Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The ‘world’ was interesting. Just what would life be like in the shadow of Olympus? What would it take to survive weather conditions on Mars? The answering inventions are quite clever and fun. The author does a great job of making it very futuristic but also keeping it understandable for the target age group.
Unfortunately, I didn’t like the heroine. I think Collins was trying to portray Belle as being very spunky and courageous, but she came across as just plain rebellious. She routinely disobeys her parents, authorities, or any adult in the general vicinity. It’s not that she’s just impulsive or thoughtless. She often takes the time to think about what she is going to do, and then she always decides that she is wiser than her parents so that she can act as she wishes. She even convinces her friend to lie to her parents. Beyond a lecture, and finally a grounding, there are never any consequences for her actions. In, fact she is constantly getting praised for what she does.
The main lesson is the evils of racism. I wouldn’t have guessed how that got settled. That was unique and would have been good, if it hadn’t relied on Belle, once again, disobeying and breaking her word.
There were a few other things that bothered me as well, some more than others. The acceptance of some of the more radical environmental theories as facts was annoying. The family unit of one or heroines best friends made me very uncomfortable. The author may not have meant anything weird, but having three parents living together is just a bit confusing and unsettling.
Because of the age of the target audience and the behavior encouraged by the heroine, I cannot recommend this book.
I received this as a free ARC from NetGalley and Capstone. No favorable review was required. These are my own honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

Redworld is a fun adventure for late elementary or early middle school readers. Each section of the book is a new adventure of Belle and her friends and each reads as a somewhat independent story. There is a bunch of repetition at the start of each section, which makes it seem like they may have been intended to be separate books. The stories are each enjoyable with a nice messages on friendship and acceptance. They reminded me of the Little House books in how they talk about homesteading, although it is a sci-fi version! Boys and girls would equally enjoy Belle and her adventures.

Was this review helpful?

ARC Copy for review...It was nice. very much a coming of age tale of living on the western frontiers alias the pioneer days except the twist is...it's all on a terraformed Mars. I like Belle...she is smart, adventurous but tends to leap before she looks and breaks the rules when she wants to do what she thinks is right. Liken the world building in both the Martian landscape, the social interplay between the three major species on the planet, and the slice of life approach to the narrative. The illustrations are beautiful and makes the narrative feel more in-depth and beautiful.

Was this review helpful?