Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I thought this was fantastic. I've never read anything quite like it. I have no idea how the author managed to keep all the bits and pieces of this story straight in his head while writing. It's quite the feat, and I'm impressed. This book is tense from start to finish, and I loved it.

Thanks NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

First off, let’s get one thing clear: this review isn’t fair. It’s not fair because I feel that the only way to properly review this book is to do so only after a second, if not a third, close read.

The 7 1/2 Deaths is Evelyn Hardcastle is a complex murder mystery that will keep you guessing until the very last few pages. There’s just enough foreshadowing that you can see the ending coming, but at the same time, I doubt I could have guessed it correctly, which makes this book so valuable in my eyes.

I won’t lie, it’s hard to keep track of this story. It took me a long time to read it (I usually put a book away per week, but this one took me almost two months - and it wasn’t exceptionally long either) because I had to start it over at about the 20% mark just to make sure I had grasped what had happened in the first few chapters. I wish I had the time to read through this book again just so I can pick up on everything I’ve missed, as I did with my favourite book from Agatha Christie, And Then There Were None.

I would recommend this book to anyone looking for a complex “Who Dun It” type of mystery with a bit of a supernatural twist. It was really good, although it took me forever to go through it. Some reviewers said they couldn’t put it down, but I find its the type of book that you have to enjoy slowly to pick up on the nuances that made it such a deliciously elegant mystery.

I’d like to thank Sourcebooks Lanark, as well as Netgalley, for the free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I will start by saying whilst I thoroughly enjoyed this, I would hazard a guess that this would be best read as a physical book. A really interesting and well told story with wonderful writing. I found myself thinking about it when I was reading it and raced pack to pick it up. Packed with intrigue, a hyped book worth the hype,

Was this review helpful?

The premise of this book was really original and I thought the book itself was well executed. I struggled a bit with the language, as I usually read more contemporary material, but the story itself kept me hooked. The ending was just as explosive as you would expect.

Was this review helpful?

Holy wow, I loved this book! Like, really loved it. It was fast paced, interesting, unique and just all around GOOD. It has similarities to Agatha Christie novels, and reminded me a bit of Clue, with some Momento, Inception, and Groundhog Day thrown in. The whole premise is fascinating, I don’t even have words to describe it. I had no idea what I was getting into, but it was better than I imagined. The twists, the turns, the ending! The author astounds me with the world he’s built, because the whole story is so complex it must take a brilliant mind to create it. Although long in pages, it was a quick read that I couldn’t put down, and it was a very satisfying read. I’d recommend it anyone and everyone. Pick it up, read it, love it.

Was this review helpful?

What would you do if you awoke in a new body every day, without any memories of the life you led before that moment? For Aiden, the difference between forgetfulness and remembering is a matter of life and death, and not just his own. As the days roll by, the plot thickens, as plots should. Race along with Aiden as he tries to hold onto a thin, strained thread of himself so he can solve a mystery, prevent a murder, and save a girl he doesn't really know. In the tradition of Agatha Christie, the suspects are many, and the clues are doled out just so.

Was this review helpful?

I stayed up late trying to finish this book for a week. It is a mystery that is absolutely engrossing and impossible to put down. The nail-biting tension begins on the first page and never lets up.

I absolutely loved how the author plays with the genre, allowing the main character to witness the same murder eight times from eight perspectives.

I cannot wait to hand this to every reader who approaches me asking for "something good".

Was this review helpful?

I adored this book! It was a bit slow at times and I constantly put it down, but I think it was a worth it read!

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Agatha Christy meets Quantum Leap. I couldn't put this book down.

It took me a moment to understand what was happening at the very beginning but then it became addictive. Each character bringing another piece of the puzzle and more insight into the other characters. So many twists along the way. Stuart Turton is a genius.

I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

Stuart Turton's deft writing style made this book such a joy to read. It felt so timeless and classic, like I was reading an Agatha Christie novel. Each character/suspect is so intricately fleshed out and you can chart the growth of the narrator as he experiences each new twist and turn.

The story involves murder - a murder that Aiden Bishop must solve before midnight. But in a Groundhog's Day twist, he gets to relive the same day eight times, in eight separate hosts, which he must use to question suspects and piece together all the evidence to discover who-dunnit. And only piece by piece can he put together who he, himself, is in the process.

I loved how complicated and puzzle-like this story is. The plot picks up within the first few chapters and then it takes off. It's fast-paced and it kept me guessing throughout it all. There are plenty of twists and with each new piece of evidence uncovered, I kept gasping in surprise. I love mysteries, especially murder mysteries, and this was one of the best I've ever read.

I'd highly recommend this book to anyone, but especially mystery lovers who don't like predictable plots - this will keep you guessing!

Was this review helpful?

The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle reminds me of an old fashioned mystery told in a more modern style. It is reminiscent of Agatha Christie mysteries. Every night at 11 PM Evelyn Hardcastle dies. Aiden is doomed to repeat the same day over and over in a different body until he solves the puzzle of her murder. At first this book was a little complicated to get into because of the details. However, it was very enjoyable once it got going. Readers who like books with an intricate puzzle mystery will definitely love this book. Thank you to the publisher and Net Galley for a free copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thouroughly enjoyed this book.
Was very entertaining.
Mixture of drama, mystery, murder.
Very Agatha Christie but definable a stand alone author.
Very well written.

Was this review helpful?

An utterly original premise that made for a complex and satisfying read. The rich cast of characters could have come straight from an Agatha Christie novel. This mystery kept me engrossed until the final page.

Was this review helpful?

Really interesting plot-twisty mystery. I did find the events a little bit challenging to follow as the main character moved from body to body, living the same day. Trying to figure out what time something happened to character A in order to see how the ripple affected characters B-Z was difficult. The guest list at the beginning of the book was helpful.

Definitely one of the the most creative story ideas I've ever read!

Was this review helpful?

I found this book on Instagram and Litsy and was dying to get my hands on it. When I found it for request on NetGalley, I jumped on the opportunity and kept my fingers crossed I would get approved. When I received the email saying it was ready for me to download, I literally squealed for joy.
This gem is marketed as Agatha Christie meets Groundhog Day, and, honestly, I didn’t expect it to live up to that hype. I love Agatha Christie’s novels, but at the same time, I knew no publishing company would use the comparison lightly, or at least, I hoped not. It did, however, live up to the hype. All the wonderful things people have said about this lovely, are true.
I was hooked in from the beginning. Who is this person? Who is the doctor in the plague mask? Why is he being forced to live out this day again and again? How many times has he been through this but doesn’t remember?
And the ending, did not see that coming. The whole book is set up for you to try to figure out who kills Evelyn Hardcastle, but there, like usual, are more variables to factor into the overall equation than what first meets the eye. Each day, Aiden, the person he believes himself to truly be, has to figure out bits and pieces of the puzzle. Each body he inhabits provides him with a different set of clues and a new perspective to evaluate. It’s like Clue on steroids. And to add to the chaos, Aiden has to survive in each body for as long as possible because the one only referred to as the footman is trying to kill him before he solves the murder.
There was so much going on and so many things to keep track of, but, just like in Clue, attention to detail is key. For me, it wasn’t confusing to keep track of the story, the only confusing part was who was Aiden really and how did he end up in this strange series of events, forced to live the same day over again and again in a different body. Of course, that is pieced together in the end (Thank goodness), but that plot-line falls to the wayside while trying to figure out: Who killed Evelyn Hardcastle? But, I could see how the multiple points of view and details of the day could be difficult and infuriating to get a handle on.
This was unlike anything I have read before or possibly ever again. With each “day,” Aiden is a new person. He has to adopt that person’s mannerisms, tone, habits, and completely ignore himself, or who he believes he is, in order to not draw attention to what would be viewed by others as bizarre behavior but also to gain as much information as possible to solve the murder. When he lets himself take control of the body, he suffers for the decision by losing a day and not gaining any clues. There was this constant inner battle between who he was or thought he was and who he was supposed to be. It actually reminded me of the inner turmoil of Prufrock in T.S. Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock.”
In the end, the mystery is solved and questions answered, which is not an easy task. I wasn’t left angry that I had more questions than answers. I was infuriated that there was a twist ending that felt forced or like the author ran out of story at the end. I was pleasantly surprised by how conclusive the ending was and that the story was so well built. I received a digital copy of this from NetGalley and honestly, I want a physically copy to keep on my shelf and possibly read again. Just like with Agatha Christie, even when you know the ending, the journey is still enjoyable. And that cover! Read the novel then look at the cover again and it sheds an entirely new light on it and the designer is a genius!
Happy Reading!

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks go to Stuart Turton, Raven Books, and Netgalley for the free copy of this book in exchange for my unbiased review. Who is Anna? Where is she? Is she safe? We open the book to these questions being shouted in the forest. And the investigation grows from there. Because unless our protagonist can solve a murder in seven days he's stuck. Forever. This book was brilliant. I can’t imagine what Turton's study must have looked like trying to keep up with all of his plot threads. There were so many twists and turns my heart couldn't keep up with my head. I became so obsessed with this book I read it in one day. I refused to put it down. I had to know how it ended as soon as possible. And there was no way I was ever going to ever be able to guess. There were just too many possibilities. I was kept on my toes beginning to end. I recommended this to my ladies' book club as a selection once it's released. It's perfect!

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This was absolutely AMAZING. I needed a whole day just to wrap my mind around it all, and I'm still SHOOK.

I really don't want to give too much away with the summary, but here we go:
Aiden Bishop wakes up with no memory, but a name on his lips: Anna. He is doomed to repeat the same day over and over again, and Evelyn Hardcastle will die over and over again. Aiden is trapped in this endless loop, and the only way to escape is to find out who murdered Evelyn. But how can you solve a murder that doesn't even look like one? And to make things worse, there's an enemy hidden in the shadows that is much more ruthless and incomprehensible.

The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was absolutely mind-blowing. Although the plot may sound similar to some other time loop days, this one was definitely very unique in one thing (mind the mild spoilers): [Aiden is forced to live the same day over and over again, but in a different host. And he has eight days to solve the mystery. The way time worked in this book was therefore so different from any other book I had ever read.] This entire story was absolutely mind-boggling from beginning to end, and I absolutely could not put the book down.

There were definitely lots of characters within this story, but surprisingly I found that I was able to get a clear picture of what kind of person every character was. It made the setting much more realistic, and as a sort of mystery book, this set my brain into overdrive as I tried to figure out the story for myself. Which I did not, by the way. There was absolutely NO WAY to predict what was coming.

The writing style was superb. It was delicate and elegant, but also intense and cryptic. The writing style reminded me a bit of books like Caraval or The Night Circus, and it made the book immersive and absolutely magical. (Not gonna lie - I had to force myself to pause reading halfway through because it was nighttime and I was slightly afraid and creeped out. But in a good way.)

Overall, I would HIGHLY recommend this to everyone. Seriously. Everyone. Stuart Turton has written a spectacular page-turner that will absolutely blow your mind.

Was this review helpful?

A complex and enjoyable read. Reminiscent of the movie Groundhog Day with a murder twist. This book kept my interest throughout.

Was this review helpful?

This will mark the second time in my Netgalley history that I'm going to stop reading to write a review and then go back to it. I'm halfway through this book right now, and I'm mesmerized. The writing is stunningly strong. Stuart Turton has a gift for turning a phrase. This plotline is so intricately detailed. I can't wait to finish it. I have a feeling it will be tomorrow. There are elements of Agatha Christie, Groundhog Day, and Quantum Leap here. What a combination. I'm only slightly embarrassed to say that there was even a moment about 60 pages ago that reminded me of one of the coolest moments in time travel movie history -- a particular scene that I won't mention from Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure. I know that sounds dopey, but I love time travel movies, and this moment hit me exactly in that satisfying spot. There are laugh-out-loud moments (now talking about 7 1/2 Deaths, not Bill & Ted) and so many times when I've found myself in awe of a plot point or even a metaphor I'd never imagined. I will come back here and edit this if I get to the end unsatisfied, but I am confident that my review will stand, and it will have a permanent place on my shelf of recommendations -- just like the other book I stopped reading to write a review.

Was this review helpful?

What a brilliant and clever read. From the start to the finish I was hooked on ever page, It is a book that really should be read in one sitting- which won't be hard to do because it's amazing! It has so many different elements interwoven within this book that I can do define it under one genre. It's a very refreshing read as it is something different and I absolutely loved this book.

Was this review helpful?