Cover Image: The Goose Girl

The Goose Girl

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I was unable to review this book because of a conflict in my schedule. Sorry for any inconvenience this has caused the publisher or the author of the work. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review for you and I look forward to reviewing for you in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Although this was an interesting premise and fairly-well done, I felt like it has been done before - and more capably - in Shannon Hales The Goose Girl (Books of Bayern)..The brevity of this version and overall style would lead me not to purchase this title.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun fairy tale retelling with a great LGBT+ twist. A link to my full review on my blog is provided.

Was this review helpful?

I’m very familiar with the original Brothers Grimm Tales which, if you don’t know, are actually quite violent with lots of bloodshed, body parts getting chopped off and such – more like a pre-Stephen King at times. This story is based on one of those tales but thankfully the author added a cool twist with a lot less blood.

It’s a very short story comparatively so you’ll breeze through it in an hour or less. I didn’t have a problem with the length but the conclusion really threw me. It just suddenly ended and I kept flipping back and forth to check because I thought I must be missing something but no that’s just how they wrote it.

I liked what the author did with the characters for the most part but there were so many unanswered questions and that drop off conclusion I wish they would have made it a bit longer to fill out the holes. But that twist was definitely neat.

Was this review helpful?

This novella is based on a fairy tale by the brothers Grimm. I loved the new twist the author added to the original tale and it was a fun read. However, it felt like an early draft and it could have done with more editing. I also wanted more backstory to the characters and the setting. I would happily buy a copy of a full novel by the same author.

Was this review helpful?

This is a very cute, very quick retelling of the Goose Girl fairytale, but with a few twists in certain places. One of which is a huge spoiler – so I can’t talk about it – which is a shame, because that’s a large part of what makes this such an endearing and lovely read.

Without spoilers, Ava is a princess who doesn’t want to marry, has a maid who forces her to switch places and is left adrift as a servant whom everyone thinks is a little slow and mute, while she tries to pick up the pieces of her shattered life. She’s naive at first, but I liked the strength she shows to keep going, to learn new things and accept her new place in life, watching the geese with Konrad.

It doesn’t deviate too far from the more traditional story, though I did like the explanation for why she can suddenly talk to her horse. If you’re familiar with the story, you might miss Falada’s larger role, but I have to say I preferred the non-talking-death-head version. I also preferred this version of Konrad for many different reasons, but mostly because he gives Ava an alternative to what she’s lost as well as showing her things in life she might have missed.

In all this was a delightful short read, with a demisexual princess, a bit of magic here and there and a few interesting twists on an old tale.

Was this review helpful?

<i>*I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley and Less Than Three Press in exchange for an honest review.</i>*

I was not aware of the Goose Girl story fairy tale before reading this story here. Well, I’ve a vague idea I’ve heard the title before, and that it was a fairy tale, but I’ve not read it so I can’t say how this story here is similar or different.

*looks it up* Okay, so, ‘The Goose Girl’ was put out by the Brothers Grimm in 1815. *reads* And, as might be expected, the Brothers Grimm story is vastly more horrifying than you might expect for a fairy tale, as the original tales actually are. I was reading along and the story was similar – the fairy tale and the retelling, then the horse’s head gets nailed to a door and the little girl talks to it when she passes by. That’s the Grimm tale. No severed horse’s heads appear in Gallica’s version. Right, enough of that.

As both the Brothers Grimm story, and this story here has it – a young woman is sent off by her royal parent(s) (Grimm story – pop’s is dead; Gallica story – both king and queen are still alive) to be married. The young princess has no ability to get out of it, no choice. She is forced to conform, to do her duty. So she sent off to marry this mostly unknown boy (they had apparently been near each other at least once as very young children). One maid travels with her. As in the Grimm story, the maid refuses to continue serving the young princess, steals her identity and wanders off to the castle to marry the prince (actually, not sure if it is a prince in the Grimm version) while the real Princess is forced to be a servant.

I already mentioned two differences (severed horse head, dead/not dead pops), another is that the goose boy in the Grimm story is named Conrad, and in the Gallica story is named Konrad. And here ends my comparison because I’ve not read any more of the Grimm version.

Right, so, Ava (the princess, and the main point of view character) rides off on her favorite horse Falada (same name in the Grimm tale) with the maid Otilla. Before they left, the Queen – the mother – gives Ava a charm so that she would not be harmed on her journey by anything found along the way (which is important, of course, the wording). Along the way Ava is forced to change places with Otilla, and once they arrive at the castle where Ava was to be married, fake Princess Ava is warmly greeted while fake servant is said, by fake Ava, to be super bad as a servant and clumsy and stuff. So fake servant is lead away to work in the castle. Otilla – as Ava – says that the servant’s name is Margrit.

One thing leads to another and Margrit works as a goose girl who, for reasons, pretends to be mute (and they are important reasons). She watches the geese, watches Otilla as Ava (who makes a point of always being nearby at the end of the day looking super happy), and lives this life for a week or so until the wedding day appears. But let’s not give everything away, eh?

I rather liked this story. Quite interesting and entertaining.

<blockquote>Ava sighed. She’d heard that many little girls dreamed of being princesses, but that was only because they had no idea what being a princess entailed. They thought of it as having all the money in the world and the freedom to do with it as one wished. They weren’t thinking of the impeccable manners, the endless tutors, the state visits, the social schedule so full that going for a ride was a treasured treat. Or the arranged marriages. For that matter, every single one of Ava’s friends had been chosen for her by her mother . . .</blockquote>

Rating: 3.73

June 8 2017

Was this review helpful?