Wow, it took a good bit to build the story but the long build up was so worth it in the end. I received this book as an ARC but this review is not swayed by that.

The need for the build up is that it is set in what is now Russia and the tales of that area aren't as well known in the west. The world building is beautifully woven into the story so it grows as you follow the tale like a tapestry out of a loom.

If you enjoy stories that have a basis in old tales you owe it to yourself to read both the books in Katherine Arden's Winter Night Trilogy and eagerly await the third book.

"Sasha looked at his sister. He had never thought of her as girlish, but the last trace of softness was gone. The quick brain, the strong limbs were there: fiercely, almost defiantly present, though concealed beneath her encumbering dress. She was more feminine than she had ever been, and less.
Witch. The word drifted across his mind. We call such women so, because we have no other name."

4.5 stars.

The Girl in the Tower is the highly-anticipated sequel to The Bear and the Nightingale in Katherine Arden’s The Winternight Trilogy.

It continues the story of Vasilisa Petrovna – Vasya – after her village shunned her and cast her out as a witch, leaving her with only two options: go to a convent or get married. Being a headstrong, independent, and obstinate girl who fears being locked away, she instead defies convention and rides out with her horse, Solovey, disguised as a boy in search of adventure. It isn’t long until she finds trouble – or trouble finds her – and she finds herself in Moscow.

The Girl in the Tower was a very intriguing read, and I think it was even better than The Bear and the Nightingale. The story drew me in from the first page, and I kept wanting to know what would happen next to Vasya and her siblings.

Both of Arden’s books have been very atmospheric reads, which are perfect for the season. I think The Girl in the Tower was a little more action-packed whereas the previous book was more set-up, though both were equally magical.

The second book isn’t even officially released yet, and I already can’t wait.

Thank you to NetGalley and Del Rey (Random House Publishing Group – Ballantine) for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Well, that was a wild climax!

This second in Arden's series expertly mixes gritty realistic detail about medieval life in Russia (not for wimps!) with figures of Russian folklore. There's more subtle blending of the new replacing the old, less value judgment, in this book, and likewise the characters are more complex.

Vasya is wonderful as she beats her head against the narrow lives expected of women (convent or marriage, and those marriages often began in one's early to mid teens). She takes a third option, cross-dressing, at first terrified, then gaining confidence, until the reader is turning those pages expecting a fall.

Fall happens.

I love the way Arden spun it all out, and then resolved that particular plot in this book, without dragging it into the third to repeat the plot over again. Key elements still remain (oh, those horses) to be explained, in the meantime we get to know Vasya's brother and sister better, as well as medieval Moscow.

There is also a new male character who seems to be set opposite the frost king, as the crazy priest (who appears again in this book) seemed to be in the first: Kasyan Lutovich. As in the first, Arden tips her hand concerning his arc with certain over-used craft elements, but those will only be noted by the older reader, and it's still exciting to see the story spin out, and how Vasya rises to the challenge.

Besides the vivid detail of everyday life, and the Russian feel to everything, I really appreciated the attention to horse care, as well as the horse body language. Special horses exist here, but they still act like horses. Love that.

A terrific, exciting read, leaving me looking forward to the third.

The first novel was great and the second novel is epic! The Girl in the Tower is the second novel in The Winternight Trilogy by Katherine Arden. I don't read fantasy books that often but after the great reviews the first book received I decided to give it a go and I am so glad I did. Katherine Arden has created wonderful characters in an epic story that takes place in medieval Russia.

The story picks up right were the first novel ended. Vasya begins her journey of exploring Russia only to be surprised by meeting Sasha on the road. Soon they travel to Moscow for a reunion with Olga. From beginning to end, Vasya's story is full of emotion and adventure and I could not get enough of this epic fantasy.

I look forward to the exciting conclusion to this wonderful trilogy and more than anything, I look forward to Katherine Arden's next project. She is a masterful storyteller.

Ever read a book and get completely swept away in it? That is what happened to me in The Girl in the Tower. Call me a cynic but usually, when I read the 2nd book in a series that I enjoy, the book falls flat. There is almost always something missing from it. Or I can’t connect with the characters, even if I did in the earlier books. Not with The Girl in the Tower. I connected with the book right from the beginning. You know when a book can do that then it is worth reading!!

I enjoyed the 3 separate but intertwined storylines that made up the book. They detailed how life was in medieval Russia. From the opulent courts of Russia to the drudgery of being a peasant, the author did a great job bringing them alive. The 3 storylines are all connected to one person, Vasya. Vasya is the backbone of this book.

I loved Vasya in this book. She was strong. I am not talking about psychical strongness either. She was mentally strong. She had to be, considering what she had gone through in the last book and what she went through in this book. She made decisions, while not always right, were right for her. She knew her mind in a time where women were considered chattel. That made her a very dangerous person to men. I got why she didn’t reveal that she was a girl when she was leading the Prince to the barbarians. She would have to conform to their rules. I get it and I admire that the author chose for her to go that path.

The love story between Vasya and Morozko was very interesting. On one hand, I could see why the author didn’t progress it beyond a few kisses. I got it. It would be weird. But I wished that it did. I do agree with Morozko’s mare when she told him to forget Vasya. But he couldn’t leave her alone. He was feeling things for her that a frost demon/death god shouldn’t feel. That made it dangerous for him because he became more human.

The end of the book was heartbreaking but uplifting at the same time. I do think that Vasya should have been more upfront with Sasha and Olga about what exactly happened to her father and stepmother. That would have saved a lot of heartbreak on all sides. But, Vasya did redeem herself and was given a great honor by Olga. I can’t wait to read book 3.

The Girl in the Tower is a mystical read. I was taken on a journey through medieval Russia with all its lore. This is a wonderfully written story that will keep you glued to the book. I am thankful that the author included a glossary and an afterward about Russian names. I was a little confused about the different names each person was called and that afterward summed it up perfectly. This is a book that I will read again in the future and I cannot wait to read book 3.

Will I reread: Yes

Will I recommend to family and friends: Yes

Age range: Older teen

Why: Violence. No language or sex. There is a very explicit scene of a woman giving birth to a stillborn baby.

I would like to thank Katherine Arden, Random House Publishing Group, Del Ray and NetGalley for allowing me to read and review The Girl in the Tower.

All opinions stated in The Girl in the Tower are mine

**I chose to leave this review after reading an advance reader copy**

I was fortunate to review Katherine Arden’s The Bear and the Nightingale. I really enjoyed it. Arden created characters whose voices were so clear that I could keep them straight regardless of the Russian naming conventions attached to them. That book look place in the mid 14th century, before it is truly Russian. If you have not read The Bear and the Nightingale, please do not read any further.

The tension between the old beliefs and the new religion were central to The Bear and the Nightingale. It was a book about a country, a people and a family in the process of change. The Girl in the Tower picks up shortly after the end of The Bear and the Nightingale. Vasilisa (Vasya) is still the central character. Vasya chooses to flee her family home after the death of her father and stepmother. Both deaths are blamed on her.

Vasya flees to the only ally she has, Morozko, who is more dangerous than her enemies. Vasya chooses to take any limited assistance and sets out to see what is beyond the forest of northern Russia. Morozko has an agenda in helping Vasya. All that Vasya learned as a child about the old ways can help her survive anything except the monsters that are men. Characters from the first book, like Sasha and Konstantin, return and new characters are introduced. The story is just as intriguing as the first book.

Arden continues her description, rich prose in this book.The language of the book is gorgeous. It flowed very easily. I did purchase the audiobook of The Bear and the Nightingale and preordered the audiobook of The Girl in the Tower. Reading Arden’s prose is enjoyable but hearing it read with correct pronunciations is a feast for your ears..

I would recommend The Girl in the Tower as soon as you finish The Bear and the Nightingale for a captivating journey to a lost world of magic. It really is an enchanted series.

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and Random House through Bookishfirst for an honest review.

A beautiful sequel that lives up to its predecessor, "The Girl in the Tower" brings us back to Katherine Arden's enchanting dark world of Russian fairy tales. As compared to "The Bear and Nightingale" there is a lot more action and adventure, some more romance though I wouldn't say it is a focal point, and lots of character growth.

No one is as they seem including Vasilisa who spends a good amount of the time masquerading as boy in order to see the world. While she makes a good amount of mistakes along the way, she always has the best intentions. With all the intrigue and jumping from one adventure to the next, the story is captivating. Top that with Katherine Arden's magical writing and it is hard not to imagine yourself there.

The Girl in the Tower is the 2nd in Katherine Arden's enchanting Winternight series, set in an alternate old Russia. The first episode told the coming of age of spirited young Vasilisa, who can see the otherworld and who does whatever it takes to protect those she loves, with no thought to herself. It ended in tragedy.

In this second episode, Vasya flees to find her sister in Moscow, where circumstances lead to her pretending to be a boy, and becoming rather too close to the centre of power. When an enemy reveals her sex, not only is Vasya undone, but her beloved brother and sister are also endangered. I can't wait to see where the author takes her determined heroine next.

Katherine Arden strikes gold again in this lavish sequel to The Bear and the Nightingale. I cannot express how thrilled I was to find out their was not only a sequel but a trilogy planned.

The Girl in the Tower picks up at a good place from where The Bear and the Nightingale leaves off. Vasya is older and has so much more experience under her belt. Ms. Arden does an incredible job with her character arcs. The writing is eloquent and the backdrop of this book is set in Frozen Russia. I remember with book one and this one too, feeling frozen to my bones just reading. Ms. Arden truly sends you there through her writing.

I felt their struggles, I felt their joys and fears, I felt Morozko. The ending left me satisfied and craving more at the same time. I want so desperately to know how this spellbinding trilogy ends.

It's lyrical, lush and beautiful. Ms. Arden's writing is perfect for young and old alike. Simply stunning ...

The Bear and the Nightingale was so touching and original that it was impossible not to love. It was a little harder to get into The Girl in the Tower because the beginning follows secondary characters from the first novel. Not that I didn't want to know what happened to Vasya's siblings, Sasha and Olga, in Moscow, but the political intrigue was at first a little confusing. I was glad to see that this was just a brief interlude before we see Vasya again. She is as enchanting and strong and wonderful as in the first novel. Her adventures after having run away from home were so entertaining, that the pages just flew by. Once her story is introduced into the Moscow political intrigue, it all made more sense. The last chapters were so suspenseful, that I found myself worrying about Vasya at work, wondering what she was going to do and how it all was going to end. Again, I was impressed at Katherine Arden's command of the subject matter. I'm no expert, but I would have believed that this was a classic fairy tale from Russian yesteryears. I hope that the next volume comes out soon, I will keep wondering about Vasya for as long as it takes to find out what happens next.

Magical tale of Medieval Russia.

After reading The Bear and the Nightingale, I was eager to get my hands on this book to find out what happened next with Vasya. Unfortunately, the first ten percent or so of the story focused on her elder siblings Olga and Sascha whom she had not seen for about a decade. No Vasya. Once she did make an appearance, though, my frustration eased and I once again became invested in the story.

After being driven from her home with accusations of witchcraft, Vasya (dressed as a boy) and her horse Solovey set out to see the world but end up embroiled in trouble. The same curiosity and bravery that made her an oddity at home make her Vasya the Brave when she’s thought to be a boy. The ruse becomes a problem, though, when she is reunited with Sascha who then is forced to go along with her lie and to tell it to their cousin and liege, the Grand Prince of Moscow. Rival forces are challenging the Grand Prince, and deceptions from friends and foes make it difficult to know whom to trust.

Throughout it all, Vasya struggles with what seem to be necessary lies about her gender and ability to communicate with magical folk while trying both to be true to herself and not to harm those she loves. It doesn’t always work, and others also are not completely honest with her. She finds danger, adventure, and heartbreak while learning some hard lessons about life and who—and what—she is.

This is the second book in a trilogy, and I look forward to seeing what Vasya’s fate will be in the third. I’ve got my fingers crossed that it will be a happy one.

LOVE LOVE LOVE. This book is just as wonderful as the first, which I also adored. I love Arden's writing. Highly recommend, particularly if you enjoy fairy tale retellings.

A dark, brooding, middle book to Arden's WINTERNIGHT TRILOGY, set in medieval Russia. Vasilia Petrovna, or Vasya, the unconventional protagonist who grew from wild child to frustrated adolescent in THE BEAR AND THE NIGHTINGALE, knows she cannot tolerate a conventional marriage or banishment to a nunnery, each of which would lead her to being locked away from the doings of the larger world she so longs to see. And so, in the wake of the family and village tumult that concluded the earlier book, she flees home to wander the world with her magical horse Solovey, gifted to her by the Morozko, the demon Winter-king who is attached to Vasya through a mysterious jewel given to her by her father.

After this brief opening, the story immediately shifts to the point of view of Vasya's older brother, Sasha, a warrior/monk and advisor to his cousin Dmitri, the Grand Prince of Moscow. Word of terrible attacks by mysterious raiders on villages in 'Rus, and the attackers' kidnapping of young girls, lead Sasha, the Prince, a local lord's son, and others out to try and put an end to the threats. During their travels, they meet with death and devastation, never quite able to catch up with the attackers pillaging the land. Until a young man rides into the monastery where they are taking shelter with three young girls he's rescued from the attackers with him. A young man whom Sasha immediately recognizes as his younger wild sister Vasya.

The story then shifts back in time, relating Vasya's wanderings after leaving Morozko, and how she almost immediately needs rescuing by him when she is pursued by mysterious strangers and almost dies in the winter forest of illness and exposure. Once again, though, she refuses to remain with the winter demon, choosing to go out on her own. This time, she meets with the pillagers, and determines to follow them and rescue the girl children they have taken. At which she succeeds—until she is faced with her brother.

Neither Sasha nor Vasya, for quite different reasons, are ready to reveal the secret of her true sex. And so Vasya becomes Vasilii the Brave, rescuer of children and boon companion to the Grand Prince, celebrated by villagers and Muscovites alike for the role she plays in helping vanquish the pillaging ruffians. But Moscow is rife with plots, not all of them set in motion by men...

Arden gives us brief insights into the thoughts of Morozko, glimpses that suggest the the bargain the winter demon made to help preserve himself from death may be having unintended consequences, consequences which the heartless demon is finding it difficult to cope: "You cannot love and be immortal. Do not let it come to that. You are not a man." (Kindle Loc 1271). But Vasya is not at all pleased to find out that Morozko has been using her without her permission, which she discovers towards book's end, and any chance the two will come together in any meaningful way seems to be nil.

We will have to wait until volume 3 to find out just how Morozko, and Vasya, come to terms with their unusual connection, and with their own desires ("I want freedom.... But I also want a place and a purpose. I am not sure I can have either, let alone both" [3381]).

Gorgeously written and heavy with Russian fairytales and folklore, this second installment in the Winternight trilogy continues the beautiful and wintry journey of Vasilisa and her magical horse as she treks through the harsh and unforgiving Russian countryside in search of true freedom.

No longer safe in Lesnaya Zemlya, Vasya chooses the only option that makes sense — flee the home and people she loves. The only other options, enter a convent or marry, are constraints and certainly not for a woman who was born to traverse the wide-open. Disguised as a young lord, Vasya’s journey is fraught with danger, and more frightening are he bandits she meets along the way who’ve taken to burning villages and kidnapping girl children. Her journey eventually leads her to Moscow where she has a chance to reunite with Olga and Sasha, although the reunion is just as tense as the journey that brought them together.

Set during the medieval period of Russia, women are expected to live as commodities and objects, seen simply as breeders for a man’s children and expected to find happiness in nothing more than what a man chooses to give her. Standards were quite different back then, as any history book will point out, and virtue - especially concerning women, was as desirable as any currency. I love books and stories where women shun societal standards and conventions, and that is definitely what this series shows with Vasya. Often referred to as unmanageable and defiant, Vasya just wants to be able to live and see the world, knowing that the societal constructs forced upon women is certainly not for her. She’s definitely a woman lightyears ahead of her time, and her wandering spirit and her lust for life are such endearing qualities that add such strength to her already amazing character.

While the book focuses much on Vasya and her journey, I enjoyed the interactions between Morozko and Vasya the most. The frost-demon, much like Vasya, is also wrestling with his version of “life”, or lack thereof. There’s always been a hint of something between the demon and Vasya, and while most times his motives are certainly in the category of self-interest, he may be the character that’s transforming the most. A hint of romance is blossoming between the two and while that’s certainly unfounded, it definitely adds another layer to this tale that’s already filled with depth. I’m already eagerly anticipating the third and final book in this trilogy, but more than anything, I’m looking forward to what happens between Morozko and Vasya now that they’ve reached an apex in their most unconventional relationship.

Bottom line - I love this series, I love these characters, I love the cold and harsh and unforgiving world. Arden’s writing is absolutely gorgeous and her passion for Russia and its history and folklore is so palpable that it just oozes off the pages. I can’t recommend this series enough and if you haven’t yet started it, do yourself a favor and get to it.

*I received a free copy of this book courtesy of NetGalley and BookishFirst in exchange for my honest opinion.

Vasilisa Petrovna’s adventures continue in The Girl in the Tower, by Katherine Arden, the sequel to The Bear and the Nightingale. Without her family to shield her from the hostile villagers of Lesnaya Zemlya, she lights out for the territories on her trusty, magical horse to become a traveler. But because a) Russian fairy tales tend to be as bloodthirsty or more than Grimms’ and b) fourteenth century Russia is no picnic anyway, Vasilisa is almost immediately in peril.

In fourteenth century Russia, women have few options. It’s either marriage or a convent. And, for high ranking women, marriage came with lifelong seclusion in terem. All Vasilisa wants is to see the world. Though her protector, Morozko (the snow-king) tries to dissuade her, Vasilisa takes to the road. Meanwhile, we also check in with Vasilisa’s older sister, Olga, in Moscow, and her warrior-monk brother, Sasha. As Vasilisa is making her way, disguised as a boy, Olga is trying to maintain order in her haunted tower and Sasha is dealing with the fallout of a series of violent attacks on villages around Moscow by bandits who don’t leave tracks.

It doesn’t take long for the siblings’ stories to intersect and for Vasilisa to realize that she’s up against something supernatural. Again. I don’t want to say too much because if I start talking about what happens, anyone who knows a bit about Russian folklore might be able to figure things out too soon. But I will say that I love the way Vasilisa and her family are caught between the native spirits of Russia who are still hanging on in the banyas and hearths of the country and the new Orthodox faith that dismisses the bannik and domovoi as devils. A few centuries before, Vasilisa might not have had to deal with everything alone or been accused of witchcraft. Half (or more) of Vasilisa’s fight is just trying to get people to at least allow her get on with things.

I remember liking The Bear and the Nightingale a lot, but I think I might have enjoyed this entry in the series even more. The stakes have been raised in The Girl in the Tower. The story has widened to bring in even more figures from Russian folklore. But most of all, I love who Vasilisa is becoming. She is learning that she is mostly on her own and she grows increasingly capable with every new challenge. She also has a gift for pushing her family and allies to be better people, to become heroes. There’s so much in The Girl in the Tower that I loved. I strongly recommend these books for fans of folklore and folklore retellings.

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley for review consideration. It will be released 5 December 2017.

I'll begin by saying thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review.

I'm not a historical fiction fan. Occasionally, I can get into it, but not often. Books like this one though, with the hints of magic and deeper moments than many authors are capable of (so many are "oh, info dump about history, here you go!"), really make me want to try harder.

I mentioned in my review for book one, The Bear and the Nightingale, that when I first requested it based off of the description, I was disappointed to learn that it was not a standalone and was in fact the first of a trilogy. I also mentioned that by the end of book one, I was beyond happy that it had worked out that way... well, I'm still thrilled, because it means I get one more book, one more story in this world, one more adventure with one of my favorite heroines of 2017 - Vasya. Seriously, she's everything a good character should be -- strong but vulnerable, brave, smart, flawed, deep, and fiery. She's got the badass thing down pat.

I can't rave enough about Vasya or the depth and beauty of these two books. Give them a shot, even if historical fiction isn't really your thing. They have a fantasy element that kicks it up a notch, and they're beautiful, timeless, powerful stories about how one person can truly make a difference in her world, and how living life the way you're told isn't always the path you should take. Unless it means listening to me telling you to read this. That's one command you need to heed!

The Bear and the Nightingale was a big hit last year, and reminded me of Naomi Novik’s Uprooted, which also enchanted a lot of readers. I think bibliophiles are always impressed with something new and unique, which Katherine Arden has created with this series. In The Girl in the Tower the story continues, with Vasya escaping her intolerant village home to go out into the world on an adventure, which would be normally be unheard of for a woman in her era. Entertaining and impressive in setting and tone, The Girl in the Tower is a satisfying sequel containing engaging characters, a compulsive plot and is filled with magic.

I was a little let down by the follow-up to The Bear and the Nightingale, but only because I loved the first book so much! The Girl in the Tower is a thoroughly enjoyable historical fantasy about a young woman struggling to escape the constraints of gendered expectations. Russian folklore enthusiasts will have another delightful read from Katherine Arden in December.

The Girl in the Tower is ambitious and interesting. It's fun to follow the heroine on her fairy tale all over ancient Russia.  There's a little bit of everything - magic, love (of a sort), nobility, and lots of adventure. As with the first book, the writing becomes a little less strong as the story is coming to its conclusion. But it's still impressive writing.
I was provided an ARC from Netgalley.