Tarnished City

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 09 Apr 2018

Member Reviews

Not bad at all for a middle book. The pace kept right on roaring along and the author didn't rest on her momentum. Looking forward to see how it all wraps up.

This review is in exchange for a free e-galley received from netgalley.com.
Was this review helpful?
Better than the 1st in the series. Unique and highly entertaining. This is a great Teen-Adult crossover title. Will have broad appeal. Easy to recommend.
Was this review helpful?
WHY DID I LISTEN TO TARNISHED CITY BY VIC JAMES?
Tarnished City by Vic James is a book that I ABSOLUTELY had to listen to. This book is the sequel to Gilded Cage. With the way that Gilded Cage ends, there’s no way I am not continuing. And so, as I said I above, I immediately put a hold on this audiobook at the library. I could have read a physical copy, either as an eARC or a Hardcover. I just wanted to continue reading in the same format that I had already become accustomed to, however. Now I am ready for book three to see how everything plays out and ends for the Dark Gifts trilogy.

WHAT’S THE STORY HERE?
Okay, so, Tarnished City takes the dark nice of Gilded Cage and brings it up a notch. Basically the story picks up with Abi and Luke reunited for a hot few seconds. They then proceed to spend the rest of the book apart. Luke is forced to wear a golden, magical collar, given his rebellion. He’s also shipped off to a remote castle run by this sadistic lord who was said to have murdered another Equal. Abi is a fugitive from Millmoor. Daisy is still with the Jardines taking care of the baby. Gavar is getting married to another Skilled person named Bouda, who is the worst. And well, Silyen is kind of hard to really place into a category box. There’s a few storylines and a LOT going on.

HOW DID I LIKE TARNISHED CITY?
The ending to this book is really wild. I mean, there’s something really dark that happens and I was just hoping against hope. Then there’s kind of this zero hour thing. It’s just really tense. I enjoyed reading that. Granted, I am still looking back at this book thinking about it and reflecting on it. It is very grim. I liked it, but I also wish that I had physically read it so that I retained more of it.

HOW’S THE NARRATION?
Avita Jay also narrated the audiobook of Tarnished City. She does a nice job. I also listened to this one sped up — this time at 1.75 speed. It’s a relatively decent audiobook. It is well produced. There’s nothing really wrong with it. I am not sure how I will experience the next book in this trilogy though. The audio was good, but I am leaning hard towards physically reading it.
Was this review helpful?
Tarnished City is an outstanding sequel to Gilded Cage. The story is darker and even more exciting. The stakes are high. This is a hard one to get into the plot for fear of spoiling the series, but just know it holds up. The series gets better from here. It is fast-paced and unputdownable. Highly recommended!
Was this review helpful?
This is the second book in Vic James Dark Gifts exciting trilogy. It picks up where we left off . Luke is now a prisoner , Abi is on the run . I will say you need to read the first book to get the whole story for these characters . The story takes place in Britain where the world is governed by Equals upper Gentry with magical skills. If you are an ordinary citizen you have to be a slave for 10 years . The characters are so intriguing and the book is so well written you become enthralled with the story. You will be angry and sad at some injustices . All in all this a thrilling series and I cannot wait for the third
Was this review helpful?
I struggled through Gilded Cage because I found it to be an intriguing but very bleak read. This second volume in the series was a real page-turner, though. 

The action picks up right where the previous book left off, with slaves Luke and Abi facing their fates as a prisoner and a newly minted revolutionary, respectively. Luke has to adjust to an unusual prison that consists of mind games as well as casual cruelty. Abi and Luke’s friends plot his rescue before turning their attention to overthrowing the Slave Days system and the rule of the Equals. Meanwhile, brothers Gavar and Silyen both also chafe at the Equal regime now led by their father, if for different reasons. 

Part of my difficulty with the first book was the huge power imbalance between the ordinary people and the Equals, which made their resistance seem almost futile. That imbalance remains, but the resilience of the freedom fighters keeps it from being quite so prominent this time around. However, the world depicted is full of brutality, and people do die, including some of the important characters from the first book.

One thing that really intrigues me about this novel is the way the author depicts the Equals in her story. Some of them do horrible things, but they aren’t all one-dimensional baddies. For example, the first book opens with Gavar murdering his slave lover, the mother of his child, which would seem to make him irredeemable. In this book, though, we learn some additional information about that death, which casts Gavar in a somewhat different light. And while he’s no revolutionary willing to pursue change for the sake of justice or some other ideal, more practical considerations seem to be leading him in the same direction. (The various motivations for and the paths the characters are taking toward regime change are really a highlight of the book.)

I think Gavar’s brother Silyen is the most fascinating character, though. At first, he seemed like a sociopath, but I’m not sure that’s the case. Something he says near the end of the book suggested to me that he might be more of “the end justifies the means” kind of person, willing to accept necessary casualties to achieve his aims. But what his goals are and who they will truly benefit are murky, to say the least. I’m really curious as to how his objectives tie into the connection he has formed with Luke, the other character I find interesting. 

So, I’m hooked and will definitely be reading the next book in the series. I’d highly recommend it to readers interested in dark fantasy with political themes.

A copy of this book was provided through NetGalley for review; all opinions expressed are my own.
Was this review helpful?
I'm really enjoying this series and cannot wait for the third!
I think it's really unique in what the author does with magic and the characters are so twisty it's hard to grasp who are the good guys vs the bad guys. I maintain my opinion from book 1, Silyen is my favorite brother and I'm excited to see where his story goes in book 3!
Was this review helpful?
I love the plot idea, but the execution was severely lacking.
-Too many characters and told from too many perspectives.  No emotional connection could be made with any character because you do not get to spend more than a handful of pages with anyone.
-Too much "telling" rather than showing.
-Poor world building, info-dumping only when it is convenient to the plot.
-Personal pet peeve: always saying each characters first and last name.  Silyen Jardine. Bouda Matravers. Luke Hadley.  Maybe if you focused on 3 characters instead of 30, the readers wouldn't need to be reminded who they are all the time.

Disappointing.  Won't be continuing this series.
Was this review helpful?
I'm a bit disappointed with Tarnished City. The first in the series, Gilded Cage, held potential to kick off a great series but much like many a sequel, this book fell short. And it begins with the plot.

Have you ever read a book that didn't really go anywhere? I felt that way with Tarnished City, as if I was being turned in circles until the very end when FINALLY something big happened. The last quarter of the book (maybe not even that much, to be honest) was fantastic. Not only were tensions high but things were happening, I was intrigued. I needed more. And THAT ENDING. I was finally hooked. 

A little too late.

The first 75% of the book lacked that excitement. I'm not talking constant action scenes because I don't need that, but I do need the stakes to be upped from the first book, for there to be a drive, a reason to want to follow these characters. I didn't get that until the end which is good in terms of engaging readers to pick up the upcoming third book but not so good when it comes to my faith in this series to really bring it home. 

I'll say this, though: James didn't pull her punches when it came to the content. I thought Gilded Cage was gloriously dark but Tarnished City takes it a step further into the land of gritty and gruesome. This book may not be suited to younger readers, though that's ultimately up to you. While I enjoyed the fact that James didn't gloss over the underside of this world, at times it didn't flow either and felt thrown in for shock value rather than a necessary plot point.

As for the characters. . . I still don't like Luke. I find him boring. Sure, he does some exciting things but I don't care about him. I'm not invested, therefore his chapters became a chore to get through. His sister, Abi, on the other hand, was much more interesting especially at the end. She's the intelligent, determined heroine I enjoy reading about. I'm also glad we got in the head of Silyen because the enigma that he is drove me crazy last book. Out of all the characters, he's the one I want to follow. A bit morally gray with plenty of secrets, he makes me want to know more. I'm hooked. And even his brother (I won't spoil which one) became a person of interest, as well as one of the reasons I still plan to read book 3.

If you read Gilded Cage, expect some of the same pacing issues but a much darker story. While it wasn't a bad sequel, it didn't impress, acting as the set-up for the finale. Which, if it's anything like the end of Tarnished City, could be the best book in the series. But in terms of this book, it felt like too much filler for my tastes.
Was this review helpful?
An impressive sequel!
I loved diving back into the world of the Skilled and Skilless. Strong characters in a fascinating world that resonated with me, especially in light of recent events. Family, love, loyalty, morality all play a part. I can’t wait to see where this fascinating tale leads next.
Was this review helpful?
When I read Gilded Cage, the first book in the Dark Gifts series, I found it to be quite enjoyable but thought that it fell a bit short of what it could be. Tarnished City is one of the rare sequels that is better than the original. It is darker, more twisty, and overall much more interesting. Tarnished City shines a more critical eye on the power structure and imbalances inherent to this world while also expanding the focus of the series beyond the main characters. This book started off a bit slow but by the time I'd read a few chapters, I was completely and utterly hooked. 

After the events of Gilded Cage, Luke has been condemned for the murder of Chancellor Zelston. Taken away from his family, he fights to survive in a prison that wouldn't be out of place in a horror novel. Abi, desperate to prove her brother's innocence, is on the run. Not knowing who to trust, she goes to Millmoor in search of Heir Meilyr. However, stripped of his Skill and damaged, Heir Meilyr is struggling to survive each day. At the same time, Bouda is solidfying her political position with questionable means. Silyen, the ultimate wildcard, is researching Skill for his own purposes.

Tarnished City was a huge, multi-character epic story. There were a variety of viewpoints, which allowed for an understanding of the complex political situation from all sides. While it may be too much for some readers, I loved the amount of detail and political plotting included in this novel. However, the political aspect was nicely balanced out by the action-oriented plot. Overall, the story was thoroughly enjoyable. I love that I'm not entirely sure of each character's end game. In general, I'm intrigued and excited by the direction the story is heading.

The broader scope of Tarnished City meant that the main characters, namely Luke, Abi, and Silyen, weren't as present. However, I really liked all of the new secondary characters introduced. They had more diversity in terms of viewpoints, political beliefs, and experience that added another level of richest to the novel. There was also more exploration of privilege and unequal power dynamics in this novel, particularly in terms of political and romantic relationships. James did an excellent job of portraying the effect of these dynamics on the characters relationships. They felt significantly more realistic and added a lot of the depth that was missing in the first book.

Tarnished City was a complex, constantly shifting novel that I thoroughly enjoyed. That cliffhanger was somewhat brutal. Although it draws many of the storylines in this novel to a close, it still managed to leave me anxiously awaiting Bright Ruin. I would recommend this series to readers who enjoy a darker, more politically inclined dystopian world.

*Disclaimer: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Was this review helpful?
4.5/5 *

TARNISHED CITY is an amazing follow-up to last year's GILDED CAGE. In fact, I think I liked this one just a little bit more!

Even though I see this listed and shelved as YA, it's much darker than most YA I've tried, (which admittedly is not a lot because it's usually too angst-y for me.) In this case however, the author nixes a lot of the extraneous stuff and focuses on the characters and the intricately plotted story. 

It took me a little while to get back into the flow, (it's been just over a year since I've visited this world),  but once I did, I was so happy to be there! There's no real re-cap, which I appreciated. I feel that if an author's characters are strong enough, they should come back without my having to be reminded and these certainly did. There's a big cast here and the characters refer to other characters using the names by which they know them-sometimes resulting in 2 or 3 different names for a person, depending upon the point of view at the time.

I noted that a lot of what is going on here is going on in the real world right now. Perhaps not slavery exactly,  (those with no Skill must serve 10 years as a slave), but classism, (against those born with no Skill), and the increasingly outspoken attitudes and acceptance of those with racist views. It comes all the way up to the sanction of violence against those who disagree or who dare to stand up against those in power. I guess I'm trying to say that it's obvious to me that the author knows what she's talking about as far as how the story relates to the world today, and it's downright scary. 

I feel like I needed to make these points, but now that I have, I want to say how much I loved this tale! I loved the characters, they're well drawn and oh, so human. They aren't perfect, in fact, many of them are downright horrible people, but they're fun to read about. The machinations and the conniving going on rival that in any adult fantasy that I've read-with the added bonus of not having to wait 5+ years for the next book! 

I say BRAVO, Vic James! You've created a compelling, fun and interesting world, populated with deep, complicated characters and I can't wait to come back to it once again. Highly recommended! 

*Thanks to the publisher and to NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book, in exchange for my honest feedback. This is it!*
Was this review helpful?
Just published this week, TARNISHED CITY by Vic James is the second book (after Gilded Cage) in the Dark Gifts Trilogy. Taking place in a futuristic Britain, this work of fantasy concentrates on the power struggle between the privileged, led by the magically proficient and power-hungry Jardine family, and their rebellious slaves, called the Unskilled. The latter group includes Abi Hadley, currently a fugitive, and her brother, Luke, condemned to prison in Scotland for an assassination he did not commit. Author James describes a harrowing existence filled with betrayal, secrets, and political intrigue. These books are dark, cruel, and complicated. If you like dystopian action adventure, start with Gilded Cage and then turn to TARNISHED CITY. The final book, Bright Ruin, is scheduled for publication in October.
Was this review helpful?
I really enjoyed this. I thought the first book was creepy, but this installment totally raises the standards. The writing style sets the mood of those old Victorian vibes but with a horrible class gap that sets people apart. Whether they like it or not. Then you have those with special abilities, who either are forced to do without or get a huge enhancement without warning. You'd think that's exciting enough, but then you have the whole mental torture feel with one of the character's journeys and it's just all near-overwhelming and... wow. You know? The best part is the author doesn't even have to resort to profanity or gory descriptions. She totally relies on the reader's imagination to set the limitations on how creepy a scene can turn.

The characters were complex, they had a lot going on with themselves. It was all political and scandals and while you're watching all this, in the end, you're still asked the question as to whether or not you really know what mankind is capable of. I think because of that, I seriously enjoyed the character Silyen. He wasn't a favorite in the first book but this one totally changes my opinion of him.
Was this review helpful?
Vic James continues to blow me away with this series! Every time I thought I knew where things were going, a new surprise or twist would throw everything out the window. The action picks up right where book 1, Gilded Cage, left off, so readers should be aware that this is book 2 in a trilogy and is not a standalone.

There were some truly amazing and wonderful moments in this book, but there were also some horrible lows and heartbreaking losses. The overall feel of Tarnished City was darker and grittier than the previous book, which really amped up the intensity and emotion. Told in multiple POVs, we are privy to the inner thoughts, fears, and hopes of both our heroes and villains. We become painfully aware that few things are as they seem on the surface and are left questioning the true intentions of some of our characters. Unlikely heroes rise, the depth of evil will at times seem limitless, and we are forced to say goodbye too soon to some of our motley crew. I'm not going to lie, there were a few times when I was just gutted. I was barely done processing the events, when another thing would smash my heart again to bits. I think part of what left me so heartbroken, was the sheer surprise and lack of fanfare surrounding these events. No heroics or blaze of glory. Just a sudden and profound loss.

I thought the commentary on human nature and the disparity between the haves and have nots was especially moving. The entire "social experiment" at Eilean Dochais as well as the Blood Fair was disturbing to say the least. It really makes one question what humanity is capable of when they can act with impunity. Familial love and loyalty also play a huge part in this series. The love between siblings and between parent and child influence so many of the actions of our characters. Abi, Luke, and especially Gavar grew so much through the course of this book. I cannot wait to find out what's next for our characters, as new alliances are formed and bridges are burned. Highly recommend this series!

*I voluntarily read an advance reader copy of this book*
Was this review helpful?
4.5 stars. Tarnished City, the second book in Vic James’s DARK GIFTS YA fantasy series, is a hard-hitting novel that picks right up where Gilded Cage left off, without any infodumping to remind the reader what happened in the first book. In this alternate version of our world, England is controlled by a minority group, the ironically-named Equals, who have magical powers and brutally use them to enforce their rule on everyone who isn’t magically skilled. The heaviest burden is the slavedays, a ten year period that each ordinary person is required to spend serving at the whim of the Equals. 

In Gilded Cage (here’s your warning of some spoilers for that book), the Hadley family decided to serve their slavedays together, hoping to work them out on the Jardine estate in relative comfort. But the experience has turned disastrous in only a few months. Their teenage son Luke is now a prisoner of the sadistic Lord Crovan, accused of murdering a prominent Equal. Older daughter Abigail is a fugitive on the run, and the Hadley parents have been sent to the industrial slavetown Millmoor (conveniently removing them from the action). The youngest daughter Daisy remains with the Jardines as a babysitter for the baby daughter of their eldest son, Gavar Jardine.

Tarnished City, like Gilded Cage, shifts between the viewpoints of several characters. Its primary focus is on the teenage siblings Luke and Abi. Luke, now wearing Lord Crovan’s magical golden slave collar, is helicoptered to a remote estate in Scotland, where the worst political prisoners are given over to Crovan’s sadistic control. Luke is terrified of the mental and physical torture for which Crovan is infamous, but what actually happens at the inescapable Eilean Dòchais is something he had never imagined. Abi heads to the south of England to find the revolutionaries ― including some sympathetic Equals ― that her brother Luke had previously been working with. Her hope and goal is to rescue Luke with their assistance. 

But Tarnished City also follows the viewpoints of a few key Equals: the oldest son and Jardine heir Gavar, a playboy who is beginning to take life more seriously and is finding himself at odds with his father’s plans to control England; Javar’s fiancée Bouda, an ambitious young woman who will do almost anything to increase her own power; and the youngest Jardine brother Silyan, an immensely gifted Equal who is following his own mysterious agenda.

Life is chaotic and holds unforeseen twists for all of these characters and others. The odds against the commoners and their few Equal allies are nearly overwhelming in the face of the immense magical powers of the Equals. Vic James uses this setting to examine the ills of slavery and humanity’s tendency to abuse power.

"The truth was, everyone in Britain wore a collar they couldn’t see. Millions of people, unquestioningly obeying the Equals. Slaving for ten years in appalling conditions. Subject to rulers they couldn’t choose or criticize. Confined to a country they couldn’t leave until their days were done. And accepting it all as normal. 

Better to wear a collar you could see. That way you never forgot."

Tarnished City is a darker YA Fantasy, focusing on a culture of modern slavery that leads to foreseeable results, including murder and public executions, torture (both physical and psychological), profound betrayal, and hinted-at sexual assault.

James’s characters are complex and do unexpected things. After two books, I still haven’t figured out the end game for some key characters, and whether they’re trustworthy or not, which adds a great element of suspense and intrigue. Two characters in particular undergo shocking shifts in their behavior and outlook, heading in opposite directions from where they started. In both cases it improves the plot tremendously, although the shift in characterization is so profound it left me with the sneaking suspicion that James had a change of heart and plans after writing Gilded Cage, possibly in response to some criticism of one particular plotline: (view spoiler) Whether or not that’s true, I’m still a fan of the new directions for these characters.

I’m also a fan of this DARK GIFTS series, which creates an imaginative though brutal magical society, brimming with political and social intrigue and upheaval, and uses it to pose some serious questions. Highly recommended!
Was this review helpful?
I loved this book! It was just as enthralling as The Gilded Cage. Perhaps the best part of this book, to me, was seeing the character development. I don't want to give any spoilers, so I'll just say that some of the characters shocked me, while others made me proud to see growth. I was happy to see more of certain Equals' thought processes. I can't wait for the third and final book!
Was this review helpful?
Thank you to Netgalley and Delray for a copy of the eARC in exchange for a fair review.

Fair Warning this is Book 2 in the Dark Gifts series, I highly suggest you read Gilded Cage before you read this review.

So our favorites are back and new additions. This is told from even more points of view than the first one. Luke has been condemned for assassinating the Chancellor. He is taken by Lord Crovan up north to a prison that no one can escape from. He finds himself stuck in a horrible and twisted place.  He makes friends with a young woman who has been on the island since she was a child. 

Abi finds her way to Heir Meilyr who has been stripped of his Skill in some horrible fashion. They want to plan a rescue of Luke, but unsure how to get past all the defenses and rumors surrounding Lord Corvan's island. Jenner joins her for a bit, but leaves when becomes the Heir to his Aunt's estate. 

Gavar finds himself in a horrible marriage with Heir Bouda and faced with his father being named the temporary chancellor, his brother Silyen has become the Heir to Lord Rix, and his father plans to enact legislation that will affect his daughter and he must decide which path to take.

 Silyen is just learning to understand the depth of his abilities. He has a certain bond with Luke, and his own agenda that may be darker then even his father's.

First off I was a little thrown off with so many different POV's, there were a lot in this book and I almost suggest reading the first one again before reading this that being said. Whew is this book darker, more game of thrones than the first one. There are so many secrets revealed in this book, and so many more questions to ask at the end of it. I almost wonder how it could be wrapped up in the next book.

 That being said I loved every minute of it, it hit the ground running and did not stop until the breathless end where you feel almost out of breath and wondering what just happened to you. Sigh I can't believe I have to wait a whole year for the next book. I think next time I will reread both books before savoring the 3rd.
Was this review helpful?
My mind is reeling, and I'm still decompressing my thoughts and feelings about Tarnished City. What a sequel...

Luke is locked up for something he didn't do. Abi is on the run trying to find a way to get her brother back. And the Jardines are more powerful than ever. 

Tarnished City is darker than book 1, and it reveals how cruel society can be. It's a complicated mess, and I can't wait for the next book to find out how everything ends.
Was this review helpful?