Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I love the idea of necromancers since reading another series and this author has done a great take on it.



This book started off on a great pace and full of details without overdoing it. Odessa “Sparrow” and her partner are getting ready to raise the dead king just like any other time. It’s nothing knew, the royals have been raised countless times before and just as they finish up they can go have dinner. Yep, totally normal.



Things are going well for everyone, that is until they see one of their masters’ dead in the deadlands and shades start appearing. A shade is never a good thing and they don’t kill that easily unless you’ve had experience in killing them before. While Sparrow and Evander are in the deadlands with the rest of their crew, things go south as they split up. Evander faces off a shade and doesn’t win.



While Sparrow is mopping about, the book had turned and become annoying. It was like any other book that had a death. Sparrow was lost and hurt. Drinking, needing potions to be able to see Evander, not wanting to ever see the deadlands again or work. For those few chapters, the book will bore you until Sparrow finally starts getting herself together.



The ending wasn’t what I had expected and it certainly left me wanting more. I can’t wait for the next book to be released!

Was this review helpful?

The premise of the book is interesting - the noble class kept "alive" by constant resurrection at the hands of necromancers. The book is reminiscent of "Three Dark Crowns" and "Carve the Mark"; supernaturally abled people contending with positions of power and what their abilities mean for their own complicity in keeping the status quo.

The writing style was colorful and interesting, but the plot and the final reveal seemed too predictable, which meant I eventually felt like I was finishing the book more because I needed to finish it and less because I was interested in how it ended.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love the premise of this book. The worldbuilding was good and well thought out. The characters had real depth. But it was so overhyped to become the next big thing. And too much was crammed into one book. It was a jumping off point, but it was like a massive preview and not its own thing.

Was this review helpful?

It was nice not to have the King be the antagonist for a change. All the deaths were heartbreaking, but in the best possible way. I wish the book would have been a bit more unpredictable, but overall I still really enjoyed it. This book wrapped up nicely, but Im anticipating some piraty stuff in the second book and its getting me real excited to get my hands on it.

Was this review helpful?

I was so incredibly excited for this book and just so let down. Every major point, relationship, everything was breezed past in writing and never allowed the reader to sink any emotional hooks into. Marshall spent so much time focusing on points that she didn't build up to well enough and so then the reader just didn't care. Her whole addiction and recovery was predicated on a completely out of character reaction, to me it was out of character because we were only TOLD about how we should feel about the relationship but never given a chance to feel it and be drawn in.

This book suffers greatly from being told and not shown. It was a quick read because it read like an outline.

Marshall has the potential to be a great author, there were chunks of this book that were gorgeous, I just really think the editing and development process let this book down which was heartbreaking for me because a book with this representation could be so important, and instead it was left to flounder under what they thought would make up for the underdevelopment.

Was this review helpful?

It took me a little while to get into Reign of the Fallen, but once I did, I was hooked. I was so excited to see a YA fantasy novel with an LGBTQ relationship and it had a satisfying slow burn that kept me reading. I'm not sure how I feel about the ending, but perhaps it's situated for a sequel so I can see more of how things turn out. The plot was really creative, a society built around dead leaders who must be raised by necromancers periodically. I've never read anything like that and I read a lot. I've since recommended this book to a co-worker who also enjoyed it. Overall, an clever, engaging YA fantasy that I'll gladly add to my shelves.

Was this review helpful?

In the land of Karthia, death isn't always final. Necromancers cater to the Dead, bringing their souls back from the Deadlands and allowing them to move among society, even rule their lands. They must, however, remain shrouded; if their shrouds should fall off, they will become Shades - essentially, ravening zombies - and have to be put down before they can cause harm. Odessa is a master necromancer, as is her lover, Evander; they work together to discover the death of their mentor at the hands of a Shade until another Shade attacks leaves Evander dead and Odessa grieving. In the midst of her grief, Odessa and one of Evander's sisters stumble onto a plot to overthrow the kingdom of the Dead; it's a conspiracy that will leave her home in chaos. As Odessa works with Evander's sister to untangle the mystery, she finds herself drawn to this young woman - as she was to Evander.

There's a lot going on in Reign of the Fallen, and Sarah Glenn Marsh puts some nice worldbuilding into her story. She's created a society where the dead can still be as productive as they were in life, but this causes strife among those who feel that it's time for the dead to step aside and let the living rule. She's created a world where sexuality and gender are fluid; it's a part of the fabric of their society. To refer to this an LGBT novel is, however, a bit premature, at least to me; the main character spends a good part of the storyline in love with or mourning her lost, cis-male, love, and only just starts to notice and act on her attraction for another female fairly late in the book. Other same-sex relationships are referred to, but this is a society where love is love, and neither gender nor sexuality changes the rules. There are sex-positive LGBT themes; I'm just not sure that having a bisexual character who only seems to discover her bisexuality 2/3 through the novel qualifies it as an LGBT book, rather than a well-written, immersive fantasy.

Overall, Reign of the Fallen is a nice add to fantasy collections and will satisfy fantasy readers that enjoy intrigue and worldbuilding. The book has a starred review from School Library Journal.

Was this review helpful?

If I’d have to choose only one word to describe Reign of the Fallen, I’d choose the word unique.
In my life, I’ve read many books (almost 500), but I’ve never read anything similar to this story.

Reign of the Fallen is a novel set in a world where people after their death can come alive, with the help of people who’s job is to take them out of the Deadland into their real world.
As you can imagine, most people that rule this world have already died many times.
However cool that might sound, there is one catch: if a dead person stays “alive” for too long, there’s a chance for her to become a Shadow, which is basically some sort of evil zombie that eats and kills everything and everyone.
So therefore, after some time, a person who is Undead (that’s the word for a person who was brought back to life) should be killed and then brought back to life again.
As you can imagine, the circle goes on and on and on…

As I already stated, reading Reign of the Fallen was a pleasant surprise since I have never read anything like that.
It took me some time to figure out how this world really works, but I thing that the world building was done great and I really enjoyed all the elements of it (also, I couldn’t help but think how this world must smell really bad!).

The story follows Sparrow who is the best in bringing Dead people back to life. She works for the king and she lives and breathes her job. She wouldn’t know who she’d be without it.

Sparrow was an interesting character, to say the least. She made some decisions that really left me confused, but I have to stress out that after everything that has happened to her, she was very lost and confused herself.
She was pretty selfish and self centered, and even though that is a turn off in a way, it is also a very realistic thing, because it is in human nature to centre the world around your own self.

There was one situation in the book that I just have to mention.
We got to see how a character got herself addicted to drugs, and how painful it was to take herself off it, and I have never saw anything similar in ya fantasy.
It was kind of silly, to be honest, but in the same time, I welcome it.

I also have to emphasize that this novel has a great diversity representation.

When I look at Reign of the Fallen as a whole, I honestly think it would have been a better book if it was an adult fantasy novel.

Overall, I am glad I gave this book a chance because it was like a breathe of fresh air, but when I look at the whole picture, it was a solid read.
I would still recommend it, though!

Was this review helpful?

Three and a half stars: A solid YA book with an interesting premise, but it stumbles with a lengthy introspection section that drags down the story.

Odessa is a necromancer. As a necromancer it is her responsibility to watch over the raised dead. Whenever a noble dies, it is the job of the necromancer to cross into the dangerous Deadlands in order to retrieve a soul and bring it back to the body. The Dead live amongst the living, but they must remain shrouded at all times, even a tiny peek at exposed flesh will cause a horrible transformation into a Shade. A Shade is a zombie like creature that feasts on humans. Odessa loves her life and her partner and best friend, Evander. On a routine trip into the Deadlands, everything goes horribly wrong. The master Necromancer comes stumbling out, mortally wounded by a Shade. Suddenly there are murderous Shades attacking everyone, and everyone is pointing fingers at the Necromancers. Who is behind the deadly attacks and why?

What I Liked
*Reign of the Fallen is a book with a lot to like. It has interesting characters, excellent world building, fascinating concepts, lots of action, magic, and a hint of romance. If you want a different type of YA, this is one to try.
*I enjoyed the world building. The book is set in a world where the souls of the nobles are retrieved and returned to their bodies, allowing the Dead to continue to live and rule among the humans. There are drawbacks to being a living dead. The Dead cannot expose any flesh, if they do they transform into grotesque monsters known as Shades. Shades devour the living. It is the job of the Necromancers to watch over the Dead, and also to retrieve their souls from the Deadlands. The Deadlands are the world of the Dead. I was drawn into this strange world of magic, monsters and the Dead. I thought the author did a terrific job with the world building.
*Once the book gets going, there is plenty of action and danger. I loved venturing into the Deadlands with Odessa, Meredy and her grizzly bear. I also enjoyed the betrayal and the fight to save the kingdom.
*Odessa is a character who requires a great deal of patience. At first, she is the formidable Sparrow. A talented Necromancer, one of the best. She is fearless. Then something happens, and Odessa spirals downward. I have to admit, during this portion of the book, I almost gave up because she irritated me so much. Thankfully, she gets it together. I was glad when she did the turn around. By the end, she is a force to be reckoned with.
*Meredy saves the book in my opinion. She doesn’t make her appearance until the midway portion of the book. I loved Meredy. She should be the heroine of the book. She is the one that saves the day time and time again. Not to mention, she is a talented Beastmaster, and her animal of choice is a huge grizzly bear. The grizzly bear is kick butt awesome. I also enjoyed the rest of the secondary characters, Jax, Simeon, Danial, Valoria and Kasmira. The author brings forth a diverse cast of characters, and there are a couple of LBGT characters.
*The romance, I don’t want to give much away. Don’t read the synopsis if you don’t want to ruin it. I took out some spoilers in the synopsis on my post. The book starts out with Odessa in love and committed to someone, and then things happen. Something unexpected happens in the final third of the book. A surprising romantic relationship blossoms. I loved that the relationship starts out antagonistic, the two hate each other. Things happen and a shaky trust forms, and then it changes. One of the things that I liked the most was that the romance was more focused on friendship and trust. When the relationship changes, it develops slowly with bonding and gentle, comforting touches. I loved that there was so much heat, emotion and tenderness in a simple touch. I also loved that the romance is subtle, it isn’t the main part of the story. It is done just right.
*After a dramatic climax and finale, the dust settles and all ends well. I was so surprised to find that the book didn’t end with a cliffhanger. In fact, all of the main story lines are concluded, and I thought this was a stand alone. However there were story lines laid down for future expansion and exploration. I cannot tell you how nice it was to pick up a YA book and not get a cliffhanger. This could work as a stand alone.
*I listened to the audiobook version narrated by Alex McKenna. This was my first book narrated by Ms. McKenna. I thought she was outstanding. Her male voices were great, and I especially enjoyed her voices for the female characters. I will definitely listen to her narration again.
And The Not So Much:
*I have one huge complaint with this book. There is a lengthy, drawn out section where Odessa becomes a potion addict after a horrible catastrophe. I got sick and tired of reading about Odessa’s drug addiction and her hallucinations. I was so bored by her behavior and irritated that I almost put the book down. If Meredy hadn’t arrived and shaken things up, I would have quit. This portion of the book dragged down the pace.
*The other problem I had was that I never felt the connection between Odessa and Evander because not much time is spent on the relationship, so I was disconnected emotionally later in the book.
Meredy was what saved the book, and after I finished, I found myself wondering on her backstory. I wish there had been more on Meredy.
*There are two villains in the book, and the first one is done away with rather quickly before learning all of his secrets. I wanted a better understanding on this character, his motives and his powers.
*I think too much is revealed in the synopsis. It is better to let the reader discover the relationships for themselves without giving it away. Do not read the synopsis before going into this one.

Reign of the Fallen is one of the better YA books I have read in awhile. I enjoyed the interesting world build and the concept of the Shades and the Dead. The characters were fascinating, and I appreciated the diversity. The one thing that held this book back for me was a lengthy section dealing with the heroine’s emotional upheaval and drug addiction. This caused the pace to drag. Thankfully, Meredy comes in and saves the day and the book. This was definitely worth the read.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own, and I was not compensated for this review.
Posted@Rainy Day Ramblings.

Was this review helpful?

Reign of the Fallen is a beautifully written YA fantasy about a necromancer. The concept is unique making this a fresh plot among the sea of unoriginal YA fantasy. There is excellent LGBTQ representation. The characters are complex. The world-building is wonderful. The theme of grief was beautifully done in a raw, very real way. Reign of Fallen is a great read for anyone looking for something different in YA fantasy.

Was this review helpful?

This book was only ok. There wasn't really anything special about it. I never really felt invested in the characters. The story was kind of dragged out. The topic/story line seemed interesting but never had the umph it needed to get me really into the story. The middle especially slowed down. I think teens who are really into grief fantasy might enjoy this book though, so I give it 3 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I should have loved this book more. When I read the description, I thought, "Is this the queer Abhorsen story I've been waiting ten years for?" Alas, it didn't really live up to my expectations.

The good: There are multiple queer characters, POC, different gender expressions, etc. I loved that this was a diverse cast, but it never felt like the author was saying, "Look! This is a diverse cast!" It just was, and people didn't bat an eye at queer love. I'm so over stories of gay oppression, so this was refreshing. The world was complicated, but I got a grasp on it pretty quickly and was genuinely interested in the story.

The bad: The story fell away to focus on the MC's grief. I think grief is something that should be explored more often in YA, but it felt wrong in this book. The MC basically fell apart with grief for what felt like half of the book, while the main story line was put on the back burner. This section was so tedious, I almost didn't make it through.

Luckily, I slugged through the middle section and made it to the end, which I enjoyed. I absolutely adored the queer love interest, and even though my feelings about this book were mixed, I would love to see a sequel with her featured more. For a character who is a main love interest and HAS A FREAKING BEAR, you'd think she would get more screen time!

Overall a mixed bag, but I'll definitely check out a sequel. Also, the cover is so dreamy that even though I didn't love the book, I would consider buying it just to stare at that beautiful hardback.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. It has excellent LGBT rep (a bi main character) and a pretty cool magic system. Though it has a little bit of shallowness at times, that doesn't distract from the point of the thing. I want to read more in this world that focuses on the various forms of magic.

Was this review helpful?

Reign of the Fallen is an okay ya fantasy book. It has a unique premise. Odessa, known as Sparrow, lives in a world where things need to remain the same. The same holidays are celebrated and the same royalty rules the world. To keep things this way, Sparrow and her fellow Necromancers use their magic to bring back the dead, including the king to help rule the land and keep things going as is. The dead live shrouded, if any piece of them is seen by the living they turn into Shades. Monstrous things the kill humans.
I liked the setting and the fact that there is other types of magic in this world. I also liked how the king is a nice guy. You learn this early on the book. He really wants to do what he thinks is best for his people. I liked the supporting characters in the book. Odessa has great friends. They have unique personalities and were a nice addition to the book. I loved Valoria and Meredy.
This is a book that I should have loved but despite all of the good things about it, I found it just okay. I think my main issue was with Odessa. She's not immediately dislikable but as the story goes on you realize just how selfish and self centered she is. She spends her time being miserable about the things that happened and ignoring her friends pain. I couldn't understand why her friends loved her so much. This made the romantic sub story in this problematic because I couldn't understand the attraction to Odessa. (view spoiler)
I was not surprised at the plot twist at the end. There had been enough hints on the way that everyone probably knew except Odessa. The other issue that I had with this book, and this is not unique to other YA books like this, but all of these momentous events in this land revolve around the actions of a bunch of teenagers. While this works in some stories, in this one it just didn't click for me.
Not sure if I will read the second book. If it focuses on Odessa then I might skip it but maybe if it follows some of the other characters like Valoria or Simeon then I might give it a chance.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

"Life will be hard and painful as long as I cling to it, but there's beauty in it, too."

Even though it's set in the fantasy realm of Karthia -- a world centered on necromancers, Shades (read: zombies), and genetically predisposed mages -- this diverse novel still manages to remind you of home. Full of love, loss, grief, coups, and magic it reminds us that "every monster can be beaten" as long as we try.

I enjoyed this more than I thought I would, and I applaud the author for taking bold and tear-inducing plot twists. Full RTC.

Was this review helpful?

A lot of my friends from Book Twitter have been very vocal about their love for a certain January '18 release, and that is Reign of The Fallen by Sarah Glenn Marsh. Established influencers like Ava of Bookishness and Tea, Rebeca of The Life of A Booknerd Addict, Cait of Paper Fury, Brittany of Brittany's Book Rambles, Alex of The Book's Buzz, and a lot of other bookish people have been championing this release, and I for one am so glad to have been given the chance to read it in advance and promote it here on BFR today. Now, read on for my detailed review of Reign of The Fallen.

I love the amazing cast of characters that Sarah Glenn Marsh introduced to her readers, and I absolutely adore how easy it was to root for them. In order for me to completely fall in love with a fantasy story, I honestly have to be fully invested in the characters, whether they be major or minor ones. Unsurprisingly, that's exactly what I got with Odessa, Evander, Meredy, Jax, Simeon, and a lot more. Way before I passed the 50-page mark, I was already in awe with the individuality of the story's characters, and I massively enjoyed getting to know each of them. I'm not gonna lie, there were times that I had a confusing time distinguishing some of their tones and voices, but overall, I loved the story mostly because I loved these characters.

The world building and the action scenes were all pretty impressive as well. Reign of The Fallen is filled with so much thrill and adventure and I love how electrifying most of the action scenes were. There was a lot going on in every page, but it wasn't in excess, and I find that the story was pretty well-balanced. I enjoyed going on the adventures that Odessa had to endure, and I hope that other readers will be as allured by the story as I was, if not more.

Other than that, I also loved Odessa's story in Reign of The Fallen because of the utter disregard for the characters' sexual orientation. I love how the story didn't so much as linger on the issues of being gay, or lesbian, or bisexual. People just fell in love with other people not caring about their gender. Honestly, I dream of one day being able to live in a community where love is a universally respected idea, and that people won't be judged by their choices as to who to fall madly in love with. I love the message that this book shared with it's readers, and I most certainly appreciated Karthia a lot more because of this.

"Reign of The Fallen is an electrifying novel that's charged with action, adventure, and aspiration. It focuses on giving readers an amazingly electrifying reading experience that's perfect for fans of Marie Lu, Leigh Bardugo, and Holly Black. It offers a unique story that's about love, friendship, loss, grief, and what it entirely means to be a protector of an ever-changing world. I massively enjoyed reading this, and I look forward to reading more books by Sarah Glenn Marsh. Believe me when I say that you have never read a fantasy novel that's as captivating as Reign of The Fallen."

Was this review helpful?

Another mediocre read hiding behind a pretty cover.

Now that’s not to say that the book wasn’t good, because parts of it were definitely enjoyable. It just suffered from poor pacing and uninteresting side characters. But the world was enthralling, the story was unique, and the concept of the Living Dead is presented in a new way that made me think. This could have been a wonderful book if not for a few execution errors.

Odessa is a Necromancer, able to bring the spirits of the dead back to the world of the living, and her skill is unparalleled. But when the Dead are being turned into Shades, rogue spirits intent on death and destruction, all of her skills are put to the test. As a main character, Odessa was interesting enough. She made some questionable decisions throughout the course of the story that made me scratch my head, but overall, she was a strong female lead. I also liked that she is a bi character, but I wish the romance was a bit more fleshed out so I could have been more invested.

I did have an issue with the side characters, and I really wish time was taken to get to know them better. Most appeared whenever Odessa needed them, and then they promptly disappeared again. At the end, it was hard to differentiate between them at all, and that’s never a good sign.

My main issue with this book is the pacing. The plot was stagnant in the first half of the story, and it was really hard to continue reading when the characters and world-building weren’t up to par with carrying the story themselves. The premise of the story lays out the conflict: “Soon a crushing loss of one of their own reveals a disturbing conspiracy: someone is intentionally creating Shades by tearing shrouds from the Dead--and training them to attack.” However, this plot point isn’t introduced until almost halfway through the book. Every time Odessa wondered what was going on, I was just twiddling my thumbs waiting for her to figure things out. It was achingly slow. But once this plot was introduced, things ramped up and became much more interesting. I really enjoyed the second half of the story, and I wish that the first half could have been more interesting.

I applaud Marsh for creating such a unique concept and world. I’m really hoping we learn more about the magic system and the Deadlands, because what was presented really held my interest.

Overall, this was a decent read, and with a sequel having been announced already, my interest is piqued. Let’s see where things go!

Was this review helpful?

The concept alone (and also the sparkly cover. I'm a sucker for sparkly covers) made me request it immediately when it was available on Netgalley. That and I follow Sarah Glenn Marsh on Twitter and she's mentioned how it was a story about queer girls.

I was hyped. I was ready.

I ended up a little disappointed.

I want to establish how much I loved the concept. The concept was the coolest thing ever. I loved the idea of necromancers working for good, doing their best to keep the dead "alive". I loved a kingdom that's had the same king for hundreds of years, a king that outlawed change.

But nothing felt right when I read the book. Maybe it wasn't for me, that happens. I felt the execution needed work. Few scenes felt tense, and the ones that did were immediately rectified by having the tension swept away. At one point, the main character sacrifices herself to kill a Shade--the undead monsters--by pulling it into a raging bonfire, since fire is one of two ways to kill the Shades.

That's such a good moment! The main character sacrificing herself, her health, to save the people around her! She's pulled out of the fire, horribly burned, and I just knew that was going to be a huge tension point for the entire book! She's burned! She's hurt, but she's supposed to be the kingdom's best necromancer, how will she defend everyone from Shades when she... oh... a healer came up. Okay, sure, he'll take away the worst of the pain but she'll still be worse off because of her rash actions... Oh. She's 100% healed, good as new, like nothing happened. Well. Shit.

That, I think, was the worst that can happen in a story. Characters fall to ruin from their own actions but never feel the lasting consequences. Yes, they spend half a page thinking they're going to die from the burning, but then by the next page they're perfectly okay thanks to a healer's magic and they learn nothing. I wanted to see characters suffer from their own misguided actions and become better for it--that's how character development works! But it never happened within Reign of the Fallen and it sucked all the fun out of the book for me.

I have to give this one three stars for stellar concept, a pretty cover, lots of queers and badass ladies, a deep look into addiction and grief, and getting me to at least finish the book instead of DNF'ing it. Unfortunately, this won't be one I'll be revisiting or picking up a sequel to. Though I've seen lots of other people love it, so perhaps it just wasn't my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

As a book reviewer, I don’t get a whole lot of free time for book hangovers. If I fall behind in my reading schedule, it can throw a kink in the entire year’s schedule. That means, unfortunately, I don’t have time to give a book a few days of respectful silence before jumping into a new story. Often, I only wait a few hours before starting the next one.

So it was pretty surprising (and frustrating, but also awesome) when, three days after finishing Reign of the Fallen, I still couldn’t get into my next book. It was too good.

A short summary: Odessa raises the dead for a living. It’s a fairly simple job: Someone dies, she goes into the Deadlands to retrieve them, and they’re returned to their body. In fact, the current king has been reigning for over 200 years — why give up the throne when you can just keep coming back, right? There’s just one catch: The Dead have to wear a shroud, covering their bodies completely, or they’ll turn into rampaging, murder-crazed monsters called Shades. Is the risk the Dead pose to the living worth allowing them to come back?

I’ve probably read hundreds of YA fantasy books in my life so far, and it’s safe to say there are some… prominent plot tropes. Some prominent worldbuilding techniques, prominent magic wielding systems, prominent romances, even prominent character traits. Sometimes I literally confuse one YA fantasy book with another, because they’re actually that similar. It’s like publishers look at their competition’s lineup and say, “Let’s publish that exact book, but with the character and location names changed.”

Reign of the Fallen was the most original YA fantasy I’ve read in a long, long time. There are some books that just stand out from the crowd, and Reign of the Fallen is one of them. It was intriguing, heart-wrenching, exciting, and completely unexpected. I feel like this book didn’t get much hype from the book community, but it should have. This book wasn’t on my shortlist of most exciting 2018 releases, but it absolutely should have been.

Did it have its fair share of issues? Sure. There were times when it seemed a “rule” about the type of magic the characters wielded randomly cropped up, as if it was inserted halfway through the book to make the subsequent scene make sense (when it should have been inserted near the beginning, where the worldbuilding is heaviest). There were some times when the story was more predictable than others. But if you let go and enjoy the story, it’s honestly an amazing ride.

A few people have voiced questions on social media about representation in this book: There is bisexual representation, as well as lesbian and gay representation. The relationships are fairly realistic to me, and there isn’t any homophobia in the book. Odessa is also described as having darker skin, but the book doesn’t really go into race at all. The most it does is mention that another character’s skin is much, much lighter than Odessa’s.

Was this review helpful?

5 stars. This book was great! In a world where death isn't the end, it makes total sense that the rich and the powerful would never want to die - and yet I have never read a book like this! I found this world absolutely fascinating. The aspects of necromancy in the novel - traveling to the Deadlands (and the effects of doing so) and the interactions between the dead and living - were so interesting. I loved that the dead were so afraid of change that they outlawed it.

The bi rep in this book is just... amazing. I loved it. It felt completely real and natural and not overexplained (this is why #ownvoices is so important). I especially loved that it was explicitly stated that Odessa knew she was bi when she was so young (as Simeon knew he was gay when he was young) - we have so many stories where characters discover their sexuality, and while that's fantastic!!! I really enjoy reading when they've known it all along too.

I loved the characters. I was thrilled to see a ~strong female character~ be so weak at points (strong characters don't have to be strong all the time!). I also loved the incredibly strong friendships (let's hear it for found family, y'all know I love it) - the friendships are so rich and vivid and just made my heart feel full. I figured out who the bad guy was pretty early on but I still enjoyed watching Odessa try to figure it out.

I highly recommend this book. I wasn't a huge fan of how it ended ([Odessa literally peacing out without a word to anyone??? her friends are going to be so worried??? what the fuck??? I understand she deserves to have some time for herself and have her own adventures but christ leave a note or something (hide spoiler)]), so I'm really looking forward to seeing where the next book goes - I'd love to learn more about the religion and the 5 faced Goddess. And I can't wait to read about Odessa and Meredy's next adventure.

Was this review helpful?