Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Such an amazing book by an amazing author. I loved all the twists and turns

Was this review helpful?

The beginning sucked me right in, a horrific scene that is unexplained. Some 20+ years later, the three kids involved are still being haunted by the event. I loved the characters of Patrick and Hannah, and was ambivalent toward Matthew, who has his own sad back story.The story is so well written, I will read more by this author. Thanks to Netgalley for this amazing tale.

Was this review helpful?

A bit reminiscent of A Secret History yet not as well written as a Donna Tartt book, this one involves a trio of 'friends,' a word one could use quite lightly in this story. Three young teens are drawn together in a small upstate New York town: Patrick (ie. Patch), good boy in town with aspiring political father, husband and failed financier and current obsessive chef, witness, participant, and savior to a horrible crime; Matthew, new boy to town, messed up family life, perpetrator of horrible crime; and Hannah, wife to Patrick, crime reporter, and victim of horrible crime. As the strings of this story slowly come together, one can see how the past has impacted the character's today with each one struggling to find who they are. My problem with this book is that the two males were both unlikable, and thinly developed; I don't mind crappy humans, but give them a bit more depth. I just didn't care about Matthew's past issues, or Patrick's cooking blog. Now Hannah, on the other hand, was a compelling character as she searches for answers to her past with her NYC police officer friend as well as her job that drags her into the dark corners of city crime. The ending was anti-climatic for me, having gotten to a point of apathy for Patch. At times a page turner, and at times just 'meh' for me.

Was this review helpful?

Grist Mill Road tells the story of 3 young teens, 2 boys and a girl, from different backgrounds, who are growing up in a small town. They are unlikely friends until a tragic incident tears them apart one afternoon at the hideout the boys have in the woods. One goes to a juvenile detention center, one moves away, and one remains in the town until she can escape to college. Years later, they are reunited and a score needs to be settled that, at least for one of them, was never resolved.

Was this review helpful?

I almost DNF'ed this book after 100 pages, but I stuck with it in the hopes that it would get better. I just did not care for this at all. I thought the way Patrick reacted in the beginning of the story was just ridiculous. I wasn't invested in any character and the story was just too slow for my liking.

Was this review helpful?

I was hoping for a better ending with this one. I was left confused with the relationships between characters and questions about Patch were left unresolved.

Was this review helpful?

I highly enjoyed this book. I loved how to story was told, in three parts, each with different version of what happened that day. It makes you change your mind about the characters, you start hating some, and loving some, and by the end, your original opinions aren't valid anymore. I also really liked that it kept going from past to present, and vice versa. It kept it really interesting and gave room for some twists in the story. I must admit thought that the ending left me quite disappointed. Some might like this kind of ending but it wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a refreshing literary suspense novel. I wouldn't put it in the thriller category like so many other books to have come out in the past two years. I loved the slow burn of the novel. It worked beautifully in this case, with nothing feeling slow but everything building and building until the last 100 pages when so many questions are answered. What a fantastic book to kick off 2018!

Was this review helpful?

I've seen several reviews that referred to GRIST MILL ROAD as a complex read, and though I agree with that assessment, you might add that the story is an engrossing read as well. It starts simply from the premise of three young people--Patrick, Matthew, and Hannah--meeting in the tiny town of Roseborn. The town is driven economically by Hannah's family's cement business, and other than that not much else is happening. Yet with Patrick, Matthew, and Hannah a major incident takes place that both bonds and separates them. More than two decades later they are brought back together and the ghosts of the past resurface. The story is well told in a literary style that reminds me a bit of Cormac McCarthy. The characters are drawn with broad brushstrokes that make them come to life on the pages. And the back and forth nature of the plot (two timelines) doesn't distract, but rather adds layer to the story. This novel is a winner.

Was this review helpful?

Every life is complicated. And every story has multiple points of view. In his new psychological thriller, Christopher Yates attempts to reveal the truth of a story by examine all sides.

In 1982 three teenagers, Hannah, Patrick, and Matthew, take part in an unthinkable act of violence. One will lose an eye and gain a lifetime of nightmares. One will live with the guilt of inactivity, doing, saying nothing to stop the brutality. And one will go to jail for the crime, marked with the brand of viciousness.

Twenty-six years later, and circumstances are bringing the three back together, each revealing his or her perspective of the circumstances surrounding the event that upended their lives. Through each retelling, more is revealed about the lives of these kids. Sympathies waiver and switch. The violence that seemed horrific and inevitable at the start of the book becomes sad, the result of childish misunderstandings. Misunderstandings color their adult lives as well, leading them to a potentially even worse confrontation.

Abuse, sexuality, and bigotry are central to Grist Mill Road, themes presented head on without flinching. Yates reveals the tragedy of ordinary lives gone wrong and the effects of keeping secrets hidden from the ones we love.

Was this review helpful?

The story starts in 1982 where three friends Matthew, Patrick (who has 2 nicknames, Patch & Tricky), and Hannah are in the woods where an extremely violent crime occurs between them. And then in 2008, we have the re-telling of the event from all three adult perspectives, whose lives are forever defined by this tragic moment (It’s amazing as adults how we perceive things differently). You also have the build-up to when their paths will cross again, and it’s defiantly anxiety inducing. The story is character driven; it exposes the coming of age feelings of jealousy, resentments, sexual longings and confusion.

Honestly, I am having mixed emotions about this book. “Grist Mill Road” started off with a really gruesome bang and I was just soaking up every word and page, with complete excitement, but then something happened and it lost its momentum. I felt like it became bogged down at times with information that was just not relevant to the story. But then it would pick back up, so it was a lot of back and forth for me. There is also the absence of quotation marks which was a little confusing for me at first, until I got in the hang of it. The ending was defiantly a, Huh? What. The. Heck! Overall, Yates spins a well-written, riveting tale that is incredibly gloomy at times with some really dark themes.

And just a side note; I loved Matthew so much. At the beginning you think there is no way you can have empathy for any character but Matthew definitely stands out for me, and my heart broke for him so much.

Thank you to Netgalley, Picador and Christopher Yates for an advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Great book, had me a bit flustered at times, but definitely worth reading. This book had some surprising twists and then you wonder who is really the victim! Not sure I liked the ending, so that's why I give a 4.5. Would love a second book, to follow up!

Was this review helpful?

I could not get into this book, it did not pique my interest so I decided to stop reading it rather than finish it and post a low review.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately a DNF for me. The writing was okay but the descriptions were too graphic, I found it a bit distributing and end up not finishing.

Was this review helpful?

Patrick, Matthew, and Hannah are bound together by a violent act that severed their relationships when they were teens in the summer of 1982. Years later, not all the truths of those events have come to light. The three are reunited once again, and it is time to face the truths of those events.

Grist Mill Road is filled with secrets and deception. Each characters having their own secrets and truths that they hide from the world and those closest to them. Their individual world’s start to fall apart when they are forced to think back all those years and face the events that happened so long ago. Ultimately it comes down to whether they are willing to forgive and move on, or get vengeance.

I’m torn about this book. I thoroughly enjoyed the writing and getting to know the characters from the switching of perspectives. I’m always drawn to novels that are written from multiple points of view because you are able to empathize with each characters and know multiple angles of every situation. I found myself wanting more from the plot, though. The story moved quickly, and there was much to learn from the events that transpired all those years ago, but there was not much for a suspense thriller. I felt that the ending happened abruptly, and without a clear resolution. I wouldn’t call this a “on the edge of your seat” thriller, rather a redemptive drama. Worth a read because of the writing, but if you are looking for a wild roller coaster thriller, this is not the read for you.

Was this review helpful?

This started out with a bang, kind of fizzled and then picked up at the end. The last part of the first half and the middle really slowed down and I almost gave up, but I’m glad I stuck it out.

This story starts out involving three adolescents and a tragic incident. It then goes on to follow them as adults and what has happened to them in the following years. I don’t want to go into too much detail since I don’t want to give anything away.

Like I stated earlier, I almost bagged it at the 30% mark but I kept with it and I’m glad I did. The writing style won’t be for everybody and I think that’s what initially what turned me off. I did get us to it. I didn’t finish his first book Black Chalk for that same reason. All in all it was a good read.

Was this review helpful?

I felt this book tried to manipulate me into sympathising with a paedophile.

This is abhorrent. It marred the entire book for me and I won't be recommending or reading this author again.

Was this review helpful?

Michael tied Hannah up and shot her in the eye when they were preteens, an act witnessed by his best friend Patrick. Fast forward a couple of decades, and Patrick and Hannah are married and living in New York City when Michael comes back into Patrick’s life. Suddenly, everything they knew about the event is called into question. Told in flashback and from alternating points of view, the whole story is revealed gradually and inexorably.

Read if: You like not knowing how it’s going to end.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for some more great reading in exchange for honest reviews.

Was this review helpful?

Great read.. Page turning thriller of a ride! Thank you to net galley for an arc.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a very intense read. There are three main characters and they all go back and forth with their stories.. The story is also told in two different time periods. I was absolutely mesmerized by this. The setting is a small town in New York about ninety miles north of New York city. When these three were in middle school there was a terrible incident that tears their friendship apart. When they meet twenty years later things only get worse. I was somewhat disappointed with the ending. I feel there was a lot left unsaid and the reader has to fill in the blanks.. All in all it is still a wonderful book and I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?