Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I had high hopes for this book but was unable to finish. I had a difficult time connecting with any of the characters and following the story. It does have a Groundhog’s day quality to it as the same day is being relived over and over again but being experienced from different perspectives each time.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know how the author managed to write such a maze-of-a-novel. I don’t believe I’ve ever read anything like this before!

I knew this novel was being hugely praised and it made me even more determined and ready to solve this whodunnit on my own. If you already read this novel you’ll know how ridiculous my assumption was because there is no way that you can anticipate and solve this on your own, as I figured out quite soon as well ;-). There’s so much cause and effect in this novel, so much detail that went into this grand scheme of things that it just wasn’t possible to get a clear picture of the whole puzzle. It didn’t spoil any of the fun though, there was so much to be discovered in this novel, there were new insights and revelations with every character change.

Although I loved the start of the novel I was a bit worried how the story was going to develop and if I’d be able to keep up. I felt quite confused with what was going at first… was it just me I wondered? Should I start making notes of timelines and characters? Bell seemed awfully focused on someone called Anna but I thought it was all about a woman called Evelyn Hardcastle.. and then there was quite a large cast of characters in the novel that were kept an eye on. As the story progressed everything became clear though so not to worry, if you keep going it’ll all make sense eventually, you just have to go with the flow and let the main character lead you on, it’ll all become clear as water.

I had a hunch that the present mystery and a past event were in some way connected but I didn’t know how. I also had no clue who was chasing him, trying to get him killed or who this masked man is called The Plague Doctor. He’s the one who doesn’t let him leave unless he solves the murder but also provides him with info. Is he to be trusted and who is he? Lots and lots of intriguing questions *big smiles*. The main character (Aiden) will have to use each character’s strong points to his advantage and learn as much as he can about the others in order to solve this one. I was satisfied with all the answers in the end though and it exceeded my expectations entirely.

The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle is not an easy relaxed read, one where you’re able to have one eye on your cooking, child or husband, but you will want to keep with it when reading anyway, in the end it’s really insanely twisted!

This novel takes you on a mind-boggling trip with many many twists, secrets, and even a little sprinkle of futuristic sci-fi in it. The details of that last part were not developed but it’s not something I wished for either, the idea was enough to make it work. Even the sci-fi part was great for me, go figure!

I’m going to stop here because I could keep going on forever. I think you’ll have realised by now that this is a must-read! Don’t give up in the beginning, it’s totally worth it. The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle is the most complex novel I’ve probably ever read. It’s incredibly clever and utterly addictive. I don’t say this often but I most definitely would love to reread this in the future even when I know – and won’t forget any time soon – how it ends and who killed Evelyn Hardcastle. It’s that good!

Was this review helpful?

This was such an interesting concept- murder mystery mixed with a time travel paradox! I really enjoyed the beginning but the plot was slow and obviously repetitive. I found that I didn't really feel like continuing the book so I ended up not finishing it.

Was this review helpful?

Sebastian awakes to find that he has no memory.of who he is or where he is. In fact he isn’t even Sebastian at all. As he comes round he finds himself shouting “Anna”. Who Anna is he has no idea but she is running through the woods and then there is the sound of a gunshot. The next day he awakes as the butler and sees “himself” arrive at the door exactly as he did the day before. Think period drama groundhog day. On day three, in yet another guise, he sees the plagues doctor whom he briefly saw beforehand. He tells him that a murder is to be committed and that the guises will keep happening a total of eight times. He will spend 24 hours in each however if they fall asleep or die he will then either move back to one he hasn’t completed or onto a new one. He has to find whom the murderer is to escape the scenario within the time frame. There are also two others whom this is happening to. Only one can escape from Blackheath. This is not as complicated as it sounds. Each chapter gives which day (and part in some cases). A very different way of telling a crime story and a very interesting one at that. Characters pick up various clues and Aiden (the person whose mind is in all of the bodies/guises) can remember these clues.In the questions and answers with the author at the back, Stuart mentions the TV programme Quantum Leap- if you are of the age to remember this- then this will all make sense. One of the most imaginative, and creative books I have read for a long time One to keep the grey matter active.
For more reviews please see my blog http://nickibookblog.blogspot.co.uk/
or follow me on Twitter @nickijmurphy1
(rest of links when blog post live)

Was this review helpful?

When I started this book I wasn’t quite sure what I was getting into, but the further I read and as the story unfolded, I knew I had found a winner. The writing is nothing short of brilliant; it is hauntingly evocative of a dark, damp, brooding country manor inhabited by a cast of rather unsavory characters. No one is who they seem to be and the main character keeps changing the body he’s inhabiting. Add to that the fact he is part of a competition to solve the title mystery. Whoever solves the murder gets to leave the estate. Oh, one other little thing, he starts the book and week with no memories. Just plopped into a body and off we all go. Good times all around, especially for the reader!

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

I will say that this book is pretty original in its concept. However, I just could not get into it at all and found myself wondering what the heck was happening. Also, the writing is very much like an Agatha Christie novel and way too British for my taste. However, if you really like those type of mysteries or the movie Gosford Park you will probably really like this novel. I like the concept and maybe if it was done in a different setting with different characters it would have worked better for me.

Was this review helpful?

Stuart Turton must have the mind of a literary genius to have written this book with all its characters, twists and turns, mystery and thought process.
I'm not sure I can do this book justice by giving a summary of its contents so all in going to say is Read It for yourself and be transported inside Blackheath for a week of mystery and excitement. I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
Even better than Agatha Christie in my opinion loved it.

Was this review helpful?

What you really need to know:

This beautiful book is essentially a larger scale Murder on the Orient Express* with a combination Every Day*/Groundhog Day* twist.

Other things to know:

I LOVED IT. This book is a masterpiece. Unfortunately for me, I didn’t have any idea what this book was going to be, so I was immediately put off by the realization that there was a male narrator (who was clearly not Evelyn Hardcastle). I had somehow thought that Evelyn was narrating and I don’t even know what. But as soon as I figured out what was going on (well, as much as the author allows), I was completely sucked in.

Characters:

All of the characters in this book were fantastically developed and interesting. No one, I repeat no one, is innocent in this book. Everyone has some kind of dark secret or past, and it is really impossible to know who to trust. The main character doesn’t even know what to make of himself, let alone the people around him. He is in a different body (as a different person) every day, so as he progresses through the book (and his time limit), his “hosts” become stronger and stronger and it becomes more and more difficult for him to focus on his mission. It’s nearly impossible to stay true to yourself and your morals/personality without actually knowing who you are (or anything about yourself), so naturally, that’s what he’s tasked with.

Plot:

OH MY GOODNESS the plot is so good. The author clearly worked out the timeline of this book many, many times to make it perfect, and it shows. The timeline makes sense. Even though there’s a Miss Peregrine type of loop, I was able to follow what was happening, and he kept everything that was supposed to be understood quite simple. There is so much happening in this book that it’s hard to even talk about, but it’s extremely well woven, and all of the backstory/past that is uncovered later on in the book ties in perfectly with the current timeline, and is kept separate in the best way.

Okay! Can we mention! I am so ridiculously pleased with how he wrapped up this story. I enjoyed the adventure as it was happening, but I was concerned that there wouldn’t be a real/good explanation for why all of this was happening and whether this was real, what the outside world was like, etc. Thankfully (amazingly) this was not the case, and when the circumstances were explained, it seemed natural, and it didn’t lose any of its magic.

Final thoughts:

Overall, I just really enjoyed this, and I highly highly recommend that you pick it up in September (or if you live outside of the US, maybe even sooner!). I will say, some of the darker parts of the story were quite dark (just how I like them), so just be aware that this is definitely an adult book. Other than some gory descriptions/topics, there’s really nothing to worry about with this book. I adored everything about it, and I just really hope it gets picked up and adapted to a movie. It would be incredible to see this play out on the big screen, and I can’t wait to see where Stuart Turton’s writing goes from here.

Was this review helpful?

Unputdownable, unforgettable, unbelievable. Those are just some words to describe this book. This was a stunning journey and I loved every minute of it. It was original and fun, not to mention (again) unputdownable.

I don't usually read mystery/thriller but I'm so glad I read this one. It was very complex but it was not confusing and I had to read it when I didn't have any distractions.

I will reread this again in the near future it was that good.

Was this review helpful?

Think of a cross between the best Agatha Christie novel you could imagine and the movie Groundhog Day and you will arrive at the premise of this novel. Our protagonist is tasked with finding the murderer as he is thrown into the different guests invited to a party. The plot thickens and we are mired in a struggle for our main character to find the murderer and repot him back to the Plague Doctor. This book is exquisitely written, with twists and turns that are worthy of the best true mystery writer. Reminiscent of early 20th century mysteries and a dash of Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children, I guarantee once you open this book it will be a struggle to put it back down until the very end.

Was this review helpful?

Mind boggling. Intense. I finished this book several days ago and I really had to take some time to process and decide how I felt. I won’t lie, it is a tedious book to read between the multitude of characters and narrative and timing of everything. This book is probably the most unique book I have ever read. The main character must attempt to solve the death of a woman by inhabiting eight different hosts who are all tied to her death in some small manner. Because each day is in a new host with new personality, I find it difficult to grasp the character’s development throughout. Regardless, this is unlike anything you e ever read. Far from your typical murder mystery!!

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced copy of this book through Netgalley. This book had me from the very beginning. I love that it kept me on the edge of my seat the whole time. I would highly recommend this book to my fellow readers. Thank you for the chance to review this book!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Wow - where to start??? Aiden Bishop wakes up reliving every day trying to figure out who murdered Evelyn Hardcastle.

Overall, I really liked this book - I found it completely different from anything else I have ever read - which I LOVED!!! Too many books lately feel like the same story I have already read.

I loved seeing the same day played out by different characters and really enjoyed how each of them influence the day. I enjoyed the setting (mansion party), it sort of reminded me of the movie/game Clue. While, I liked the bouncing between days/characters, I also found this to be extremely confusing at some points. There were definitely chapters that held my interest more than others. I think the book might have been drawn out and more lengthy than it needed to be - if it would have been a bit shorter, I think I would have enjoyed it more. There were times when it lagged and I really felt like abandoning it.

I really liked that the ending wasn't predictable at all for me.

Was this review helpful?

I found this boom quite difficult to get into initially but after the 'rules' were established I enjoyed it much more. The storyline was very clever and well-written but the nature of time meant it was quite difficult to follow. The premise is strong and I can imagine that I would enjoy stories from the same universe.

Was this review helpful?

I knew the premise of this book before reading but still wasn't prepared. The movement between the characters and 'days' was masterful. While it did take me a few chapters to get into the flow of the story, once there I was stuck.

So creative. I loved it. This would be a great Fall read. 4.5/5 stars.

Thanks to the publisher for providing an e-ARC through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
The 7 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle is a murder mystery combined with the movie Groundhog Day. I’ll be honest. I hate the movie Groundhog’s Day. It’s personally a very frustrating concept for me. This story is the first instance where I immediately fell in love with this storytelling style, read the book in one sitting, and couldn’t get enough!
Evelyn Hardcastle will be killed again. Everyday Aiden Bishop tries to save her, without any success. Here’s the twist, though. Aiden Bishop wakes up in someone else’s body every day that he tries to save her. Aiden is given 8 days and 8 different identities in order to solve Evelyn’s murder.
Every identity and character is secretive and well-developed. As you are reading you only know what Aiden knows, which is both frustrating and exciting. I’ve never experienced such a limiting field-of-view as a reader before, and it’s done wonderfully.
This is definitely one of my top books for 2018. It’s such a unique experience, and it’s rich with information and mystery.

Was this review helpful?

4.5* - recommended.
Aiden narrates Seven (and a half) Deaths. It begins with him waking up in a wood believing he has seen a murder, he makes it to a large house only to find that he is Dr Simon Bell and so begins this well written and well-crafted story.

Aiden finds out that he will wake up every day as another of the guests in this grand, but shabby home of the Hardcastle family and the only way to get back to being himself away from this house is to solve Evelyn Hardcastle’s murder.

We go with him and as the story unfolds we meet the different house guests and pieces of the puzzle slowly emerge. It is well written, gripping and layered as we learn what happened from one point of view we also see how the other protagonists are viewed by each other. Some of the ‘guests’ that Aiden inhabits aren’t what he thinks and other guests aren’t quite what they seem. Will he solve the murder? Will he escape, indeed will he escape alive?

Aiden is also wondering why him? And it is this storyline, for me, that brings a lovely, subtle sub story with a conclusion that makes this an even more gratifying read.

With this book you get a murder mystery with a mind boggling plot to enjoy over and over again. It delivers many levels and delivers on many levels. This is a terrific book and well worth reading. I enjoyed it and would certainly recommend.

With thanks to SourceBooksLandmark, via NetGalley, for providing me with an eBook of The Seven and a half Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle. I have not received any payment in relation to my review.

Was this review helpful?

Evelyn Hardcastle is going to die; that much has been foretold. But who did it? That is the question Aiden Bishop must answer if he ever hopes to be free of Blackheath. He has eight hosts – each a player on a deadly chessboard he can’t fully see. Eight different points of view, eight chances to solve a mystery before time runs out…

The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle is an intense, evocative, intricately-plotted tale that will keep you on your toes. From the start, I was drawn into the rich imagery of the decaying world of Blackheath, its inhabitants unique and vividly drawn. There are so many secrets in this complex mystery, so many puzzle pieces and point of view jumps that it’s no wonder our protagonist needs eight hosts to even have a glimmer of a chance at solving Evelyn’s murder.

The more you know about a mystery going in, the less enjoyable it is, so I’m loathe to say much about what happens in the story. I will say that I loved watching Aiden put the pieces of this sizeable puzzle together. It’s no easy feat, as he’s hindered as well as aided by the hosts chosen for him. In the hands of another author, this story might have been a tangled mess. But Stuart Turton has done an exceptional job of weaving together a massive number of threads to form one solid mystery. The worldbuilding in this book is fantastic and I loved that I couldn’t tell what would happen next. With so many personalities swirling about, no one can be entirely predictable. There’s also a sinister presence dogging Aiden’s steps that adds a slightly chilling quality to the story, which I enjoyed. The only thing that kept me from absolutely loving this book was the ending. When it comes to stories like these, you really have to stick the landing or it’s a bit of a letdown and while the ending was satisfying enough, it did leave me wanting a bit more. That being said, I still highly recommend The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle to anyone looking for an original, engaging mystery and I’m looking forward to seeing what Mr. Turton comes up with next.

Was this review helpful?

This book is something I really love: Different. And in a good way. I had read no more than a few chapters when I thought it was like playing the game of Clue! My GR friend Sandy already said that in her review but the interesting thing is that we had that same feeling separately, so it must really be true!
I can't believe this is a debut novel. It's incredible how the author could keep trace of everything. I'm not sure the plot is completely believable, but how can I say if something was missing while I was lost most of the time!? I didn't try to read it with too much attention, I choose to enjoy the mood and the strangeness of it as a whole thing, made to be admired rather than dissected. I would have never discovered who was the coulprit and I didn't bother to try. In the end I am happy to have read it that way because in my opinion the wodunnit wasn't the important thing. I can't say more because it would spoil the ending which in my opinion was terrific!
When I start reading a book I usually decide my rating very early on, than it could change on the way. A very good ending could gain the novel one more star. A bad ending could detract even two if it spoiled my memories of the story. In that case it was a five stars from beginning to end. The middle was a bit to long maybe, but there was no part I would have cut out. In fact while I was in the middle I was having nightmares at night because I couldn't stop trying to solve the plot (not the whodunnit, they are two different thing, I wasn't wondering who was the killer but why the MC was there)
I have to admit this book is maybe not for everyone, but if you find the plot summary interesting you should give it a try. And yes, the plot summary probably gives away too much of the story, but I don't know how it would be possible to describe the book without giving away at least something, and anyway I was happy to know a little of what was going on, otherwise I could have had worst nightmares!!
I recommend that book with all of my heart! (My mind is still a bit numb)

I would like to thank NetGalley, the publisher and the author for giving me ARC of that book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Turton has created a true mystery with his debut. When Mr. Bell wakes up in the woods remembering only the name "Anna" and that she is in grave danger. Bell quickly finds himself embroiled in a plot to stop the death of Evelyn Hardcastle, but not all is as it seems. Turton had me guessing constantly, while never leaving me feeling duped by the true ending. He has a masterful sense of writing that will keep even reluctant readers enthralled. Turton has written a perfect bridge for readers moving from YA to Adult fiction by having his debut be so reminiscent of Kristen Cashore's "Jane Unlimited". Highly Recommend.

Was this review helpful?