention to detail, the story is told from the viewpoints of Cass and Forensic Psychologist Abby and the two complement each other perfectly. A great plot with plenty of twists throughout, I hope to see this played out on the big screen.

Was this review helpful?

This started out as an interesting idea...two girls disappear, and one returns years later without the other. Where has she been? Is what she is telling her parents and police true? The idea of the narcicistic mother controlling her families choices was interesting and fresh, but the end felt hurried and a little muddy. Overall, not a bad read.

Was this review helpful?

A very well written book about two sisters that go missing and years later only one returns. This book kept me guessing through out it. The reader is presenting with multiple viewpoints that make you question everything you thought you knew. The forensic psychologist is pretty quick to figure out that things don't add up and maybe the narcassistic mother has more to do with the disappearance than she originally lets on. However, the doctor's past makes her colleagues question her. A very engaging read. .

Was this review helpful?

Emma in the Night is Walker’s second novel after 2016’s All is Not Forgotten, and while the two books share much in style and substance, I found this one more compelling and enjoyable. Three years ago, the Tanner sisters – 17-year-old Emma and 15-year-old Cassandra – went missing with no explanation. The circumstances were suspicious – Emma’s car was found abandoned in a parking lot near the beach, and her shoes abandoned by the shore. There was no evidence that Cass was with her, and yet she is gone too.

Now, three years later, Cass shows up on her mother’s doorstep – without Emma. She tells an incredible tale about kidnapping and captivity on an isolated island which cannot be located, and a daring and dangerous plan for escape. Forensic psychiatrist Abigail Winter worked on the Tanner sisters’ case years before, and she always felt that there was some obvious clue that she was missing. Now, hearing Cass’s story and watching her interactions with her mother, she suspects that the reason for the girls’ disappearance is close to home. With Cass’s help, Abby slowly uncovers the dysfunctional family’s secrets of narcissism and abuse.

The novel is told in dialogue, as Cass slowly reveals her (perhaps unreliable) story in careful moderation – she manipulates her audience much as Walker leads the reader on this fascinating journey. The structure of this novel is much like Walker’s first novel – it is an unconventional thriller in which the story takes place after the main action has concluded. It is more like reading the case notes of a crime, delving into the obsession and mental illness that formed these characters. There is much more telling than showing, and yet it works. Cass’s story is perhaps even more compelling because we did not witness the action and therefore cannot know if anything she’s saying is true.

The procedural aspects of the story are not all that realistic, but it is worthwhile to suspend disbelief and trust that each piece will eventually fit together. The slow reveal is geared towards reader manipulation – to keep us guessing and successfully create suspense. I thought some of the characters could have been more complex, instead of so clearly good or evil – but Cass especially was intriguing. Her narration is detached and cold, which keeps the reader at a distance, but it works because she withholds her true feelings and motivations right up to the last scene.

While Emma in the Night has its flaws, Walker is a talented storyteller who manages to lead the reader without oversimplifying the story. The descriptions of mental illness are fascinating and disturbing, especially as Emma and Cass are affected by their mother’s behaviour in very different ways. Cass’s flat narration has a strong emotional undercurrent that gives depth to the novel, creating an intelligent and thoughtful mystery that crosses genres in unexpected ways.

I received this book from St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

There are always stories about dysfunctional families, mysteries, police investigations... Emma in the Night kept my interest as it weaved its way through past and present and told the story of 2 girls and a manipulative mother. Now, we've all known those people who know how to manipulate others, but Emma in the Night added in multiple perspectives and timeframes in a seamless way that keeps you going, wondering who is telling the truth. There isn't anything in this that's merely for shock value or to serve as a red herring... it all ties together.

Cass and Emma are sisters. Their parents have divorced, their mother is manipulative, there's a step-brother and step-father thrown in the mix. Their mother is a narcissist and uses situations to use the girls against each other to prove who loves her most, granting favors to the favored child and leaving the other always trying for approval.

One night, Cass and Emma disappear and an investigation ensues. The psychologist on the case has a family history with narcissistic parents and suspects there's more to the story but can't prove it. They remain missing for several yearsr, and then Cass returns.. but where's Emma? Cass's return has multiple twists and does a remarkable job telling how life in the household affected her, how Emma reacted, the roles that their mother, father, stepfather, stepbrother, and half-brother all played. The original investigator and psychologist are back as well, so through brilliant storytelling, you learn how the original disappearance and return affected everyone. I was honestly surprised at the ending and thoroughly enjoyed the book.

If you're looking for a great read with intrigue and family dynamics, this book is for you.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book for an honest review. Two sisters go missing on the same day, three years later, one sister comes home so what happened to the other sister? Great roller coaster ride.

Was this review helpful?