Cover Image: Batman: The Dark Knight: Master Race

Batman: The Dark Knight: Master Race

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The artwork and storyline that is followed in this book is amazing, I loved every second of it and couldn't put it down until I was finished with the last page. Great editing and a great addition to the world of The Dark Knight!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading this graphic novel. It was much longer than a typical graphic novel (probably about twice as long) and had a really interesting chapter-like structure rather than the typical comic break up. I liked that many JL characters were present in the book and found the story interesting.

Was this review helpful?

I've been reading Frank Miller's Dark Knight installments for quite literally most of my life. Batman is my favorite comic figure and comic franchise and Miller's first two installments are some of the most re-readable comics I have ever encountered, especially true of the original Dark Knight. It is truly one of the greatest classics in comic history.

This third installment continues the story of Bruce Wayne, aged and picking back up his crimefighting mantle three years after the deaths of Lex Luthor and Dick Grayson. Miller's noir writing style shines in every issue, from the gripping beginning and a Batman who seems to wreaking havoc rather than helping control it.

Ray Palmer, aka Atom, works to restore the inhabitants of Kandor to full-size after a distress signal is discovered- but their true intentions are quickly revealed upon his success. A cult lead by a maniacal leader, Quar, the Kryptonians set to bend Earth to their will.. Acknowledgment as gods or death.

The story is gripping, with excellent tie-in issues through The Dark Knight Universe. Miller's game is still strong, and while I think it may be impossible to touch the behemoth perfection of the original Dark Knight, this installment ranks above The Dark Knight returns for me.

Was this review helpful?

Miller's writing for me was too dark at times though it the graphic novel held my interest. I will be purchasing this graphic novel for my graphic novel collection as there is a high interest in Batman stories.

Was this review helpful?

Better than DKR 2 (But could anything be worse than that mess?), but not as good as the original. This is almost a World's Finest comic, focusing mainly on Batman and Superman. Some of the characters were very one dimensional, especially all the villains. The text speak drove me nuts. I had to translate each line in my head to English and none of it ultimately matters to the story. Frank Miller's art in the backups is wildly inconsistent. The early issues which weren't inked look like blown up thumbnails. The lack of detail is awful. But once Klaus Jansen comes in to do inks, Miller's art becomes much more palatable. Andy Kubert knocks it out of the park. He's got this nice, concise style and once Klaus Janson inks it, it does remind you of the art in Dark Knight Returns.

Was this review helpful?

Oh I *wanted* to love this...honestly I did, but ruddy hell. What a mess.
I'd get all 'ranty' if I focused on what was wrong with this revisit of hallowed turf, so instead I'll focus on the good.
The relationship between Bats and Carrie is as great as ever, and really is the spine (and balls) of volume 3, and there's also some fun Bats/Supes interplay that manages to just stay on the right side of homo-erotic...just.
The plotting is a shambles, some of the art is disgracefully bad and lazy (how can you make Wonder Woman that ugly ffs?), and the characterisations are weak and nonsensical.
Yes, Miller's The Dark Night has been influential to hundreds of creators. The thing is - many of those creators are now out there making tens times better comics than this balls-up.

Was this review helpful?

Meandering and un focused
are the nicest things I can say about this book.
Miller was once a brilliant
artist on the bleeding edge
of comics innovation.
Now so many years later
of writing what amounts to
the same story over and over again.
This story sadly feels
tired, not sure what
it's really trying to tell
and sadly unoriginal.

Hell, the book collecting the

different variant covers

was more interesting.

Was this review helpful?

This is a must read if you are a Batman fan, I live with the believe that every Batman fan loves "the dark knight" and Frank Miller is one of the greatest authorsof this character so...this rarely will be bad. Isn't the best of Batman, with or without Miller, niether is one of the best Millers jobs. but works good.

Was this review helpful?

ARC from Netgalley.
This graphic novel got so much acclaim, I had to check it out. I went in very hesitant, having found the first two Volumes unreadable due to Miller's horrible art, but the man can certainly write a story!
Batman is dead.... well not quite, but that's how it starts. Superman is gone. The daughter of Wonder Woman and Superman is feeling both alone and curious, so she goes to explore the Fortress of Solitude. Finding the bottle city of Kandor, and enlisting the help of The Atom, a large portion of Kandorians are released and she is no longer alone. But.... they are terrorists.
Batman comes back. Superman comes back. Both Flash and Green Lantern return (though quickly Barry's legs break and Hal gets his hand chopped off) and the war is on.
The story unfolds much like you think it would, but the telling of it is pretty good. And as Bats is not only back, but also young again (thank you convenient Lazarus Pit), the story may continue in the future.
Recommend, but with reservations. Kubert's art saves this one, but there is still some not great character design.

Was this review helpful?

Not as good at the Dark Knight Returns, better than The Dark Strikes again (not that that's hard). The plot was interesting enough, and I enjoyed the fact that so many DC characters had their own plot points that were woven in and presented in this collection. Miller and Azzarello did a good job at taking the format of the Dark Knight Returns and updating the references for a 2016-2018 audience. However, this still seems like a good place for the saga to end.

Was this review helpful?

This is more a DC Trinity book rather than straight Batman. It postulates a grim future with Batman believed dead, Superman in seclusion, and Wonder Woman with two kids. Lara, Supe's and Wonder Woman's daughter is bored and frustrated and easily manipulated by Baal from Kandoor. She then manipulates Atom into enlarging the inhabitants who then run wild under the influence of Baal's father Quar and the cult he has initiated. Wanting to be worshiped as gods, Quar and his cult initiate a rain of terror on earth. Superman is roused, but refuses to fight Lara. Batman comes out of hiding when Quar threatened to destroy Gotham City, but orchestrates a take-down instead. Then Superman and Wonder Woman take the fight forward. Plenty of action, plenty of manipulation, plenty of weird DC action with Green Lantern being handed his comeuppance that all gets resolved in the end.

Was this review helpful?

A great story line that was really enjoyable featuring many characters from the DC Universe including some I did not expect. My only criticism would be that the art work at times lacks definition and is a little less well drawn than I would expect.

Was this review helpful?

I tried, but I just couldn't get into this one. The artwork didn't impress me (I guess I'm not a fan of Miller's style), and the stories kept jumping around so much that it just couldn't keep my interest, which is a shame because part of it seemed great, but I didn't care enough to put up with the rest of it to find out where it all went.

Was this review helpful?

This is Batman. Yes it was amazing! I was surprised to see so many Justice League characters as Miller has not really included them in either of the others in the series.

Was this review helpful?

I am a rare breed. I am one of the very few, if not only, person who read Fran Miller's The Dark Knight Returns graphic novel and hated it. I didn't like it so much I never read the follow up book The Dark Knight Strikes again. So you might be asking why on earth am I reviewing this book? I got caught up in the hype. I follow DC Comics on twitter, and I keep up with the DC Comics All Access app and every article and snippet of art wasn't missed when I was nerding out. Now I have been very fortunate to have been approved for books from DC Comics and Netgalley in the past, but I never expect to get anything I request. This was one book that I would have been fine if I got turned down but was still interested enough to want to read this.

Thank you DC Comics for the opportunity to read this book for a review. When I first opened the digital file and saw it was over 300 pages my first thought was what did I get myself into? Now that I have gotten my negativity out of my system you will see there is a reason for it. I couldn't believe how fast I flew through this book. I sat down one evening with my wife and I started this book and finished it in no time. Once I started I couldn't tear myself from this book. I loved every page of this and I was so shocked at how much I was enjoying this.

So this books is set will in the future. Batman has been missing and Superman has hidden himself away in his fortress. Not getting into specifics but The Bottle City of Kandor get released and the Kryptonians are made full size. They want our planet as their own. This story line has a very similar story line to the movie Man of Steel where Zod and the Kryptonians tried to turn Earth into New Krypton. Another similarity to the movies is we get to see Batman in the armored Bat-suit again. Again, I'm not going to give it away as to why, but Batman isn't the only one donning armor this time. Superman gets an upgrade too.

I was so impressed with this story and I might even wait for a deluxe slip cover edition and add this to my collection. I will admit that that I'm not a huge fan of the art work in these books but I can understand that it fits the gritty writing style. All of my little peeves and such I liked this book. I never could believe that I am about to type this next sentence, but I give this book 5 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Batman: The Dark Knight III: The Master Race by Frank Miller is one of the better books out there that stands on its own. Its take on JLA characters and with the dark and twisted view of Miller make it one of the more enjoyable reads to be found.

Frank Miller's The Dark Knight is a classic in comic book lore. Unfortunately, it has made every sequel look like a sad sack sister in comparison. That is too bad because read on its own, The Master Race is an incredibly well developed and thought out piece of comic book writing. It sheds the wrappings of a Batman book and embraces the characters that surround the Batman Universe. Mainly Superman and Wonder Woman and their love child.

It has been years since anyone has seen the Batman alive. Years since he faced down Lex Luthor and saved the world. But now an army of Krptonians has been unleashed, aided by Wonder Woman's and Superman's daughter, and they want to take over the Earth. To cleanse it of humanity and become the Master Race. Now an old and broken Bruce must suit up for one final fight. But he needs his old friends by his side. A forgotten Superman and Wonder Woman who must deal with her rebellious and super daughter.

It has occurred to me that an older, angrier and bitter Batman is such freaking awesome addition to the Batman world that any comic with him in it would be praised. But the great success of the first Dark Knight book has cast a heavily critical lens on the rest of the books. That is too bad because The Master Race is a very good book. Think about it, what if a race of super beings came to Earth and were not enamored with humanity. What if they didn't want to save us but instead, saw us so far down the food chain that our only value was in enslavement or annihilation. Consider this if you will, what if Superman had not landed in Smallville, Kansas but landed in Los Angeles or New York. Could we survive with a Superhero raised by such narcissism and lack of good old American values?

Or worse, a country where human life has no value and only the darkest and most evil of humanity survive. What if a Kryptonian was raised there? This is something that is currently being explored in Action Comics and the Oz Effect which I will talk about at a later blog. Add to that, that it is not one being but an entire city of beings that have been kept hostage in a glass container for decades. When finally released, yeah, they would be a little pissed.

I will admit that my favorite character in this book is not Bats but Wonder Woman and not because of her current run of fame. No, fans of the Wonder Woman movie will not recognize her here. She is an Amazon, intent on protecting her people and her children. Teaching them strength and their heritage and dealing with a rebellious and super strong teenage daughter. All that and fighting monsters with her baby son strapped to her back in a papoose. You do not mess with this single mother. Yeah, she is that kickass.

The Master Race is an awesome Batman book that could have only been told by Frank Miller. It is that simple. A terrific read!

Was this review helpful?

We reviewed this book in detail on the following podcast: http://www.krayzcomix.solitairerose.com/?p=1200

Was this review helpful?

The heroes looked like every day was upper body day, Bruce Wayne was still a stubborn, old fool, and you didn’t need any experience in what had happened prior to this story. It was a really good read and I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

'Batman: The Dark Knight: Master Race'written by Frank Miller and Brian Azzarello with art by Klaus Janson, Andy Kubert and others includes all nine main issues as well as the nine tie-in issue. At 376 pages, it's a lot of comic, but is it any good?

Following up after The two previous Dark Knight series, this time around Carrie (the Robin from the first series) is all grown up and patrolling Gotham dressed as Batman, because apparently Batman is dead, but this feels like a feint. When a group of Kryptonians threatens the planet, it's going to take more than Carrie and an aging Bruce Wayne to stop them.

This is not strictly a Batman story. It includes members of the Justice League and others, but at it's core, it follows the Batman characters.

I own and love the original Dark Knight. I was less crazy about the odd second part. This one loses some of the darkness and hyperviolence and even feels like it ends on a note of hope. It's a different feeling for this series, but I liked it quite a bit.

I received a review copy of this graphic novel from DC Entertainment and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

I have always loved Frank Miller's writing. It's been fascinating to see the changes in the Dark Knight books over the years as his personal politics have evolved. The first Dark Knight series was personal, he wrote it because he realized he was older than Batman and wanted to see a book in which Batman's character aged and changed. I think this element is one of the things that elevates his Batman stories. It was also interesting to see the concept of hero turned on its head by mixing in very contemporary issues with police forces and Gotham's finest in this series. The interplay between the police and Batman has always been touch and go, this series takes it to a whole new level. I did feel this wasn't quite as good as the first Dark Knight series but it was still a great read and fans of modern superhero films will surely enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?